Same-sex partner immigration and the civil rights frame: A comparative study of Australia,Israel,and the USA

Abstract

As of 2011, only 19 countries around the world grant immigration rights to the foreign same-sex partners of gay and lesbian citizens. Of these, Australia and Israel are two countries that recognize same-sex couples in the immigration system without the recognition of same-sex marriages or civil unions. Since the Defense of Marriage Act prohibits any federal recognition of same-sex unions in the USA, we compare Australia and Israel with the USA in this comparative-historical, cross-sectional study to identify the factors that led to the inclusion of same-sex partners in the immigration systems of Australia and Israel and determine whether these factors are present in the USA. Through secondary data analysis from 1988 to 2000, we find that parliamentary politics, the autonomy of ministers, and access to elite allies in Australia and Israel created a political opportunity structure that was favorable to gay rights activists. Activists then used a civil rights frame, further legitimizing their cause and reducing opposition. Although gay immigrant rights activists in the USA use a similar frame, we conclude that the political opportunity structure of the USA limits successful advocacy for gay immigration equality.

Keywords

civil rights frame gay rights immigration political opportunity structure same-sex partner

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Australian Government: Attorney-General’s Department (2009) Same-sex Reforms. Available at: http://www.ag.gov.au/samesexreform#immigration (accessed 18 January 2010).

Australian Government: Department of Immigration and Citizenship (2009) Migration Changes Same-Sex Relationships, 2 September. Available at: http://www.immi.gov.au/legislation/key-changes/2009/migration-key-changes.htm (accessed 18 January 2010).

Ayoub

Wong

(2006) Separated and unequal. William Mitchell Law Review 32(2): 559–598.

Bareto

Walker

(2010) May 2010 Washington Poll. WISER: University of Washington Institute for the Study of Ethnicity, Race, and Sexuality. Available at: http://www.washingtonpoll.org/results/June1_teaparty.pdf (accessed 27 July 2011).

Bernstein

(1997) Celebration and suppression: The strategic uses of identity by the lesbian and gay movement. American Journal of Sociology 103(3): 531–565.

Betts

(2003) Immigration policy under the Howard Government. Australian Journal of Social Issues 38(2): 169–192.

Bumiller

(2011) Obama ends ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ policy. The New York Times, 22 July. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/07/23/us/23military.html?_r=2 (accessed 27 July 2011).

Cannick

(2011) Gays first, then illegals. The Advocate.com, 1 January. Available at: http://www.advocate.com/article.aspx?id=43754 (accessed 27 July 2011).

D’Anjou

Van Male

(1998) Between old and new: Social movements and cultural change. Mobilization: An International Journal 3(2): 207–226.

10.

Dasgupta

(2006) Is the gay rights movement anti-immigrant rights? New America Media, 7 April. Available at: http://news.newamericamedia.org/news/view_article.html?article_id=1fffbc2232811516638cbe4e2e3c587a (accessed 27 July 2011).

11.

De Waal

(2002) Lesbians and Gays Changed Australian Immigration: History and Herstory. Darlinghurst, New South Wales, Australia: Gay and Lesbian Immigration Task Force.

12.

Davy

Meyers

Batalova

(2005) Who does what in U.S. Immigration. Migration Information Source. Available at: http://www.migrationinformation.org/USFocus/display.cfm?ID=362 (accessed 18 January 2010).

13.

D’Emilio

(1983) Sexual Politics, Sexual Communities. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

14.

Devetak

(2004) In fear of refugees: The politics of border protection in Australia. International Journal of Human Rights 8(1): 101–109.

15.

Edelman

(1994) Courts, Politics, and Culture in Israel. Charlottesville: The University Press of Virginia.

16.

Fenna

(2001) Essentials of Australian Government. Croydon, Victoria, Australia: Tertiary Press.

17.

Fugolo

(2003) Panel discussion: Immigration policy, law enforcement, and national security. In: Fugolo

(ed.) In Defense of the Alien, Vol. 26. Staten Island, NY: The Center for Migration Studies of New York, Inc, 3–36.

18.

Garber

(2010) New poll looks at tea party views toward minorities. The Seattle Times, 1 June. Available at: http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/politicsnorthwest/2012005031_new_poll_looks_at_tea_party_vi.html (accessed 27 July 2011).

