A review of outcome indicators in the treatment of chronic limb oedema

Abstract

Objectives: To provide an overview of physical and psychological outcome indicators which have been used to evaluate conservative treatments for chronic oedema.

Methods of finding papers: Papers were located via the MedLine, CINAHL and GEARS databases, and the British Lymphology Interest Group Key References lists.

Issues reviewed: The literature reveals that only a small amount of work has addressed conceptual issues in outcome evaluation. Above all, outcome indicators have been adopted in clinical practice in a haphazard manner, with little discussion regarding the purpose of outcome assessment/measurement and little agreement on the most appropriate assessment/measurement techniques.

Results: Eleven outcome indicators appear in the literature, each of which is discussed in terms of instrumentation and application in clinical practice. Practitioners have focused on objective measures, with change in limb volume the outcome measure most commonly used.

Conclusion: It is concluded that more rigour is needed in many aspects of outcome evaluation. Practitioners and researchers in this field should become more questioning of existing evaluation practices, and should explore the many potential outcome indicators, such as limb movement and limb function, which have to date been neglected.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Casley-Smith JR Modern treatment of lymphoedema. Mod Med Aust 1992; 35(5): 70-83.

Browse NL , Stewart G. Lymphoedema: pathophysiology and classification. J Cardiovasc Surg 1985; 26: 91-106.

Cesarone MR , Belcaro G. , Nicolaides AN , Incandela L. , de Sanctis MT , Laurora G. Lymphedema: noninvasive methods for diagnosis and follow-up. Scope Phlebol Lymphol 1996; 3(3): 16-22.

Badger C. , Reynard C. Oedema in advanced disease: a flow chart. Palliat Med 1989; 3: 213-15.

Mortimer PS Investigation and management of lymphoedema. Vasc Med Rev 1990; 1: 1-20.

Logan V. Incidence and prevalence of lymphoedema: a literature review. J Clin Nurs 1995; 4: 213-19.

Mortimer PS , Bates DO , Brassington HD , Stanton Awb , Strachan DP , Levick JR The prevalence of arm oedema following treatment for breast cancer. Q J Med 1996; 89: 377-80.

Green G. , Lawrance S. , Sitzia J. , Woods M. A pilot audit of referrals to ten lymphoedema treatment centres. A report from the BLIG Research Forum. Paper presented at the BLIG Annual Conference, Derby, 7-8 October 1996.

Badger C. A problem for nurses - lymphoedema. Surg Nurse 1988; 1: 14-19.

10.

Jeffs E. The effect of acute inflammatory episodes (cellulitis) on the treatment of lymphoedema. J Tissue Viability 1993; 3(2): 51-55.

11.

Tobin MB , Lacey HJ , Meyer L. , Mortimer P. The psychological morbidity of breast cancer related arm swelling. Cancer 1993; 72: 3248-52.

12.

Mirolo BR , Bunce IH , Chapman M. et al. Psychosocial benefits of postmastectomy lymphedema therapy. Cancer Nurs 1995; 18: 197-205.

13.

Dawson A. Why do we investigate patients? In: Hopkins A ed. Appropriate investigation and treatment in clinical practice. London: Royal College of Physicians of London, 1989: 1-7.

14.

Klein MJ , Alexander MA , Wright JM , Redmond CK, Le Gasse AA. Treatment of adult lower extremity lymphoedema with the Wright linear pump: statistical analysis of a clinical trial. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1988; 69: 202-206.

15.

Bertelli G. , Venturini M. , Forno G. , Macchiavello F. , Dini D. Conservative treatment of postmastectomy lymphedema: a controlled, randomized trial. Ann Oncol 1991; 2: 575-78.

16.

Bertelli G. , Venturini M. , Forno G. , Macchiavello F. , Dini D. An analysis of prognostic factors in response to conservative treatment of postmastectomy lymphedema. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1992; 175: 455-60.

17.

Zeissler RH , Rose GB , Nelson PA Postmastectomy lymphoedema: late results of treatment in 385 patients. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1972; 53: 159-66.

18.

Pappas CJ , O'Donnell TF. Long-term results of compression treatment for lymphedema. J Vasc Surg 1992; 16: 555-62.

19.

Liu NF , Olszewski W. The influence of local hyperthermia on lymphedema and lymphedematous skin of the human leg. Lymphology 1993; 26: 28-37.

20.

NcNair TJ , Martin IJ , Orr JD Intermittent compression for lymphoedema of arm. Clin Oncol 1976; 2: 339-42.

21.

Kim-Sing C. , Basco VE Postmastectomy lymphedema treated with the Wright Linear Pump. Can J Surg 1987; 30: 368-70.

22.

Yamazaki Z. , Idozuki Y. , Nemoto T. , Tagawa Y. Clinical experiences using pneumatic massage therapy for edematous limbs: the last ten years. Angiology 1988; 39: 154-213.

23.

Eccles MV Hand volumetrics. Br J Phys Med 1956; 19: 5-8.

24.

