An Evaluation of the Paired Reading Program Using Competency-Based Training

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of the Paired Reading (PR) method using a competency-based training program with parents of children who are poor readers. PR consists of two phases: simultaneous and independent reading. The PR method focuses on parent modeling, practice, praise and a positive atmosphere. Fifty-two parents of second and third graders receiving Chapter 1 services and fourth graders who received Chapter 1 services in the year prior were recruited for this study. Participants were assigned to either the experimental (PR) condition where they were trained to use the PR Program through a competency-based training format or to a wait-list control condition. Twenty-four of the 26 parents in the PR condition participated in the training. Parents were asked to read with their child using the PR method five times a week, for 10 to 15 minutes, across eight weeks and to tape record their reading sessions. Seven of those 24 parents returned all eight audio recordings of the reading sessions. Eight participants returned no tapes and 9 subjects returned between one and seven tapes. Overall reading improvement based on reading accuracy, rate and comprehension was assessed in the children, using difference scores obtained on the Paragraph Reading subtest of the Gray Oral Reading Test-Diagnostic. Child and parent perceptions of the child's reading skills and reading habits were also assessed. Comparisons were made between participants in the trained PR and untrained control conditions. Significant attrition effected the analysis of the data and an intent-to-treat-analysis was conducted. Children in the PR condition did not improve more than children in the control condition on overall reading scores. The small subset of children who completed the program did, however, improve more in their overall reading scores than their matched controls. A post-hoc analysis indicated that second and third graders who were receiving Chapter 1 services in school improved significantly in their overall reading scores and that the fourth graders, who no longer were eligible for Chapter 1 services in their school, did not show improvement over the course of this study. Implications and future directions are discussed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adams, M.J. (1990) Beginning to Read: Thinking and Learning About Print. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

Bandura, A. (1965) 'Influence of a Model's Reinforcement Contingencies on the Acquisition of Imitative Responses', Jour nal of Personality and Social Psychology 11: 589-595.

Bandura, A. (1977)Social Learnilg Theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Binkley, M.R. (1988)Becomninga Nation of Reader-s: What Parents Can Do. Office of Educational Research and Improvement of the US Department of Education.

Bryan, T. , Kidd, A. and Levey, M. (1985) 'The Kings Health Project', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds)Parental Involvement in Children's Reading, pp. 231-240. New York: Nichols Publishing.

Bush, A.M. (1982) 'Can Pupils' Reading be Improved by Involving their Parents?' Remedial Education 18: 167-170.

Bushell, R. , Miller, A. and Robson, D. (1982) 'Parents as Remedial Teachers', Journal of the Association of Educational Psychologists 5: 7-13.

Carrick-Smith, L. (1985) 'A Research Project in Paired Reading', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds)Parental Involvement in Children'sReading, pp. 143-52. New York: Nichols Publishing.

Cavazos, L. (1989) Educating our' Children: Parents and Schools Together. Washington, DC: Department of Education.

10.

Friedman, L. , Furberg, C. and DeMets, D. (1985) Fundamentals of Clinical Trials (2nd Edn). Littleton, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing.

11.

Hannon, P. , Jackson, A. and Page, B. (1985) 'Impleinentation and Take-up of a Project to Involve Parents in the Teaching of Reading', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds)Parental Involvement in Children'sReading, pp. 54-64. New York: Nichols Publishing.

12.

Hewison, J. (1985) 'Parental Involvement and Reading Attainment: Implications of Research in Dagenhamn and Haringey', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds) Parental Involvemenzt in Children's Reading, pp. 42-53. New York: Nichols Publishing.

13.

Holdsworth, P. (1985) 'Parental Involvement at Mobray School', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds)Parental Inuolvement in, Children'sReading, pp. 208- 24. New York: Nichols Publishing.

14.

Hresko, W.P. , Reid, D.K. , Hammill, D.D. , Ginsburgh, H.P. and Baroody, D.D. (1988) Screening Childr-en for Related Ear-ly Educational Needs. Austin, TX: PRO-ED.

15.

