Labour standards and regulation in global value chains: The case of the New Zealand Fishing Industry

Abstract

Building on the concept of polarity in global value chains, we explore how the nature of the governance of a global value chain can evolve and how contingencies can reshape governance arrangements. A case-study of the New Zealand fishing industry highlights how parties inside and outside the global value chain came to contest labour standards, laying the base for credible regulation. In 2011 through a series of convergent events, migrant crew on board South Korean fishing vessels, hitherto exploited, abused and isolated, emerged as a significant actor to bring about a clear transition in the governance of a multipolar global value chain. In this paper, we analyse the series of events which led to regulatory change and consider whether the dynamics from the case offer lessons for improving labour standards and regulation in global value chains more generally.

Keywords

Global value chains multipolar governance labour chains fishing industry labour exploitation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Azmeh

(2014) Labour in global production networks: Workers in the qualifying industrial zones (QIZs) of Egypt and Jordan. Global Networks 14(4): 495–513.

Bair

(2009) Frontiers of commodity chain research, Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Bair

Palpacuer

(2015) CSR beyond the corporation: Contested governance in global value chains. Global Networks 15(s1): S1–S19.

Barrientos S (2011) ‘Labour chains’: Analysing the role of labour contractors in global production networks. BWPI Working Paper 153, University of Manchester, pp. 1–24. Available at: http://wiego.org/sites/wiego.org/files/publications/files/Barrientos_Labour_Chains.pdf (accessed 16 May 2016).

Barrientos

(2013) ‘Labour chains’: Analysing the role of labour contractors in global production networks. The Journal of Development Studies 49(8): 1058–1071.

Barrientos

Kothari

Phillips

(2013) Dynamics of unfree labour in the contemporary global economy. The Journal of Development Studies 49(8): 1037–1041.

Bastia T and McGrath T (2011) Temporality, migration and unfree labour: Migrant garment workers, Manchester Papers in Political Economy, Working Paper No. 6, University of Manchester, Manchester. Available at: https://tanjabastia.files.wordpress.com/2013/06/bastia-mcgrath-2011-unfree-labour-wp.pdf (accessed 16 May 2016).

Coe

Dicken

Hess

(2008) Global production networks: Realizing the potential. Journal of Economic Geography 8(3): 271–295.

Coe

Hess

(2013) Global production networks, labour and development. Geoforum 44: 4–9.

10.

Dawson P (2012) Foreign charter vessels: A confused legal regime. Speech to the Maritime Law Association of Australia and New Zealand (MLAANZ) – NZ Branch Conference, 27 April 2012. Available at: http://www.maritimelaw.co.nz/uploads/file/MLAANZ%20Conference%20Speech%2027_4_12.pdf (accessed 16 May 2016).

11.

Dawson

Hunt

(2011) The legal regime governing the operation of foreign charter fishing vessels in New Zealand. Australian and New Zealand Maritime Law Journal 25(2): 195–211.

12.

Department of Labour (2004) Department of Labour. Employment Conditions in the Fishing Industry – Final Report on Foreign Crew on New Zealand Fishing Vessels, Wellington, New Zealand.

13.

Department of Labour, Seafood Industry Council, NZ Fishing Industry Guild Inc (2006) Code of Practice on Foreign Fishing Crew, Wellington, New Zealand: Department of Labour.

14.

Devlin

(2009) Modern day slavery: Employment conditions for foreign fishing crews in New Zealand waters. Australian and New Zealand Maritime Law Journal 23(1): 82–98.

15.

Dong Wong (2015) Overseas business. Available at: http://www.dongwonfish.co.kr/eng/work02.php (accessed 16 May 2016).

16.

Fenton

(2012) Foreign Charter Fishing Vessels—Labour Law Breaches. New Zealand Parliamentary Debates, 2 August, Wellington: Hansard.

17.

Field M (2011a) Sailors in hiding after nightmare of ‘slavery’. Sunday Star Times, 3 July, A6.

18.

Field M (2011b) Families of fishing crew face backlash. Sunday Star Times, 10 July, A5.

19.

Fold

(2002) Lead firms and competition in ‘bi-polar’ commodity chains: Grinders and branders in the global cocoa-chocolate industry. Journal of Agrarian Change 2: 228–247.

20.

Gereffi

Korzeniewicz

(1994) Commodity Chains and Global Capitalism, Westport, CT: Praeger.

21.

Gereffi

Lee

(2016) Economic and social upgrading in global value chains and industrial clusters: Why governance matters. Journal of Business Ethics 133: 25–38.

22.

Gereffi G, Lee J and Christian M (2008) The governance structures of U.S.-based food and agricultural value chains and their relevance to healthy diets. Available at: http://cggc.duke.edu/pdfs/GlobalHealth/Gereffi_Lee_Christian_RWJFpaper_17June2008.pdf (accessed 16 May 2016).