Kettle JH , Rundle FF , Oddie TH Measurement of upper limb volumes: a clinical method. Aust NZJ Surg 1958; 27: 263-70.

25.

Dirette D. , Hinojosa J. Effects of continuous passive motion on the edematous hands of two persons with flaccid hemiplagia. Am J Occup Ther 1994 ; 48: 403-409.

26.

Badger C. Guidelines for the calculation of limb volume based on surface measurements . Br Lymphol Interest Group Newsletter 1993 ; 7: 3-7.

27.

Sitzia J. Volume measurement in lymphoedema treatment: examination of formulae. Eur J Cancer Care 1995; 4: 11-16.

28.

Pettund CF Volumetry of limbs. In: Olszewski WL ed. Lymph stasis, pathophysiology, diagnosis and treatment. Boca Raton: CRC Press, 1991: 443-51.

29.

Pani SP , Vanamail P. , Yuvaraj J. Limb circumference measurement for recording edema volume in patients with filarial lymphedema. Lymphology 1995; 28: 57-63.

30.

Fischbach JU , Mönter B. , Göltner E. Messungen von armöden durch optoelektronische volumetrie. Phlebol Proktol 1986; 15: 184-89.

31.

Göltner E. , Gass P. , Haas JP , Schneider P. The importance of volumetry, lymphscintigraphy and computer tomography in the diagnosis of brachial edema after mastectomy. Lymphology 1988; 21: 134-43.

32.

Bednarczyk JH , Hershler C. , Cooper DG Development and clinical evaluation of a computerized limb volume measurement system (CLEMS). Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1992; 73: 60-63.

33.

Stanton Awb , Northfield JW , Holroyd B. , Mortimer PS , Levick JR Validation of an optoelectronic limb volumeter (Perometer®). Lymphology 1997; 30: 77-97.

34.

Airaksinen O. , Partanen K. , Kolari PJ , Soimakallio S. Intermittent pneumatic compression therapy in posttraumatic lower limb edema: computed tomography and clinical measurements . Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1991; 72: 667-70.

35.

Martin PE , Mungiole M. , Marzke MW , Longhill JM The use of magnetic resonance imaging for measuring segment inertial properties . J Biomech 1989; 22: 367-76.

36.

Collins CD , Mortimer PS , D'Ettorre H. , A'Hern RP, Moskovic EC. Computer tomography in the assessment of response to limb compression in unilateral lymphoedema. Clin Radiol 1995; 50: 541-44.

37.

Casley-Smith JR Measuring and representing peripheral oedema and its alterations. Lymphology 1994; 27: 56-70.

38.

Kaulesar Sukul DM , den Hoed PT , Johammes EJ , van Dolder R. , Benda E. Direct and indirect methods for the quantification of leg volume: comparison between water displacement volumetry, the disk model method and the frustum sign model method, using the correlation coefficient and the limits of agreement. J Biomed Eng 1993; 15: 477-80.

39.

Stern EB Volumetric comparison of seated and standing test postures. Am J Occup Ther 1991; 45: 801-805.

40.

Kissen MW , Querci della Rovere G, Easton D, Westbury G. Risk of lymphoedema following the treatment of breast cancer. Br J Surg 1986; 73: 580-84.

41.

Stranden E. A comparison between surface measurements and water displacement volumetry for the quantification of leg edema. J Oslo City Hosp 1981; 31: 153-55.

42.

Bland JM , Altman DG Statistical methods for assessing agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. Lancet 1986; i: 307-310.

43.

Engler H. , Sweat R. Volumetric arm measurements: technique and results. Am Surgeon 1962; 28: 465-68.

44.

Swedborg I. Voluminometric estimation of the degree of lymphedema and its therapy by pneumatic compression. Scand J Rehabil Med 1977; 9: 131-35.

45.

Woods M. An audit of swollen limb measurements. Nurs Standard 1994; 9(5): 24-26.

46.

Lennihan R. , Mackereth M. Calculating volume changes in a swollen extremity from surface measurements . Am J Surg 1973; 126: 649-52.

47.

Brennan MJ Lymphoedema following the surgical treatment of breast cancer: a review of pathophysiology and treatment. J Pain Symptom Management 1992; 7: 110-16.

48.

Casley-Smith JR, Casley-Smith JR. Modern treatment of lymphoedema. 1: Complex physical therapy: the first 200 Australian limbs. Australas J Dermatol 1992; 33: 61-68.

49.

Bunce IH , Mirolo BR , Hennessy JM , Ward LC , Jones LC Post-mastectomy lymphoedema treatment and measurement. Med J Aust 1994; 161: 125-28.

50.

Kuhnke E. Volumbestimmung aus umfangmessungen. Folia Angiologica 1976; 24: 228-32.

51.

Carroll D. , Rose K. Treatment leads to significant improvement. Prof Nurse 1992; 8(1): 32-36.

52.

Rose K. , Taylor H. , Twycross R. Volume reduction of arm lymphoedema. Nurs Standard 1993; 7(35): 29-32.