19.

Garcia

(2010) Ariz. Law bad for binational couples. The Advocate, 29 April. Available at: http://www.advocate.com/News/Daily_News/2010/04/29/Arizona_Law_Bad_for_Gay_Binational_Couples/ (accessed 27 July 2011).

20.

Gay Law Net (2000) Israel Allows Partner Immigration. Available at: http://www.gaylawnet.com/news/2000/im00.htm#israel_allows (accessed 3 August 2007).

21.

Gotham

(1999) Political opportunity, community identity, and the formation of a local anti-expressway movement. Social Problems 46(3): 332–354.

22.

Graff

(2011) 15 years after DOMA, hearing reveals a nation transformed. The Atlantic, 20 July. Available at: http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2011/07/15-years-after-doma-hearing-reveals-a-nation-transformed/242273/ (accessed 27 July 2011).

23.

Grant

(2009) ENDA will provide critical employment protections for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender workers. The Hill’s Congress Blog, 5 November. Available at: http://thehill.com/blogs/congress-blog/civil-rights/66575-enda-will-provide-critical-employment-protections-for-lesbian-gay-bisexual-and-transgender-workers (accessed 18 January 2010).

24.

Green

Guth

Hill

(1993) Faith and election: The Christian Right in Congressional campaigns 1978–1988. The Journal of Politics 55(1): 80–91.

25.

Gross

(2009) Harvey Milk was here. ZEEK: A Jewish Journal of Thought and Culture, 26 October. Available at: http://zeek.forward.com/articles/115761/ (accessed 17 July 2011).

26.

Harel

(2000) The rise and fall of the Israeli gay legal revolution. Columbia Human Rights Law Review 31(2): 443–472.

27.

Hart

(1993) Gay and lesbian couple immigration to Australia: Pressure group compromises and achievements. In: Hendrisk

Helman

Van Der Veen

(eds) The Third Pink Book: A Global View of Lesbian and Gay Liberation and Oppression. Buffalo, NY: Prometheus Books, 100–108.

28.

Hart

(2002) Stories of Gay and Lesbian Immigration: Together Forever? Binghamton, NY: The Haworth Press, Inc.

29.

Higginbotham

(1992) African-American women’s history and the metalanguage of race. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 17(2): 251–274.

30.

Hugo

(2002) Australian immigration policy: The significance of the events of September 11. International Migration Review 36(1): 37–40.

31.

Immigration Equality (2009a) Current Co-sponsors. Available at: http://www.immigrationequality.org/template.php?pageid=152 (accessed 17 January 2010).

32.

Immigration Equality (2009b) Imeq Mission. Available at: http://www.immigrationequality.org/template.php?pageid=8 (accessed 18 January 2010).

33.

Immigration Equality (2011a) Binational Couples. Available at: http://www.immigrationequality.org/issues/couples-and-families/binational-couples/ (accessed 17 July 2011).

34.

Immigration Equality (2011b) Nadler, House champions of immigration reform, introduce the Uniting American Families Act to provide equal LGBT immigration rights. Available at: http://immigrationequalityactionfund.org/press/pr/nadler_house_champions_of_immigration_reform_introduce_the_uniting_american_families_act_to_provide_equal_lgbt_immigration_rights/ (accessed 27 July 2011).

35.

Jasper

(2004) A strategic approach to collective action: Looking for agency in social movement choices. Mobilization: An International Journal 9(1): 1–16.

36.

Johnson

(2003) Heteronormative citizenship: The Howard Government’s views on gay and lesbian issues. Australian Journal of Political Science 38(1): 45–62.

37.

Johnson

(2011) Choi slams DOMA hearing witnesses as ‘exclusively white and privileged’. The Washington Blade, 18 July. Available at: http://www.washingtonblade.com/2011/07/18/choi-slams-doma-hearing-witnesses-as-exclusively-white-and-privileged/ (accessed 27 July 2011).

38.

Jupp

(2007) From White Australia to Woomera: The Story of Australian Immigration, 2nd edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

39.

Kagan

Ben-Dor

(2008) Nowhere to Run: Gay Palestinian-Asylum Seekers in Israel. Tel Aviv, Israel: Tel Aviv University Public Interest Law Program. Available at: http://www.law.tau.ac.il/Heb/_Uploads/dbsAttachedFiles/NowheretoRun.pdf (accessed 19 July 2011).

