There is a strong case that mortgage-backed securities were at the root of the 2007–09 financial crisis. Even though geographers have convincingly demonstrated that loan origination is strongly locally rooted and that the fallout from the subprime mortgage crisis clearly had spatially circumscribed effects, securitization is still generally perceived as a universal, private, and purely market-based financial technique. In this paper we use a description of the securitization chain in the Netherlands to contest these perceptions. Building on and adding to Thomas Wainwright's analysis of securitization in the UK, we first argue that securitization in the Netherlands has taken a form which reflects Dutch corporatist institutional arrangements, implying that both geography and states do matter for the supposedly aspatial process of securitization. Second, we argue that the Dutch state has been very much implicated in the construction of the securitization market in the Netherlands. Third, we suggest that this can best be seen as an effect of ‘cognitive closure’ rather than of ‘regulatory capture’: that is, Dutch pro-banking regulation is not so much an effect of bankers hijacking regulators but, rather, more the result of bankers seducing regulators with their stories. This paper is a detailed case study of the workings of financialization and adds to the growing body of work which seeks to analyze the different ‘varieties of financialization’ and the variegated geographies of the financial crisis.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AalbersM B, 2008, “The financialization of home and the mortgage market crisis”Competition and Change12148–166.
2.
AalbersM B, 2009a, “Geographies of the financial crisis”Area4134–42.
3.
AalbersM B, 2009b, “The sociology and geography of mortgage markets: Reflections on the financial crisis”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33281–290.
4.
AalbersM B, 2009c, “The globalization and Europeanization of mortgage markets”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33389–410.
5.
AalbersM B, 2011Place, Exclusion and Mortgage Markets (Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford).
6.
AbolafiaM, 1997Making Markets: Opportunism and Restraint on Wall Street (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
7.
AlinkBBrugginkAVan der HarstP, 1998, “Mortgage backed securities: Ontwikkelingen in Nederland”Bank- en Effectenbedrijf (May) 34–37.
8.
AshtonP, 2009, “An appetite for yield: The anatomy of the subprime mortgage crisis”Environment and Planning A411420–1441.
Blundell-WignallAAtkinsonP, 2010, “Thinking beyond Basel III: Necessary solutions for capital and liquidity”OECD Financial Market Trends number 98, 1–23.
11.
BlythM, 2002Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
DardenJ TWylyE, 2010, “Cartographic editorial—mapping the racial/ethnic topography of subprime inequality in urban America”Urban Geography31425–433.
15.
DjelicM-L, 2004, “Social networks and country-to-country transfer. Dense and weak ties in the diffusion of knowledge”Socio-Economic Review2341–370.
16.
DNB, De Nederlandse Bank, Amsterdam1997, “Memorandum inzake securitisatie en toezicht”, Tz-Sbv/1997/1184 2005, “Securitisatie. Consultatiedocument (implementatie Bazel II)”, no. K04A/NL 2008, “‘Verpakken’ van hypotheken door banken scherp teruggevallen”Statistisch Bulletin (June) 15–23.
17.
DymskiG A, 2010, “Confronting the quadruple crisis”Geoforum41837–840.
EngelenEFaulconbridgeJ, 2009, “Introduction: Financial geographies—the credit crisis as an opportunity to catch economic geography's next boat”Journal of Economic Geography9587–595.
20.
EngelenEGroteM H, 2009, “Stock exchange virtualisation and the decline of second-tier financial centres—the cases of Amsterdam and Frankfurt”Journal of Economic Geography9679–696.
21.
EngelenEKoningsM, 2010, “Financial capitalism resurgent: Comparative institutionalism and the challenges of financialization”, in The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Institutional Analysis Eds MorganJCGCrouchCKristensenP HPedersenO KWhitleyR (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 601–624.
22.
EngelenEKoningsMFernandezR, 2010a, “Geographies of financialization in disarray: The Dutch case in comparative perspective”Economic Geography8653–73.
23.
EngelenEErturkIFroudJLeaverAWilliamsK, 2010b, “Reconceptualizing financial innovation: Frame, conjuncture and bricolage”Economy and Society3933–63.
24.
EngelenEErturkIFroudJLeaverAWilliamsK, 2011After the Great Complacence: Financial Crisis and the Politics of Reform (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
25.
FabozziF JModiglianiFJonesF JFerriM G, 2002Foundations of Financial Markets and Institutions (Pearson, Upper Saddle River, NJ).
