Attachment Representations in a Sample of Neglected Preschool-Age Children

Abstract

A number of studies (see Éthier, 1999) have shown that neglect has a deleterious impact on children's development. However, the effect of neglect on a child's internal representations of their family still needs to be investigated. The aim of this study was to examine the attachment patterns observed in a subsample of neglected children as compared with a control group, using a representational assessment method. The overall sample consisted of 74 preschool-age children, with a clinical group comprised of 39 children referred to social services because of neglect and a control group including 35 children recruited in ordinary kindergartens. Children's attachment representations were assessed with the Doll Play Narrative Classification System (George and Solomon, 1990, 1996, 2000) as well as the complementary Disorganization Scales (George and Solomon, 1998). Mothers' reports consisted of: (1) an in-house socio-demographical questionnaire and (2) the shorter French version of the Parental Stress Index (Bigras et al., 1996). Results showed: (1) a significant difference in attachment representation classifications between the neglected group and the control group even when socio-economic status and maternal stress were controlled for and (2) a significantly higher proportion of avoidant attachment classification in the neglected group. Moreover, neglected avoidant children displayed more overall disorganized markers, and specifically more frightening markers, than normative avoidant children; they also depicted their mother as being less available than normative children. These results are discussed in the light of other findings as well as on theoretical grounds.

Keywords

attachment doll play narratives internal representations neglect preschool age

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adam, K. (1994) `Suicidal Behaviour and Attachment: A Developmental Model', in M. B. Sperling and W. H. Berman (eds) Attachment in Adults: Clinical and Developmental Perspectives, pp. 275—98. New York: Guilford Press.

Ainsworth, M.D.S. , Blehar, M.C. , Waters, E. and Wall, S. (1978) Patterns of Attachment: A Psychological Study of The Strange Situation. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

Bar-Haim, Y. Sutton, B. , Fox, N. and Marvin, R. (2000) `Stability and Change of Attachment at 14, 24, and 58 Months of Age: Behavior, Representation, and Life Events', Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry and Allied Disciplines 41(3): 381—88.

Barnett, D. , Ganiban, J. and Cicchetti, D. (1997) Maltreatment, Emotional Reactivity, and the Development of Type D Attachments from 12- to 24-Months of Age. Unpublished manuscript.

Bigras, M. , LaFrenière, P.J. and Abidin, R.R. (1996) Indice de stress parental: Manuel d'utilisation . Toronto: Multi-Health Systems Inc.

Bigras, M. and Dessen, M.A. (2002) `Social Competence and Behaviour Evaluation in Brazilian Preschoolers', Early Educationand Development 13(2): 139—51.

Bohlin, G. , Hagekull, B. and Rydell, A.-M. (2000), `Attachment and Social Functioning: A Longitudinal Study from Infancy to Middle Childhood', Social Development 9(1): 24—39.

Bowlby, J. (1953) Child Care and the Growth of Love. Harmondsworth: Penguin.

Bowlby, J. (1969/1982) Attachment and Loss, Vol. 1: Attachment New York: Basic Books.

10.

Bowlby, J. (1973) Attachment and Loss, Vol. 2: Separation. New York: Basic Books.

11.

Bowlby, J. (1980) Attachment and Loss, Vol. 3: Loss, Sadness and Depression. New York: Basic Books .

12.

Bretherton, I. and Munholland, K.A. (1999) `Internal Working Models in Attachment Relationships: A Construct Revisited', in J. Cassidy and P. R. Shaver (eds) Handbook of Attachment: Theory, Research, and Clinical Applications, pp. 89—111. New York: Guilford.

13.

Bretherton, I. , Oppenheim, D. , Buchsbaum, H. and Emde, R.N. and the MacArthur Narrative Group ( 1990) MacArthur Story-Stem Battery. Unpublished manual.

14.

Bretherton, I. , Ridgeway, D. and Cassidy, J. (1990) `Assessing Internal Working Models of the Attachment Relationship: An Attachment Story Completion Task for Three-Year-Olds', in M. T. Greenberg , D. Cicchetti and E. M. Cummings (eds) Attachment in the Preschool Years: Theory, Research, and Intervention , pp. 273—308. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

15.

