Written Language Maturity and Formal Reasoning in Male and Female Adolescents

Abstract

The purpose of the present study was to test the hypothesis that a significant relationship exists between the development of formal reasoning and written language maturity as measured by length of minimal terminable units or T-units. Fifty subjects (25 males, mean-age 14.67 years and 25 females, mean-age 14.50 years) enrolled in high school freshman English classes were administered a series of 15 reasoning tasks requiring various aspects of formal reasoning for solution plus a test of field dependence-independence. Subjects were also given an in-class assignment to write an essay of 500 words about an important object in their lives.

Various aspects of formal reasoning were found to correlate significantly with mean T-unit length for the males (r = 0.28 N.S. to 0.58 p < 0.001). The cumulative reasoning score correlated at 0.59 p < 0.001 with mean T-unit length. These coefficients were not substantially altered when field dependence-independence was partialled out.

Surprisingly, for the females, formal reasoning did not correlate significantly with mean T-unit length. Although the reason for the discrepancy between the results for males and females is not clear, it is suggested that the reasoning tasks may be biased against females, and therefore not adequately assess their level of intellectual development.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Crutchfield, R.S. , Woodworth, D.G. and Albrecht, R.S. ( 1958). Perceptual performance and the effective person. Report of the Personnel Laboratory, Lackland Air Force Base, Texas.

Davelaar, E. ( 1977). Formal operational reasoning and its relationship to complex speech patterns and tentative statement use. Language and Speech, 20, 73-9.

Greenfield, P. ( 1972). Oral or written language: the consequences of cognitive development in Africa, the United States and England. Language and Speech, 15, 169-78.

Hunt, K.W. ( 1965). Grammatical Studies Written at Three Grade Levels . Nat. Council of Teachers of Eng., Res. Rep. No. 3.

Hunt, K.W. ( 1970). Syntactic maturity in school children and adults . Monog. of the Soc. for Res. in Child Devel., Serial No. 134, Vol. 35.

Inhelder, B. and Piaget, J. ( 1958). The Growth of Logical Thinking from Childhood to Adolescence (New York).

Jones, P.A. ( 1972). Formal operational reasoning and use of tentative statements . Cog. Psych., 3, 467-71.

Kagan, J. ( 1964). Acquisition and significance of sex typing and sex-role identity. In M.L. Hoffman and L.W. Hoffman (eds.), Review of Child Development Research (New York).

Karplus, R. and Lavatelli, C. ( 1969). The Development Theory of Piaget: Conservation ( San Francisco).

10.

Lawson, A.E. ( 1977). Relationships among performances on three formal operations tasks. J. of Psych., 96, 235-42.

11.

Lawson, A.E. ( 1978). The development and validation of a classroom test of formal operations. J. of Res. in Sci. Teaching, 15, 11-24.

12.

Loban, W. ( 1963). The Language of Elementary School Children. Nat. Council of Teachers of Eng., Res. Rep. No. 1.

13.

Longeot, F. ( 1965). Analyse statistique de trois tests génétiques collectifs. Bulletin de l'Institut National d'Etude du Travail et d'Orientation Professionelle, 20, 219-37.

14.

Milton, G.A. ( 1958). Five studies of the relation between sex role identification and achievement in problem solving. Tech. Rep., No. 3, Dept. of Indust. Admin., Dept. of Psych, Yale University .

15.

Neimark, E.D. ( 1975). Intellectual development during adolescence. In F.D. Horowitz (ed.), Review of Child Development Research (Chicago).

16.

Neimark, E.D. ( 1977). Toward the disembedding of formal operations from confounding with cognitive style. Symp. paper at the Seventh Ann. Meeting of the Jean Piaget Soc.

17.

O'Donnel, R.C. , Griffin, W.J. and Norris, R.C. ( 1967). Syntax of Kindergarten and Elementary School Children: A Transformational Analysis. Nat. Council of Teachers of Eng., Res. Rep. No. 8.

18.

Piaget, J. and Inhelder, B. ( 1962). Le Développement des quantités physiques chez l'enfant, 2nd ed. (Neuchâtel ).

19.

Piaget, J. and Inhelder, B. ( 1975). The Origin of the Idea of Chance in Children ( New York).

20.

Rosenthal, D.A. ( 1977). Language skills and formal operations. Unpublished Ms . Melbourne State College.

21.

Suarez, A. and Rhonheimer. (1974) Lineare Funktion (Zurich).

22.

Witkin, H.A. , Oltman, P.K. , Raskin, E. and Karp, S.A. ( 1971). A Manual for the Embedded Figures Tests ( Palo Alto, California).

23.

Wollman, W. ( 1977). Controlling variables: assessing levels of understanding . Sci. Ed., 61, 371-83.