This article explores the relationship between justice and child sexual abuse, developing a broader theoretical conception of justice than that customarily applied. The traditional legal perception of justice as the attempted prosecution of alleged perpetrators is widened to encompass justice as initial prevention of abuse, the fair treatment of children by the criminal justice and child protection systems, and the subsequent after-care and compensation of abused children and adults. Concepts of justice are therefore examined within a chronological lifecourse trajectory, as well as being extended from traditional notions of due process and desert to include understandings of justice as human rights, ‘fair shares’ and liberation. Particular social constructions of childhood are revealed to be highly significant regarding how justice is perceived and operationalized. Therefore, the interaction between perceptions of justice and responses to child sexual abuse is examined, relative to wider understandings of childhood.
Archard, D.1999‘Can Child Abuse be Defined?’, in M. King (ed.) Moral Agendas for Children's Welfare. London: Routledge .
2.
Armstrong, L.1996Rocking the Cradle of Sexual Politics. London: Women's Press .
3.
Bacon, H. and Richardson, S.2001‘Attachment Theory and Child Abuse: An Overview of the Literature for Practitioners’ , Child Abuse Review10: 377–397 .
4.
Bagilhole, B.1997Equal Opportunities and Social Policy: Issues of Gender, Race and Disability. London: Longman .
5.
Baginsky, M. (ed.) 2001Counselling and Support Services for Young People Aged 12–16 Who Have Experienced Sexual Abuse: A Study of the Provision in Italy, The Netherlands and the United Kingdom. London: NSPCC .
6.
Beckett, C.2002‘The Witch-Hunt Metaphor (and Accusations Against Residential Care Workers)’ , British Journal of Social Work32: 621–628 .
7.
Bennell, C. , Alison, L. J. , Stein, K. L. , Alison, E. K. and Canter, D. V.2001‘Sexual Offenses Against Children as the Abusive Exploitation of Conventional Adult-Child Relationships’ , Journal of Social and Personal Relationships18(2): 155–171 .
Burman, E.2003‘Childhood, Sexual Abuse and Contemporary Political Subjectivities’, pp. 34–51 in P. Reavey and S. Warner (eds) New Feminist Stories of Child Sexual Abuse: Sexual Scripts and Dangerous Dialogues. London: Routledge .
10.
Campbell, B.1988Unofficial Secrets: Child Sexual Abuse, the Cleveland Case. London: Virago .
11.
Carabine, J.2004‘Lesbian and Gay Politics and Participation in New Labour's Britain’ , Social Politics11(2): 312–327 .
12.
Cawson, P. , Wattam, C. , Brooker, S. and Kelly, G.2001Child Maltreatment in the United Kingdom: A Study of Prevalence of Abuse and Neglect. London: NSPCC .
13.
Christensen, C. A. and Dorn, S.1997‘Competing Notions of Social Justice and Contradictions in Special Educational Reform’ , Journal of Special Education31(2): 181–198 .
14.
Clark, C. L.2000Social Work Ethics: Politics, Principles and Practice. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
15.
Cloke, C. and Davies, M. (eds) 1995Participation and Empowerment in Child Protection. London: Pitman .
16.
Conrad, J.1999‘Lost Innocence and Sacrificial Delegate: The JonBenet Ramsay Murder’ , Childhood6(3): 313–352 .
17.
Copperman, J. and McNamara, J.1999‘Institutional Abuse in Mental Health Settings: Survivor Perspectives’, pp. 157–172 in N. Stanley , J. Manthorpe and B. Penhale (eds) Institutional Abuse: Perspectives Across the Lifecourse. London: Routledge .
18.
Cox, P.2000‘Knowledge and Resistances in Child Sexual Assault’, pp. 3– 18 in P. Cox , S. Kershaw and J. Trotter (eds) Child Sexual Assault: Feminist Perspectives. Basingstoke: Palgrave .
19.
Cresswell, M. 2004 ‘Psychiatric “Survivor” Knowledge and Testimonies of Self Harm’ , Conference paper for ‘Imaging Social Movements Conference’, 2 July, Edge Hill College, UK.
20.
