Scenario praxis, critically explored as the theory-informed practice of scenarioing, is proposed as a modality for institutionalising knowing within a systemic governance framework. Framing and institutional considerations associated with a constructivist inquiry-based learning approach that might open capacity for innovation in future scenarioing praxis are outlined to complement and counterbalance positivistoriented evidence-based approaches. Drawing on espoused theoretical and epistemological commitments, background literature, researcher experience, and our framing choices, we describe a heuristic device for use ex post to critically examine accounts of past scenario development, or ex ante to generate scenarios. The heuristic and its process of generation are designed for use in context-sensitive ways suited to the systemic governance of climate change adaptation and similar situations that can be framed as ‘wicked’ or uncertain.
AllanCCurtisA, 2005, “Nipped in the bud: why regional scale adaptive management is not blooming”Environmental Management36414–425
2.
AmundsenHBerglundFWestkogH, 2010, “Overcoming barriers to climate change adaptation—a question of multilevel governance?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy28276–289
BawdenR B, 2010, “The community challenge: the learning response”, in Social Learning Systems and Communities of Practice Ed. BlackmoreC P (Springer, London) pp 39–56
BerkhoutF, 2002, “Technological regimes, path dependency and the environment”Global Environmental Change121–4
8.
BerkhoutFHertonJJordonA, 2002, “Socio-economic futures in climate change impact assessment: using scenarios as ‘learning machines’”Global Environmental Change1283–95
9.
BlackmoreCIsonRJigginsJ, 2007, “Social learning: an alternative policy instrument for managing in the context of Europe's water”Environmental Science and Policy10493–498
10.
BlundenMDandoM (Eds), 1994, “Rethinking public policy making: questioning assumptions, challenging beliefs. Essays in honor of Sir Geoffrey Vickers on his centenary”American Behavioral Scientist383–192
11.
BoxelaarLPaineMBeilinR, 2006, “Community engagement and public administration: of silos, overlays and technologies of government”Australian Journal of Public Administration65113–126
12.
CallonM, 1986, “Some elements of a sociology of translation: domestication of the scallops and the fisherman of St Brieux Bay”, in Power, Action and Belief: A New Sociology of Knowledge Ed. LawJ (Routledge, London) pp 196–229
13.
CarolanM, 2006, “Science, expertise, and the democratization of the decision-making process”Society and Natural Resources19661–668
14.
ChecklandP BPoulterJ, 2006Learning for Action (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex)
15.
CollinsK BIsonR L, 2009, “Living with environmental change: adaptation as social learning”Environmental Policy and Governance19351–357
16.
ColvinJ DBlackmoreC PChimbuyaSCollinsK BDentMGossJIsonR LRoggeroP PSeddaiuG, 2014, “In search of systemic innovation for sustainable development: learning from a decade of inquiry with the SLIM social learning praxis”Research Policy43760–771
17.
CookS D NWagenaarH, 2011, “Navigating the eternally unfolding present: toward an epistemology of practice”The American Review of Public Administration10(5) 1–36
18.
CookS D NYanowD J, 1993, “Culture and organizational learning”Journal of Management Inquiry2373–390
19.
CSIRO, 2006The Heat is On: The Future of Energy in Australia. Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Canberra
20.
DavidsonJLockwoodMCurtisAStratfordEGriffithR, 2006, “Governance principles for regional natural resource management”, report no. 1 of the project ‘Pathways to good practice in regional NRM governance’, University of Tasmania, Hobart
DewulfAGrayBPutnamLLewickiRAartsNBouwenRvan WoerkumC, 2009, “Disentangling approaches to framing in conflict and negotiation research: a meta-paradigmatic perspective”Human Relations62155–193
23.
DochertyIMcKiernanP, 2008, “Scenario planning for the Edinburgh city region”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy26982–997
24.
FrameB, 2008, “‘Wicked’, ‘messy’, and ‘clumsy’: long-term frameworks for sustainability”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy261113–1128
25.
FrameBBrownJ, 2008, “Developing post-normal technologies for sustainability”Ecological Economics65225–241
26.
