A popular view holds that men and women differ in the types of social support they provide to distressed others: women provide emotional support and empathy while men offer instrumental support or try to minimize the importance of problems. Despite the prevalence of this view, there is limited evidence to support it. The present study sought to empirically assess the merit of this view. A total of 119 college students responded to seven situations involving a distressed other. Although women's responses were longer and contained more talk about emotions, women also talked more about instrumental actions than did men. Men devoted a greater proportion of their responses to talk about the problem and a larger proportion of their problem talk involved denying the problem. However, there were substantial similarities between men and women in the relative frequencies of different types of supportive responses used, and sex differences accounted for small percentages of variance. In contrast, situation exerted a strong, consistent influence on the responses of men and women alike.
Antonucci, T.C. & Akiyama, H. (1987) `An Examination of Sex Differences in Social Support Among Older Men and Woman', Sex Roles17: 737-749.
2.
Barbee, A.P. (1990) `Interactive Coping: The Cheering-Up Process in Close Relationships', in S.W. Duck (ed.) with R.C. Silver, Personal Relationships and Social Support. London: Sage.
3.
Barbee, A.P. & Cunningham, M.R. (1995) `An Experimental Approach to Social Support Communications: Interactive Coping in Close Relationships', in B.R. Burleson (ed.) Communication Yearbook 18. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
4.
Barbee, A.P. , Gulley, M.R. & Cunningham, M.R. (1990) `Support Seeking in Personal Relationships', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships7: 531-540.
5.
Barbee, A.P. , Cunningham, M.R., Winstead, B.A., Derlega, V.J., Gulley, M.R., Yankeelov, P.A. & Druen, P.B. (1993) `Effects of Gender Role Expectations on the Social Support Process', Journal of Social Issues49: 175-190.
6.
Berg, J.H. (1984) `Development of Friendship Between Roommates', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology46: 346-356.
7.
Brackstone, M.J. & Zingle, H.W. (1993) `Women's Perceptions of the Nature and Adequacy of Their Present Support Relationships', International Journal of the Advancement of Counselling16: 119-134.
8.
Burleson, B.R. (1982) `The Development of Comforting Communication Skills in Childhood and Adolescence', Child Development53: 1578-1588.
9.
Burleson, B.R. (1994) `Comforting Messages: Significance, Approaches, and Effects', in B.R. Burleson, T.L. Albrecht & I.G. Sarason (eds) Communication of Social Support. Messages, Interactions, Relationships, and Community. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
10.
Burleson, B.R. & Samter, W. (1985) `Consistencies in Theoretical and Naive Evaluations of Comforting Messages', Communication Monographs52: 103-123.
11.
Burleson, B.R. , Kunkel, A.W., Samter, W. & Werking, K.J. (1996) `Men's and Women's Evaluations of Communication Skills in Personal Relationships: When Sex Differences Make a Difference- and When They Don't', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships13: 201-224.
12.
Caldwell, M.A. & Peplau, L.A. (1982) `Sex Differences in Same-Sex Friendship', Sex Roles8: 721-732.
13.
Canary, D.J. & Hause, K.S. (1993) `Is There Any Reason to Research Sex Differences in Communication?', Communication Quarterly41: 129-144.
14.
Chappell, N.L. , Segall, A. & Lewis, D.G. (1990) `Gender and Helping Networks Among Day Hospital and Senior Centre Participants', Canadian Journal on Aging9: 220-233.
15.
Clark, R.A. (1993) `Men's and Women's Self-Confidence in Persuasive, Comforting, and Justificatory Communication Tasks', Sex Roles28: 553-567.
16.
Clark, R.A. (1995) `A Comparison of Young Men's and Women's Topics and Objectives in a Cross-Section of Everyday Conversations', paper presented at the meeting of the Central States Speech Communication Association, Indianapolis, IN.
17.
Cohen, J. (1977) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. New York: Academic Press.
18.
Cowen, E.L. (1982) `Help is Where You Find It', American Psychologist17: 385-395.
19.
Cutrona, C.E. & Suhr, J.A. (1994) `Social Support Communication in the Context of Marriage: An Analysis of Couples' Supportive Interactions', in B.R. Burleson, T.L. Albrecht & I.G. Sarason (eds) Communication of Social Support: Messages, Interactions, Relationships, and Community. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
20.
Deaux, K. & Major, B. (1987) `Putting Gender into Context: An Interactive Model of Gender-Related Behavior', Psychological Review94: 369-389.
21.
Depner, C.E. & Ingersoll-Dayton, B. (1985) `Conjugal Social Support: Patterns in Later Life', Journal of Gerontology40: 761-766.
22.
Depner, C.E. & Ingersoll-Dayton, B. (1988) `Supportive Relationships in Later Life', Psychology and Aging3: 348-357.
23.