26.
GortonG, 2010Slapped by the Invisible Hand: The Panic of 2007 (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
27.
GothamK F, 2006, “The secondary circuit of capital reconsidered: Globalization and the US real estate sector”American Journal of Sociology112231–275.
28.
GothamK F, 2009, “Creating liquidity out of spatial fixity: The secondary circuit of capital and the subprime mortgage crisis”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33355–371.
29.
HallPSoskiceD, 2001Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
30.
HamnettC, 1994, “Restructuring housing finance and the housing market”, in Money, Power and Space Eds CorbridgeSThriftNMartinR (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 281–308.
31.
HoK, 2009Liquidated: An Ethnography of Wall Street (Duke University Press, Durham, NC).
32.
HoltonG A, 2003Value at Risk: Theory and Practice (Academic Press, New York).
ImmergluckD, 2009Foreclosed (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
36.
JacksonG, 2010, “Actors and institutions”, in The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Institutional Analysis Eds MorganJCGCrouchCKristensenP HPedersenO KWhitleyR (Oxford University Press, Oxford), pp 63–86.
37.
LaffontJ JTiroleJ, 1991, “The politics of government decision making: A theory of regulatory capture”Quarterly Journal of Economics1061089–1127.
38.
LewisM, 1989Liar's Poker. Two Cities, True Greed (Hodder and Stoughton, New York).
39.
LewisM, 2010The Big Short: Inside the Doomsday Machine (W W Norton, New York).
40.
MacKenzieD, 2006An Engine, not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
MoranM, 1991The Politics of the Financial Services Revolution: The USA, UK and Japan (Macmillan, London).
43.
MorganG, 2008, “Market formation and governance in international financial markets: The case of OTC derivatives”Human Relations61637–660.
44.
MorganG, 2010, “Legitimacy in financial markets: Credit default swaps in the current crisis”Socio-Economic Review81–29.
45.
PosnerEVéronN, 2010, “The EU and financial regulation: Power without purpose”Journal of European Public Policy17400–415.
46.
RosenthalJ AOcampoJ M, 1988Securitization of Credit: Inside the New Technology of Finance (John Wiley, New York).
47.
RouwenhorstK G, 2005, “The origins of mutual funds”, in The Origins of Value: The Financial Innovations that Created Modern Capital Markets Eds GotzmannW NRouwenhorstK G, (Oxford University Press, New York) pp 249–270.
48.
SCP, 2010, “Kopers in de de knel: Een scenariostudie naar de gevolgen van de crisis voor huiseigenaren met een hypotheek”, Sociaal Cultureel Planbureau, Den Haag.
49.
SidawayJ D, 2008, “Subprime crisis: American crisis or human crisis?”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space26195–198.
50.
SinclairT J, 2005The New Masters of Capital: American Bond Rating Agencies and the Politics of Creditworthiness (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
51.
StiglerG, 1971, “The theory of economic regulation”Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science23–21.
52.
TsingouE, 2009, “Regulatory reactions to the global credit crisis: Analyzing a policy community under stress”, in Global Finance in Crisis: The Politics of International Regulatory Change Eds HelleinerEPagliariSZimmermannH (Routledge, London) pp 20–36.
UnderhillGBlomJMüggeD, 2010Global Financial Integration Thirty Years On: From Reform to Crisis (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge).
55.
WainwrightT, 2009, “Laying the foundations for a crisis: Mapping the historico-geographical construction of RMBS securitization in the UK”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33372–388.
56.
WainwrightT, 2010, “‘It's crunch time’: The ‘lost’ geographies of the crisis”Environment and Planning A42780–784.
57.
WesterJ, 2009, “Hoe Den Haag de banken bediende: Onderzoek politiek en kredietcrisis”NRC Handelsblad Magazine 27–28 June, pp 18–22.
58.
WójcikD, 2009, “Geography, stupid! A note on the credit crunch”Environment and Planning A41258–260.
59.
WoodD, 2005Governing Global Banking: The Basel Committee and the Politics of Financial Globalization (Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey).
60.
WylyE KMoosMKabahiziEHammelD, 2009, “Cartographies of race and class: Mapping the class-monopoly rents of American subprime mortgage capital”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33332–354.
61.
ZaloomC, 2006Out of the Pit: Traders and Technology from Chicago to London (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL).
