This study reports an empirical investigation of the influence of felt (internal
locus — IL) emotion versus expressed (external locus — EL)
emotion upon preference in music. Sixty-fve participants rated IL and EL of emotions
for fve pieces of romantic western art music. For each locus task `emotional
strength', `valence', `arousal' and `dominance' were rated and converted into
magnitude scores. Ratings of familiarity and preference were also collected. Gap
across emotion loci (GAEL) was calculated overall — which combined GAEL
scores in polar-coordinate emotion-space, and for each dimension. Familiarity, felt
emotional strength and overall GAEL explained 46.9 percent of the variance in
preference. Both IL and EL negative valence were correlated with preference
suggesting enjoyment of negative emotion in music through dissociation. The study
suggests that the way music makes the listener feel is more important in determining
enjoyment than noticing the emotion the music is trying to convey. Also, matching of
IL and EL emotions (i.e. minimizing GAEL) is more preferred than when IL emotions
are lower in magnitude than EL. Hence two principles of enjoyment are identifed in
this study: (1) dissociation and (2) GAEL.
Budd, M.
(1995) Values of Art: Pictures, Poetry, and Music.
London: Penguin
.
2.
Buhler, J.
,
Flinn, C.
and
Neumeyer, D.
(eds) (2000) Music and Cinema.
Hanover, NH: University Press of New England
.
3.
Carroll, N.
(2000) `
Art and Ethical Criticism: An Overview of Recent Directions of Research'
, Ethics110(2):
350—87
.
4.
Cohen, A.J.
(2000) `flm Music: Perspectives from Cognitive
Psychology ', in
J. Buhler
,
C. Flinn
and
D. Neumeyer
(eds) Music and Cinema, pp.
360—77.
Hanover, NH: University Press of New England
.
5.
Dibben, N.
(2004) `
The Role of Peripheral Feedback in Emotional Experience with Music'
, Music Perception22(1):
79—115
.
6.
Feagin, S.L.
(1983) `
The Pleasures of Tragedy
', American Philosophical Quarterly20(1):
95—104
.
7.
Fubini, E.
(1990[1987]) The History of Music Aesthetics
(trans. M. Hatwell).
London: Macmillan
.
8.
Gabrielsson, A.
(2001—02)
`Emotion Perceived and Emotion Felt: Same or Different?'Musicae Scientiae, Special Issue:
123—47
.
9.
Galgur, E.
(2001) `
The Poetry and the Pity: Hume's Account of Tragic Pleasure'
, British Journal of Aesthetics41(4):
411—24
.
10.
Gatewood, E.L.
(1927) `An Experimental Study of the Nature of Musical
Enjoyment', in
M. Schoen
(ed.) The Effects of Music, pp.
78—120.
New York: Harcourt Brace
.
11.
Goldstein, I.
(1989) `
Pleasure and Pain — Unconditional, Intrinsic Values'
, Philosophy and Phenomenological Research50(2):
255—76
.
12.
Gorbman, C.
(1987) Unheard Melodies: Narrative flm Music.
Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press
.
13.
Hargreaves, D.J.
(1984) `
The Effects of Repetition on Liking for Music', Journal of Research in MusicEducation32(1):
35—47
.
14.
Harrison, A.C.
and
O'Neill, S.A.
(2002) `
The Development of Children's Gendered Knowledge and Preference in Music
', Feminism & Psychology12(2):
145—52
.
15.
Helm, B.W.
(2002)
`Felt Evaluations: A Theory of Pleasure and Pain'
, American Philosophical Quarterly39(1):
13—30
.
16.
Iwanaga, M.
and
Tsukamoto, M.
(1998) `
Preference for Musical Tempo Involving Systematic Variations of Presented
Tempi for Known and Unknown Musical Excerpts'
, Perceptual & Motor Skills86(1):
31—41
.
17.
Izard, C.E.
(1991) The Psychology of Emotions.
New York: Plenum
.
18.
Janovic, T.
,
Ivkovic, V.
,
Nazor, D.
,
Grammer, K.
and
Jovanovic, V.
(2003)
`Empathy, Communication, Deception'
, Collegium Antropologicum27(2):
809—22
.
19.
Kant, I.
(1952) The Critique of Judgement (trans. J.C. Meredith)
.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
20.
Kingsbury, J.
(2002) `
Matravers on Musical Expressiveness'
, British Journal of Aesthetics42(1):
13—19
.
21.
Kivy, P.
(1990) Music Alone: Philosophical Reflections on the Purely
Musical Experience.
Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press
.
22.
Knobloch, S.
and
Zillmann, D.
(2003) `
Appeal of Love Themes in Popular Music'
, Psychological Reports93(3):
653—8
.
23.
Leder, H.
,
Belke, B.
,
Oeberst, A.
and
Augustin, D.
(2004) `
A Model of Aesthetic Appreciation and Aesthetic Judgments', British Journal ofPsychology95:
489—508
.
24.
Levinson, J.
(1990) `Music and Negative Emotions', in Music,
Art and Metaphysics: Essays in Philosophical Aesthetics, pp.
306—35.
Ithaca: Cornell University Press
.
25.
Levinson, J.
(1992) `
Pleasure and the Value of Works of Art'
, British Journal of Aesthetics32(4):
295—306
.
26.
Makris, I.
and
Mullet, E.
(2003) `
Judging the Pleasantness of Contour—Rhythm—
Pitchtimbre Musical Combinations', American Journal ofPsychology116(4):
581—611
.
27.
Martindale, C.
