Governance for Rights-based Welfarism in India: Context and Assessment

Abstract

India’s welfare trajectory has shifted from a constitutionally grounded, state-led model to a market-oriented approach, often overlooking rights-based social security policies. This article examines the governance of rights-based welfare policies (RBWPs) targeting economic security (work and food) and human development (health and education). Despite progressive mandates, implementation remains fragmented due to siloed ministries, administrative inefficiencies and uneven fiscal allocations, particularly at sub-national levels. The shift towards market-led welfare has failed to stabilise employment or secure the rights of informal workers. Gaps between policy intent (dharma) and execution (karma), compounded by low public investment and weak inter-departmental coordination, undermine constitutional entitlements. To address these challenges, this article proposes an integrated welfare provisioning model for economic and human development (IWP-EHD), a unified ministerial framework emphasising cross-sectoral coherence, participatory planning and digital governance. This model aims to transition from charity-based welfarism to a rights-based citizenship paradigm.

Keywords

Constitutional commonsense rights-based programmes integrated welfare provisioning model new welfarism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Andersen

T. M.

, & Svarer

(2012). Active labour market policies in a recession. IZA Journal of Labor Policy, 1(1), 7. https://doi.org/10.1186/2193-9004-1-7

Bajpai

, & Sachs

J. D.

(2004). National Common Minimum Programme of the Congress-led UPA: Policy reform and public investment requirements. https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/

Balagopal

(1988). Probings in the political economy of agrarian classes and conflicts. Perspectives.

Balaramulu

(2016). Governance of food security policies in India. Kalpaz Publications.

Balaramulu

(2024). Indian administration: A saga of continuity and change. Economic & Political Weekly, 59(3), 17–20.

Balaramulu

(2025). Food security policies and governance in the South Indian states: Inclusive approach. Development strategies and governance in India: Predicaments and challenges. Routledge.

Bhat

B. A.

, Ahmad

, & Mir

J. A.

(2009). Rapid appraisal of RHM implementation: Rajouri, Jammu & Kashmir. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. http://www.mohfw.nic.in/NRHM/PRC_RA_Reports/Jammu%20&%20Kashmir/Rajouri/Detailed%20Report.p

Bose

, Ghosh

, & Sardana

(2020). Financing the right to education: Role of the Fifteenth Finance Commission. Economic & Political Weekly, 4(37), 44–52.

Cataldi

(2024). New public governance as a hybrid: A critical interpretation. Cambridge University Press.

10.

Cavalcanti

D. M.

, Ordoñez

J. A.

, Da Silva

A. F.

, Basterra

E. L.

, Moncayo

A. L.

, Chivardi

, Hessel

, Pietro Sironi

, De Sousa

R. P.

, Campello

, Souza

L. E.

, & Rasella

(2025). Health effects of the Brazilian Conditional Cash Transfer programme over 20 years and projections to 2030: A retrospective analysis and modelling study. Lancet Public Health, 10(7), e548–e558. https://cee.fiocruz.br/sites/default/files/Lancet_PH_05302025.pdf

11.

Chakraborty

, & Sarmah

S. P.

(2019). India 2025: The public distribution system and National Food Security Act 2013. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 65(2), 230–249.

12.

Chatterjee

, & Robitaille

M.-C.

(2023). State of Indian public schools since the Right to Education Act. Economic & Political Weekly, 58(16), 17–25.

13.

CNES. (2025). Post budget analysis. Mere tinkering with direct tax reform won’t address India’s structural economic woes. Centre for New Economic Studies (CNES).

14.

Desai

, Singh

, & Verma

(2025). Post-budget analysis 2025–26. https://www.cnesinfosphere.com/_files/ugd/85c814_f9a016f63bab453e8bbde02330f95317.pdf

15.

Drèze

(2013). Summary of the National Food Security Bill, 2013. Right to Food Campaign.

16.

Drèze

, & Khera

(2017). Recent social security initiatives in India. World Development, 98, 555–572.

