A variety of new information technologies have emerged that clearly can improve the efficiency and effectiveness of marketing programs. However, the use of technologies such as computer matching or automatic order-entry systems to support marketing programs also can lead to legal and societal difficulties. The authors review the types of problems that marketers could encounter when using new information technologies. Particular attention is paid to the possibilities of being charged with (1) participating in collusive information exchanges, (2) maintaining an illegal “essential facility,” (3) storing or transmitting inaccurate and harmful information, and (4) violating the privacy rights of individuals. They offer ideas about how marketing managers and researchers can reduce the chances of facing these types of problems.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
American Column and Lumber Company v. U.S. (1921), 257 U.S. 377.
2.
AndrewsJ. Craig, NetemeyerRichard G., and DurvasulaSrinivas (1990), “Believability and Attitudes Toward Alcohol Warning Label Information: The Role of Persuasive Communications Theory,” Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 9, 1–15.
3.
Antitrust & Trade Regulation Report (1991), “FTC and Federal Institutions Council Will Develop Joint FCRA Policy Statement,” 60 (June 13), 821.
4.
AreedaPhillip E. and HovenkampHerbert (1989), Antitrust Law: 1989 Supplement.Boston: Little, Brown and Company.
5.
Aspen Skiing v. Aspen Highlands (1985), 472 U.S. 585.
6.
Associated Press v. U.S. (1945), 326 U.S. 1.
7.
BirnbaumJeffrey H. (1991) “House Says ‘Sorry, Wrong Number’ to Telephone Sales,” Wall Street Journal (November 19), B1.
8.
BlattbergRobert C. and DeightonJohn (1991) “Interactive Marketing: Exploring the Age of Addressability,” Sloan Management Review (Fall), 5–14.
9.
BowersDiane K. (1991), “The Privacy Challenge, Part I,” Marketing Research, (June) 59–62.
10.
Brockelesby v. United States (1985), 767 F. 2d 1288 (9th Cir. 1985), cert. denied, 106 S. Ct. 882 (1986), cited in Marx, 1988.
11.
Brown v. United States (1984), 599 F. Supp. 87–7 (D. Mass. 1984), cited in Marx, 1988.
12.
BuzzellRobert D. (1985), Marketing in an Electronic Age.Boston: Harvard Business School Press.
CulnanMary J. (1992), “How Did They Get My Name?: An Exploratory Investigation of Consumer Attitudes Toward Secondary Information Use,” working paper, School of Business Administration, Georgetown University.
25.
DahlJonathan (1991), “Agents Rankle Airlines with Fare-Checking Programs,” Wall Street Journal (May 20), B1.
26.
DavidsonJoe and ZacharyG. Pascal (1993), “FTC to Hold Feb. 5 Meeting on Microsoft,” Wall Street Journal (January 8), A3.
27.
Talamodi (1991), “Private Secrets,” Direct Marketing (April), 42–44.
28.
Direct Marketing Association (1990a) DMA Government Affairs Compendium Update (January 1, 1990–April 30, 1990).
29.
Direct Marketing Association (1990b), Telemarketer's Guide to State Laws.
30.
Dun and Bradstreet v. Greenmoss Builders (1985), 105 U.S. 2939.
31.
Equifax (1990), Report on Consumers in the Information Age.
FarhiPaul (1989), “Some Machines Won't Take No For an Answer,” Washington Post National Weekly Magazine (October 16–22), 34 at col. 4.
34.
FisherPaul M., RichardsJohn W.Jr., BermanEarl J., and KrugmanDean M. (1989), “Recall and Eye Tracking Study of Adolescents Viewing Tobacco Advertisements,” Journal of the American Medical Association, 261 (January 6), 84–89.
35.
GeyelinMilo and CarnevaleMary Lu (1992), “Caller ID Service Is Ruled Illegal in Pennsylvania,” Wall Street Journal (March 20, 1992), B1.
36.
GivensRichard A. (1989), Antitrust: An Economic Approach.New York: Law Journals Seminars-Press.
37.
GlazerRashi H. (1991), “Marketing in Information-Intensive Environments: Strategic Implications of Knowledge as an Asset,” Journal of Marketing, 55 (October), 1–19.
38.
Guerin-CalvertMargaret E. (1989), “Vertical Integration as a Threat to Competition: Airline Computer Reservation Systems,” in The Antitrust Revolution, KwokaJohn E. and WhiteLawrence J., eds. Glenview, IL: Scott, Foresman & Co, 338–70.
39.
Harvard Law Review (1990), “The Legal and Regulatory Implications of Airline Computer Reservation Systems,” 103 (June), 1930–50.
40.
HerringPhil (1992), “Life Beyond the Spreadsheet,” Direct Marketing (February), 49–51.
41.
HonomichlJack (1992), “Industry Seeks Support for $500,000 Lobbying Effort,” Marketing News (March 2, 1992), 9.
42.
HumeScott (1991), “Consumers Target Ire at Data Bases,” Advertising Age (May 6).
43.
HyltonKeith N. (1991), “Economic Rents and Essential Facilities,” Brigham Young University Law Review, 191 (3), 1243–89.
44.
IngrassiaLawrence (1992), “Judge Says MIT Broke Antitrust Laws by Sharing Financial Aid Information,” Wall Street Journal (September 3), A4.
45.
In re Domestic Air Transportation Antitrust Litigation (1990), DC NGa, No. L90-CV-2485-MHS, MDL No. 861.
46.
LevyAlan S. (1992), “An Experimental Study of Food Label Formats,” completed by the Food and Drug Administration and presented at the 1992 Marketing and Public Policy Conference, Washington, DC (May 15).