Bus, A.G. , Belsky, J. , van IJzendoorn, M.H. and Crnic, K. (1997) `Attachment and Book-Reading Patterns: A Study of Mothers, Fathers, and Their Toddlers', Early Childhood Research Quarterly 12(1): 81—98.

16.

Carlson, E.A. (1998) `A Prospective Longitudinal Study of Attachment Disorganization/Disorientation', Child Development 69(4): 1107—28.

17.

Carlson, E.A. , Sroufe, A. and Egeland, B. (2004) `The Construction of Experience: A Longitudinal Study of Representation and Behavior', Child Development 75(1): 66—83.

18.

Cassibba, R. , Van IJzendoorn, M.H. and D'Odorico, L. (2000) `Reliability and Validity of the Attachment Q-Sort for Mothers and Professional Caregivers in Italy', International Journal of Behavioral Development 24(2): 241—55.

19.

Cassidy, J. (2003) `Continuity and Change in the Measurement of Infant Attachment: Comment on Fraley and Spieker (2003)', Developmental Psychology 39(3): 409—12.

20.

Cassidy, J. and Kobak, R.R. (1988) `Avoidance and its Relation to Other Defensive Processes', in J. Belsky and T. Neyworski (eds) Clinical Implications of Attachment Child Psychology, pp. 300—23. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

21.

Cassidy, J. and Marvin, R.S. with the MacArthur Working Group on Attachment (1992) Attachment Organization in Three and Four Year Olds: Procedures and Coding Manual. Unpublished manuscript, University of Virginia.

22.

Cassidy, J. and Berlin, L.J. (1994) `The Insecure/Ambivalent Pattern of Attachment: Theory and Research', Child Development 65: 971—91.

23.

Cicchetti, D. and Barnett, D. (1992) `Attachment Organization in Maltreated Preschoolers' , Development and Psychopathology 3: 397—411.

24.

Cohn, D.A. (1990) `Child—Mother Attachment of Six-Year-Olds and Social Competence at School', Child Development 61: 152—16.

25.

Crittenden, P.M. (2000) `A Dynamic-Maturational Approach to Continuity and Change in Pattern of Attachment', in P. M. Crittenden and A. H. Claussen (eds) The Organization of Attachment Relationships, pp. 343—58. New York: Cambridge University Press.

26.

Culp, R.E. , Watkins, R.V. , Lawrence, H. and Letts, D. (1991) `Maltreated Children's Language and Speech Development: Abused, Neglected, and Abused and Neglected', First Language 11(33, Pt. 3): 377—89.

27.

DiTommaso, E. , Brannen-McNulty, C. , Ross, L. and Burgess, M. (2003) `Attachment Styles, Social Skills and Loneliness in Young Adults', Personality and Individual Differences 35(2): 303—12.

28.

Easterbrooks, M.A. and Abeles, R. (2000) `Windows to the Self in Eight-Year-Olds: Bridges to Attachment Representation and Behavioral Adjustment', Attachment and Human Development 2: 85—106.

29.

Eckenrode, J. , Laird, M. and Doris, J. (1993) `School Performance and Disciplinary Problems Among Abused and Neglected Children', Developmental Psychology 29(1): 53—62.

30.

Egeland, B. , Sroufe, A. and Erickson, M. (1983) `The Developmental Consequence of Different Patterns of Maltreatment', Child Abuse and Neglect 7: 459—69.

31.

Erickson, M. , Egeland, B. and Pianta, R. (1989) `The Effects of Maltreatment on the Development of Young Children', in D. Cicchetti and V. Carlson (eds) Child Maltreatment: Theory and Research on the Causes and Consequences of child Abuse and Neglect , pp. 647—84. New York: Cambridge University Press.

32.

Erickson, M.F. and Egeland, B. (1996) `A Developmental View of Psychological Consequences of the Psychological Consequences of Maltreatment', School Psychology Review 16(2): 156—68.

33.

