Scenario-based investigations of possible futures have been used since the middle of the 20th century to help decisionmakers cope with alternative courses of action and elements of uncertainty. Since the early 1970s, they have been increasingly used for landscape planning. Each scenario-based study is founded on assumptions of possible change. Often these beliefs are only implicit among scenario creators and scenario users. I discuss the beliefs and perceptions about the future of scenario creators and scenario users, and argue that they should be explicitly addressed before an investigation is undertaken in order to avoid methodological biases in the creation of the scenarios and misunderstanding of the results. As part of this discussion, the basic features of a scenario-based study are reviewed, and applications to landscape and environmental planning are considered, with examples drawn from two studies that were focused on the same concerns and in the same region but which employed different kinds of scenarios.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AckoffR, 1981Creating the Corporate Future: Plan or Be Planned For (John Wiley, New York)
2.
Alberta Environment, Olson+Olson Planning & Design, 2000The Southern Rockies Landscape Planning Pilot Study: Summary ReportIntegrated Resource Management Division, Land and Forest Service, Alberta Environment, Edmonton, Canada
3.
AndrewsK R, 1970The Concept of Corporate Strategy (Dow-Jones Irwin, Homewood, IL)
4.
BellD, 1964, “Twelve modes of prediction—a preliminary sorting of approaches in the social sciences”Dœdalus—Proceedings of the American Academyof Arts and Sciences93, 845–888
5.
BellW, 1997Foundations of Future Studies: Human Science for a New Era, Volume 1—History, Purposes, and Knowledge (Transaction Books, New Brunswick, NJ)
6.
BeresL RTargH R, 1977Constructing Alternative World Futures: Reordering the Planet (Schenkman, Cambridge, MA)
7.
BluetJ-CZémorJ, 1970, “Prospective géographique, méthode et directions de recherche”Metra9(1) 111–127
8.
BurkeK, 1945A Grammar of Motives (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
9.
CarpenterS R, 2002, “Ecological futures: Building an ecology of the long now”Ecology83, 2069–2083
10.
CarsonG, 1978, “How the West was won”Natural History87(9) 84–98
11.
ChatmanS, 1980Story and Discourse: Narrative Structure in Fiction and Film (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY)
12.
ChermackT JLynhamS ARuonaW E A, 2001, “A review of scenario planning literature”Futures Research Quarterly17(2) 7–31
13.
ChristensenN LBartuskaA MBrownJ HCarpenterSD'AntonioCFrancisRFranklinF FMacHahonJ ANossR FParsonsD JPetersonC HTurnerM GWoodmanseeR G, 1996, “The report of The Ecological Society of American Committee on the scientific basis for ecosystem management”Ecological Applications6, 665–691
14.
ClarkD A, 2004, “Sources or sinks? The responses of tropical forests to current and future climate and atmospheric compositions”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London Series B—Biological Sciences359(1443) 477–491
15.
Congressional Research Service, 1994Ecosystem Management and Federal Agencies report 94–339-ENR (Library of Congress, Washington, DC)
16.
CornishE, 2004Futuring: The Exploration of the Future (The World Future Society, Washington, DC)
17.
CostanzaR, 1999, “Four visions of the century ahead: Will it be Star Trek, Ecotopia, Big Government, or Mad Max?”The Futurist33(2) 23–28
18.
CostanzaR, 2000, “Visions of alternative (unpredictable) futures and their use in policy analysis”Conservation Ecology (on-line edition) 4(1) article 5, http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol4/iss1/art5
19.
CournandALévyM (Eds), 1973Shaping the Future: Gaston Berger and the Concept of Prospective (Gordon and Breach, New York)
20.
