The author argues for the increased use of population cartograms to visualize changing geographies and uses British localities as an example. Population cartograms are increasingly being recognized by researchers as a major solution to many spatial visualization problems. The gross misrepresentation of many groups of people on conventional topographic maps has long been seen as a major problem of thematic cartography, highlighting difficulties such as the modifiable areal unit problem in preventing the development of visual palliatives. Population cartograms made up of many thousands of areal units are simple to construct with an appropriate algorithm. The author has designed a particular solution for use in the visualization of high-resolution spatial social structure. The problem now is not of writing more computer programs, but of convincing other researchers of the necessity of using cartograms in place of conventional choropleth maps for showing many population-related distributions. The author shows how our pictures of space can be changed and argues why they should be.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AndersonG C, 1989, “Images worth thousands of bits of data”The Scientist3(3) 1, 16–17.
2.
AngelSHymanG M, 1972, “Transformations and geographic theory”Geographical Analysis4350–367.
3.
BenigerJ R, 1976, “Science's ‘unwritten’ history: The development of quantitative and statistical graphics”, in Abstracts of the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association (American Sociological Association, New York) page 55.
4.
BungeW, 1966, “Theoretical geography”Lund Studies in Geography, Series C11–285.
5.
ChernoffH, 1973, “The use of faces to represent points in k-dimensional space graphically”Journal of the American Statistical Association68361–368.
6.
ChernoffH, 1978, “Graphical representations as a discipline”, in Graphical Representation of Multivariate Data Ed. WangP C C, (Academic Press, New York) pp 1–11.
7.
ChernoffHRizviM H, 1975, “Effect on classification error of random permutations of features in representing multivariate data by faces”Journal of the American Statistical Association70548–554.
8.
CoulsonM R, 1977, “Political truth and the graphic image”The Canadian Cartographer14(2)101–111.
9.
CraigJ, 1976, “1971 census grid squares”Population Trends614–15.
10.
CRU, 1980People in Britain—A Census Atlas Census Research Unit (HMSO, London).
11.
DorlingD, 1991The Visualization of Spatial Social Structure PhD thesis available from the British Library, taken at The Univesity of Newcastle upon Tyne.
12.
DorlingD, 1992a, “Visualizing people in time and space”Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design19613–637.
13.
DorlingD, 1992b, “Stretching space and splicing time: From cartographic animation to interactive visualization”Cartography and Geographic Information Systems19(4) 215–227; 267–270.
14.
DorlingD, 1993a, “From computer cartography to spatial visualization: A new cartogram algorithm”, in Proceedings of the Eleventh International Symposium on Computer Assisted CartographyAmerican Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, and American Congress on Surveying and Mapping, Bethesda, MD, pp 208–217.
15.
DorlingD, 1993b, “Map design for census mapping”The Cartographic Journal30(2) 167–183.
16.
DorlingD, 1994a, “Bringing elections back to life”Geographical Magazaine66(12) 20–21.
17.
DorlingD, 1994b, “The negative equity map of Britain”Area26327–342.
18.
DorlingD, 1995a, “Visualizing changing social structure from a census”Environment and Planning A27353–378.
19.
DorlingD, 1995b, “The changing human geography of Britain”Geography Review8(4) 2–6.
20.
DougenikJ AChrismanN RNiemeyerD R, 1985, “An algorithm to construct continuous area cartograms”Professional Geographer37(1) 75–81.
21.
EastmanJ RNelsonWShieldsG, 1981, “Production considerations in isodensity mapping”Cartographica18(1) 24–30.
22.
FluryBRiedwylH, 1981, “Graphical representation of multivariate data by means of asymmetrical faces”Journal of the American Statistical Association76757–765.
23.
HarleyJ B, 1990, “Cartography, ethics and social theory”Cartographica27(2) 1–27.
24.
HollingsworthT H, 1964, “The political colour of Britain by numbers of voters”The Times 19 October, page 18.
25.
HollingsworthT H, 1966, “The political colour of Britain by winning parties”The Times 4 April, page 8.
26.
LevisonM EHaddonW, 1965, “The area adjusted map: An epidemiological device”Public Health Reports80 (1) 55–59.
27.
OlsonJ M, 1976, “Noncontiguous area cartograms”The Professional Geographer28371–380.
28.
PorterPVoxlandP, 1986, “Distortion in maps: The Peters projection and other devilments”Focus3622–30.
29.
RaiszE, 1934, “The rectangular statistical cartogram”The Geographical Review24292–296.
30.
RaiszE, 1936, “Rectangular statistical cartogram of the world”The Journal of Geography358–10.
31.
RhindD, 1983, “Mapping census data”, in A Census User's Handbook Ed. RhindD, (Methuen, London) pp 171–198.
32.
SelvinSMerrillD WSchulmanJSacksSBedellLWongL, 1988, “Transformations of maps to investigate clusters of disease”Social Science in Medicine26215–221.
33.
SenA K, 1975, “A theorem related to cartograms”American Mathematics Monthly82382–385.
34.
SkodaLRobertsonJ C, 1972, “Isodemographic map of Canada”, Geographical Paper 50, Department of the Environment, Ottawa, Canada.
35.
ToblerW R, 1961Map Transformations of Geographic Space PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University of Washington, Seattle, WA.
36.
ToblerW R, 1963, “Geographic area and map projections”The Geographical Review5359–78.
37.
ToblerW R, 1973, “A continuous transformation useful for districting”Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences219215–220.
38.
ToblerW R, 1976, “Cartograms and cartosplines”, in Proceedings of the Workshop on Automated Cartography and EpidemiologyNational Center for Health Statistics, US Department of Health, Hyattsville, MD, pp 53–58.
39.
ToblerW R, 1985, “Interactive construction of continuous cartograms”, in Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Computer-Assisted Cartography (American Society for Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, Falls Church, VA and American Congress on Surveying and Mapping, Bethesda, MA) page 525.
40.
ToblerW R, 1986, “Pseudo-cartograms”The American Cartographer13(1) 43–50.
41.
TufteE R, 1990Envisioning Information (Graphics Press, Cheshire, CT).