Davis, G. , Hoyano, L. , Keenan, C. , Maitland, L. and Morgan, R.1999An Assessment of the Admissibility and Sufficiency of Evidence in Child Abuse Prosecutions. London: Home Office Publications .
21.
DfES (Department for Education and Skills)2003Every Child Matters. Green Paper, Cm. 5860. London: The Stationery Office .
22.
Dineen, T.1998Manufacturing Victims: What the Psychology Industry is doing to People, 2nd edn.Montreal: Robert Davies .
23.
Dobson, R.1996‘Names Named in Welsh Child Abuse Scandal’, Independent1 September.
24.
Ehman, R.2000‘What Really is Wrong with Pedophilia’ , Public Affairs Quarterly14(2): 129–140 .
25.
Elliot, M. , Browne, K. and Kilcoyne, J.1995‘Child Sexual Abuse: What Offenders Tell Us’ , Child Abuse and Neglect19(5): 579–594 .
26.
Evans, D.1994‘Falling Angels: The Material Construction of Children as Sexual Citizens’ , International Journal of Children's Rights2: 1–33 .
27.
Fawcett, B. , Featherstone, B. and Goddard, J.2004Contemporary Child Care Policy and Practice. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
28.
Finkelhor, D.1986A Sourcebook on Child Sexual Abuse. London: SAGE .
29.
Fontaine, R. , Salvano-Pardieu, V. , Crouzet, S. and Pulford, B. D.2002‘Physically Abused and Non Maltreated Boys’ Moral Judgements of Violence’ , Child Study Journal32(4): 200–216 .
30.
Foucault, M.1998The Will to Knowledge: The History of Sexuality, Vol 1. Harmondsworth: Penguin .
31.
Franklin, B. (ed.) 2002The New Handbook of Children's Rights: Comparative Policy and Practice. London: Routledge .
32.
Franklin, B. and Horwath, J.1996‘The Media Abuse of Children: Jake's Progress from Demonic Icon to Childhood Innocent’ , Child Abuse Review5(5): 310–318 .
33.
Freel, M.2003‘Child Sexual Abuse and the Male Monopoly: An Empirical Exploration of Gender and a Sexual Interest in Children’ , British Journal of Social Work33: 481–498 .
34.
Frosh, S.2002‘Characteristics of Sexual Abusers’, in K. Wilson and A. James (eds) Handbook of Child Protection. Edinburgh: Balliere Tindall .
35.
Gabora, N. J. , Spanos, N. P. and Joab, A.1993‘The Effects of Complainant Age and Expert Testimony in a Simulated Child Sexual Abuse Trial’ , Law and Human Behavior17: 103–119 .
36.
Gilman, R. and Whitlock, R.1989‘Sexuality: A Neglected Component of Child Sexual Abuse Education and Training’ , Child Welfare68: 317–329 .
37.
Giroux, H. A.2000Stealing Innocence: Corporate Culture's War on Children. New York: Palgrave .
38.
Glaser, D. and Frosh, S.1988Child Sexual Abuse. Basingstoke: Macmillan .
39.
Glasser, M. , Kolvin, I. , Glasser, A. , Leitch, I. , Farrelly, S. , Cannon, M. and Bailey, S.2001‘Cycle of Child Sexual Abuse: Links Between Being a Victim and Becoming a Perpetrator’ , British Journal of Psychiatry179: 482-482 .
40.
Goldman, R. and Goldman, J.1982Children's Sexual Thinking. Melbourne: Routledge and Kegan Paul .
41.
Goodman, G. S. , Taub, E. P. , Jones, D. P. H. , England, P. , Port, L. K. , Rudy, L. and Prado, L.1992‘Testifying in Criminal Court: Emotional Effects on Child Sexual Assault Victims’ , Monographs for the Society for Research in Child Development57(5): 1–161 .
42.
Green, L. 1998 ‘Caged by Force, Entrapped by Discourse: A Study of the Construction and Control of Children and their Sexualities Within Residential Children's Homes’, unpublished PhD thesis, University of Huddersfield, UK.
43.
Green, L.1999Getting the Balance Right: A Cross Comparative Analysis of the Balance between Legal Intervention and Therapeutic Support Systems in Relation to Responses to Child Sexual Abuse in England, Belgium and the Netherlands, A Report Prepared for the European Commission under the Daphne Initiative, project 98/205, University of Huddersfield.
