Abstract
Objective:
Benzodiazepines are common therapies for mental illness and insomnia, and are used during pregnancy and lactation. Although benzodiazepines have been shown to be transferred into breast milk, the amount transferred is small and compatible with breastfeeding. However, information is not available for all drugs. Therefore, we aimed to determine the milk to plasma (M/P) ratio and relative infant dose (RID), which are used as indicators of drug transfer to breast milk, to determine the safety of such drugs for lactating women and breastfeeding infants.
Methods:
The study comprised of 11 pregnant women who visited the obstetrics department of Hokkaido University Hospital (approval number: 017–0131) and Tenshi Hospital (approval number: 103) for childbirth. The samples were analyzed using liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry, and the M/P ratio and RID were calculated. The condition of the mother and baby at 1 month after delivery was determined from the clinical information. The target benzodiazepines were alprazolam, brotizolam, clonazepam, clotiazepam, etizolam, ethyl loflazepate, flunitrazepam, and lorazepam.
Results:
For all drugs, the M/P ratios were <1 and remained constant over time. For drugs other than ethyl loflazepate, the RID values were <10%, which are considered safe; however, even with ethyl loflazepate, it was only slightly >10%. No abnormalities were found in breastfeeding infants whose mothers were receiving these medications.
Conclusions:
The RID results of this study suggest that drug exposure through breast milk is small; thus, maternal drug treatment and breastfeeding are compatible.
Introduction
Mental health care for perinatal women has emerged as an important area of research. Depression is one of the most common complications during the perinatal period1,2; panic disorder and anxiety are also common.3,4 Anxiety and stress during pregnancy may have various adverse effects, including morphological abnormalities of the baby, impaired fetal development, complications of labor, and altered mental development of the newborn.5–10 Therefore, drug therapies are considered necessary for anxiety symptoms that occur or worsen during pregnancy; however, it is necessary to examine the risk of congenital abnormalities, perinatal complications, and side effects.11–13 In addition, most patients with postpartum depression and anxiety experienced depression and anxiety during pregnancy, respectively, 14 suggesting that continued drug therapy may be necessary after birth. Maternal depression causes a decrease in infant milk intake.15,16
On the contrary, the benefits of breastfeeding to the mother and the infant are well established. 17 The benefits for the mother are the reduction of physical damage, such as the promotion of uterine involution and the lengthening of the birth interval. Long-term breastfeeding has also been reported to reduce the risk of developing several diseases, including breast cancer, ovarian cancer, and metabolic diseases. 18 The benefit to infants is that breast milk is a source of nutrition and immunity that will prevent future illness19–21 ; furthermore, improved neurological prognosis has been reported.20,21 Valproic acid use by the mother was reported to lower the intelligence quotient of the offspring; however, this decrease was smaller in infants fed breast milk. 22 Given these benefits, breastfeeding should be recommended, except in special cases in which breastfeeding is contraindicated. However, the available information on the compatibility between drug use and breastfeeding is insufficient. Hence, it is not uncommon for people to give up breastfeeding.
Benzodiazepines are often prescribed for anxiety symptoms in pregnant women.23,24 Drugs used during pregnancy are likely to continue to be needed during lactation. Several benzodiazepines, namely alprazolam, clonazepam, diazepam, and lorazepam, are reported to be transferred to breast milk. Recently, the relative infant dose (RID) has been used as a parameter to indicate drug migration to infants through breast milk. The RID is calculated by dividing the infant's dose through breast milk in “mg/kg/day” by the maternal dose in “mg/kg/day” multiplied by 100. If this value is <10%, it is considered unlikely to have a clinical effect on the infant. 25 In a study of eight lactating women who took a single dose of 0.5 mg alprazolam, 26 the milk to plasma (M/P) ratio was 0.36 and the RID was 3%. Based on the reported data, Hale calculated the RID of 8.5% as a corrected value using an average maternal weight of 70 kg and an average infant feeding volume of 150 mL/kg/day. 25 One study reported an M/P ratio for clonazepam of 0.33. 27 The RID was reported to be 2.5% after the oral administration of clonazepam 2 mg, 28 and Hale estimated it to be 2.8%. 25 After administration of a high dose (80 mg) of diazepam, the M/P ratio was 0.2, and the RID was 4.7%. 29 Calculations based on the previous report by Hale showed that the M/P ratio was 0.2–2.7 and the RID was 0.88–7.14%. 25 For lorazepam, the M/P ratio was reported to be 0.15–0.26, based on data from four patients who received 3.5 mg. 30 After the administration of 2.5 mg twice daily, it was reported that the concentration in breast milk was 12 μg/L; consequently, the RID was estimated to be 2.6–2.9%.25,31
Benzodiazepines and central nervous system (CNS)-acting drugs taken by mothers do not appear to pose a significant risk of direct adverse effects on breastfeeding infants.32,33 However, neonates are more susceptible to the effects of CNS depressants; thus, these drugs should be taken with caution. 34 Therefore, information and evaluation of individual drugs, rather than analogies based on similar drugs, are necessary. The purpose of this study was to calculate the M/P ratio and RID in eight benzodiazepines, and to establish if mothers taking these drugs can safely breastfeed.