47.
Marketing News (1990), “Environmentalists Give Nod to Some Direct Mail” (December 10), 7.
48.
MarxPeter (1988), “The Legal Risks of Using Information as a Competitive Weapon,” Software Law Journal, 2, 185–201.
49.
Maryland Commercial Law, Section 13–317. Use of consumer identification in connection with credit card payments.
50.
Maryland Commercial Law, Section 13–318. Use of credit card information in connection with payment by check.
51.
MazisMichael B., MorrisLouis A., and SwasyJohn L. (1991), “An Evaluation of the Alcohol Warning Label: Initial Survey Results,” Journal of Public Policy and Marketing, 10 (1), 229–41.
52.
MCI Communications v. AT&T (1983) 708 F. 2d 1081 (7th Cir.), cert. denied, 464 U.S. 891.
53.
MenellPeter S. (1987), “Tailoring Legal Protection for Computer Software,” Stanford Law Review, 39 (July), 1329–72.
54.
MillerCyndee (1989), “Telemarketing Foes: Don't Reach Out to Us,” Marketing News, 23 (July 3), 1,14.
55.
MillerMichael W. (1990), “Coming Soon to Your Local Video Store: Big Brother,” Wall Street Journal (December 26), 12.
56.
MillerMichael W. (1991a), “Six States Sue TRW Over Credit-Reporting Practices,” Wall Street Journal (July 10), B1.
57.
MillerMichael W. (1991b), “Lotus is Likely to Abandon Consumer Data Project,” Wall Street Journal (January 23), B1.
58.
MillerMichael W. (1991c), ‘“Greens’ Add to Junk Mail Mountain,” Wall Street Journal (May 13), B1.
59.
MillerMichael W. (1992), “Patients’ Records Are Treasure Trove For Budding Industry,” Wall Street Journal (February 27), A1.
60.
NomaniAsra Q. (1991a), “TWA Settles Price-Fixing Suit, Meaning Sweeter Deals for Passengers Involved,” Wall Street Journal (June 20), A4.
61.
NomaniAsra Q. (1991b), “NWA, TWA Agree to Alter Pricing Actions,” Wall Street Journal (June 21), B1.
62.
O'CallaghanRamon, KaufmannPatrick J., and KonsynskiBenn R. (1992), “Adoption Correlates and Share Effects of Electronic Data Interchange Systems in Marketing Channels,” Journal of Marketing, 56 (April), 45–56.
63.
Otter Tail Power v. U.S. (1973), 410 U.S. 366.
64.
PeckRobert S. (1984), “Extending the Constitutional Right to Privacy in the New Technological Age,” Hofstra Law Review, 12 (Summer), 893–912.
65.
PodellDavid M. (1989), “The Evolution of the Essential Facilities Doctrine and its Application to the Deregulation of the Natural Gas Industry,” Tulsa Law Journal, 24, 605–25.
66.
Privacy Act of1974, 5 U.S.C. § 552a et. seq.
67.
PulleyBrett and O'BrianBridget (1992), “More Airlines to Settle Suit on Price-Fixing,” Wall Street Journal (June 23), A3.
68.
RaddingAlan (1991), “Consumers Worry Halts Data Bases,” Advertising Age (February 11), 28.
69.
RangaswamyArvind, EliashbergJehoshua, BurkeRaymond R., and WindJerry (1989), “Developing Marketing Expert Systems: An Application to International Negotiations,” Journal of Marketing, 53 (October), 24–39.
70.
RebelloKathy (1993), “Is Microsoft Too Powerful?” Business Week (March 1), 82–90.
71.
Right to Financial Privacy Act of 1978, 12 U.S.C. § 1341 et. seq.
72.
RothfederJeffrey (1992), Privacy for Sale.New York: Simon and Schuster.
73.
SalopSteven C. (1986), “Practices that (Credibly) Facilitate Oligopoly Co-ordination,” in New Developments in the Analysis of Market Structure, StiglitzJoseph E. and MathewsonG. Frank, eds. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press, 265–94.
74.
SanchezJesus (1992), “Airline Lawsuit Won't Mean Quick Benefits for Consumers,” Raleigh News and Observer (December 27), F1.
75.
SimitisSpiros (1987), “Reviewing Privacy in an Information Society,” University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 135 (March), 707–46.
76.
SmithGlenn Chatmass (1989), “We've Got Your Number! (Is It Constitutional to Give It Out?): Caller Identification Technology and the Right to Informational Privacy,” UCLA Law Review, 37 (13), 145–223.
77.
StaceyRobert T. (1992), “Canada's Push for Privacy Legislation,” Direct Marketing (March), 57.
78.
SternLouis W. and EovaldiThomas L. (1984), Legal Aspects of Marketing Strategy: Antitrust and Consumer Protection Issues.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.
79.
Texas v. TRW, Inc. (1991), Texas DistCt (Dallas), No. 91-07999, 7/8/91.
80.
TRW, Inc. v. Texas (1991), DC NTexas, No. CA3-91-1340 H, 7/8/91.
81.
United Airlines et al. v. Civil Aeronautics Board (1985), 776 F.2d 1107, 1109 (7th Cir., petition denied).
82.
U.S. v. Brown University et al. (1991), DC E PA, May.
83.
U.S. v. Container Corporation of America (1969), 399 U.S. 333.
84.
U.S. v. Terminal Railroad Assn. (1912), 224 U.S. 383.
85.
U.S. v. United States Gypsum Co. (1978), 43 U.S. 422.