Erickson, M.F. , Sroufe, L.A. and Egeland, B. (1985) `The Relationship of Quality of Attachment and Behavior Problems in Preschool in a High Risk Sample', in I. Bretherton and E. Waters (eds) Growing Points in Attachment Theory and Research . Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 50(1—2, serial no. 209).

34.

Éthier, L.S. , Couture, G. and Lacharité, C. (2004) `Risk Factors Associated with the Chronicity of High Potential for Child Abuse and Neglect', Journal of Family Violence 19: 13—24.

35.

Éthier, L.S. (1999) `La négligence et la violence envers les enfants' , in E. Habimana , L. S. Éthier , D. Petot and M. Tousignant (eds) Psychopathologie de l'enfant et de l'adolescent, pp. 595—611. Montréal: Gaetan Morin.

36.

Evans, L.D. (2001) `Interactional Models of Learning Disabilities: Evidence From Students Entering Foster Care', Psychology in the Schools 38(4): 381—92.

37.

Farinatti, F.A. , Fonseca, N.M. , Dondonis, M. and Brugger, E. (1990) `Child Abuse and Neglect in a Developing Country' , Child Abuse and Neglect 14(1): 133—34.

38.

Fonagy, P. , Steele, M. , Stelle, H. , Leigh, T. , Kennedy, R. , Mattoon, G. and Target, M. (1995) `Attachment, the Reflective Self, and Borderline States: The Predictive Specificity of the Adult Attachment Interview and Pathological Emotional Development', in S. Goldberg , R. Muir and J. Kerr (eds) Attachment Theory: Social, Developmental, and Clinical Perspectives , pp. 233—78. Hillsdale, NJ: The Analytic Press.

39.

Gauvain, M. and Rogoff, B. (1989) `Collaborative Problem Solving and Children's Planning Skills', Developmental Psychology 25: 139—51.

40.

George, C. and Solomon, J. (1990, 1996, 2000) Six-Year Attachment Doll Play Classification System. Unpublished Classification Manual. Mills College, Oakland, CA.

41.

George, C. and Solomon, J. (1998) Six-Year Doll Play Classification System Supplement Attachment Disorganization Coding. Unpublished Classification Manual. Mills College, Oakland, CA.

42.

Granot, D. and Mayseless, O. (2001) `Attachment Security and Adjustment to School in Middle Childhood', International Journal of Behavioural Development 25(6): 530—41.

43.

Greenberg, M.T. , Speltz, M.L. , DeKlyen, M. and Endriga, M.C. (1991) `Attachment Security in Preschoolers With and Without Externalizing Problems: A Replication', Development and Psychopathology 3: 413—30.

44.

Harvey, M. and Byrd, M. (1998) `The Relationship Between Perceptions of Self-Esteem, Patterns of Familial Attachment, and Family Environment During Early and Late Phases of Adolescence', International Journal of Adolescence and Youth 7(2): 93—111.

45.

Hildyard, K.L. and. Wolfe, D.A. (2002) `Child Neglect: Developmental Issues and Outcomes' , Child Abuse and Neglect 26(6—7): 679—95.

46.

Howes, C. (1999) `Attachment Relationships in the Context of Multiple Caregivers', in J. Cassidy and P. R. Shaver (eds) Handbook of Attachment: Theory and Research, pp. 671—87. New York: Guilford.

47.

Jacobsen, T. , Edelstein, W. and Hofmann, V. (1994) `A Longitudinal Study of the Relation Between Representations of Attachment in Childhood and Cognitive Functioning in Childhood and Adolescence' , Developmental Psychology 30(1): 112—24.

48.

Jacobsen, T. and Hofmann, V. (1997) `Children's Attachment Representations: Longitudinal Relations to School Behavior and Academic Competency in Middle Childhood and Adolescence', Developmental Psychology 33: 703—10.

49.

Jimerson, S. , Egeland, B. , Sroufe, L.A. and Carlson, B. (2000) `A Prospective Longitudinal Study of High School Dropouts Examining Multiple Predictors Across Development', Journal of School Psychology 38: 525—49.

50.

Kendall-Tackett, K.A. and Eckenrode, J. (1996) `The Effects of Neglect on Academic Achievement and Disciplinary Problems: A Developmental Perspective', Child Abuse and Neglect 20(3): 161—69

51.