53.

Charge H. Treatment of lymphoedema. Nurs Times 1995; 91(30): 53-58.

54.

Mortimer PS , Levick JR , Stanton Awb. On the pathophysiology of arm lymphocdcma after treatment for breast cancer [Letter]. Lymphology 1993; 28: 156-58.

55.

Aslam M. , Tierney S. , Grace P. , Standfield N. , Pflug J. Swollen leg or just big? Eur J Lymphol 1996 ; 6 (Sp. Co.): 21 (abstract).

56.

Pflug J. Intermittent compression in the management of swollen legs in general practice . Practitioner 1975; 215: 69-76.

57.

Egawa Y. , Sato A. , Katoh I. , Natori Y. , Monden Y. Reduction in arm swelling and changes in protein components of lymphedema fluid after intraarterial injection of autologous lymphocytes. Lymphology 1993; 26: 169-76.

58.

Dennis B. Acquired lymphoedema: a chart review of nine women's responses to intervention . Am J Occup Ther 1993; 47: 891-99.

59.

Chang TS , Han L. , Gan J. , Haung W. Microwave: an alternative to electric heating in the treatment of peripheral lymphedema. Lymphology 1989; 22: 20-24.

60.

Casley-Smith JR , Casley-Smith JR Treatment of lymphedema by complex physical therapy, with and without oral and topical benzopyrones: what should therapists and patients expect. Lymphology 1996; 29: 76-82.

61.

Soria P. , Cuesta A. , Romero H. , Martinez FJ , Sastre A. Dietary treatment of lymphedema by restriction of long-chain triglycerides . Angiology 1994; 45: 703-707.

62.

Chang TS , Huang W. , Han L. , Liu W.

Heat and bandage treatment for chronic lymphedema of extremities. Report of 1045 patients. Chin

Med J 1984; 97: 567-77.

63.

Weissleder H. , Weissleder R. Lymphedema: evaluation of qualitative and quantiative lymphoscintigraphy in 238 patients. Radiology 1988; 167: 729-35.

64.

Proby CM , Gane JN , Joseph Aea , Mortimer PS Investigation of the swollen limb with isotope lymphography. Br J Dermatol 1990; 123: 29-37.

65.

Cambria RA , Gloviczki P. , Naessens JM , Wahner HW Noninvasive evaluation of the lymphatic system with lymphoscintigraphy: a prospective, semiquantitative analysis in 386 extremities. J Vasc Surg 1993; 18: 773-82.

66.

Kiely PD , Joseph AE , Mortimer PS , Bourke BE Upper limb lymphedema associated with polyarthritis of rheumatoid type. J Rheumatol 1994; 21: 1043-45.

67.

Eliska O. , Eliskova M. Are peripheral lymphatics damaged by high pressure manual massage? Lymphology 1995; 28: 21-30.

68.

Bates DO , Levick JR , Mortimer PS Quantification of rate and depth of pitting in human edema using an electronic tonometer. Lymphology 1994; 27: 159-72.

69.

Liu NF , Olszewski W. The use of tonometry to assess lower extremity lymphedema. Lymphology 1992; 25: 155-58.

70.

Chang TS Microwave heating in the management of peripheral lymphoedema. Scope Phlebol Lymphol 1996; 2(4): 18-20.

71.

Cornish BH , Bunce IH , Ward LC , Jones LC , Thomas BJ Bioelectrical impedance for monitoring the efficacy of lymphoedema treatment programmes. Breast Cancer Res Treat 1996; 38: 169-76.

72.

Jeffs E. Management of lymphoedema: putting treatment into context. J Tissue Viability 1992; 2: 127-31.

73.

Cole TM , Tobis JS Measurement of musculoskeletal function. In: Kottke FJ , Lehmann JF eds. Krusen's handbook of physical medicine and rehabilitation, fourth edition. Philadelphia: WB Saunders , 1990: 20-71.

74.

Todd J. Movement screening tool. A report from the BLIG Movement and Exercise Working Party. Paper presented at the BLIG Annual Conference , Derby, 7-8 October 1996.

75.

Getz DH The primary, secondary, and tertiary nursing interventions of lymphedema. Cancer Nurs 1985; 8: 177-84.

76.

Potter SA An investigation into the problems and needs of patients with secondary lymphoedema of the leg. Unpublished MSc (Advanced Clinical Practice) thesis, University of Surrey, 1995.

77.

Zanolla R. , Monzeglio C. , Balzarini A. , Martino G. Evaluation of the results of three different methods of postmastectomy lymphedema treatment. J Surg Oncol 1984; 26: 210-13.

78.

Woods M. Patients' perceptions of breast-cancer-related lymphoedema. Eur J Cancer Care 1993; 2: 125-28.

79.

Fitzpatrick R. Measurement of patient satisfaction. In: Hopkins A , Costain D eds. Measuring the outcomes of medical care. London: Royal College of Physicians of London, 1990: 19-26.