DavidsdottirBRuthM, 2004, “Capital vintage and climate change policies: The case of US pulp and paper”Environmental Science and Policy7, 221–233
21.
de AraujoJ CDollDGunterAKrollMAbreuC B RHauschildMMendiondoE M, 2004, “Water scarcity under scenarios for global climate change and regional development in semiarid northeastern Brazil”Water International29, 209–220
22.
de JouvenelB, 1967The Art of Conjecture translated by LaryN (Weidenfeld and Nicholson, London) pp 42–43
23.
DownsA, 1968, “Alternative futures for the American ghetto”Dœdalus—Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences97, 1331–1378
24.
DownsA, 1970, “Alternative forms of future urban growth in the United States”Journal of the American Planning Institute36, 3–11
25.
DucotCLubbenG J, 1980, “A typology for scenarios”Futures12, 51–57
26.
ElkingtonJTrisoglioA, 1996, “Developing realistic scenarios for the environment: Lessons from Brent Spar”Long Range Planning29, 762–769
27.
EmeryF ETristE L, 1965, “The causal texture of organizational environments”Human Relations18, 21–32
28.
EmeryF ETristE L, 1973Towards a Social Ecology: Contextual Appreciations of the Future in the Present (Plenum Press, New York)
29.
EveredR, “So what is strategy?”Long Range Planning16(3) 57–72
30.
FaheyLRandallR M, 1998, “What is scenario learning?”, in Learning from the Future: Competitive Foresight Scenarios Eds FaheyLRandallR M (John Wiley, New York) pp 3–21
GregoryW LDuranA, 2001, “Scenarios and acceptance of forecasts”, in Principles of Forecasting: A Handbook for Researchers and Practitioners Ed. ArmstrongJ S (Kluwer Academic, Boston, MA) pp 519–540
33.
HareF K, 1985, “Future environments: Can they be predicted?”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series10, 131–137
34.
HeugensPvan OosterhoutJ, 2001, “To boldly go where no man has gone before: Integrating cognitive and physical features in scenario studies”Futures33, 861–872
35.
HirschhornL, 1980, “Scenario writing: A developmental approach”Journal of the American Planning Association46, 172–182
36.
HugillP J, 1982, “Good roads and the automobile in the United States 1880–1929”Geographical Review72, 327–349
37.
HulseDEilersJFreemarkKHummonCWhiteD, 2000, “Planning alternative future landscapes in Oregon: Evaluating the effects of water quality and biodiversity”Landscape Journal19 (1–2) 1–19
38.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2001Climate Change 2001: Synthesis Report—Summary for PolicymakersIPCC Plenary XVIII, Wembley, http://www.ipcc.ch/pub/un/syreng/spm.pdf
39.
JantschE, 1967Technological Forecasting in Perspective (OECD, Paris)
40.
KahnH, 1966, “On alternative world futures: Issues and themes—draft”, Hudson Institute report HI-525-D/3, The Hudson Institute, Croton-on-Hudson, NY
41.
KahnHMannI, 1956, “Techniques of systems analysis”, RAND report RM-1829, RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA
42.
KahnHWienerA J, 1967The Year 2000: A Framework for Speculation on the Next Thirty Years (Macmillan, New York)
43.
KerrSLiuS GPfaffA S PHughesR F, 2003, “Carbon dynamics and land-use choices: Building a regional-scale multidisciplinary model”Journal of Environmental Management69, 25–37
44.
KleinerA, 1996The Age of Heretics: Heroes, Outlaws, and the Forerunners of Corporate Change (Currency Doubleday, New York)
45.
Landrieu-ZémorJ, 1971, “Une méthode d'analyse prospective—son élaboration dans le cadre d'un scénario tendanciel français”Metra10, 569–626
46.
LempertR JPopperS WBankesS C, 2003, “Shaping the next one hundred years: New methods for quantitative, long-term policy analysis”, RAND report MR-1626 (RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, CA)
47.
Liddell-HartB H, 1965Strategy (Praeger, New York)
48.
MarienM, 1973, “Herman Kahn's things to come”The Futurist7(1) 7–15
49.
