Heuristic Generation of Layouts (HeGeL): Based on a Paradigm for Problem Structuring

Abstract

Based on protocol analysis of the designers solving spatial problems in architecture, a paradigm for the designers' behavior was proposed in terms of: problem (re)Structuring, when problem parameters are established or transformed, and problem solving, when these parameters are satisfied in a design solution. In order to calibrate and verify the paradigm, a computer-based system called HeGeL (Heuristic Generation of Layouts) was implemented. The development of HeGeL, its architecture and performance are all described. Implemented as a production system, the computer program simulates behavior of the designers observed in the protocol experiments conducted earlier. This paper is intended to serve multiple purposes. First, architecture of HeGeL is described in terms of representations and operations used, and flow of actions. Based on performance of HeGeL, the validity of the proposed paradigm for the designers' behavior and adequacy of the methodology is discussed. Some research issues that need further exploration are also highlighted.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Akin

, 1978, “How do architects design?”, in Artificial Intelligence and Pattern Recognition in Computer-aided Design Ed. Latombe

J-C

(North-Holland, New York) pp 65–104

Akin

, 1986a, “A formalism for problem restructuring and resolution in Design” Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 13 223–232

Akin

, 1986b Psychology of Architectural Design (Pion, London)

Akin

Chen

Dave

Pithavadian

, 1986, “A schematic representation of the designers' logic”, in CAD and Robotics in Architecture and Construction (Kogan Page, London) pp 31–40

Baykan

, 1984, “Heuristic methods for structuring architectural design problems”, unpublished manuscript, Department of Architecture, Carnegie-Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA

Baylor

G W

Jr , 1971 A Treatise on the Mind's-eye: An Empirical Investigation of Visual Mental Imagery PhD dissertation, Department of Psychology, Carnegie-Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA

Eastman

, 1972, “On the analysis of intuitive design processes”, in Emerging Methods in Environmental Design and Planning Ed. Moore

G T

(MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 21–37

Foz

, 1973, “Observations on designer behavior in the parti” DMS-DRS Journal: Design Research and Methods 7 320–323

Freeman

P A

Newell

, 1971, “A model for functional reasoning in design”, in Proceedings of the Second International Joint Computer Conference on Artificial Intelligence (British Computer Society, London) pp 621–640

10.

Moran

T P

, 1972, “A model of a multilingual designer”, in Emerging Methods in Environmental Design and Planning Ed. Moore

G T

(MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 69–78

11.

Reitman

W R

, 1964, “Heuristic decision procedures, open constraints and structure of ill-defined problems”, in Human Judgements and Optimality Eds Shelly

M W

Bryan

G L

(John Wiley, New York) pp 282–315

12.

Simon

, 1973, “Structure of ill structured problems” Artificial Intelligence 4 181–201