Fish consumption advisories (FCAs), or voluntary state recommendations for foraging and consuming fish from compromised waters, place the onus of negotiating contaminated environments squarely upon individuals who consume local fish. As a result, peoples who eat fish caught from local waters for reasons of food insecurity, cultural practice, or religious practice are ignored, producing environmental inequalities. This paper examines the political history of FCAs in a specific geographical context, New York State, in order to assess the explicit environmental governance frameworks through which these inequalities are generated. It demonstrates that FCA policy is principally an outgrowth of a conservation movement geared towards support for recreational anglers and not those who fish for subsistence. However, conservationism is not the only governance framework at work, as this paper also demonstrates that commercialized processes of neoliberal environmental governance substantially mediate scientific data that inform FCA recommendations. In this way this study illustrates how multiple frameworks—conservationist, neoliberal, or other—can, and often do, intertwine to construct environmental policies.
BakkerK, 2005, “Neoliberalizing nature? Market environmentalism in water supply in England and Wales”Annals of the Association of American Geographers95542–565.
2.
BakkerK, 2009, “Neoliberal nature, ecological fixes, and the pitfalls of comparative research”Environment and Planning A411781–1787.
3.
BakkerK, 2010, “The limits of ‘neoliberal natures’: Debating green neoliberalism”Progress in Human Geography34715–735.
4.
BarnettH JMorseM, 1963Scarcity and Growth: The Economics of Natural Resource Availability (Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, MD).
5.
BeehlerG PMcGuinnessB MVenaJ E, 2001, “Polluted fish, sources of knowledge, and the perception of risk: Contextualizing African American anglers' sport fishing”Human Organization60288–297.
6.
BeehlerG PMcGuinnessB MVenaJ E, 2003, “Characterizing Latino anglers' environmental risk perceptions, sport fish consumption, and advisory awareness”Medical Anthropology Quarterly1799–116.
7.
BogueM B, 2000Fishing the Great Lakes: An Environmental History 1783–1933 (University of Wisconsin Press, Madison, WI).
8.
BrulleR J, 2000Agency, Democracy, and Nature: The U.S. Environmental Movement from a Critical Theory Perspective (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA).
9.
BurgerJ, 2000, “Consumption advisories and compliance: The fishing public and the deamplification of risk”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management43471–488.
10.
CastreeN, 2008, “Neoliberalising nature: The logics of deregulation and reregulation”Environment and Planning A40131–152.
11.
CastreeN, 2011, “Neoliberalism and the biophysical environment 3: Putting theory into practice”Geography Compass535–49.
12.
ChessCBurgerJMcDermottM H, 2005, “Speaking like a state: Environmental justice and fish consumption advisories”Society and Natural Resources18267–278.
13.
ColtonC E, 1990, “Historical hazards: The geography of relict industrial wastes”Professional Geographer42143–156.
14.
ConnellyN AKnuthB A, 1998, “Evaluating risk communication: Examining target audience perceptions about four presentation formats for fish consumption health advisory information”Risk Analysis18649–659.
15.
ConnellyN ABrownT LKnuthB A, 1988, “New York statewide angler survey 1988”, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, New York.
16.
ConnellyN ABrownT LKnuthB A, 1996, “New York statewide angler survey, 1996”New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, New York.
17.
CrononW, 1991Nature's Metropolis: Chicago and the Great West (WW Norton, New York).
18.
DEC, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, New York.
19.
DEC1973, “The 1973 New York statewide angler survey”.
20.
DEC1985, “Final environmental impact statement for contaminants in fish for NYS”.
21.
DEC2009, “New York State freshwater angler survey general summary: Report 1”.
22.
DEC, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, New York 2013, “Division of Fish, Wildlife and Marine Resources”, http://www.dec.ny.gov/about/634.html.
23.
DOH, 2012, “2012–2013 Health advice on eating sportfish and game”, Department of Health, New York.
24.