44.
Green, L. and Masson, H.2002‘Adolescents Who Sexually Abuse and Residential Accommodation: Issues of Risk and Vulnerability’ , British Journal of Social Work32: 149–168 .
45.
Green, L. , Butt, T. and King, N.2002‘Taking the Chaste out of Chastisement: An Analysis of the Sexual Implications of the Corporal Punishment of Children’ , Childhood9(2): 205–224 .
46.
Gregory, J. and Lees, S.1999Policing Sexual Assault. London: Routledge .
47.
Grover, S.2003‘On Power Differentials and Children's Rights: A Dissonance Interpretation of the Rind and Associates 1998 Study on Child Sexual Abuse’ , Ethical Human Sciences and Services5(1): 21–33 .
48.
Grubin, D.1999Sex Offending Against Children: Understanding the Risk. London: HMSO .
49.
Haaken, J. and Lamb, S.2000‘The Politics of Child Sexual Abuse Research’, SocietyMay/June: 6–14.
50.
Haugaard, J. H.2000‘The Challenge of Defining Child Sexual Abuse’ , American Psychologist55(9): 1036–1039 .
51.
Haydon, D.2002‘Children's Rights to Sex and Sexuality Education’, in B. Franklin (ed.) pp 182–195The New Handbook of Children's Rights: Comparative Policy and Practice. London: Routledge .
52.
Hearn, J. , Pringle, K. , Muller, U. , Olesky, E. , Lattu, E. , Tallberg, T. , Chernova, J. , Ferguson, H. , Gullvag Hollter, O. and Kolga, V.2002‘Critical Studies on Men in Ten European Countries: (3) The State of Law and Policy’ , Men and Masculinities5(2): 192–217 .
53.
Helwig, C. C. and Jasiobedzka, U.2001‘The Relation between Law and Morality: Children's Reasoning about Socially Beneficial and Unjust Laws’ , Child Development72(5): 1382–1393 .
54.
Howitt, D.1998Paedophiles and Sexual Offences against Children. Chichester: Wiley .
55.
Hoyano, L.2002 Review of E. Heinz (ed.) Of Innocence and Autonomy: Children, Sex and Human Rights (Aldershot: Ashgate, 2000), International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family16: 301-301 .
56.
Jacobson, M.2001‘Child Sexual Abuse and the Multidisciplinary Team Approach’ , Childhood8(2): 231–250 .
57.
James, A. and Prout, A.1997‘Re-presenting Childhood: Time and Transition in the Study of Childhood’, in A. James and A. Prout (eds) Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood. London: Falmer Press .
58.
James, A. , Jenks, C. and Prout, A.1998Theorizing Childhood. Cambridge: Polity Press .
59.
Jenks, C.1996Childhood. London: Routledge .
60.
Johnson, A. M. , Wadsworth, J. , Wellings, K. and Field, J.1994Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific .
61.
Kelly, L.2000‘Foreword, Disconnection or Connections: or Will We Ever Learn?’, pp. ix–xxii in P. Cox , S. Kershaw and J. Trotter (eds) Child Sexual Assault: Feminist Perspectives. Basingstoke: Palgrave .
62.
Kelly, L. , Regan, L. and Burton, S.1991An Exploratory Study of the Prevalence of Sexual Abuse in a Sample of 16-21 Year Olds. London: Child and Woman Abuse Studies Unit, University of North London .
63.
King, M. , Coxell, A. and Mezey, G.2002‘Sexual Molestation of Males: Associations with Psychological Disturbance’ , British Journal of Psychiatry181: 153–157 .
64.
Kinsey, A. , Pomeroy, W. B. and Martin, C. E.1953Sexual Behaviour in the Human Male. Philadelphia: WB Saunders .
65.
Kitzinger, J.1997‘Who are you Kidding? Children, Power and the Struggle Against Sexual Abuse’, pp 165–189 in A. James and A. Prout (eds) Constructing and Reconstructing Childhood. London: Falmer Press .
66.
Kleinhans, M.2002‘Criminal Justice Approaches to Paedophilic Sex Offenders’ , Social and Legal Studies11(2): 233–255 .