FuntowiczSRavetzJ, 1992, “Three types of risk assessment and the emergence of post normal science”, in Social Theories of Risk Eds KrimskySGoldingD (Praeger, New York) pp 230–251
27.
GhoshalS, 2005, “Bad management theories are destroying good management”Academy of Management Learning and Education475–91
28.
GidleyJ MFeinJSmithJ-AThomsenDSmithT, 2009, “Participatory futures methods: towards adaptability and resilience in climate-vulnerable communities”Environmental Policy and Governance19427–440
29.
HajerMWagenaarH (Eds), 2003Deliberative Policy Analysis: Understanding Governance in the Network Society (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
30.
HarawayD, 1991, “Situated knowledges: the science question in feminism and the privilege of partial perspective”, in Simians, Cyborgs and Women: The Reinvention of Nature (Routledge, New York) pp 183–202
31.
HeadB W, 2008, “Wicked problems in public policy”Public Policy3101–118
32.
HealyS, 2004, “A ‘post-foundational’ interpretation of risk: risk as ‘performance'”Journal of Risk Research7277–296
33.
HigginsV, 2007, “Performing users: the case of computer-based dairy decision-support system”Science, Technology and Human Values32263–286
34.
HollingC S, 1973, “Resilience and stability of ecological systems”Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics41–23
35.
IngramH, 2008, “Beyond universal remedies for good water governance: a political and contextual approach”, paper presented at the Sixth Biennial Rosenberg Water Policy Forum on ‘Water for food: quantity and quality in a changing world’, Zaragoza, http://rosenberg.ucanr.org/documents/V%20Ingram.pdf
36.
INRA-CIRAD, 2009Agrimonde® Scenarios and Challenges for Feeding the World in 2050: Summary Report December, French National Institute for Agricultural Research and French Agricultural Research Centre for International Development, Paris
37.
IPCC, 2007, “Climate change 2007: synthesis report”, contribution of working groups I, II and III to the fourth assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, Geneva
38.
IsendahlNDewulfABrugnachMFrancoisGMollenkampSPahl-WostlC, 2009, “Assessing framing of uncertainties in water management practice”Water Resources Management233191–3205
39.
IsonR L, 2010Systems Practice: How to Act in a Climate Change World (Springer, London)
40.
IsonR LRölingNWatsonD, 2007, “Challenges to science and society in the sustainable management and use of water: investigating the role of social learning”Environmental Science and Policy10499–511
41.
IsonRGrantABawdenR, 2010, “Scenario praxis for systemic and adaptive governance: a critical review”, working paper presented at Victorian Centre for Climate Change Adaptation Research Scenarios for Climate Adaptation: Critical Perspectives Seminar, University of Melbourne, 11 November, http://piarn.org.au/resource/249
42.
IsonR LCollinsK BColvinJ CJigginsJRoggeroP PSeddaiuGSteyaertPToderiMZanollaC, 2011, “Sustainable catchment managing in a climate changing world: new integrative modalities for connecting policy makers, scientists and other stakeholders”Water Resources Management253977–3992
43.
IsonR LBlackmoreC PIaquintoB, 2012, “Towards systemic and adaptive governance: exploring the revealing and concealing aspects of contemporary social-learning metaphors”Ecological Economics8734–42
KeenMBrownV ADyballR (Eds), 2005Social Learning in Environmental Management: Towards a Sustainable Future (Earthscan, London)
46.
LawJ, 2009, “Actor network theory and material semiotics”, in The New Blackwell Companion to Social Theory Ed. TurnerB S (Blackwell, London) pp 141–158
47.
LeachM, 2008, “Pathways to Sustainability in the forest? Misunderstood dynamics and the negotiation of knowledge, power, and policy”Environment and Planning A401783–1795
48.
LevidowL, 2001, “Precautionary uncertainty: regulating GM crops in Europe”Social Studies of Science31842–874
49.
MaturanaH R, 1988, “Reality: the search for objectivity or the quest for a compelling argument”The Irish Journal of Psychology925–82
50.
MaturanaHPoerksenB, 2004From Being to Doing: The Origins of the Biology of Cognition (Carl-Auer, Heidelberg)
51.
MaturanaHVarelaF J, 1987The Tree of Knowledge (Shambala, London)
52.