Methods
Ethics
The study subjects were pregnant women who were visiting or were admitted to the Obstetrics Department of Hokkaido University Hospital and Tenshi Hospital, and met the following conditions: (1) ≥20 years of age at the time of obtaining consent; (2) were taking benzodiazepines before delivery; and (3) after receiving sufficient explanation of the study and understanding the study, freely gave their consent to participate. This study was approved by the Hokkaido University Hospital Clinical Research Ethics Committee (approval number: 017-0131) and Tenshi Hospital Ethics Committee (approval number: 103).
Sample collection
Maternal blood samples and breast milk samples were collected 3–6 days after delivery, at the time when the plasma concentration peaked and before the drug administration, and at any time during the 1-month postexamination screening. According to the package insert information, the time of the peak plasma concentration was 2 hours for alprazolam, 1–1.5 hours for brotizolam, 2 hours for clonazepam, 1 hour for clotiazepam, 1 hour for etizolam, 1 hour for ethyl loflazepate, 2 hours for lorazepam, and 2 hours for flunitrazepam. Breast milk samples were manually collected from one breast with the help of a nurse. The plasma samples were centrifuged at 2,300 g for 10 minutes at 15°C; the isolated plasma and breast milk were stored frozen at −30°C until analysis.
Quantification of benzodiazepines in breast milk and plasma
The concentration of benzodiazepines in breast milk and plasma was quantified using liquid chromatography-electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), as previously described. 35 In brief, sample preparation was performed by liquid–liquid extraction with ethyl acetate. The benzodiazepines were separated on a C18 column using a gradient elution of acetonitrile in aqueous ammonium acetate solution and were detected in the positive ion electrospray mode with multiple reaction monitoring. As ethyl loflazepate is immediately and completely metabolized to an unstable metabolite after intestinal absorption, 36 we measured the ethyl loflazepate metabolite, CM7116, in this study. The lower limit of quantification (LLOQ) in breast milk was 0.25 ng/mL for alprazolam, brotizolam, clotiazepam, flunitrazepam, and CM7116 and 0.5 ng/mL for clonazepam, etizolam, and lorazepam. The LLOQ in plasma was 0.25 ng/mL for brotizolam; 0.5 ng/mL for alprazolam, clonazepam, clotiazepam, etizolam, flunitrazepam, and lorazepam; and 1.0 ng/mL for CM7116.
Analysis of breast milk concentration
The M/P ratio was calculated by dividing the total breast milk concentration by the total plasma concentration.
RI was calculated from the following formula:
Infant intake of breast milk (mL/kg/day) is the theoretical value (150 mL/kg/day), and the measured value is [single breast milk intake (mL) × number of nursing episodes per day/infant weight (kg)].
Estimation of maternal mental condition
Maternal mental status was evaluated from the medical records. We used the results of drug administration, childcare/lactation, nursing records, psychiatric evaluations immediately after delivery and 1 month after delivery, and the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale at 1 month after delivery.
Results
The concentration of eight benzodiazepines in breast milk was measured in 11 patients. The patients' demographics are shown in Table 1. The median age was 34 years (range: 31–36), and the complications included panic disorder, anxiety, depression, dissociative disorder, and personality disorder. In seven patients (64%), this was their first delivery. Vaginal delivery occurred in five patients and six patients underwent cesarean section. The median gestation period was 39 weeks 2 days (38 weeks 1 day–40 weeks 0 days). Preterm birth occurred in one patient.
Maternal Characteristics
IQR, interquartile range.
Plasma and breast milk were collected 3–6 days after delivery, before drug administration and at the time of peak plasma concentration after administration, and at any time during the 1-month checkup.
The drug concentrations, M/P ratios, and RIDs determined for plasma and breast milk collected 3–6 days after delivery are shown in Table 2. For lorazepam and brotizolam, the trough concentration in milk was below the LLOQ. For other drugs, the concentration was within the measurable range. The calculated M/P ratios at peak concentrations were 0.35–0.49 for alprazolam, 0.12 for brotizolam, 0.40 for clonazepam, 0.15 for clotiazepam, 0.17 for etizolam, 0.11–0.13 for ethyl loflazepate, 0.47–0.85 for flunitrazepam, and 0.21–0.26 for lorazepam. At the trough concentrations, the M/P ratios were 0.35–0.52 for alprazolam, 0.37 for clonazepam, 0.21 for etizolam, 0.10–0.17 for ethyl loflazepate, 0.49–0.89 for flunitrazepam, and 0.17 for lorazepam; M/P ratios were not calculable for brotizolam and clotiazepam. The drug concentration in breast milk was lower than that in plasma, and the peak and trough values were similar.
