Climate change is a powerful reminder of the interdependencies of the human–nature relationship and the fallacy of the modernist assumption about our ability to tame nature for our exploitation with little or no consequences. However, it is argued that such reflexivity is being subverted by the dominant discourses of climate change which portray: nature as risk, our relation to it in terms of security, and the quest for urban resilience as emergency planning. By construing nature as a threat to rather than an asset for cities, they signify a departure from sustainability discourses. They represent a hark back to a premodern conception of human–nature relations that was centred on what nature does to us rather than what we do to nature. Seeing nature as risk ushers in deep concerns with security. The ‘risk society’ becomes entwined with the security society. This paper examines the political implications of this discursive shift and argues that, as securitisation becomes the hegemonic discourse of our time, the postpolitics of hope, which underpinned sustainability, is giving way to the postpolitics of fear which underlies climate change.
AdgerNTorABrownKHanneS, 2001, “Advancing a political ecology of global environmental discourse”Development and Change32681–715
2.
AradauC, 2009, “Climate emergency: Is securitisation the way forward”, in A Warming World Volume 1 of Course DU311 Earth in Crisis Eds HumphreysDBlowersA (Open University, Milton Keynes, Bucks) pp 165–205
3.
AradauCLobo-GuerreroLVan MunsterR, 2008, “Security, technologies of risk, and the political: Guest Editors' introduction”Security Dialogue39147–154
4.
BaldwinAStanleyA, 2013, “Editorial: Risky nature, natures of risk”Geoforum452–4
5.
BarnetR J, 1980The Lean Years: Politics in the Age of Scarcity (Simon and Schuster, New York)
6.
BarnettJ, 2001, “Security and climate change”, WP 7, Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research, University of East Anglia, Norwich
7.
BarnettJAdgerN, 2007, “Climate change, human security and violent conflict”Political Geography26639–655
8.
BaumanZ, 1998Globalization: The Human Consequences (Polity Press, Cambridge)
9.
BeckU, 1996, “World risk society as a cosmopolitan society? Ecological questions in a framework of manufactured uncertainty”Theory, Culture and Society131–32
10.
BeckU, 2012, “The social and political dynamics of the world at risk: The cosmopolitan challenge”, paper presented at the 26th Annual Congress of the Association of European Schools of Planning, 11–15 July, Ankara, http://www.arber.com.tr/aesop2012.org/index.php/page,113,ulrich_beck
11.
BettiniG, 2013, “Climate barbarians at the gate? A critique of apocalyptic narrative on ‘climate change”’Geoforum4563–72
12.
BlakeW, 1808 [1978] Milton, A Poem (Random House Group, London)
13.
BlowersABoersemaJMartinA, 2009, “Whatever happened to environmental politics?”Town and Country Planning July–August, pages 311–315
14.
BlühdornIWelshI, 2007, “Eco-politics beyond the paradigm of sustainability: A conceptual framework and research agenda”Environmental Politics16185–205
15.
BotkinD B, 1990Discordant Harmonies: A New Ecology for the Twenty-first Century (Oxford University Press, New York)
16.
BowlerP, 1992The Fontana History of The Environmental Sciences (Fontana Press, London)
17.
BoykoffM T, 2008, “The cultural politics of climate change discourse in the UK tabloids”Political Geography27549–569
BulkeleyH, 2010, “Cities and the governing of climate change”Annual Review of Environment and Resources35229–253
20.
CalhounC, 2004, “A world of emergencies: Fear, intervention and the limits of cosmopolitan order”Canadian Review of Sociology4374–395
21.
CarsonR, 1962Silent Spring (Houghton Mifflin, Boston, MA)
22.
CNA Corporation, 2007National Security and the Threat of Climate ChangeAlexandria, VI
23.
CoaffeeJWoodMurakami DRogersP, 2008The Everyday Resilience of the City: How Cities Respond to Terrorism and Disaster (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants)
24.
CrononW, 1995, “The trouble with wilderness, or, getting back to the wrong nature”, in Uncommon Ground: Rethinking the Human Place in Nature Ed. CrononW (W W Norton, New York) pp 69–90
25.
DalbyS, 2008, “Green geopolitics”, in A Companion to Political Geography Eds AgnewJMitchellKToalG (Blackwell, Oxford) pp 440–454
26.