DuttaS KMitraP AGhoshSZangSSonnebornDHertz-PicciottoITrnovecTPalkovicovaLSovcikovaEGhimbovschiSHoffmanE P, 2012, “Differential gene expression and a functional analysis of PCB-exposed children: Understanding disease and disorder development”Environment International40143–154.
25.
ElliottJ RFrickelS, 2013, “The historical nature of cities: A study of urbanization and hazardous waste accumulation”American Sociological Review78521–543.
26.
EmeryM RPierceA R, 2005, “Interrupting the telos: Locating subsistence in contemporary US forests”Environment and Planning A37981–993.
EPA2002National Environmental Justice Advisory Council Report: Fish Consumption And Environmental Justice.
29.
EPA2004Report to Congress: Impacts and Controls of CSOs and SSOs.
30.
EPA2012“EPA orders Buffalo sewer authority to reduce water pollution in Niagara River: Four billion gallons of sewage and wastewater pollutes Niagara River and tributaries every year”.
31.
EPA Region 2 in conjunction with DEC Region 9, 2012Annual Status Update For: Reduction of Toxics Loadings to The Niagara River From Hazardous Waste Sites in the United States. Report for the Year Ending 2011US Environmental Protection Agency Region 2, Washington, DC, in conjunction with the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation-Region 9, New York.
FaroonOJonesDde RosaC, 2000, “Effects of polychlorinated biphenyls on the nervous system”Toxicology and Industrial Health16(7–8) 305–333.
34.
FitzgeraldE FBrixK ADeresDHwangD ABushBLambartGTarbellA, 1996, “Polychlorinated biphenyl (PCB) and dichlorodiphenyl dichloroethylene (DDE) exposure among Native American men from contaminated great lakes fish and wildlife”Toxicology and Industrial Health3361–368.
35.
HabronGBarbierMKinnunenR, 2008, “Local understanding of fish consumption advisory risks in Michigan's upper peninsula: The role of structure, culture, and agency”Rural Sociology73275–299.
36.
HaysS P, 1959Conservation and the Gospel of Efficiency: The Progressive Conservation Movement, 1890–1920 (Harvard, Cambridge, MA).
37.
Imm P, Knobeloch L, Anderson H A, The Great Lakes Sport Fish Consortium, 2005, “Fish consumption and advisory awareness in the Great Lakes Basin”Environmental Health Perspectives1131325–1329.
38.
JardinC G, 2003, “Development of a public participation and communication protocol for establishing fish consumption advisories”Risk Analysis23461–471.
39.
KarmausWZhuX, 2004, “Maternal concentration of polychlorinated biphenyls and dichlorodiphenyl dichlorethylene and birth weight in Michigan fish eaters: A cohort study”Environmental Health3(1) DOI: 10.1186/1476-069x-3-1.
40.
KnobelochLTurykMImmPSchrankCAndersonH, 2009, “Temporal changes in PCB and DDE levels among a cohort of frequent and infrequent consumers of Great Lakes sportfish”Environmental Research10966–72.
41.
KretserW AKlattL E, 1981, “1976–1977 New York angler survey final report”, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Bureau of Fisheries, New York.
42.
LauberB TConnolyN AKnuthB ANiderdeppeJ, 2011, “Assessment of the Great Lakes states' fish consumption advisory programs”, Human Dimensions Research Unit series No. 11–7, Department of Natural Resources, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
43.
McAfeeKShapiroE, 2010, “Payments for ecosystem services in Mexico: Nature, neoliberalism, social movements, and the state”Annals of the Association of American Geographers100579–599.
44.
McCarthyLPrudhamS, 2004, “Neoliberal nature and the nature of neoliberalism”Geoforum35275–283.
45.
McElweeP, 2012, “Payments for environmental services as neoliberal market-based forest conservation in Vietnam: Panacea or problem?”Geoforum43412–426.
46.
