Racial Disparities in the Enforcement of COVID-19 Public Health Violations

Abstract

To curb the spread of the novel coronavirus, most cities and states implemented COVID-19 public health restrictions that became enforceable offenses. Unfortunately, concerns about unequitable enforcement arose among minority and impoverished communities. The current study uses official data from San Antonio, Texas to investigate the relationship between zip code racial and ethnic composition and income on the enforcement of COVID-19 public health violations. Over 28,000 enforcement activities from March 2020 to March 2021 were analyzed using random effects logistic regression. Results indicate that enforcement activities in zip codes with above average percent Black and above average percent Hispanic were more likely to receive citations, even though citations were issued in less than one percent of all enforcement activities.

Keywords

COVID-19 public health violations disproportionate minority contact pandemic policing racial disparities

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Agnew

(2015). Race and youth crime: Why isn’t the relationship stronger? Race and Justice, 6(3), 195–221.

Ashby

M. P. J.

(2020). Changes in police calls for service during the early months of the 2020 coronavirus pandemic. Policing, 14(4), 1054–1072.

Bishop

D. M.

(2000). Juvenile offenders in the adult criminal justice system. Crime and Justice, 27, 81–167.

Blalock

H. M.

(1967). Toward a theory of minority-group relations (Vol. 325). Wiley.

Blumstein

(1982). On the racial disproportionality of United States’ prison populations. Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology, 73, 1259.

Blumstein

(1993). Racial disproportionality of US. prison populations revisited. University of Colorado Law Review, 743, 759.

Boman

J. H.

Gallupe

(2020). Has COVID-19 changed crime? Crime rates in the United States during the pandemic. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 45(4), 537–545.

Campedelli

G. M.

Aziani

Favarin

(2021). Exploring the immediate effects of COVID-19 containment policies on crime: An empirical analysis of the short-term aftermath in Los Angeles. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 46, 704–727.

Carvalho

A. A. S.

Mizael

T. M.

Sampaio

A. A.

(2022). Racial prejudice and police stops: A systematic review of the empirical literature. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 15, 1213–1220.

10.

Crutchfield

R. D.

Bridges

G. S.

Pitchford

S. R.

(1994). Analytical and aggregation biases in analyses of imprisonment: Reconciling discrepancies in studies of racial disparity. Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 31(2), 166–182.

11.

DiTomaso

(2013). The American non-dilemma: Racial inequality without racism. Russell Sage Foundation.

12.

Donnelly

E. A.

(2022). Neighborhoods, criminal incidents, race, and sentencing: Exploring the racial and social context of disparities in incarceration sentences. The British Journal of Criminology, 62(1), 145–164.

13.

Dunbar

Jones

N. E.

(2021). Race, police, and the pandemic: Considering the role of race in public health policing. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 44(5), 773–782.

14.

Elliot

D. S.

Ageton

S. A.

Canter

R. J.

(1980). Reconciling race and class differences in self-reported and official estimates of delinquency. American Sociological Review, 45, 95–110.

15.

Evans

Bauer

(2020, May 26). Chicago police only arrested people for social distancing violations on the south and west sides, data shows. Block Club Chicago. https://blockclubchicago.org/2020/05/26/chicago-police-only-arrested-people-for-social-distancing-on-the-south-and-west-sides-data-shows/

16.

Fagan

Davies

(2000). Street stops and broken windows: Terry, race, and disorder in New York City. Fordham Urban Law Review, 28, 457.

17.

Felson

Jiang

(2020). Routine activity effects of the Covid-19 pandemic on burglary in Detroit, March 2020. Crime Science, 9(1), 1–7.

18.

Free

M. D.

(2001). Racial bias and the American criminal justice system: Race and presentencing revisited. Critical Criminology, 10(3), 195–223.

19.

Gerell

Kardell

Kindgren

(2020). Minor covid-19 association with crime in Sweden, a five week follow up. Crime Science 9(1), 1–9.

20.