DavisM, 1999aEcology of Fear—Los Angeles and the Imagination of Disaster (Vintage Books, New York)
27.
DavisM, 1999bCity of Quartz: Excavating the Future in Los Angeles (Pimlico, London)
28.
DavisM, 2001Late Victorian Holocausts: El Nino, Famines, and the Making of the Third World (Verso, London)
29.
DavoudiS, 2012a, “Climate risk and security: New meanings of ‘the environment’ in the English planning system”European Planning Studies2049–69
30.
DavoudiS, 2012b, “Resilience: A bridging concept or a dead end?”Planning Theory and Practice13299–307
31.
DavoudiSPorterL, 2012, “The politics of resilience for planning: A cautionary note”Planning Theory and Practice13329–333
32.
DavoudiSBrooksEMehmoodA, 2013, “Evolutionary resilience and strategies for climate adaptation”Planning Practice and Research28307–322
33.
DemerittD, 2001, “The construction of global warming and the politics of science”Annals of the Association of American Geographers91307–337
DryzekJ, 1997The Politics of the Earth (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
36.
EC, 2000, “Science, society and citizen in Europe”, Working Document, SEC (2000)1973 (European Commission, Brussels)
37.
EllawayAMorrisGCurticeJRobertsonCAllardiceGRobertsonR, 2009, “Associations between health and different kinds of environmental incivility: A Scotland wide study”Public Health123708–713
38.
FreemanC, 1973, “Malthus with a computer”, in Thinking About the Future: A Critique of The Limits to Growth Eds ColeH S DFreemanCJahodaMPavittK L R (Chatto and Windus, London) pp 1–10
39.
FünfgeldHMcEvoyD, 2012, “Resilience as a useful concept for climate change planning?”Planning Theory and Practice13324–328
40.
Geoforum2013, “Risky nature, natures of risk”45
41.
GLA, 2010The Draft Climate Change Adaptation Strategy for London: Public Consultation DraftGreater London Authority, London
42.
GrahamS, 2002, “Special collection: Reflections on cities, September 11 and the ‘war on terrorism’—one year on”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research26589–590
43.
GrubbMThompsonKSullivanF, 1983The Earth Summit Agreements: A Guide and Assessment (Earthscan, London)
44.
HajerM AVersteegW, 2011, “Voices of vulnerability: The reconfiguration of policy discourses”, in The Oxford Handbook of Climate Change and Society Eds DryzekJ SNorgaardR BSchlosbergD (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 82–95
45.
HamdouchAZuindeauB, 2010, “Sustainable development 20 years on: Methodological issues, practices and open issues”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management52427–438
46.
HigginsP, 2012, “What will your legacy be?”Resurgence January/February, issue 270, pages 30–33
47.
HodsonMMarvinS, 2009, “Urban ecological security: A new urban paradigm?International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33193–215
HollingC S, 1973, “Resilience and stability of ecological systems”Annual Review of Ecological Systems41–23
50.
HollingC SGundersonL H, 2002, “Resilience and adaptive cycles”, in Panarchy: Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems Eds GundersonL HHollingC S (Island Press, Washington, DC) pp 25–62
51.
HulmeM, 2007, “Newspaper scare headlines can be counter-productive”Nature445(7130) 818
52.
International Journal of Urban and Regional Research2002, “Debates and developments special collection”26(3)
53.
JamesonF, 1991Postmodernism, or the Cultural Logic of Late Capitalism (Duke University Press, Durham, NC)
54.
JayM, 1994, “The apocalyptic imagination and the inability to mourn”, in Rethinking Imagination: Culture and Creativity Eds RobinsonGRundellJ (Routledge, New York) pp 30–47
55.
LashSWynneB, 1994, “Introduction”, in Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity Ed. BeckU (Sage, London) pp 1–8
56.
LatourB, 2004Politics of Nature: How to Bring the Sciences into Democracy (Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA)
57.
LuhmannN, 1991Soziologie des Risikos (de Gruyter, Berlin)
58.
LukeT W, 1997, “The (un)wise (ab)use of nature: Environmentalism as globalized consumerism?”, paper presented at the annual meeting of the International Studies Association, 18–22 March, http://www.cddc.vt.edu/tim/tims/Tim528.htm
59.
