Pressure transient identification of depleted appliance trap seals: a pressure pulse technique

Abstract

The appliance trap seal plays a vital role in safeguarding occupied space from ingress of foul sewer gases driven by the barrage of pressure transients generated within the system during normal appliance discharge. The health risks related to depleted trap seals can be severe. In 2003, the rapid spread of the SARS virus at the Amoy Gardens housing complex in Hong Kong was attributed to depleted bathroom floor-drain traps.

This paper presents a technique whereby depleted trap seals can be located remotely by monitoring the system response to an applied single pressure pulse. A Method of Characteristic based numerical model allows the system pressure response to be predicted while laboratory and site test results are shown to validate this proposed technique.

Practical application: Appliance trap seal depletion poses a serious health risk by providing a route for cross-contamination and infection spread. Implementing a routine and regular maintenance regime would help to ensure that the water level within the trap seal remains above the critical level. However, current methods rely on visual inspections which are highly impractical in large complex buildings. A technique allowing the status of all connected trap seals to be quickly determined would be an invaluable tool for facility managers by improving operational efficiency and by indicating persistent failures, thus, highlighting areas requiring modification to ensure performance compliance.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Swaffield JA , Galowin LS The engineered design of building drainage systems. 1992; England, Ashgate Publishing Limited .

World Health Organisation. Summary of SARS in the WHO European Region, CD News, Communicable Disease Report, No. 31, Oct. 2003.

World Health Organisation. Inadequate plumbing systems likely contributed to SARS transmission. Press Release WHO/70, 26 September 2003, WHO, Geneva.

Hung HCK , Chan Dwt , Law LKC , Chan EHW , Wong ESW. Industrial experience and research into the causes of SARS virus transmission in a high-rise residential housing estate in Hong Kong . Building Services Engineering Research and Technology 2006; 27(2): 91-102.

Jack LB Drainage design: factors contributing to SARS transmission . Proceedings of the Institute of Civil Engineers, ICE Municipal Engineer 159, March 2006; Issue ME1: 43-48.

Wylie EB , Streeter VL Fluid transients. New York, McGraw-Hill , 1979.

Swaffield JA , Boldy AP Pressure surge in pipe and duct systems. England, Avebury Technical Press , 1993.

Brunone B. Transient test-based technique for leak detection in outfall pipes . J Water Resour Plan Manage 1999; 125(5): 302-06.

Stephens M. , Vitkovsky J. , Lambert M. , Karney B. , Nixon J. Transient analysis to assess valve status and topology in pipe networks : 9th Int. Conf. Pressure Surge, BHR Group, Chester, 24-26 March 2004; 211-24.

10.

Lister M. The numerical simulation of hyperbolic partial differential equations by the Method of Characteristics. In: Ralston and Wilf (eds), Mathematical methods for digital computers. New York, John Wiley, 1960; pp. 165-79.

11.

Doyle TJ , Swaffield JA An evaluation of the method of characteristics applied to a pressure transient analysis of the Concord refuelling system : Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part E, 1972; 216: 133-42.

12.

McDougal JA , Swaffield JA The influence of water conservation on drain sizing for building drainage systems . Building Services Engineering Research and Technology 2003; 24(4): 229-43.

13.

Streeter VL Waterhammer analysis including fluid friction . J Hyd Div ASCE 1962; 39: 127-31.

14.

Swaffield JA , Campbell DP Numerical modelling of air pressure transient propagation in building drainage systems, including the influence of mechanical boundary conditions . Building and Environment 1992; 27(4): 455-67.

15.

Swaffield JA , Campbell DP Air pressure transient propagation in building drainage vent systems, an application of unsteady flow analysis . Building and Environment 1992; 27(3): 357-65.

16.

Swaffield JA , Jack LB Simulation and analysis of airborne cross contamination routes due to the operation of building drainage and vent systems . Building Research and Information 2004; 32(6): 451-67.

17.

Joukowsky N. Uber den hydraulisher Stoss in Wasserlietungsrohen . Memoirs de l'Academie Imperiale des Sciences de St Petersburg , 1900 , translated by Simin O. Proceedings American Water Works Association, 1904; 24: 341-424.