Development of an emulation method for the performance evaluation of radiant floor heating systems

Abstract

Since radiant floor heating systems utilise part of the building as a system for controlling the indoor environment, the integrated analysis considering the interaction between the building and the system needs to be conducted for the performance evaluation. Integrated simulation can be applied for this purpose; however, it is somewhat difficult to evaluate the impact of the system hardware such as hydronic circuits and heat sources due to the lack of modeling information. Although the experimental methods can guarantee the most reliable results, they have a limitation on the repetitive comparison due to the restriction of time, space and cost. For this reason, this study presents an emulation method that can mitigate the disadvantage of the simulation as well as experimental methods, especially for the performance evaluation of radiant floor heating systems. To achieve this, the factors to be considered in radiant floor heating systems were examined by reviewing the previous studies on the emulation. This study suggested an emulation method that can physically represent pressure loss in the hydronic circuits and heat output from the floor structure, which are distinguishing features of radiant floor heating systems. With the developed emulation method, this study showed that the control performance and energy consumption of a radiant floor heating system can be investigated.

Practical application: This study presents an emulation method to evaluate the energy consumption and control performance of radiant floor heating systems. The proposed emulation method will be able to supplement a pure simulation and to contribute to the development of an evaluation method considering the impact of system hardware on the overall performance of radiant floor heating systems. Therefore, it is expected that the results will be helpful to researchers for indoor environment, heating, ventilating and air conditioning engineers, system manufacturers and those who want to analyse the energy performance of radiant floor heating systems.

Keywords

Radiant floor heating system emulator emulation hydronic circuit performance evaluation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Hensen

. Towards an integral approach of building and HVAC system. Energy Building 1993; 19: 297–302.

Athienitis

. A methodology for integrated building-HVAC system thermal analysis. Building Environ 1993; 28: 483–496.

Crawley

Lawrie

Pederson

. EnergyPlus: energy simulation program. ASHRAE J 2000; 42: 49–56.

Haves P and Xu P. The building controls virtual test bed - a simulation environment for developing and testing control algorithms, strategies and systems. Proceedings of 10th international IBPSA conference, Beijing, China, 2007.

Haves P, Norford L and Desimone M. A standard simulation test bed for the evaluation of control algorithms and strategies. ASHRAE RP–825 report. American Society of Heating, Refrigerating and Air-Conditioning Engineers, 1998.

Visier J, Vaezi-Nejad H and Jandon M. Results of the application of a quality assessment procedure to different building energy management systems. 3rd IEEE conference on control applications 1994; 3: 1867–1872.

Peitsmann

Wang

Kaerki

. The reproducibility of tests on energy management and control systems using building emulators. ASHRAE Transac 1994; 100: 1455–1464.

Trčka

Hensen

JLM

. Overview of HVAC system simulation. Automat Construct 2010; 19: 93–99.

Trčka M. Co-simulation for performance prediction of innovative integrated mechanical energy systems in buildings. PhD Thesis, Eindhoven University of Technology, Netherlands, 2008.

10.

Zupančič

. Extension software for real-time control system design and implementation with MATLAB-SIMULINK. Simulat Pract Theory 1998; 6: 703–719.

11.

Clarke

. Energy simulation in building design, 2nd ed. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann, 2001.

12.

Dexter

Haves

. Building control systems: evaluation of performance using an emulator. Building Serv Eng Res Technol 1994; 15: 131–140.

13.

McGregor I. The relationship between simulation and emulation. Proceedings of the 2002 winter simulation conference, San Diego, California, USA, 2002.

14.

Palla S, Srivastava A and Schulz N. Hardware in the loop test for relay model validation. Proceedings of IEEE electric ship technologies symposium, Arlington, Virginia, USA, 2007.

15.

Schlager

. Hardware-in-the-loop simulation: a scalable, component-based, time-triggered hardware-in-the-loop simulation framework, Saarbruecken: VDM, 2008.

16.

Lebrun

Wang

. Evaluation and emulation of building energy management systems — synthesis report. IEA (BCS) Annex 17 Final Report, Belgium: University of Liege, 1993.

17.

Vaezi-Nejad H, Hutter E, Haves P, et al. The use of building emulators to evaluate the performance of building energy management systems. Proceedings of 3rd international IBPSA conference, Nice, France, 1991.

18.

Decious G, Park C and Kelly G. A low-cost building/HVAC emulator. HPAC (heating/piping/airconditioning), 1997 (January); 69: 188--193.

19.

Bushby S, Castro N, Galler M, et al. Using the virtual cybernetic building testbed and FDD test shell for FDD tool development. National Institute of Standards and Technology, 2001.