67.
Krivacska, J. J.1992‘Child Sexual Abuse Programs: The Prevention of Childhood Sexuality?’ , Journal of Child Sexual Abuse1(4): 83–112 .
68.
Lee, N.1999‘The Challenge of Childhood: Distributions of Childhood's Ambiguity in Adult Institutions’ , Childhood6(4): 455–474 .
69.
Levesque, R. J. R.1995‘Combatting Child Sexual Maltreatment: Advances and Obstacles in International Progress’ , Law and Policy17(4): 441–470 ,
70.
Lieb, R.2000‘Social Policy and Sexual Offenders: Contrasting United States and European Policies’ , European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research8: 423–440 .
71.
Lillienfield, S.2002‘When Worlds Collide: Social Science, Politics and the Rind et al. 1998 Child Sexual Abuse Meta-Analysis’ , American Psychologist57(3): 176–188 .
72.
Loiselle, C. and Gaulin, D.1995‘The Care for Kids Initiative: Moving from Child-Focussed Sexual Abuse Prevention to Early Childhood Sexuality Education and Adult Responsibility for Protection’ , The Canadian Journal of Sexuality4(1): 84–88 .
73.
Martone, M. , Jaudes, P. K. and Cavins, M. K.1996‘Criminal Prosecution of Child Sexual Abuse Cases’ , Child Abuse and Neglect20(5): 457–464 .
74.
Mayall, B.2002Towards a Sociology of Childhood. Buckingham: Open University Press .
75.
McCauley, M. R. and Parker, J. F.2001‘When Will a Child Be Believed? The Impact of a Victim's Age and Juror's Gender on Children's Credibility and Verdict in a Sexual Abuse Case’ , Child Abuse and Neglect25(4): 523–539 .
76.
Mirkin, H.1999‘The Pattern of Sexual Politics: Feminism, Homosexuality and Pedophilia’ , Journal of Homosexuality37(2): 1–24 .
77.
Moran, J.2001‘Childhood Sexuality and Education: The Case of Section 28’ , Sexualities4(1): 73–89 .
78.
Moss, P. and Petrie, P.2002From Children's Services to Children's Spaces: Public Policy, Children and Childhood. London: Routledge/Falmer .
79.
NSPCC2004Sexual Offences Act Media Briefing [http://nspcc.org.uk/html/home/newsandcampaigns/sexualoffencesact/htm]. Accessed 15 June 2004.
80.
Oellerich, T. D.2000‘Rind, Tromovitch and Bauserman: Politically Incorrect, Scientifically Correct’ , Sexuality and Culture4(2): 67–82 .
81.
Oellerich, T. D.2001‘Child Sexual Abuse: Is the Routine Provision of Psychotherapy Unwarranted?’, IPT [Issues in Child Abuse Accusations] 11 [http://www.ipt-forensics.com/journal/volume11/j11_1_3.htm]. Accessed 11 June 2004.
82.
Panorama2005'Crimewave’, BBC1 television programme broadcast on Sunday 30 January.
83.
Parton, N.1991Governing the Family: Child Protection, Child Care and the State. London: Macmillan .
84.
Parton, N. and Wattam, C. (eds) 1998Child Sexual Abuse: Responding to the Experiences of Children. Chichester: Wiley/NSPCC .
85.
Pierce, J.1996‘Rambo Litigators: Emotional Labor in a Male Dominated Occupation’, in C. Cheng (ed.) Masculinities in Organizations. California: SAGE .
86.
Piper, C.2000‘Assumptions about Children's Best Interests’ , Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law22(3): 261–276 .
87.
Pringle, K.1998Children and Social Welfare in Europe. Buckingham: Open University Press .
88.
Prior, V. , Glaser, D. and Lynch, M. A.1997‘Responding to Child Sexual Abuse: The Criminal Justice System’ , Child Abuse Review6(2): 128–140 .
89.
Pritchard, C.2004The Child Abusers: Research and Controversy. Milton Keynes: Open University Press .
90.
Ramsbotham, Sir D. 2001 ‘ What Price Imprisonment?’ , Sixteenth Annual Lecture of the Faculty of Law, University of Southampton, 21 February.
91.