Kennedy, J.H. and Kennedy, C.E. (2004) `Attachment Theory: Implications for School Psychology' , Psychology in the Schools 41(2): 247—59.

52.

Klagsbrun, M. and Bowlby, J. (1976) `Responses to Separation from Parents: A Clinical Test for Young Children', British Journal of Projective Psychology 21: 7—27.

53.

Kovess, V. and Fournier, L. (1990) `The DISSA: An Abridged Self-Administered Version of the DIS', Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 25: 179—86.

54.

Larose, S. , Bernier, A. and Tarabulsy, G.M. (2005) `Attachment State of Mind, Learning Dispositions, and Academic Performance During the College Transition', Developmental Psychology 41: 281—89.

55.

Leiter J. and Johnsen, M.C. (1997) `Child Maltreatment and School Performance Declines: An Event-History Analysis', American Educational Research Journal 34(3): 563—89.

56.

Leiter, J. and Johnsen, M.C. (1994) `Child Maltreatment and School Performance', American Journal of Education 102(2): 154—89.

57.

Lyons-Ruth, K. , Alpern, L. and Repacholi, B. (1993) `Disorganized Infant Attachment Classification and Maternal Psychosocial Problems as Predictors of Hostile-Aggressive Behavior in the Preschool Classroom', Child Development 64: 572—85.

58.

Lyons-Ruth, K. , Easterbrooks, A. and Cibelli, C. (1997) `Infant Attachment Strategies, Infant Mental Lag, and Maternal Depressive Symptoms: Predictors of Internalizing and Externalizing Problems at Age Seven', Development and Psychopathology 3: 377—96.

59.

Lyons-Ruth, K. , Connell, D.B. , Grunebaum, H.U. and Botein, S. (1990) `Infants at Social Risk: Maternal Depression and Support Services as Mediators of Infant Development and of Attachment', Child Development 61: 85—98.

60.

Lyons-Ruth, K. , Melnick, S. , Bronfman, E. , Sherry, S. and Llanas, L. (2004) `Hostile-Helpless Relational Models and Disorganized Attachment Patterns Between Parents and Their Young Children: Review of Research and Implications for Clinical Work', in L. Atkinson and S. Goldberg (eds) Attachment Issues in Psychopathology and Intervention, pp. 65—94. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

61.

Main, M. and Cassidy, J. (1988) `Categories of Response to Reunion with the Parent at Age Six: Predictable from Infant Attachment Classifications and Stable Over a One-Month Period', Developmental Psychology 24: 415—526.

62.

Main, M. and Solomon, J. (1990) `Procedures for Identifying Infants as Disorganized/Disoriented During the Ainsworth Strange Situation', in M. T. Greenberg , D. Cicchetti , and E. M. Cummings (eds) Attachment in the Preschool Years, pp. 121—60. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

63.

Main, M. , Kaplan, N. and Cassidy, J. (1985) `Security of Attachment in Infancy, Childhood, and Adulthood: A Move to the Level of Representation', in I. Bretherton and E. Waters (eds) Growing Points in Attachment Theory and Research . Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development 50 (1—2, serial no. 209): 66—104.

64.

Marcus, R.F. and Sanders-Reio, J. (2001) `The Influence of Attachment on School Completion', School Psychology Quarterly 16(4): 427—44.

65.

Meins, E. , Fernyhough, C. , Russell, J. and Clark-Carter, D. (1998) `Security of Attachment as a Predictor of Symbolic and Mentalising Abilities: A Longitudinal Study' , Social Development 7(1): 1—24.

66.

Milne, L.C. and Lancaster, S. (2001) `Predictors of Depression in Female Adolescents' , Adolescence 36(142): 207—23.

67.

Moss, E. , Rousseau, D. , Parent, S. , St-Laurent, D. and Saintonge, J. (1998) `Correlates of Attachment at School Age: Maternal Reported Stress, Mother-Child Interaction, and Behavior Problems', Child Development 69(5): 1390—405.

68.