17.

Duggal

(2009). Sinking flagships and health budgets in India. Economic & Political Weekly, 44(33), 14–16.

18.

Farnsworth

, & Holden

(2006). The business-social policy nexus: Corporate power and corporate inputs into social policy. Cambridge University Press.

19.

Ghosh

(2021). On the question of access to welfare and health for women during the initial phase of the pandemic. Economic & Political Weekly, 56(17), 1–15.

20.

Government of India. (2005). National Rural Health Mission (2005–2012): Mission Statement. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.

21.

GOI. (2008–2009). Second Administrative Reforms Commission reports. Haragopal

, & Balaramulu

(1989). Poverty alleviation programmes: IRDP in an Andhra Pradesh district. Economic & Political Weekly, 24(35–36), 2025–2034.

22.

Hirway

(1985). Special employment programmes in rural development: A study of NREP in Gujarat. Gandhi Labour Institute.

23.

Hobbes

(1996). Leviathan. Oxford University Press. (Original work published 1651)

24.

Husain

(2011). Health of the National Rural Health Mission. Economic & Political Weekly, 46(4), 53–61.

25.

IMPRI. (2024). Rural realities and union budget 2024–25. IMPRI 5th Annual Series of Thematic Deliberations and Analysis of Interim Union Budget 2024–25, July 27, IMPRI #WebPolicyTalk.

26.

Jayal

N. G.

(1994). The gentle Leviathan: Welfare and the Indian state. Social Scientist, 22(9/12), 18. https://doi.org/10.2307/3517911

27.

Kainth

G. S.

(2006). A mission approach to Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan. Economic & Political Weekly, 41(30), 3288–3291.

28.

Khera

, & Asjad. (2024, April 16). Guarantee is precarity, welfare is self-care. The Hindu. https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/guarantee-is-precarity-welfare-is-self-care/article68069056.ece

29.

Kumar

(2019). Evaluating the effectiveness of MGNREGS in rural development: Insights from Bihar. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 65(1), 123–138.

30.

Locke

(1988). Two treatises of government. Cambridge University Press. (Original work published 1689)

31.

Manani

, & Goswami

(2025). Amendment in the Right to Education Act from intention to implementation. Economic & Political Weekly, 60(1), 22–24.

32.

Mandal

(2018). Role of MGNREGA for economic development of women (with special reference to nearby villages of Ambikapur city). International Journal of Recent Trends in Engineering and Research, 4(3), 131–138.

33.

Marx

, & Engels

(1998). The communist manifesto. Verso. (Original work published 1848)

34.

Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food & Public Distribution. (2025). National Food Security Act: Coverage, allocation and expenditure. Government of India.

35.

Ministry of Education. (2025). Budget and performance reports: Department of School Education and Literacy. Government of India.

36.

Ministry of Finance. (2025). Union budget documents 2005–06 to 2025–26. Government of India.

37.

Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. (2025). Budget and performance reports on NHM. Government of India.

38.

Ministry of Rural Development. (2022). Annual performance report on MGNREGP. Press Information Bureau.

39.

Ministry of Rural Development. (2023). MGNREGP performance statistics. Press Information Bureau.

40.

Mooij

(1999). Food policy and Indian state: The PDS in South India. Oxford University Press.

41.

Muralidharan

, & Singh

(2021). India’s new National Education Policy: Evidence and challenges. Science, 372(6537), 36–38. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abf6655

42.

NITI Aayog & UNDP. (2024). Multidimensional poverty in India since 2005–06: A discussion paper. NITI Aayog.

43.

Nozick

(1974). Anarchy, state, and utopia. Basic Books.

44.

Nurke

(1957). Problems of capital formation in underdeveloped economies. Oxford University Press.

45.

Paul

(2020). Inequality in the utilisation of maternal healthcare services evidence from Indian states. Economic & Political Weekly, 55(45), 37–44.

46.