(1996) `
A Note on the Relationship between Prototypicality and Preference', EmpiricalStudies of the Arts14(1):
109—13
.
28.
Martindale, C.
and
Moore, K.
(1989)
`Relationship of Musical Preference to Collative, Ecological, and
Psychophysical Variables'
, Music Perception6(4):
431—45
.
29.
Martindale, C.
,
Moore, K.
and
Borkum, J.
(1990) `
Aesthetic Preference: Anomalous fndings for Berlyne's Psychobiological
Theory', American Journal ofPsychology103(1):
53—80
.
30.
Matravers, D.
(2003)
`The Experience of Emotion in Music'
, Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism61(4):
353—63
.
North, A.C.
and
Hargreaves, D.J.
(1995) `
Subjective Complexity, Familiarity, and Liking for Popular Music'
, Psychomusicology14(1):
77—93
.
33.
North, A.C.
and
Hargreaves, D.J.
(1997a) `Experimental Aesthetics and Everyday Music
Listening', in
D.J. Hargreaves
and
A.C. North
(eds) The Social Psychology of Music, pp.
84—103.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
34.
North, A.C.
and
Hargreaves, D.J.
(1997b) `
Liking, Arousal Potential, and the Emotions Expressed by Music',
Scandinavian Journal ofPsychology38(1):
45—53
.
35.
North, A.C.
and
Hargreaves, D.J.
(1998) `
Complexity, Prototypicality, Familiarity, and the Perception of Musical Quality
', Psychomusicology17(1—2):
77—80
.
36.
Peretz, I.
,
Gaudreau, D.
and
Bonnel, A.-M.
(1998) `
Exposure Effects on Music Preference and Recognition
', Memory & Cognition26(5):
884—902
.
37.
Rentfrow, P.J.
and
Gosling, S.D.
(2003) `
The Do Re Mi's of Everyday Life: The Structure and Personality Correlates
of Music Preferences', Journal of Personality &Social Psychology84(6):
1236—56
.
38.
Ritossa, D.A.
and
Rickard, N.S.
(2004)
`The Relative Utility of “Pleasantness and Liking”
Dimensions in Predicting the Emotions Expressed by Music'
, Psychology of Music32(1):
5—22
.
39.
Robinson, J.
(1994) `
The Expression and Arousal of Emotion in Music'
, Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism52(1):
13—22
.
40.
Russell, J.A.
(1980) `
A Circumplex Model of Affect', Journal ofSocial Psychology39:
1161—78
.
41.
Russell, J.A.
(1989) `Measures of Emotion', in
R. Plutchik
and
H. Kellerman
(eds) Emotion: Theory, Research and Experience, Vol. 4, pp.
81—111.
New York: Academic Press
.
42.
Russell, J.A.
and
Mehrabian, A.
(1977)
`Evidence for a 3-Factor Theory of Emotions'
, Journal of Research in Personality11(3):
273—94
.
43.
Russell, J.A.
,
Weiss, A.
and
Mendelsohn, G.A.
(1989) `
Affect Grid: A Single-Item Scale of Pleasure and Arousal', Journal ofPersonality and Social Psychology57(3):
493—502
.
44.
Schaper, E.
(ed.) (1983) Pleasure, Preference and Value: Studies in
Philosophical Aesthetics.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
45.
Scherer, K.R.
,
Zentner, M.R.
and
Schacht, A.
(2001—02)
`Emotional States Generated by Music: An Exploratory Study of Music Experts'
, Musicae Scientiae , Special Issue:
149—71
.
46.
Schubert, E.
(1996) `
Enjoyment of Negative Emotions in Music: An Associative Network Explanation'
, Psychology of Music24(1):
18—28
.
47.
Schubert, E.
(1999) `
Measuring Emotion Continuously: Validity and Reliability of the
Two-dimensional Emotion-space', Australian Journal ofPsychology51(3):
154—65
.
48.
Schubert, E.
(in press)
`Locus of Emotion: The Effect of Task Order and Age on Emotion Perceived
and Emotion Felt in Response to Music'
, Journal of Music Therapy.
49.
Scruton, R.
(1983) The Aesthetic Understanding: Essays in the Philosophy
of Art and Culture.
London: Methuen
.
50.
Szpunar, K.K.
,
Schellenberg, E.G.
and
Pliner, P.
(2004) `
Liking and Memory for Musical Stimuli as a Function of Exposure', Journal
of ExperimentalPsychology: Learning, Memory & Cognition30(2):
370—81
.
51.
Tarrant, M.
,
North, A.C.
and
Hargreaves, D.J.
(2001) `
Social Categorization, Self Esteem, and the Estimated Musical Preferences
of Male Adolescents', Journal ofSocial Psychology,141(5):
565—81
.
52.
Tekman, H.G.
and
Hortacsu, N.
(2002) `
Music and Social Identity: Stylistic Identifcation as a Response to Musical Style'
, International Journal of Psychology37(5):
277—85
.
53.
Terwogt, M.M.
(1987) `
Children's Behavioural Reactions in Situations with a Dual Emotional Impact
', Psychological Reports61(3):
1002
.
54.
Terwogt, M.M.
and
Van Grinsven, F.
(1991)
`Musical Expression of Moodstates'
, Psychology of Music19(2):
99—109
.
55.
Washburn, M.F.
and
Dickinson, G.L.
(1927) `The Sources and Nature of the Affective Reaction to
Instrumental Music', in
M. Schoen
(ed.) The Effects of Music, pp.
121—30.
New York : Harcourt Brace
.