Gibbons

F. X.

Fleischli

M. E.

Gerrard

Simons

R. L.

Weng

C. Y.

Gibson

L. P.

(2020). The impact of early racial discrimination on illegal behavior, arrest, and incarceration among African Americans. American Psychologist, 75(7), 952–968.

21.

Hawkins

D. F.

Laub

J. H.

Lauritsen

J. L.

Cothern

(2000). Race, ethnicity, and serious and violent juvenile offending. US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

22.

Hodgkinson

Andresen

M. A.

(2020). Show me a man or a woman alone and I’ll show you a saint: Changes in the frequency of criminal incidents during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Criminal Justice, 69, 1–13.

23.

Huizinga

Elliot

(1987). Juvenile offenders: Prevalence, offender incidence and arrest rates by race. Crime and Delinquency, 33, 206–223.

24.

Jahn

J. L.

Agenor

Chen

J. T.

Krieger

(2021). Frequent police stops, parental incarceration and mental health: Results among US non-Hispanic Black and White adolescent girls and boys. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 75(7), 658–664.

25.

Katznelson

(2005). When affirmative action was white: An untold history of racial inequality in twentieth-century America. WW Norton & Company.

26.

Kochel

T. R.

Wilson

D. B.

Mastrofski

S. D.

(2011). Effect of suspect race on officers’arrest decisions. Criminology, 49(2), 473–512.

27.

Leal

W. E.

Kurland

Piquero

A. R.

Gloyd

E. L.

Leeper Piquero

(2021). Where, when, and by whom: An exploratory analysis of COVID-19 public health violations. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice, 37(4), 523–542.

28.

Leal

W. E.

Piquero

A. R.

Kurland

Piquero

N. L.

Gloyd

E. L.

(2022). A case study of family violence during COVID-19 in San Antonio. Crime & Delinquency, 68(8), 1161–1182.

29.

Mauer

King

R. S.

(2007). Uneven justice: State rates of incarceration by race and ethnicity. The Sentencing Project. https://www.issuelab.org/resources/695/695.pdf

30.

McCarter

S. A.

(2018). Racial disparities in the criminal justice system. Encyclopedia of social work (pp. 1–23). National Association of Social Workers Press and Oxford University Press.

31.

Mitchell

(2005). A meta-analysis of race and sentencing research: Explaining the inconsistencies. Journal of Quantitative Criminology, 21(4), 439–466.

32.

Mohler

Bertozzi

A. L.

Carter

Short

M. B.

Sledge

Tita

G. E.

Uchida

C. D.

Brantingham

P. J.

(2020). Impact of social distancing during COVID-19 pandemic on crime in Los Angeles and Indianapolis. Journal of Criminal Justice, 68, 101692.

33.

Morenoff

J. D.

(2005). Racial and ethnic disparities in crime and delinquency in the United States. In Rutter

Tienda

(Eds.), Ethnicity and causal mechanisms (pp. 139–173). Cambridge University Press.

34.

Mykhalovskiy

Kazatchkine

Foreman-Mackey

McClelland

Peck

Hastings

Elliott

(2020). Human rights, public health and COVID-19 in Canada. Canadian Journal of Public Health, 111(6), 975–979.

35.

National Academy for State Health Policy. (2020). 2020 COVID-19 state restrictions, re-openings, and mask requirements. Author. https://nashp.org/2020-covid-19-state-restrictions-re-openings-and-mask-requirements/

36.

Nellis

(2016). The color of justice: Racial and ethnic disparity in state prisons. The Sentencing Project.

37.

Olivarius

(2019). Immunity, capital, and power in Antebellum New Orleans. The American Historical Review, 124(2), 425–455.

38.

Parker

K. F.

MacDonald

J. M.

Alpert

G. P.

Smith

M. R.

Piquero

A. R.

(2004). A contextual study of racial profiling: Assessing the theoretical rationale for the study of racial profiling at the local level. American Behavioral Scientist, 47(7), 943–962.

39.