Dindia, K. & Allen, M. (1992) `Sex Differences in Self-Disclosure: A Meta-Analysis', Psychological Bulletin112: 106-124.
24.
Duck, S.W. & Wright, P.H. (1993) `Re-Examining Gender Differences in Same-Gender Friendships: A Close Look at Two Kinds of Data', Sex Roles28: 709-727.
25.
Dunkel-Schetter, C. , Blasband, D.E., Feinstein, L.G. & Herbert, T.B. (1992) `Elements of Supportive Interactions: When are Attempts to Help Effective?', in S. Spacapan & S. Oskamp (eds) Helping and Being Helped: Naturalistic Studies. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
26.
Goldsmith, D. (1995) `The Communicative Micro Dynamics of Support', in B.R. Burleson (ed.) Communication Yearbook 18, pp. 414-433. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
27.
Gray, J. (1992) Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus. New York: HarperCollins.
Guetzkow, H. (1950) `Unitizing and Categorizing Problems in Coding Qualitative Data', Journal of Clinical Psychology6: 47-58.
30.
Hays, R.B. & Oxley, D. (1986) `Social Network Development and Functioning During a Life Transition', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology50: 305-313.
31.
Houser, B.B. , Berkman, S.L. & Bardsley, P. (1985) `Sex and Birth Order Differences in Filial Behavior', Sex Roles13: 641-651.
32.
Jones, D.C. (1991) `Friendship Satisfaction and Gender: An Examination of Sex Differences in Contributors to Friendship Satisfaction', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships8: 167-185.
33.
Kessler, R.C. , McLeod, J.D. & Wethington, E. (1985) `The Costs of Caring: A Perspective on the Relationship Between Sex and Psychological Distress', in I.G. Sarason & B.R. Sarason (eds) Social Support. Theory, Research, and Applications. Boston, MA: Martinus Nijhoff.
34.
Krause, N. & Keith, V. (1989) `Gender Differences in Social Support Among Older Adults', Sex Roles21: 609-628.
35.
Lu, L. & Argyle, M. (1992) `Receiving and Giving Support: Effects on Relationships and Well-being', Counselling Psychology Quarterly5: 123-133.
36.
Maltz, D.N. & Borker, R.A. (1982) `A Cultural Approach to Male-Female Miscommunication', in J.J. Gumperz (ed.) Language and Social Identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
37.
Mickelson, K.D. , Helgeson, V.S. & Weiner, E. (1995) `Gender Effects on Social Support Provision and Receipt', Personal Relationship Issues3: 211-224.
38.
Monsour, M. (1992) `Meanings of Intimacy in Cross- and Same-Sex Friendships', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships9: 277-295.
39.
Reis, H.T. , Senchak, M. & Solomon, B. (1985) `Sex Differences in the Intimacy of Social Interaction: Further Examination of Potential Explanations', Journal of Personality and Social Psychology48: 1204-1217.
40.
Rook, K.S. & Pietromonaco, P. (1987) `Close Relationships: Ties that Heal or Ties that Bind?', in W.H. Jones & D. Perlman (eds) Advances in Personal Relationships vol 1. Greenwich, CN: JAI Press.
41.
Scollon, R. & Scollon, S.W. (1994) Intercultural Communication. Oxford: Blackwell.
42.
Spitze, G. & Logan, J. (1990) `Sons, Daughters, and Intergenerational Social Support', Journal of Marriage and the Family52: 420-430.
43.
Sprecher, S. , Metts, S., Burleson, B., Hatfield, E. & Thompson, A. (1995) `Domains of Expressive Interaction in Intimate Relationships: Associations with Satisfaction and Commitment', Family Relations44: 1-8.
44.
Tannen, D. (1986) That's Not What I Meant! How Conversational Style Makes or Breaks Relationships. New York: Ballentine Books.
45.
Tannen, D. (1990) You Just Don't Understand: Men and Women in Conversation. New York: Ballentine Books.
46.
Thorne, B. (1993) Gender Play: Girls and Boys in School. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
47.
Trobst, K.K. , Colins, R.L. & Embree, J.M. (1994) `The Role of Emotion in Social Support Provision: Gender, Empathy, and Expressions of Distress', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships11: 45-62.
48.
Williams, D.G. (1985) `Gender, Masculinity-Femininity, and Emotional Intimacy in Same-Sex Friendships', Sex Roles12: 587-600.
49.
Winstead, B.A. , Derlega, J.V., Lewis, R.J., Sachez-Hucles, J. & Clarke, E. (1992) `Friendship, Social Interaction, and Coping with Stress', Communication Research19: 193-211.
Wright, P.H. (1982) `Men's Friendships, Women's Friendships and the Alleged Inferiority of the Latter', Sex Roles8: 1-20.
52.
Wright, P.H. (1988) `Interpreting Research on Gender Differences in Friendship: A Case for Moderation and a Plea for Caution', Journal of Social and Personal Relationships5: 367-373.