LukeT W, 1999Placing Ecocritique in Context: Technology, Democracy and Capitalism as Environment, http://www.vtonline.vt.edu/tim
60.
McKibbenR, 1989The End of Nature (Random House, New York)
61.
ManzoK, 2010, “Imaging vulnerability: The iconography of climate change”Area4296–107
62.
MarshallP, 1994Nature's Web, Rethinking our Place on Earth (Paragon House, New York)
63.
MEA, 2005Ecosystems and Human Well-being: Synthesis Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (Island Press, Washington, DC)
64.
MeadowsDRandersJBehrensW, 1972The Limits to Growth: A Report for the Club of Rome's Project on the Predicament of Mankind (Pan, London)
65.
MeyerHNillesenLoes AZonneveldW, 2012, “Rotterdam: A city and a mainport on the edge of a delta”European Planning Studies2071–94
66.
MillerC A, 2004, “Climate science and the making of a global political order”, in States of Knowledge Ed. JasanoffS (Routledge, London) pp 46–66
67.
MillerP, 2008, “Calculating economic life”Journal of Cultural Economy151–64
68.
MouffeC, 2005On the Political (Routledge, London)
69.
NewbyH, 1990, “Ecology, amenity and society: Social science and environmental change”Town Planning Review613–31
70.
NordåsRGleditschN, 2007, “Climate change and conflict”Political Geography26627–638
71.
O'BrienGO'KeefePRoseJWisnerB, 2006, “Climate change and disaster management”Disasters3064–80
72.
OelsA, 2013, “Rendering climate change governance by risk: From probability to contingency”Geoforum4517–29
73.
PattbergP, 2012, “How climate change became a business risk: Analyzing nonstate agency in global climate politics”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy30613–626
74.
PidgeonNButlerC, 2009, “Risk analysis and climate change”Environmental Politics18670–688
75.
RifkinJ, 1983Algeny: A New World—A New World (Viking Press, New York)
76.
SassenS, 2011, “Against all odds: The urbanizing of human security?”, in Bottom Politics: An Agency-centred Approach to Globalisation (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 2016–2226
77.
SchipperLPellingM, 2006, “Disaster risk, climate change and international development: Scope for, and challenges to, integration”Disasters3019–38
78.
SiedmanSAlexanderJ C, 2001, “Introduction”, in The New Social Theory Reader Eds SiedmanSAlexanderJ C (Routledge, London) pp 1–26
79.
SmilV, 1997, “China's environment and security: Simple myths and complex realities”SAIS Review17107–126
80.
SpitzerS, 1987, “Security and control in capitalist societies: The fetishism of security and the secret thereof, in Transcarceration: Essays in the Sociology of Social Control Eds LowmanJMenziesR JPlaysT S (Gower, Aldershot, Hants) pp 43–58
81.
SwyngedouwE, 2009, “The antinomies of the postpolitical city: In search of a democratic politics of environmental production”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research33601–620
82.
SwyngedouwE, 2010, “Apocalypse forever? Post-political pluralism and the spectre of climate change”Theory, Culture and Society27213–232
UN GA, 2009Climate Change and its Possible Security Implications: Report of the Secretary General A/64/350, United Nations General Assembly, United Nations, New York
86.
UNSC, 2011, “Minutes of 6587th meeting”, 20 July, S/PV 5663, United Nations Security Council, New York
87.
WarnerK, 2012, “Human migration and displacement in the context of adaptation to climate change: The Cancun Adaptation Framework and potential for future action”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy301061–1077
88.
WBGU, 2000World in Transition: Strategies for Managing Global Environmental Risks, Annual Report 1998 German Advisory Council on Global Change (Springer, Berlin)
89.
WCED, 1987Our Common Future World Commission on Environment and Development (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
90.
WhatmoreS, 2008, “Remaking environments: Histories, practices, policies”Environment and Planning A401777–1778
91.
WilliamsR, 1972, “Ideas of nature”, in Ecology, the Shaping Enquiry Ed. BenthallJ (Longman, London) pp 147–161
92.
WilsonT, 1983, “Global climate, world politics and national security”, in World Climate Change: The Role of International Law and Institutions Ed. NandaV (Westview Press, Boulder, CO) pp 71–77
