Adler's Theory of the Capitalist Labour Process: A Pale(o) Imitation

Abstract

Adler's paper raises a host of pertinent theoretical and empirical challenges for anyone interested in contemporary trends in work and organization. A version of `paleo' Marxism is invoked to correct the supposed anomalies of labour process theory and the limits of critical management studies. The theory relies on a notion of the progressive socialization of the productive forces in order to assert a positive conception of Taylorism and lean production, as well as a long-run upskilling trajectory. It is argued in this commentary that it is flawed theory and skewed empirics. Adler's perspectives result in a de-politicized workplace by removing any source of conflict over work relations between capital and labour. His evidence of skill upgrading relies overwhelmingly on a series of unreliable proxies that do not deal with actual work relations. In contrast, the commentary defends the record of labour process theory on issues of skill formation and the workplace as a contested terrain.

Keywords

Labour process theory skill formation politics of production Marxism capitalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adler, Paul 2007 `The future of critical management studies: A paleo-Marxist critique of labour process theory'. Organization Studies 28/9:

Babson, S. , editor 1995 Lean work: Empowerment and exploitation in the global auto industry. Detroit, MI: Wayne State University Press.

Braverman, H. 1974 Labor and monopoly capital: The degradation of work in the twentieth century. New York: Monthly Review Press.

Brown, P. , and A. Hesketh 2004 Playing to win: Managing employability in the knowledge-based economy. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Brynin, M. 2002 `Over-qualification in employment'. Work, Employment and Society 16/4: 637—654.

Conference of Socialist Economists , editors 1976 The labour process and class strategies. London: Stage One/CSE Books.

Danford, A. , 1998 Japanese management techniques and British workers. London: Mansell.

Delbridge, R. 2000 Life on the line in contemporary manufacturing. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Edwards, P.K. 1990 `Understanding conflict in the labour process: The logic and autonomy of struggle' in Labour process theory. D. Knights and H. Willmott (eds). London: Macmillan.

10.

Elger, T.

2001

`Critical materialist analyses of work and employment: A Third Way?' Paper to the international workshop, Between sociology of work and organisation studies: The state of the debate in Italy and in the United Kingdom (Bologna 16—17 November 2001).

11.

Felstead, A. , D. Gallie , and F. Green 2002 Work skills in Britain 1986—2001. London: Department for Education and Skills.

12.

Fleming, P. , B. Harley , and G. Sewell 2004 `A little knowledge is a dangerous thing: Getting below the surface of the growth of “knowledge work ” in Australia'. Work, Employment and Society 18/4: 725—747.

13.

Fournier, V. , and C. Grey 2000 `At the critical moment: Conditions and prospects for critical management studies'. Human Relations 53/1: 7—32.

14.

Gorz, A. , editor 1976 The division of labour: The labour process and class struggle in modern capitalism. Brighton, UK: Harvester.

15.

Jaros, J. 2005 `Marxian critiques of Thompson's (1990) “core” labour process theory: An evaluation and extension'. ephemera 5/1: 5—25.

16.

Marx, K. 1976 Capital, Volume I. Harmondsworth , UK: Pengiun.

17.

Noble, D.F. 1986 Forces of production: A social history of industrial automation. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

18.

Nolan, P. , and G. Slater 2003 ` The labour market: History, structure and prospects' in Industrial relations: Theory and practice. P. K. Edwards (ed.). Oxford, UK: Blackwell .

19.

Smith, C. 1987 Technical workers: Class, labour and trade unionism. London : Macmillan.

20.

Thompson, P. 1989 The Nature of work, 2nd edn. London: Macmillan.

21.

Thompson, P. 2004 `Brands, boundaries and bandwagons: A critical reflection on Critical Management Studies' in Critical realism in action in organisation and management studies. S. Fleetwood and S. Ackroyd (eds). London: Routledge.

22.

Thompson, P. , and B. Harley 2007 `HRM and the worker: Labour process perspectives' in The Oxford handbook of human resource management. P. Boxall , J. Purcell , and P. Wright (eds). Oxford : Oxford University Press.

23.

Warhurst, C. , and P. Thompson 2006 `Mapping knowledge in work: Proxies or practices?' Work Employment and Society 20/: 787—800.

24.

Warhurst, C. , I. Grugulis , and E. Keep , editors 2004 The skills that matter. London: Palgrave.