Moss, E. and St-Laurent, D. (2001) `Attachment at School Age and Academic Performance' , Developmental Psychology 37: 863—74.

69.

Moss, E. , Bureau, J. , Cyr, C. , Mongeau, C. and St-Laurent, D. (2004) `Correlates of Attachment at Age Three: Construct Validity of the Preschool Attachment Classification System', Developmental Psychology 40(3): 323— 34.

70.

Moss, E. , Cyr, C. , Bureau, J.-F. , Tarabulsy, G.M. and Mongeau, C. (2005) `Stability of Attachment Between Preschool and Early School-Age and Factors Contributing to Continity/Discontinuity', Developmental Psychology 41: 773—83.

71.

Moss, E. , Parent, S. , Gosselin, C. , Rousseau, D. and St-Laurent, D. (1996) `Attachment and Teacher-Reported Behavior Problems During the Preschool and Early School-Age Period', Development and Psychopathology 8: 511—25.

72.

Moss, E. , St-Laurent, D. , Rousseau, D. , Parent, S. , Gosselin, C. and Saintonge, J. (1999) `L'attachement à l'âge scolaire et le développement des troubles de comportements', Revue Canadienne des Sciences du Comportement 31: 107—18.

73.

Munson, J.A. , McMahon, R.J. and Spieker, S.J. (2001) `Structure And Variability In The Developmental Trajectory Of Children's Externalizing Problems: Impact Of Infant Attachment, Maternal Depressive Symptomatology, And Child Sex', Development and Psychopathology 13: 277—96.

74.

Muris, P. , Meesters, C. , van Melick, M. and Zwambag, L. (2001) `Self-Reported Attachment Style, Attachment Quality, and Symptoms of Anxiety and Depression in Young Adolescents', Personality and Individual Differences 30(5): 809—18

75.

Pallacio-Quintin, E. and Jourdan-Ionescu, C. (1994) `Effets de la négligence et de la violence sur le développement des jeunes enfants', PRISME 4(1): 145—56.

76.

Pauzé, R. , Toupin, J. , Déry, M. , Mercier, H. , Joly, J. , Cyr, M. , Cyr, F. , Frappier, J.-Y. , Chamberland, C. And Robert, M. (2004) `Section 2: Portrait des jeunes âgés de 0 à 5 ans' , in Portrait des jeunes âgés de 0 à 17 ans référés à la prise en charge des Centres jeunesse du Québec, leur parcours dans les services et leur évolution dans le temps. Sherbrooke: GRISE.

77.

Peretti, P.O. , Early, K. and Chmura, J. (1998) `Chronic and Acute Neglected Children: Psychological Variables', Social Behavior and Personality 26(2): 175—80.

78.

Pianta, R.C. ( 1997) `Adult—Child Relationship Processes and Early Schooling', Early Education and Development 8(1): 11—26.

79.

Pianta, R.C. and Steinberg (1992) `Teacher—Child Relationships and Adjusting to School', in R. C. Pianta (ed.) New Directions in Child Development (57) Beyond the Parent: The Role of Other Adults in Children's Lives, pp. 61—79. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

80.

Polansky, N.A. , Ammons, P.W. and Gaudin, J.M. (1985) `Loneliness and Isolation in Child Neglect', Social Casework 66(1): 38—47.

81.

Prino, C.T. and Peyrot, M. (1994) `The Effect of Child Physical Abuse and Neglect on Aggressive, Withdrawn, and Prosocial Behavior', Abuse and Neglect 18(10): 871—84.

82.

Renken, B. , Egeland, B. , Marvinney, D. , Manglesdorf, S. and Sroufe, L.A. (1989) `Early Childhood Antecedents of Aggression and Passive-Withdrawal in Early Elementary School', Journal of Personality 57: 257—81.

83.

Roberts, M.C. (1996) Model Programs in Child and Family Mental Health . Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.

84.

Roditti, M.G. (2005) `Understanding Communities of Neglectful Parents: Child Cargiving Networks and Child Neglect', Child Welfare League of America 84(2): 277—98.

85.