MeadowsM E, 2003, “Soil erosion in the Swartland, Western Cape Province, South Africa: Implications of past and present policy and practice”Environmental Science and Policy6(1) 17–28
50.
MichaelD, 1973On Learning to Plan—and Planning to Learn (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, CA)
51.
OzbekhanH, 1977, “The future of Paris: A systems study in strategic urban planning”Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society London, A287, 523–544
52.
RinglandG, 1998Scenario Planning: Managing for the Future (John Wiley, New York)
53.
RobertsC, 1996The Logic of Historical Explanation (Pennsylvania State University Press, University Park, PA)
54.
RobinsonJ, 2003, “Future subjunctive: Backcasting as social learning”Futures35, 839–856
55.
SchwartzP, 1996The Art of the Long View: Paths to Strategic Insight for Yourself and Your Company (Currency-Doubleday, New York); first published 1991
56.
SchwartzPOgilvyJ A, 1998, “Plotting your scenarios”, in Learning from the Future: Competitive Foresight Scenarios Eds FaheyLRandallR M (John Wiley, New York) pp 57–80
ShearerA W, 2005, “Whether the weather: Comments on ‘an abrupt climate change scenario and its implications for United States national security’”Futures37(6) forthcoming
59.
ShearerAMouatDBassettSBinfordMJohnsonCSaarinenJ, 2004Environmental Decisions and Uncertainty; Scenarios for the Region of MCB Camp Pendleton and MCAS Miramar, California (Harvard Graduate School of Design, Cambridge, MA)
60.
SteinitzCRogersP, 1970A Systems Analysis Model of Urban Change: An Experiment in Interdisciplinary Education MIT report 20 (Massachusetts Institute of Education Press, Cambridge, MA)
61.
SteinitzCBinfordMCotePEdwardsTJrErvinSJohnsonCKiesterRMouatDOlsonDShearerATothRWillsR, 1996Biodiversity and Landscape Planning: Alternative Futures for the Region of Camp Pendleton, California (Harvard Graduate School of Design, Cambridge, MA)
62.
StreetP, 1977, “Scenario workshops: A participatory approach to sustainable urban living?”Futures29, 139–158
63.
US Environmental Protection Agency, 1973Working Papers in Alternative Futures and Environmental Quality (Environmental Protection Agency—Environmental Studies Division, Washington, DC)
64.
US Environmental Protection Agency, 1975, “Alternative futures for environmental policy planning: 1975–2000”, EPA report EPA-540/9-75-027, prepared by Stanford Research Institute, Center for the Study of Social Policy, Environmental Protection Agency—Office of Pesticide Programs, Washington, DC
65.
van der HeijdnK, 1996Scenarios: The Art of Strategic Conversation (John Wiley, New York)
66.
van DijkT, 2003, “Scenarios of Central European land fragmentation”Land Use Policy20(2) 149–158
67.
van NottenP W FRotmansJvan AsseltM B ARothmanD S, 2003, “An updated scenario typology”Futures35, 423–443
68.
VennT JMcGavinR LRogersH M, 2003, “Managing woodlands for income maximization in Western Queensland, Australia: Clearing for grazing versus timber production”Forest Ecology and Management185, 291–306
69.
von ReibnitzU, 1987Scenario Techniques translated by RosenthalP A W (McGraw-Hill, New York)
70.
WackP, 1985a, “Scenarios: Uncharted waters ahead”Harvard Business Review63(5) 72–89
71.
WackP, 1985b, “Scenarios: Shooting the rapids”Harvard Business Review63(6) 139–150
72.
WashburnA MJonesT E, 1978, “Anchoring futures in preferences”, in Forecasting in International Relations: Theory Methods, Problems, Prospects Eds ChoucriNRobinsonT W (W H Freeman, San Francisco, CA) pp 95–115
73.
WebsterM, 2003, “Communicating climate change uncertainty to policy-makers and the public”Climatic Change61(1–2) 1–8