MaximLvan der SluijsJ P, 2011, “Quality in environmental science for policy: assessing uncertainty as a component of policy analysis”Environmental Science and Policy14482–492
53.
NorgaardR B, 2008, “Finding hope in the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment”Conservation Biology22862–869
54.
NorthD C, 1990Institutions, Institutional Change and Economic Performance (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
55.
OsberghausDDannenbergAMennelTSturmB, 2010, “The role of the government in adaptation to climate change”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy28834–850
56.
OwensSPettsJBulkeleyH, 2006, “Boundary work: knowledge, policy, and the urban environment”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy24633–643
57.
RaginC C, 2006, “How to lure analytical social science out of the doldrums: some lessons from comparative research”International Sociology21633–646
58.
RavetzJFuntowiczS, 1998, “Commentary of ‘Metatheoretical foundations for post-normal risk'”Journal of Risk Research135–38
59.
RCEP, 2010, “Adapting institutions to climate change: summary report”, Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution, London
60.
ReasonPBradburyH, 2008The Sage Handbook of Action Research: Participative Inquiry and Practice (Sage, London)
61.
ReynoldsMHolwellS (Eds), 2010Systems Approaches to Managing Change: A Practical Guide (Springer, London)
62.
RittelHWebberM, 1973, “Dilemmas in a general theory of planning”Policy Sciences4155–169
63.
RobertsonDWangQ JSosteL, 2007, “Irrigation futures of the Goulburn Broken Catchment: final report—summary”, Department of Primary Industries, Future Farming Systems Research, Tatura
64.
RockströmJSteffenWNooneKPerssonÅChapinF SIIILambinE FLentonT MSchefferMFolkeCSchellnhuberH JNykvistBde WitC AHughesTvan der LeeuwSRodheHSörlinSSnyderP KCostanzaRSvedinUFalkenmarkMKarlbergLCorellR WFabryV JHansenJWalkerBLivermanDRichardsonKCrutzenPFoleyJ A, 2009, “A safe operating space for humanity”Nature461472–475
65.
RussellD BIsonR L, 2005, “The researcher of human systems is both choreographer and chorographer”Systems Research and Behavioural Science22131–138
66.
RussellD BIsonR L, 2007, “The research—development relationship in rural communities: an opportunity for contextual science”, in Agricultural Extension and Rural Development: Breaking out of Knowledge Transfer Traditions Eds IsonR LRussellD (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 10–31
67.
SalibaGWithersG, 2009, “Scenario analysis for strategic thinking”, in A Practical Guide to Evidence for Policy and Decision-making Ed. ArgyrousG (University of New South Wales Press, Sydney) pp 116–136
68.
SchönD A, 1973Beyond the Stable State (W W Norton and Co, New York)
69.
SchönD AReinM, 1994Frame Reflection: Towards the Resolution of Intractable Policy Controversies (Basic Books, New York)
70.
SchulerD, 2008Liberating Voices: A Pattern Language for Communication Revolution. Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Boston, MA
71.
SchwartzP, 1991The Art of the Long View: Planning for the Future in an Uncertain World (Currency-Doubleday, New York)
72.
SeddonJ, 2008Systems Thinking in the Public Sector (Triarchy Press, Axminster, Devon)
73.
SmithsonM, 2008, “Social theories of ignorance”, in Agnotology: The Making and Unmaking of Ignorance Eds ProctorRSchiebingerL L (Stanford University Press, Stanford, CA) pp 209–229
74.
SunsteinC R, 2003, “Beyond the precautionary principle”University of Pennsylvania Law Review1511003–1058
75.
TompkinsEAdgerW NBrownK, 2002, “Institutional networks for inclusive coastal management in Trinidad and Tobago”Environment and Planning A341095–1111
76.
WallisPIsonR L, 2011, “Appreciating institutional complexity in water governance dynamics: a case from the Murray-Darling Basin, Australia”Water Resources Management254081–4097
77.
WengerE, 1998Communities of Practice (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
78.
WisemanJBiggsCRickardsLEdwardsT, 2011Scenarios for Climate Adaptation ReportVictorian Centre for Climate Change Adaptation Research, University of Melbourne, Carlton
