The reliability of stroke outcome measures

Abstract

Assessments of outcome in stroke should include measures of the broader aims of rehabilitation, such as handicap, mood and perceived health, and these measures should be reliable. This study compared the test-retest reliability of the Barthel, Nottingham Extended Activities of Daily Living, Geriatric Depression Score (GDS) and the Nottingham Health Profile (NHP) by postal survey of 21 stroke patients six months after their stroke. There was significant variation between test and retest scores in all the scales but the NHP and GDS were much less reliable than the disability measures, perhaps because they measure less objective or more intrinsically variable quantities. Unreliability is important because it adds to the observed variance of any study population, making it more difficult to detect real differences between groups. Analysis of test-retest reliability should be an essential part of the development of questionnaires. Currently recommended outcome measures require further development to improve reliability.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Frater A. , Costain D. Any better? Outcome measures in medial audit. Br Med J 1992; 304: 519-20.

Seale C. , Davies P. Outcome measurement in stroke rehabilitation research. Int Disabil Studies 1987; 9: 155-60.

Wade DT Assessing disability after acute stroke. In: Clifford Rose F ed. Stroke: epidemiological, therapeutic and socio-economic aspects. London: Royal Society of Medicine, 1986.

Mahoney FI , Barthel DW

Functional evaluation: the Barthel Index. Md

Med J 1965 ; 14: 61-65.

Ebrahim S. Measurement of impairment, disability and handicap. In: Hopkins A , Costain D eds. Measuring the outcomes of medical care. London : The Royal College of Physicians, 1990: 27-41.

Wade DT , Collin C. The Barthel Index: a standard measure of physical disability. Int Disabil Studies 1988; 10: 64-67.

Katz S. , Ford AB , Moskowitz RW , Jackson BA , Jaffe W. Studies of illness in the aged. The index of ADL: a standardized measure of biological and psychological function. JAMA 1963; 185: 914-19.

Whiting S. , Lincoln NB An ADL assessment for stroke patients. Br J Onccup Ther 1980; 2: 44-46.

Sheikh K. , Smith DS , Meade TW , Brennan PJ , Kinsella G. Repeatability and validity of a modified activities of daily living index in studies of chronic disability. Int Rehabil Med 1979; 1: 51-58.

10.

Ebrahim S. , Nouri F. , Barer D. Measuring disability after a stroke. J Epidemiol Community Health 1985; 39: 86-89.

11.

Nouri FM , Lincoln NB An extended activities of daily living index for stroke patients. Clin Rehabil 1987; 1: 301-305.

12.

Holbrook M. , Skilbeck CE An activities index for use with stroke patients. Age Ageing 1983; 12: 166-70.

13.

Bamford J. , Sandercock P. , Warlow CP , Slattery J. Interobserver agreement for the measure of handicap in stroke patients. Stroke 1989; 20: 828.

14.

Herbert R. , Carrier R. , Bilodeau A. The functional autonomy measurement system (SMAF): description and validation of an instrument for the measurement of handicaps. Age Ageing 1988; 17: 293-302.

15.

Wade DT Measurement in rehabilitation. Age Ageing 1988 ; 17: 289-92.

16.

Hunt SM , McEwen J. , McKenna SP Measuring health status. London: Croom Helm, 1986.

17.

Goldberg DP , Blackwell B. Psychiatric illness in general practice: a detailed study using a new method of case identification. Br Med J 1970; 2: 439-43.

18.

Ebrahim S. Physical disability, health, depressed mood, and use of services after stroke [MD Thesis]. Nottingham: University of Nottingham, 1985.

19.

Zigmond AS , Snaith RP The hospital anxiety and depression scale. Acta Psychiatr Scand 1983; 67: 361-70.

20.

Lum O. , Brink TL , Yesavage JA , Heersetma P. , Ade YM , Rose TL Screening tests for geriatric depression. Clin Gerontol 1982; 1: 37-43.

21.

Bird AS , MacDonald Ajd , Mann AH , Philpot MP Preliminary experience with the selfcare(D): a self-rating depression questionnaire for use in elderly, non-institutionalized subjects. Int J Geriatr Psychiatr 1985; 2: 31-38.

22.

Arden D. , Austin C. , Sturgeon R. Correlation between the Geriatric Depression Scale long and short forms. J Gerontol 1989; 44: 124-25.

23.

Pound P. , Gompertz P. , Ebrahim S. Patients' satisfaction with stroke services. Clin Rehab 1994 (in press).

24.

Bland J. , Altman D. Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet 1986; i: 307-10.

25.

Brennan P. , Silman A. Statistical methods for assessing observer variability in clinical measures . Br Med J 1992; 304: 1491-94.

26.

Collin C. , Wade D. , Davies S. , Home V. The Barthel ADL Index: a reliability study. Int Disabil Studies 1987; 10: 61-63.

27.

Ebraham S. , Barer D. , Nouri F. Use of the Nottingham Health Profile with patients after a stroke. J Epidemiol Community Health 1986; 40: 166-69.