Plasma and Breast Milk Concentrations of Benzodiazepines, Milk to Plasma Ratio, and Relative Infant Dose (Time After Delivery: 3–6 Days)
These data are from reference [35].
Four hours after intake.
Compared with the mass CM7116/ethyl loflazepate = 0.922.
LLOQ, lower limit of quantification; M/P, milk to plasma; RID, relative infant dose.
For all drugs, the RID calculated from the measured value was smaller than the RID calculated from the theoretical value. The calculated RID (theoretical amount) was 3.8–9.3% for alprazolam, 2.1–4.4% for lorazepam, 2.3% for brotizolam, 4.6% for clonazepam, 2.5% for clotiazepam, 0.6% for etizolam, and 1.6–2.5% for flunitrazepam; these were <10%, which is considered to be safe. The RID of the ethyl loflazepate metabolite CM7116 (molecular weight: 288.7 g/mol) was 11.9% and 11.4%, and when converted from the mass ratio to ethyl loflazepate weight (molecular weight: 360.8 g/mol), it was 12.9% and 12.4%, respectively; hence, these values were slightly >10%.
M/P ratio and RID of each of the drugs at the 1-month checkup are shown in Table 3. M/P ratio for brotizolam, the value 3 days after delivery, was 0.12, which was different from the value at the 1-month checkup (0.59). Alprazolam, lorazepam, flunitrazepam, and the ethyl loflazepate metabolite CM7116 were not very different at the 1-month checkup compared with the values at 3–6 days after delivery.
Plasma and Breast Milk Concentrations of Benzodiazepines, Milk to Plasma Ratio, and Relative Infant Dose (Time After Delivery: 1 Month)
These data are from reference [35].
The changes in breastfeeding status and maternal mental status from 3 to 6 days after delivery at the1-month checkup are shown in Table 4. Some studies suggest that symptoms of postpartum depression and anxiety tend to reduce the period of breastfeeding. Therefore, we investigated the mental conditions of the mother from the medical records in addition to breastfeeding status. There was an increase in drug dosage in two patients. There was one patient for whom the dose was reduced. Drug dosage was unchanged in eight patients. Four of the 11 patients had stopped breastfeeding by the time of the 1-month checkup, for the following reasons: neonatal death (one patient); insufficient milk production and deterioration of mental symptoms (one patient); a desire to switch to formula milk from breast milk because of maternal fatigue (two patients). Some of the infants had mild postnatal withdrawal symptoms, but there were no side effects of the drug through breast milk. No children were found to have any abnormalities at the 1-month checkup. There were no issues with weight gain (average 34.3 [22.4–46.9] g/day; data not shown).
Changes in Breastfeeding Status and Maternal Mental Status
Neonatal death.
Discussion
Benzodiazepines are used for the treatment of anxiety symptoms and insomnia, and can even be used during pregnancy.23,24 In many cases, drugs used during pregnancy continue to be required even after delivery. Given the recent public health messaging surrounding the importance of breastfeeding, information about drug transfer to breast milk is needed. Some studies have analyzed the transfer of benzodiazepines to breast milk.25–31 However, among benzodiazepines, the M/P ratio and RID parameters have been reported only for some drugs, and values for other drugs were inferred from these data. Therefore, we tried to calculate these parameters for benzodiazepines that may be used by lactating women.
The previously reported alprazolam M/P ratio was 0.36 and RID was 3–8.5%.25,26 For the two cases in this study, values were almost the same as those previously reported. The previously reported M/P ratio for lorazepam was 0.15–0.26, and the RID was 2.6–2.9%.25,30,31 The three cases in this study had similar M/P ratios; the RID was slightly higher in one case but the same as previously reported in the other two cases. These results suggested the validity of this measurement system.
The M/P ratios of all eight benzodiazepines were below one, which suggested no enrichment in breast milk. In addition, it has been reported that the time-dependent changes in plasma concentration and breast milk concentration differ depending on the fat solubility of the drug, and that these concentrations alter in parallel for highly lipophilic drugs. 37 The product information indicates that benzodiazepines are highly lipophilic. In a case report describing the plasma and breast milk concentrations of alprazolam over time, parallel changes in concentration were observed. 26 In this study, the peak and trough M/P ratios of each drug were almost the same, suggesting that plasma and breast milk concentrations were in parallel. This result was clinically significant, because it showed that it was possible to estimate the concentration in human milk from the plasma concentration at any time after taking it, even if the concentration in breast milk could not be directly measured.
