In Place of Strife? The PLP in Government,1997

Abstract

After entering government in 1997, the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) acquired a reputation for acquiescence. This article attempts to answer two related questions. Was this an accurate picture of the PLP under Blair? And if so, what explained it? The number of back-bench revolts was certainly low. Excluding the short parliaments of 1964 and February 1974, we have to go back to 1955 to find a parliament with fewer rebellions by government back benchers than the one elected in 1997 – but those rebellions that did occur were sizeable. Rebellion was also widespread amongst the PLP: 133 MPs rebelled at some point in the Parliament. There are four explanations for this compliant pattern of behaviour, in order of increasing importance: the issues on the legislative agenda; the composition of the PLP; the government's behaviour; and a desire on the part of most of the PLP to appear united.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baker

Gamble

Seawright

Bull

(1999) ‘MPs and Europe’, British Elections and Parties Review, 9, 171–85.

Bale

(1997) ‘Managing the Party and the Trade Unions’, in Brivati

Bale

(eds), New Labour in Power. London: Routledge, 159–78.

Beer

(1969) Modern British Politics. London: Faber.

Brand

(1989) ‘Factions in the British Parliament 1945–1986’, Parliamentary Affairs, 42, 148–64.

Brand

(1992) British Parliamentary Parties. Oxford: Clarendon.

Butt

(1967) The Power of Parliament. London: Constable.

Cowley

(ed.) (1998) Conscience and Parliament. London: Frank Cass.

Cowley

(2001) ‘The Commons: Mr Blair's Lapdog?’, in Norris

(ed.), Britain Votes 2001. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 251–64.

Cowley

(2002) Revolts and Rebellions: Parliamentary Voting under Blair. London: Politico's.

10.

Cowley

Childs

(forthcoming) ‘Too Scared to Rebel? New Labour's Women MPs’, British Journal of Political Science.

11.

Cowley

Norton

(1999) ‘Rebels and Rebellions: Conservative MPs in the 1992 Parliament’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 1, 84–105.

12.

Crewe

(1996) ‘1979–1996’, in Seldon

(ed.), How Tory Governments Fall. London: Fontana.

13.

Dowse

(1960a) ‘The Left Wing Opposition during the First Two Labour Governments: Part I’, Parliamentary Affairs, 14, 80–93.

14.

Dowse

(1960b) ‘The Left Wing Opposition during the First Two Labour Governments: Part II’, Parliamentary Affairs, 14, 229–43.

15.

Gilmour

(1971) The Body Politic. Revised Edition. London: Hutchinson.

16.

Lynskey

J. J.

(1970) ‘The Role of British Backbenchers in the Modification of Government Policy’, Western Political Quarterly, 27 333–47.

17.

Norris

(1999) ‘New Politicians? Changes in Party Competition at Westminster’, in Norris

Evans

(eds), Critical Elections. London: Sage, 22–43.

18.

Norris

(1998) ‘New Labour, New Politicians?’ in Dobson

Stanyer

(eds) Contemporary Political Studies. Volume 2. Nottingham: Political Studies Association, 766–80.

19.

Norton

(1975) Dissension in the House of Commons 1945–1974. London: Macmillan.

20.

Norton

(1979) ‘The Organization of Parliamentary Parties’, in Walkland

S. A.

(ed.), The House of Commons in the Twentieth Century. Oxford: Clarendon, 7–68.

21.

Norton

(1980) Dissension in the House of Commons, 1974–1979. Oxford: Clarendon.

22.

Norton

(1985) ‘Behavioural Changes’, in Norton

(ed.), Parliament in the 1980s. Oxford: Blackwell, 22–47.

23.

Norton

(1993) Does Parliament Matter? London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.

24.

Norton

(2001) ‘Parliament’, in Seldon

(ed.), The Blair Effect. London: Little Brown, 43–66.

25.

Piper

J. R.

(1974) ‘Backbench Rebellion, Party Government and Consensus Politics: The Case of the Parliamentary Labour Party, 1966–1970’, Parliamentary Affairs, 27, 384–96.

26.

Richardson

Jordan

(1979) Governing under Pressure: The Policy Process in a Post-Parliamentary Democracy. Oxford: Martin Robertson.

27.

Roth

Criddle

(1997) New MPs of 97. London: Parliamentary Profile Services.

28.

Shaw

(2001) ‘New Labour: New Pathways to Parliament’, Parliamentary Affairs, 54, 35–53.

In Place of Strife? The PLP in Government,1997–2001

Abstract

Get full access to this article

References