What is a Neighbourhood? The Structure and Function of an Idea

Abstract

In this paper we use the tension between ideals and reality as a key to comprehend the ever-changing concept of neighbourhood in architecture and planning theory. We analyze the theoretical, that is abstract, meaning of the concept of neighbourhood by using a deconstructive approach in the examination of particular texts. A shift in the sense and meaning of neighbourhood in architecture and planning theory over the years is discerned. A stratified process of transformation in the meaning attached to the neighbourhood is identified in the arguments used to construct this idea in theory and in professional practice. This process proceeds from a humanistic approach, to an instrumental and then to a phenomenological approach. The humanistic approach sees the neighbourhood as a manifestation of human activity and thus the planning of the neighbourhood as a moral requirement which is a proper response to basic human needs. The instrumental approach views the neighbourhood as a planning device, an integral building block in the development of urban structure. As such it conceives of the neighbourhood as a subsystem in a larger assemblage. The phenomenological approach emphasizes the neighbourhood as a unique urban phenomenon. Its significance is seen to stem from its conventional everyday function (residential) which involves continuity and permanence and which fixes the neighbourhood sense of place in the urban collective memory. In our paper these three approaches are related to present architectural and planning attempts to come to terms with both overall general societal developments as well as with specific demands and needs situated in the profession.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

, 1965, “The city is not a tree” Architectural Forum April/May issue, pp 58–61

Alexander

Ishikaura

Silverstein

Jacobson

Fiksdahl-King

Angel

, 1977 Pattern Language: Town, Buildings Construction (Oxford University Press, New York)

Audirac

Sherrmyn

A H

, 1994, “An evaluation of neotraditional design's social prescription: Postmodern placebo or remedy for suburban malaise?” Journal of Planning Education and Research 13 161–173

Banerjee

Baer

W C

, 1984 Beyond the Neighborhood Unit (Plenum Press, New York)

Benevolo

, 1971 The Origins of Modern Town Planning (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

Benevolo

, 1977, History of Modern Architecture first published in Italian in 1960, translated by Landry

H J

from the 1966 edition (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

Benevolo

, 1980 The History of the City translated by Culverwell

(MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

Brower

, 1996 Good Neighborhoods (Praeger, London)

Choay

, 1969 The Modern City: Planning in the 19th Century (George Braziller, New York)

10.

Colquhoun

, 1985, “The superblock”, in Essays in Architectural Criticism: Modern Architecture and Historical Change (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA) pp 83–102

11.

Cooley

C H

, 1909 Social Organization (Scribner, New York)

12.

Dickens

P G

, 1972, “Marxism and architectural theory: A Critique of recent work” Environment and Planning B 6 105–116

13.

Duany

Plater-Zyberg

, 1991 Towns and Town-making Principles (Rizzoli, New York)

14.

Durkheim

, 1972 Selected Writings (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)

15.

Fishman

, 1977 Urban Utopias in the 19th Century (Basic Books, New York)

16.

Goss

, 1961, “Neighborhood unit in British new towns” The Town Planning Review 32 (1) 66–82

17.

Herbert

, 1963, “The neighborhood unit principle and organic theory” The Sociological Review 11 (2) pp 165–213

18.

Issacs

, 1948, “The neighborhood theory” Journal of the American Institute of Planners 14 (2) 15–23

19.

Jacobs

, 1961 The Death and Life of Great American Cities (Vintage Books, New York)

20.

Kallus

, 1991 The Idea of Neighbourhood: A Study in Conceptual Dynamics PhD thesis, Technion, Haifa, Israel (in Hebrew)

21.

Kallus

Law-Yone

, 1997, “Neighbourhood: Metamorphosis of an idea” Journal of Architectural and Planning Research 14 (2) 107–124

22.

Katz

, 1994 The New Urbanism: Toward an Architecture of Community (McGraw-Hill, New York)

23.

Keller

, 1968 The Urban Neighborhood: A Sociological Perspective (Random House, New York)

24.

Krier

, 1978 Rational Architecture: The Reconstruction of the European City Archives d'Architecture Moderne, Bruxelles

25.

Krier

, 1980 Drawings 1967–980 Archives d'Architecture Moderne, Bruxelles

26.

Krier

, 1984, “The city within the city” Architectural Design 54 (7–8) 70–105

27.

Le Corbusier , 1933 The Radiant City (Faber and Faber, London)

28.

Le Corbusier , 1947 Concerning Town Planning (The Architectural Press, London)

29.

Mumford

, 1938, The Culture of Cities (Secker and Warburg, London)

30.

Mumford

, 1944, “Planning for the phases of life” Town Planning Review 20 (1) 5–16

31.

Mumford

, 1954, “The neighborhood and the neighborhood unit” Town Planning Review 24 250–270

32.

Newman

, 1981 Community of Interest (Anchor Books, Garden City, NY)

33.

Park

R E

Burgess

E W

Mckenzie

, 1925 The City (University of Chicago Press, Chicago, IL)

34.

Perry

, 1974, “The neighborhood unit”, in Neighborhood and Community Planning (Arno Press, New York) pp 22–140; first published in 1929

35.

Pevsner

, 1943 An Outline of European Architecture (Penguin Books, London)

36.

Rapoport

, 1977 Human Aspects of Urban Form (Pergamon, New York)

37.

Rossi

, 1984 The Architecture of the City (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

38.

Saunders

, 1981 Social Theory and the Urban Question (Holms and Meier, New York)

39.

Smithson

, 1970, Ordinariness and Light: Urban Theories 1952–1960 and their Application in a Building Project 1963–1970 (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

40.

de Sola-Morales

, 1978, “Towards a definition, analysis of urban growth in nineteenth century” Lotus International number 19, pp 28–36

41.

Tafuri

, 1976 Architecture and Utopia, Design and Capitalist Development (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

42.

Tafuri

Dal-Co

, 1976 Modern Architecture (Electa, Milan)

43.

Till

, 1993, “Neotraditional towns and urban villages: The cultural production of geography of ‘otherness’” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 11 709–732

44.

Tonnies

, 1955 Community and Association (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London)

45.

Warren

R B

Warren

D I

, 1977 The Neighbourhood Organizer Handbook (University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, IN)

46.

Webber

, 1963, “Order in diversity: Community without propinquity”, in Cities and Space: The Future Use of Urban Land Ed. Wingo

(Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD) pp 23–54

47.

Wirth

, 1938, “Urbanism as a way of life” American Journal of Sociology 44 1–24

48.

Wolff

, 1950 The Sociology of Georg Simmel (Free Press, London)