Jungnitz, G. (1985) 'A Research Project in Paired Reading', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds) Parental Involvement in Children's Reading, pp. 153-160. New York: Nichols Publishing.

16.

Law, M. and Kratochwill, T.R. (1993) 'Paired Reading: An Evaluation of a Parent Tutorial Program', School Psychology International 14: 119-147.

17.

Lindsay, G. , Evans, A. and Jones, B. (1985) 'Paired Reading versus Relaxed Reading: AComparison'.British Journal of Educational Psychology 55: 304-309.

18.

Mehran, M. and White, K.R. (1988) 'Parent Tutoring as a Supplement to (Compensatory Education for First-grade Children', RASE 9: 35-41.

19.

Morgan, R. and Lyon, E. (1979) '"Paired Reading"-A Preliminary Report on a Technique for Parental Tuition of Reading Retarded Children', Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry 20: 151-160.

20.

Newcomer, P.L. (1990) Diagnostic Achievement Battery, 2nd Edn., Austin, TX: PRO-ED.

21.

Pearson, L. and Lindsay, G. (1985) Special Needs in the Primary School: Identification and Intervention. Windsor, UK: NFER-Nelson.

22.

Pumfrey, P.D. (1986) 'Paired Reading: Promise and Pitfalls', Educational Research 28: 89-94.

23.

Ross, J.M. and Simpson, H.R. (1971) 'The National Survey of Health and Development: Educational Attainment', British Journal of Educational Psychology 41: 49-61.

24.

Swinson, J. (1985) 'Encouraging Parents to Listen to their Children Read', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds)Parental In volvement in Children's Reading, pp. 65-74. New York: Nichols Publishing.

25.

Thurstone, L.P. (1989) 'Helping Parents Tutor their Children: A Success Story', Academic Thzerapy 24: 579-587.

26.

Topping, K. (1985a) 'Parental Involvement in Reading: Theoretical and Empirical Background', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds)Parental Involvement in Children's Reading, pp. 17-31. New York: Nichols Publishing.

27.

Topping, K. (1985b) 'An Introduction to Paired Reading', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds) Parental Involvement in Children's Reading, pp. 109-114. New York: Nichols Publishing.

28.

Topping, K. (1986) 'WHICH Parental Involvement in Reading Scheme: A Guide for Practitioners', Reading 20: 148-156.

29.

Topping, K. (1987a) 'Paired Reading: A Powerful Technique for Parent Use', Thze Reading Teacher 40: 608-614.

30.

Topping, K. (1987b) 'Peer Tutored Paired Reading: Outcome Data from Ten Projects', Educational Psychology 7: 133-145.

31.

Topping, K. (1989) 'Peer Tutoring and Paired Reading: Combining Two Powerful Techniques', The Reading Teacher 42: 488-494.

32.

Topping, T. and McKnight, G. (1984) 'Paired Reading and Parent Power', Special Education-Forward Trends 11: 12-15.

33.

Topping, K. and Whiteley, M. (1988) 'Sex Differences in the Effectiveness of Peer Tutoring', Paired Reading Bulletin 4: 16-23.

34.

Topping, K. and Whiteley, M. (1990) 'Participant Evaluation of Parent-tutored and Peer-tutored Projects in Reading', Educational Research 32: 14-27.

35.

Vinograd-Bausell, C.R. , Bausell, R.B. , Proctor, W. and Chandler, B. (1986) 'Impact of Unsupervised Parent Tutors on Word Recognition Skills', Journal of Special Education 20: 83-89.

36.

Wilks, R.T.J. and Clarke, V.A. (1988) 'Training versus Nontraining of Mothers as Home Reading Tutors', Perceptual and Motor Skills 67: 135-142.

37.

Winter, S. (1989) 'Paired Reading Projects in Hong Kong: Second and Chinese Language Applications', School Psychology International 10: 25-35.

38.

Wolfendale, S. (1985) 'Overview of Parental Participation in Children's Education', in K. Topping and S. Wolfendale (eds) Parental Involvement in Children's Reading, pp. 3-16. New York: Nichols Publishing.

39.

Wolfendale, S. (1985) An Introduction to Parent Listening. New York: Nichols Publishing.