Pellissery

, & Sasidhar

T. V. S.

(2018). India as a post-colonial welfare state. In Greve

(Ed.), Routledge handbook of the welfare state (2nd ed., pp. 223–231). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315207049-2

47.

Rahman

, & Pingali

(2024). The future of India’s social safety nets: Focus, form, and scope. Indian Economic Review, 59, 339–343.

48.

Raj

, Dalal

, & Gupta

(2025). Evolution of the healthcare policy framework in India. Indian Public Policy Review, 5(6), 36–110 https://doi.org/10.55763/ippr.2025.05.06.003

49.

Ram Reddy

, & Haragopal

(1985). Public policy and rural poor in India. Concept Publication and Centre for Economic and Social Studies.

50.

Rath

(2018). MGNREGA and its impact on women’s empowerment: Evidence from KBK region of Odisha. International Journal of Recent Trends in Engineering and Research, 4(3), 123–130.

51.

Rawls

(1971). A theory of justice. Harvard University Press.

52.

Sánchez-Ancochea

, & Mattei

(2011). Bolsa Família, poverty and inequality: Political and economic effects in the short and long run. Global Social Policy, 11(2–3), 299–318. https://doi.org/10.1177/1468018111421297

53.

Sarasvati

N. T.

(2020, November 2). How reservation in private schools isn’t working for poor children. Business Standard. https://www.business-standard.com/article/education/how-reservation-in-private-schools-isnot-workingfor-poor-children-120110200147_1.html/

54.

Sen

(1982). Poverty and famines: An essay on entitlement and deprivation. Clarendon Press.

55.

Sharma

(2020). The role of local governance in the success of MGNREGS: A comparative study of two states. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 66(2), 245–260.

56.

Singh

(2018). Operational challenges in the implementation of MGNREGS: A case study of Uttar Pradesh. Indian Journal of Public Administration, 64(3), 456–472.

57.

Sinha

(2024). Integrated welfare empowerment in India’s new welfarism paradigm [The India Dialog Working Paper Series, WP-2024–-23]. US Asia Technology Management Center and Institute for Competitiveness.

58.

Soares

F. V.

, Ribas

R. P.

, & Osório

(2007). Evaluating the impact of Brazil’s Bolsa Família: Cash transfer programs in comparative perspective. Latin American Research Review, 45(2), 173–190. https://doi.org/10.1353/lar.2010.0017

59.

Sobhana

K. N.

(2025). With new Bill, demand-led rural jobs scheme set to turn supply-driven. The Hindu. https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/centre-to-bring-new-rural-employment-bill-mgnrega-parliament/article70397900.ece

60.

Sreekumar

(2023). Understanding Dalit equity: A critical analysis of primary health care policy discourse of Kerala in the context of ‘Aardram’ mission. International Journal for Equity in Health, 22(1), 165. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12939-023-01978-4

61.

Tabassum

(2020). A critical survey of MGNREGA implementation in India. International Journal of Science and Research, 9(2), 14957–14962.

62.

The Economic Times. (2025a, February 5). 1.55 crore MGNREGP workers deleted: Centre explains reasons. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/

63.

The Economic Times. (2025b, February 5). ₹7,500 crore MGNREGA dues pending in West Bengal. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/

64.

The Hindu. (2004, May 14). Editorial: The meaning of verdict 2004.

65.

van Ours

J. C.

, & Krogh Graversen

(2007). How to help the unemployed find jobs quickly: Experimental evidence from a mandatory activation program. CEPR Discussion Papers, Article 6057. https://ideas.repec.org//p/cpr/ceprdp/6057.html

66.

Vyas

V. S.

(2000). Ensuring food security: The state, market and civil society. Economic & Political Weekly, 35(50), 4402–4407.

67.

(2025). Income inequality, food aid, and ‘zero hunger’: Evaluating effectiveness during Lula’s administration (Version 1). https://doi.org/10.48550/ARXIV.2503.16126