40.

Kim

(2011) Both sides see same-sex marriage as winning issue in 2012. U.S. News & World Report, 27 July. Available at: http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2011/07/27/both-sides-see-same-sex-marriage-as-winning-issue-in-2012 (accessed 27 July 2011).

41.

Kimmerling

(1999) Religion, nationalism, and democracy in Israel. Constellations 6(3): 339–363.

42.

The Knesset (2010) Parliamentary Groups in the Knesset. Available at: http://www.knesset.gov.il/faction/eng/FactionPage_eng.asp?PG=4 (accessed 18 January 2010).

43.

Koopmans

(2005) Contested Citizenship: Immigration and Cultural Diversity in Europe. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

44.

Koutsoukis

(2009) Homophobia in Israel still high but declining slowly, survey says. The Sydney Morning Herald, 7 August. Available at: http://www.smh.com.au/world/homophobia-in-israel-still-high-but-declining-slowly-says-survey-20090806-ebkb.html (accessed 17 July 2011).

45.

Lacey

(2011) Birthright citizenship looms as the next immigration battle. The New York Times, 4 January. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/01/05/us/politics/05babies.html (accessed 27 July 2011).

46.

Leitsinger

(2011) For some gay couples, fight goes on to marry – and stay in the US. MSNBC Today News, 22 July. Available at: http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/43848013/ns/us_news-life/ (accessed 27 July 2011).

47.

Lynsen

(2007) U.S. law separates thousands of gay couples. The Washington Blade, 2 May. Available at: http://www.washblade.com/thelatest/thelatest.cfm?blog_id=6528 (accessed 5 March 2008).

48.

Maddox

(2005) God Under Howard: The Rise of the Religious Right in Australian Politics. Sydney, Australia: Allen & Unwin.

49.

Meyer

(2004) Protest and Political Opportunities. Annual Review of Sociology 30: 125–145.

50.

Miceli

(2005) Morality politics vs. identity politics: Framing processes and competition among Christian right and gay social movement organizations. Sociological Forum 20(4): 589–612.

51.

Moen

(1994) From revolution to evolution: The changing nature of the Christian Right. Sociology of Religion 55(3): 345–357.

52.

Peled

(2007) Towards a post-citizenship society? A report from the front. Citizenship Studies 11(1): 95–104.

53.

Polletta

Jasper

(2001) Collective identity and social movements. Annual Review of Sociology 27: 283–305.

54.

Preston

(2011) Confusion over policy on married gay immigrants. The New York Times, 29 March. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/30/us/30immigration.html?_r=1 (accessed 27 July 2011).

55.

Raijman

Kemp

(2010) The new immigration to Israel: Becoming a defacto immigration state in the 1990s. In: Segal

Elliott

Mayadas

(eds) Immigration Worldwide: Policies, Practices, Trends. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 227–243.

56.

Ralls

(2009) Senate to hold first-ever hearing addressing anti-gay discrimination in U.S. immigration law. Immigration Equality, 28 May. Available at: http://hosted.vresp.com/404947/c27d9a8fa0/135451293/f2fedd6895/ (accessed 18 January 2010).

57.

The Reuniting Families Act 2009 (2009) H.R. 2709, bill summary. Available at: http://honda.house.gov/pdf/familyunitybillsummary.pdf (accessed 17 January 2010).

58.

Ritchie

(2010) How do you say ‘come out of the closet’ in Arabic? Queer activism and the politics of visibility in Israel-Palestine. GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies 16(4): 557–576.

59.

Ronen

(2011) Cabinet extends measure preventing ‘invasion by marriage’. Arutz Sheva, 17 July. Available at: http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/news.aspx/145786 (accessed 26 July 2011).

60.

Sager

(1985) The Parliamentary System of Israel. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.

61.

Sanders

(2011) Israeli intolerance shows up on internet, in Knesset, on the street. Los Angeles Times, 23 January. Available at: http://articles.latimes.com/2011/jan/23/world/la-fg-israel-intolerance-20110123 (accessed 17 January 2010).

62.

Schneider

(1997) Framing Puerto Rican identity: Political opportunity structures and neighborhood organizing in New York City. Mobilization 2(2): 227–245.