MansfieldB, 2004, “Rules of privatization: Contradictions in neoliberal regulation of North Pacific fisheries”Annals of the Association of American Geographers94565–584.
47.
MansfieldB, 2012a, “Gendered biopolitics of public health: Regulation and discipline in seafood consumption advisories”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space30588–602.
48.
MansfieldB, 2012b, “Environmental health as biosecurity: ‘seafood choices’, risk, and the pregnant woman as threshold”Annals of the Association of American Geographers102969–976.
49.
MansfieldB, 2012c, “Race and the new epigenetic biopolitics of environmental health”BioSocieties7352–372.
50.
MasseyD SDentonN A, 1993American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass (Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA).
51.
NashR, 1967Wilderness and the American Mind (Yale University Press, New Haven, CT).
52.
NordenstamB JDarkwaS, 2010, “Fish consumption and environmental justice in the Great Lakes: The influence of fish advisories on risk perception, knowledge, and behavior of white and minority anglers”, in Environment and Social Justice: An International Perspective Ed. TaylorD, (Emerald Group, Bingley, W Yorks) pp 211–238.
53.
O'NeillC, 2000, “Variable justice: Environmental standards, contaminated fish, and ‘acceptable’ risk to Native Peoples”Stanford Environmental Law Journal19(1), http://ssm.corn/abstract=2263492.
54.
PeckJ, 2002, “Geography and public policy: Constructions of neoliberalism”Progress in Human Geography28392–405.
RockströmJSteffenWNooneKPerssonÅChapinF SIIILambinELentonT MSchefferM, 2009, “Planetary boundaries: Exploring the safe operating space for humanity”Ecology and Society14(2) 32, http://www.ecology and society.org/vol14/issz/art32.
57.
RothR JDresslerW, 2012, “Market-oriented conservation governance: The particularities of place”Geoforum43363–366.
58.
RudelT KRobbertsJ TCarminJ, 2011, “Political economy of the environment”Annual Review of Sociology37221–238.
59.
SchantzS LGardinerJ CAguiarATangXGasiorD MSweeneyA MPeckJ DGillardDKostyniakP J, 2010, “Contaminant profiles in southeast Asian immigrants consuming fish from polluted waters in Northeastern Wisconsin”Environmental Research11033–39.
60.
SchererA CTruchiyaAYoungloveL RBurbacherT MFaustmanE M, 2008, “Comparative analysis of state fish consumption advisories targeting sensitive populations”Environmental Health Perspectives1161598–1606.
61.
SilverEKaslowJLeeDLeeSLynnT MUjiharaA, 2007, “Fish consumption and advisory awareness among low-income women in California's Sacramento–San Joaquin Delta”Environmental Research104410–419.
62.
SteenportD MAndersonH AHanrahanL PFalkCDraheimL AKanerekM SNehls-LoweH, 2000, “Fish consumption habits and advisory awareness among Fox River anglers”Wisconsin Medical Journal November 43–46.
63.
StewartP, 1999, “Assessment of prenatal exposure to PCBs from maternal consumption of Great Lakes fish: An analysis of PCB pattern and concentration”Environmental Research8087–96.
64.
StradlingD, 2010The Nature of New York: An Environmental History of the Empire State (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY).
65.
SwyngedouwEHeynenN, 2003, “Urban political ecology, justice and the politics of scale”Antipode35898–918.
66.
TaylorD, 2002, “Race, class, gender and environmentalism”, United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Seattle, WA.
67.
WellockT R, 2007Preserving the Nation: The Conservation and Environmental Movements 1870–2000 (Harlan Davidson, Wheeling, IL).
68.
WestphalL MLongoniMLeBlancC LWaliA, 2008, “Anglers' apprasials of the risks of eating sport-caught fish from industrial areas: Lessons from Chicago's Calumet region”Human Ecology Review1546–62.
69.
WyantW, 1982Westward in Eden: The Public Lands and the Conservation Movement (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA).