20.

Anderson

Buehner

Young

. An experimental system for advanced heating, ventilating and air conditioning (HVAC) control. Energy Building 2007; 39: 136–147.

21.

Riederer P, Vaezi-Nejad H, Husaunndee A, et al. Development and quality improvement of HVAC control systems in virtual laboratories. Proceedings of 7th international IBPSA conference, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, 2001.

22.

Lahrech

Gruber

Riederer

. Development of a testing method for control HVAC systems by emulation. Energy Building 2002; 34: 909–916.

23.

Riederer P, Bruyat F, Clemencon B, et al. SIMTEST-ELEC: a virtual laboratory for the test of terminal controllers for electric heating systems following a draft European standard. Proceedings of 9th international IBPSA conference, Montreal, Canada, 2005.

24.

da Silva

Knabe

. LabHouse: system simulation and emulation within boiler development. Building Serv Eng Res Technol 2003; 24: 281–287.

25.

Thorsen E. Dynamic simulation of DH House Stations. Technical paper for Danfoss. Danfoss A/S, 2002.

26.

Drueck H, Kovacs P, Morlot R, et al. European test facilities for solar combisystems and heat stores. A report of IEA SHC - Task 26, International Energy Agency, 2002.

27.

Papillon P, Letz T and Albaric M. Solar combisystems: state of the art and perspectives. Proceedings of heat SET 2007: heat transfer in components and systems for sustainable energy technologies, Chambery, France, 2007.

28.

Riederer P, Partenay V and Raguideau O. Dynamic test method for the determination of the global seasonal performance factor of heat pumps used for heating, cooling and domestic hot water preparation. Proceedings of 11th international IBPSA conference, Glasgow, Scotland, 2009.

29.

Kelly

May

Kao

. Using emulators to evaluate the performance of building energy management systems. ASHRAE Transac 1994; 100.

30.

Wang

Zheng

. Dynamic and real-time simulation of BMS and air-conditioning system as a ‘living' environment for learning/training. Automat Construct 2001; 10: 487–505.

31.

Wetter M and Haves P. A modular building controls virtual test bed for the integration of heterogeneous systems. Proceedings of 3rd national conference of IBPSA-USA, Berkeley, California, USA, 2008.

32.

Gamberi

Manzini

Regattieri

. Simulink simulator for building hydronic heating systems using the Newton-Raphson algorithm. Energy Building 2009; 41: 848–855.

33.

Kalagasidis

Weitzmann

Nielsen

. The international building physics toolbox in Simulink. Energy Building 2007; 39: 665–674.

34.

van Paassen

. Simulink and bond graph modeling of an air-conditioned room. Simulat Model Pract Theory 2004; 12: 61–76.

35.

Morini

Piva

. The simulation of transients in thermal plant. Part I: mathematical model. Appl Thermal Eng 2007; 27: 2138–2144.

36.

Morini

Piva

. The simulation of transients in thermal plant. Part II: applications. Appl Thermal Eng 2008; 28: 244–251.

37.

Udagawa

. Simulation of panel cooling systems with linear subsystem model. ASHRAE Transac Symposia 1993; 99.

38.

Olesen B. Control of floor heating and cooling systems. Clima 2000/Napoli 2001 World Congress – Napoli (I), 2002.

39.

Olesen

. Radiant floor heating in theory and practice. ASHRAE J 2002; 44: 19–24.

40.

Ryu

Rhee

Yeo

. Strategies for flow rate balancing in radiant floor heating systems. Building Res Info 2008; 36: 625–637.

41.

Rhee

Ryu

Yeo

. Simulation study on hydronic balancing to improve individual room control for radiant floor heating system. Building Serv Eng Res Technol 2010; 31: 57–73.

42.

Rayment

. Boiler efficiency and gas consumption: effects on cycling and pump speed. Building Serv Eng Res Technol 1995; 16: 55–58.

43.

Damianos

Day

Ratcliffe

. The development of a dynamic model to simulate boiler controls. Building Serv Eng Res Technol 2007; 28: 105–116.

44.

Perez-Lombard

Ortiz

Coronel

. A review of HVAC systems requirements in building energy regulations. Energy Building 2011; 43: 255–268.

45.

Liao

Dexter

. The potential for energy saving in heating systems through improving boiler controls. Energy Building 2004; 36: 261–271.

46.

Peeters L, Van der Veken J, Hens H, et al. Sizing of boilers for residential buildings. Proceedings of Clima 2007 wellbeing indoors, Helsinki, Finland, 2007.

47.

Tekmar Control Systems. Control functions and benefits, Tekmar Essay, 2001; July: 1--8.