Reavey, P. and Warner, S. (eds) 2003New Feminist Stories of Child Sexual Abuse: Sexual Scripts and Dangerous Dialogues. London: Routledge .
92.
Richardson, D.2000‘Constructing Sexual Citizenship: Theorizing Sexual Rights’ , Critical Social Policy20(1): 105–135 .
93.
Rickford, F.1996‘Not in Front of the Teachers’, Guardian18 December.
94.
Rind, B. , Bauserman, R. and Tromovitch, P.1998‘A Meta-Analytic Examination of Assumed Properties of Child Sexual Abuse Using College Samples’ , Psychological Bulletin24(1): 22–53 .
95.
Rose, N.1989Governing the Soul: The Shaping of the Private Self. London: Routledge .
96.
Schmidt, C. W. and Brigham, J. C.1996‘Jurors’ Perceptions of Child-Victim Witnesses in a Simulated Sexual Abuse Trial’ , Law and Human Behaviour20(6): 581–606 .
97.
Scott, S.2001‘Surviving Selves: Feminism and Contemporary Discourses of Child Sexual Abuse’ , Feminist Theory2(3): 349–361 .
98.
Sharland, E.1999‘Justice for Children: Child Protection and the Crimino-Legal Process’ , Child and Family Social Work4(4): 303–313 .
99.
Smart, C.1999‘A History of Ambivalence and Conflict in the Discursive Construction of the “Child Victim” of Sexual Abuse’ , Social and Legal Studies8(3): 391–409 .
100.
Smith, C. and Woodhead, K.1998‘Justice for Children’, pp. 19–36 in N. Parton , and C. Wattam (eds) Child Sexual Abuse: Responding to the Experiences of Children. Chichester: Wiley/NSPCC .
101.
Sparks, R. , Girling, E. and Smith, M.2000‘Children Talking about Justice and Punishment’ , The International Journal of Children's Rights8: 199–209 .
102.
Speece, M. W. and Brent, S. B.1987‘Irreversibility, Non Functionality and Universality: Children's Understanding of Three Components of a Death Concept’, pp. 19–30 in J. E. Showalter (ed.) Children and Death: Perspectives from Birth through Adolescence. New York: Praeger .
103.
Stainton Rogers, W. 1995 ‘Children + Adults = Sex?’, Seminar paper given at Bolton Institute, March.
104.
Szasz, T.2002‘Sins of the Fathers: Is Child Abuse a Sickness or a Crime’, Reason OnlineAugust [http://reason.com/0208/fe.ts.sins.shtml]. Accessed 16 June 2004.
105.
Taylor-Browne, J.1997‘Obfuscating Child Sexual Abuse: Listening to Survivors’ , Child Abuse Review6: 118–127 .
106.
Travis, A.2002‘Clinic for Child Abusers Forced to Close’, Guardian Online 5 July.
107.
Turiel, E.1998‘The Development of Morality’, in N. Eisenberg (ed.) Handbook of Child Psychology, Vol 3: Social, Emotional and Personality Development, 5th edn.New York: Wiley .
108.
Turner, B. S.1986Equality. Chichester: Ellis Horwood .
109.
Warner, S. and Wilkins, T.2003‘Diagnosing Stress and Reproducing Disorder: Women, Child Sexual Abuse and “Borderline Personality Disorder”’, pp. 167–186 in P. Reavey , and S. Warner (eds) New Feminist Stories of Child Sexual Abuse: Sexual Scripts and Dangerous Dialogues. London: Routledge .
110.
Wellbourne, P.2002‘Videotaped Evidence of Children: Application and Implications of the Memorandum of Good Practice’ , British Journal of Social Work32(5): 553–571 .
111.
Westcott, H. L. and Page, M.2002‘Cross Examination, Sexual Abuse and Child Witness Identity’ , Child Abuse Review11(3): 137–152 .
112.
Williams, J. and Keating, F.1999‘The Abuse of Adults in Mental Health Settings’, pp. 130–151 in N. Stanley , J. Manthorpe and B. Penhale (eds) Institutional Abuse: Perspectives Across the Lifecourse. London: Routledge .
113.
Wyness, M.1996‘Policy, Protectionism and the Competent Child’ , Childhood3: 431–447 .