However, in this study, the M/P ratio was calculated using a single point because of the burden of blood collection on the mother and the ethical considerations of exploiting breast milk to feed the child. The M/P ratio should be expressed as the area under the concentration–time curve (AUC) ratio or the average concentration ratio of breast milk and maternal plasma concentrations sampled over time. Based on previous studies and the results of this study, it is suggested that breast milk and plasma concentrations move in parallel for benzodiazepines. Therefore, the calculated M/P ratio should not result in a significant error; however, this is a limitation of this study, and further studies are needed in the future.
In this study, the RID was calculated from the measured and theoretical intake (150 mL/kg/day). As the measurements were taken 3–6 days after delivery, the feeding volume was low and the calculated RID values were small. In this period, an infant's intake of breast milk increases every day; therefore, it is considered that the RID obtained from the theoretical breastfeeding volume is suitable for the general evaluation of risk. To estimate the maximum amount of drug intake by infants through breast milk, the peak concentrations of the drugs in the breast milk were used to calculate the daily drug intake in infants and were used to calculate the RID. With the exception of ethyl loflazepate, the RID determined from the theoretical feeding value in this study was <10%, the safe threshold, and we considered that taking these drugs and breastfeeding were compatible.
The RID of ethyl loflazepate exceeded the safe threshold. However, it was only slightly above the threshold. Therefore, due to the high potency and long elimination half-life of the drug, it is necessary to be careful of potential side effects arising from accumulation in the infant, but breastfeeding should not be prohibited. Although follow-up was continued to ∼1 month after delivery, in the two subjects receiving ethyl loflazepate, no adverse events, such as somnolence, were observed in the infants, and there were no issues with weight gain. However, as ethyl loflazepate shows a first-pass effect during passage through the intestinal tract and in the liver and no unchanged drug is detected in blood or breast milk, the amount of metabolites should be measured. Therefore, for an accurate evaluation of the RID, it is necessary to study the gastrointestinal absorption of this metabolite in infants.
Of breast milk samples ∼1 week after birth and ∼3–4 weeks after birth, the latter has a slightly lower protein content and a higher fat content. Brotizolam had a high M/P ratio at the 1-month checkup, but no changes were observed in the other drugs. As the number of cases was small, it was not possible to conclude whether this difference in breast milk composition altered the M/P ratio. In addition, as the sampling method does not take into account the difference in the composition of foremilk and hindmilk, further investigation is necessary regarding the relationship between the transferability of the drug to milk and the milk composition, including fat concentration.
Some reports suggest that postpartum depression and anxiety symptoms tend to reduce the period of breastfeeding. It has also been reported that breastfeeding is less likely to start, and formula supplementation is more likely to occur.38,39 These tendencies were also observed in this study. Postpartum-specific anxiety is associated with low oxytocin and low prolactin, which may interfere with the milk reflex and subsequent milk production. 40 It is theorized that these mechanisms have an adverse effect on breastfeeding. It is well known that breastfeeding is beneficial to mothers and infants, and it is important to prolong the lactation period as much as possible. Therefore, stabilization of maternal psychological symptoms is necessary, and drug treatment may continue during breastfeeding. In addition, it is reported that >90% of women in Japan wish to breastfeed, 41 and breastfeeding should not, as a rule, be stopped because of the use of drugs to treat this disease. In contrast, the risk to the infant due to the drug should be avoided, and to evaluate the risk and the benefit correctly, it is important to identify objective parameters, including the migration of the drug to breast milk.
Conclusions
For alprazolam, lorazepam, brotizolam, clonazepam, clonazepam, etizolam, and flunitrazepam, RID was <10%, which is considered an appropriate safety margin. Although the RID of ethyl loflazepate was >10%, it was not large enough to be considered to induce adverse events in infants, and breastfeeding does not need to be stopped if the mother is taking this drug. For lactating women who take benzodiazepines, there is little information to judge whether breastfeeding is safe; therefore, judgment is often based on limited information and experience. As empirical judgments can be biased, we considered that this research, which measures parameters that are objective and have a universal understanding, such as RID, is meaningful. However, the number of cases for each drug is very low; hence, further data are needed to draw firm conclusions.
Footnotes
Acknowledgment
We thank Editage for English language editing.
Disclosure Statement
No competing financial interests exist.
Funding Information
This work was supported by Grant for Research Project of Japanese Society of Drug Informatics in 2020.