63.

Schulzetenberg

(2002) U.S. immigration benefits for same sex couples: Green Cards for gay partners? William & Mary Journal of Women and the Law 9(1): 99–118.

64.

Servicemembers Legal Defense Network (2011) About ‘Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell’. Servicemembers Legal Defense Network. Available at: http://www.sldn.org/pages/about-dadt (accessed 27 July 2011).

65.

Skocpol

(1984) Vision and Method in Historical Sociology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

66.

Spillman

(1997) Nation and Commemoration: Creating National Identities in the United States and Australia. Cambridge: Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge.

67.

Stearns

Almeida

(2004) The formation of state-actor social movement coalitions and favorable policy outcomes. Social Problems 51(4): 478–504.

68.

Stern

Long

Francoeur

Immigration Equality, and Human Rights Watch (2006) Family, Unvalued: Discrimination, Denial, and the Fate of Binational Same-Sex Couples under U.S. Law. Available at: http://www.hrw.org/en/node/11327/section/1 (accessed 18 January 2010).

69.

Tarrow

(1988) National politics and collective action: Research theory and research in Western Europe and the USA. Annual Review of Sociology 14: 421–440.

70.

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel (2007) Annual Report 2006/2007. Available at: http://www.acri.org.il/pdf/Annualreport2007.pdf (accessed 18 January 2010).

71.

Tiven

(2009) 44 million readers. Immigration Equality Blog, 14 April. Available at: http://immigrationequality.org/blog/?p=854 (accessed 17 January 2010).

72.

Tumlin

(2004) Comment: Suspect first – how terrorism policy is reshaping immigration policy. California Law Review 92(4): 1173–1240.

73.

United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (2009) Bishops support family reunification Senate Bill, not able to support similar House legislation. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Office of Media Relations, 2 June. Available at: http://www.usccb.org/comm/archives/2009/09-122.shtml (accessed 27 July 2011).

74.

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (2011) ICE total removals as of May 23, 2011. Available at: http://www.ice.gov/doclib/about/offices/ero/pdf/ero-removals.pdf (accessed 27 July 2011).

75.

Vendantam

(2010) Gay couples seeking immigration rights. The Washington Post, 13 September. Available at: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/09/12/AR2010091204159_2.html (accessed 17 July 2011).

76.

Vaid

(1995) Virtual Equality: The Mainstreaming of Gay and Lesbian Liberation. New York: Anchor Books.

77.

Wald

Shye

(1994) Interreligious conflict in Israel: The group basis of conflicting visions. Political Behavior 16(1): 157–178.

78.

Walzer

(2000) Between Sodom and Eden: A Gay Journey Through Today’s Changing Israel. New York: Columbia University Press.

79.

Walzer

(2002) Queer in the land of Sodom. The Gully: Online Magazine, 21 February. Available at: http://www.thegully.com/essays/gaymundo/020220_gay_israel_history.html (accessed 18 January 2010).

80.

Waslin

(2003) Counterterrorism and the Latino community since September 11th. In: Fugolo

(ed) In Defense of the Alien, Vol. 26. Staten Island, NY: The Center for Migration Studies of New York, Inc., 83–102.

81.

Weiss

(2006) Hardim resume protest against gay parade. Israel News, 5 November. Available at: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3324133,00.html (accessed 18 January 2010).

82.

Weller

(2007) Cabinet Government in Australia, 1901–2006: Practice, Principles, Performance. Sydney, New South Wales, Australia: University of New South Wales Press Ltd.

83.

Willet

(2000) Living Out Loud: A History of Gay and Lesbian Activism in Australia. St Leonards, New South Wales, Australia: Allen & Unwin.

84.

Willet

(2010) Howard and the homos. Social Movement Studies 9(2): 187–199.

85.

Yonah

(1999) Fifty years later: The scope and limits of liberal democracy in Israel. Constellations 6(3): 411–428.

86.

Zaske

(2006) Note: Love knows no borders – The same-sex marriage debate and immigration laws. William Mitchell Law Review 32: 625–653.

87.

Zidion

(1967) Knesset: The Parliament of Israel. New York, NY: The Herzel Press.

88.

Zino

(2006) Pride event: Democracy lost. Israel News, 10 November. Available at: http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L3326564,00.html (accessed 28 March 2008).