Payne

J. L.

Morgan

Piquero

A. R.

(2021). Exploring regional variability in the short-term impact of COVID-19 on property crime in Queensland, Australia. Crime Science, 10(1), 1–20.

40.

Payne

J. L.

Morgan

Piquero

A. R.

(2022). COVID-19 and social distancing measures in Queensland, Australia, are associated with short-term decreases in recorded violent crime. Journal of Experimental Criminology, 18, 89–113.

41.

Petrocelli

Piquero

A. R.

Smith

M. R.

(2003). Conflict theory and racial profiling: An empirical analysis of police traffic stop data. Journal of Criminal Justice, 31(1), 1–11.

42.

Piquero

A. R.

(2008). Disproportionate minority contact. The Future of Children, 18, 59–79.

43.

Piquero

A. R.

Jennings

W. G.

Jemison

Kaukinen

Knaul

F. M.

(2021). Evidence from a systematic review and meta-analysis: Domestic Violence during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Journal of Criminal Justice, 74, 101806. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrimjus.2021.101806

44.

Pope

C. E.

Lovell

R. D.

Hsia

H. M.

(2002). Disproportionate minority confinement: A review of the research literature from 1989 through 2001. US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention.

45.

Rmandic

Walker

Bright

Millsteed

(2020). Police-recorded crime trends in Victoria during the COVID-19 pandemic. Brief, 10, 1–22.

46.

Rosenfeld

Lopez

(2022). Pandemic, social unrest, and crime in US cities. Council on Criminal Justice.

47.

Sampson

R. J.

Morenoff

J. D.

Raudenbush

(2005). Social anatomy of racial and ethnic disparities in violence. American Journal of Public Health, 95(2), 224–232.

48.

Sorensen

Hope

Stemen

(2003). Racial disproportionality in state prison admissions: Can regional variation be explained by differential arrest rates? Journal of Criminal Justice, 31(1), 73–84.

49.

Southall

(2020, May 29). Scrutiny of social-distance policing as 35 of 40 arrested are black. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/05/07/nyregion/nypd-social-distancing-race-coronavirus.html

50.

Stickle

Felson

(2020). Crime rates in a pandemic: The largest criminological experiment in history. American Journal of Criminal Justice, 45(4), 525–536.

51.

Stults

B. J.

Baumer

E. P.

(2007). Racial context and police force size: Evaluating the empirical validity of the minority threat perspective. American Journal of Sociology, 113(2), 507–546.

52.

Stults

B. J.

Parker

Lane

(2010). Space, place, and immigration: New directions for research on police stops. In Rice

S. K.

White

M. D.

(Eds.), Race, ethnicity, and policing: New and essential readings (pp. 411–434). NYU Press.

53.

United States Census Bureau. (2019). QuickFacts San Antonio city, Texas. Author. https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/sanantoniocitytexas/PST045219

54.

United States Census Bureau. (2022). About the American community survey. Author. https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/about.html

55.

Unnever

Owusu-Bempah

Deryol

(2019). A test of the differential involvement hypothesis. Race and Justice, 9(2), 197–224.

56.

Wang

(2020, August 27). In policing COVID-19 restrictions, violators often slapped with warnings but rarely ticketed. San Antonio Report. https://sanantonioreport.org/in-policing-covid-19-restrictions-violators-often-slapped-with-warnings-but-rarely-ticketed/

57.

Watts

M. H.

Michel

K. H.

Breslin

Tobin-Tyler

(2021). Equitable enforcement of pandemic-related public health laws: Strategies for achieving racial and health justice. American Journal of Public Health, 111(3), 395–397.

58.

Yang

T. C.

Kim

Matthews

S. A.

(2021). Face masking violations, policing, and COVID-19 death rates: A spatial analysis in New York city zip codes. The Professional Geographer, 73(4), 670–682.

59.

Zhang

(2021). Racial characteristics of areas and police decisions to arrest in traffic stops: Multilevel analysis of contextual racial effects. Policing: An International Journal, 44(5), 772–785.