Comparison of peak load predictions and treatment of solar gains in the admittance and heat balance load calculation procedures

Abstract

Calculation of design cooling loads is of critical concern to designers of HVAC systems. The work reported here has been carried out under a joint ASHRAE-CIBSE research project to compare design cooling calculation methods. Peak cooling loads predicted by the ASHRAE heat balance method are compared with those predicted by a number of implementations of the admittance method using different window models. The results presented show the general trends in overprediction or underprediction of peak load. Particular attention is given to different window modelling practices. The performance of the methods is explained in terms of some of the underlying assumptions in the window models, and by reference to specific inter-model comparisons.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Spitler J.D. and Rees S.J.

Quantitative comparison of North American and UK cooling load calculation procedures-Methodology

ASHRAE Trans. 104(2) 36-46 (1998)

Rees S.J. , Spitler J.D. and Haves P.

Quantitative comparison of North American and UK cooling load calculation procedures-Results

ASHRAE Trans. 104(2) 47-61 (1998)

Romine T.B.

Cooling load calculation: art or science?

ASHRAE J. 34(1) 14-24 (1992)

Pedersen C.O. , Fisher D.E. and Liesen R.J.

Development of a heat balance procedure for calculating cooling loads

ASHRAE Trans. 103(2) 459-468 (1997)

Spitler J.D. Fisher D.E. and Pedersen C.O.

The radiant time series cooling load calculation procedure

ASHRAE Trans. 103(2) 503-515 (1997)

Ashrae 1997 ASHRAE handbook-Fundamentals (Atlanta: ASHRAE, Inc.) (1997)

McQuiston F.C. and Spitler J.D. Cooling and heating load calculation manual 2nd edn (Atlanta: ASHRAE, Inc.) (1992)

Cibse Guide A-Design Data ( London: CIBSE) (1986)

Danter E.

Periodic heat flow characteristics of simple walls and roof

J. Inst. Heating and Ventilating Engineers 28 136-146 (1960)

10.

Loudon A.G. Summertime temperatures in buildings without air conditioning Building Research Station Current Paper 47/68 (also J. Heating and Ventilating Engineen 32 280-292, 1970) (1968)

11.

Cibse Guide A-Design Data (London: CIBSE) ( 1999)

12.

Danter E.

Room response according to CIBSE Guide procedures

Building Serv. Eng. Res. Technol. 4(2) 46-51 (1983)

13.

Bloomfield D.P. BRE-ADMIT: Thermal design of buildings (Watford : BRE Publishing) (undated)

14.

Rees S.J. , Spitler J.D. , Davies M.G. and Haves P.

Qualitative comparison of North American and UK cooling load calculation methods

Int. J. Heating, Ventilating, Air-Condtioning and Refrigeration Research 6(1) 75-99

15.

Walton G.N.

A New algorithm for radiant interchange in room loads calculations

ASHRAE Trans. 86(2) 190-208 (1980)

16.

Blast Support Office BLAST (building loads and system thermodynamics) (Urbana-Champaign: University of Illinois) (1980)

17.

Walton G. Thermal analysis research program reference manual ( Washington DC: National Bureau of Standards) ( 1983)

18.

Rees S.J. and Spitler J.D.

Proposals for a building load diagnostic test procedure

ASHRAE Trans. 105(2) 514-526 (1999)

19.

Jones R. H.L.

Solar radiation through windows-theory and equations

Building Serv. Eng. Res. Technol. 1(2) 83-91 (1980)

20.

Nfrc Procedure for determining fenestration product solar heat gain coefficients at normal incidence. Standard 200-95 (National Fenestration Rating Council) (1995 )