Rohner, R.P. (1984) Measurement of Parental Acceptance-Rejection and Its Social-Emotional Consequences. Center for the Study of Parental Acceptance and Rejection. The University of Connecticut, CT.

86.

Rowe, E. and Eckenrode, J. (1999) `The Timing of Academic Difficulties Among Maltreated and Nonmaltreated Children', Child Abuse and Neglect 23(8): 813—32.

87.

Schindler, A. , Thomasius, R. , Sack, P-M. , Gemeinhardt, B. , Kusstner, U. And Eckert, J. (2005) `Attachment and Substance Use Disorders: A Review of the Literature and a Study in Drug Dependant Adolescents', Attachment and Human Development 7(3): 207—28.

88.

Shaw, D.S. , Keenan, K. , Vondra, J.I. , Delliquadri, E. and Giovanelli, J. (1997) `Antecedents of Preschool Children's Internalizing Problems: A Longitudinal Study of Low-Income Families', Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 36: 1760—67.

89.

Shaw, D.S. , Owens, E.B. , Vondra, J.I. , Keenan, K. and Winslow, E. (1996) `Early Risk Factors and Pathways in the Development of Early Disruptive Behavior Problems', Development and Psychopathology 8: 679—99.

90.

Solomon, J. , George, C. and De Jong, A. (1995) `Children Classified as Controlling at Age Six: Evidence of Disorganized Representational Strategies and Aggression at Home and at School', Development and Psychology 7: 447—63.

91.

Speltz, M.L. , Greenberg, M.T. and DeKlyen, M. (1990) `Attachment in Preschoolers with Disruptive Behavior: A Comparison of Clinic-Referred and Nonproblem Children', Development and Psychopathology 2: 31—46.

92.

St-Laurent, D. , Bureau, J-F. and Moss, E. (2005) `Attachment, Academic Performance, and Self-Regulatory and Motivational Processes: A Closer Look at Disorganized Attachment', Society for Research in Child Development (SRCD), Atlanta, GA, USA.

93.

Teti, D.M. and Gelfand, D.M. (1997) `The Preschool Assessment of Attachment: Construct Validity in a Sample of Depressed and Non Depressed Families', Development and Psychopathology 9(3): 517—36.

94.

Valenzuela, M. (1990) `Attachment in Chronically Underweight Young Children' , Child Development 61: 1984—996.

95.

van IJzendoorn, M.H. , Schuengel, C. and Bakermans-Kraneburg, M.J. (1999) Disorganized Attachment in Early Childhood: Meta-Analysis of Precursors, Concomitants, and Sequalae ', Developmental Psychopathology 11(2): 225—49.

96.

Venet, M. and Pauzé, R. (2005) `Les effets de la négligence sur des enfants québécois d'âge préscolaire', Colloque franco-québécois IPSA/ISCEA, Université catholique de l'ouest, Angers, April 2005.

97.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1978) Mind in Society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

98.

Warren, S.L. , Huston, L. , Egeland, B. and Sroufe, A. (1997) `Child and Adolescent Anxiety Disorders and Early Attachment', Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 36(5): 637—44.

99.

Wartner, U.G. , Grossmann, K. , Fremmer-Bombik, E. and Suess, G. (1994) `Attachment Patterns at Age Six in South Germany: Predictability from Infancy and Implications for Preschool Behavior', Child Development 65: 1014—27.

100.

Winnicott, D.W. (1975) Jeu et réalité: l'espace potentiel. Paris: Gallimard.

101.

Wodarski, J.S. , Kurtz, P.D. , Gaudain, J.M. and Howing, P.T. (1990) `Maltreatment and the School-Age Child: Major Academic, Socioemotional, and Adaptive Outcomes', Social Work 35(6): 506—13.

102.

Youngblade, L.M. and Belsky, J. (1989) `Child Maltreatment, Infant-Parent Attachment Security, and Dysfunctional Peer Relationships in Toddler-hood', TECSE 9(2): 1—15.

103.

Zingraff, M.T. , Leiter, J. , Johnsen, M.C. and Myers, K.A. (1994) `The Mediating Effect of Good School Performance on the Maltreatment-Delinquency Relationship', Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency 31(1): 62—91.