23.

Gereffi G and Mayer F (2004) The demand for global governance. Terry Sanford Institute of Public Policy Working Paper, Duke University.

24.

Gibbon

Bair

Ponte

(2008) Governing global value chains: An introduction. Economy and Society 37(3): 315–338.

25.

Harrod J (1987) Power, Production, and the Unprotected Worker. New York: Columbia University Press.

26.

Haworth

(2011) A political economy of ‘The Hobbit’ dispute. New Zealand Journal of Employment Relations 36(3): 100–109.

27.

Henderson

Dicken

Hess

(2002) Global production networks and the analysis of economic development. Review of International Political Economy 9(3): 436–464.

28.

Herod

(1997) From a geography of labor to a labor geography: Labor’s spatial fix and the geography of capitalism. Antipode 29(1): 1–31.

29.

ILO (2013) Caught at Sea. Forced Labour and Trafficking in Fisheries, Geneva: International Labour Office.

30.

Islam

(2009) From pond to plate: Towards a twin-driven commodity chain in Bangladesh shrimp aquaculture. Food Policy 33: 209–223.

31.

Jakarta Post (2015) Susi seeks protection for Indonesian 'slaves' in New Zealand waters, 30 November. Available at: www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/11/30/susi-seeks-protection-indonesian-slaves-new-zealand-waters.html (accessed 16 May 2016).

32.

Kelly G (1996) United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea Bill: Second Reading. New Zealand Parliamentary Debates, 18 April. Wellington: Hansard. Available at: http://www.vdig.net/hansard/content.jsp?id=52984 (accessed 16 May 2016).

33.

Kelly

(2005) General Debate [20677]. New Zealand Parliamentary Debates, 18 May, Wellington: Hansard.

34.

Kim J (2004) Please Punish the Korean Fishing Company which Manipulates Sailors and Crews (in Korean). Ministry of Employment and Labour, 8 January. Available at: http://www.moel.go.kr/view.jsp?cate=1andsec=4andmode=viewandidx=1257 (accessed 16 May 2016).

35.

Knorringa

Pegler

(2006) Globalisation, firm upgrading and impacts on labour. Journal of Economic and Social Geography 97(5): 470–479.

36.

Lakhani

Kuruvilla

Avgar

(2013) From the firm to the network: Global value chains and employment relations theory. British Journal of Industrial Relations 51(3): 440–472.

37.

Maritime Union of New Zealand (2011) Flags of Convenience. Available at: www.munz.org.nz/tag/flag-of-convenience (accessed 16 May 2016).

38.

Ministerial Inquiry into Foreign Charter Vessels (2012) Report of the Ministerial Inquiry into the use and Operation of Foreign Charter Vessels. Wellington: Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries. Available at: http://www.fish.govt.nz/NR/rdonlyres/1CD50F2C-5F55-481D-A3CB-9A7EC25CBE54/0/2012foreignchartervesselsreport.pdf (accessed 16 May 2016).

39.

Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport (2012) Korean Government Decide to Severely Punish Human Rights Abuses for Foreign Crews Aboard Deep Sea Fishing Vessels (in Korean). Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, 28 September. Available at: http://www.korea.kr/policy/pressReleaseView.do?newsId=155852809&call_from=naver_news (accessed 16 May 2016).

40.

Nadvi

Lund-Thomsen

Xue

(2011) Playing against China: Global value chains and labour standards in the international sports goods industry. Global Networks 11(3): 334–354.

41.

National Human Rights Commission of Korea (NHRCK), Standing Committee’s Decision (2012) Opinion on the Case of Sexual Harassment and Wage Discrimination against Foreign Sailors of Deep-sea Fishing Vessels (in Korean). NHRCK, 15 May. Available at: http://www.humanrights.go.kr/04_sub/body02.jsp?m_link_url=04_sub/body02.jsp&m_id1=72&m_id2=75&m_id3=&m_id4=&flag=VIEW&SEQ_ID=604839 (accessed 16 May 2016).

42.

Neilson

Pritchard

(2009) Value Chain Struggles: Institutions and Governance in the Plantation Districts of South India, West Sussex, UK: Wiley-Blackwell.

43.

OECD (2013) Implications of global value chains for trade, investment, development and jobs. Report prepared for the G20 Leaders Summit, St Petersburg, September.

44.

Phillips

Mieres

(2015) The governance of forced labour in the global economy. Globalizations 12(2): 244–260.

45.

Phillips

Sakamoto

(2012) Global production networks, chronic poverty and ‘slave labour’ in Brazil. Studies in Comparative International Development 47(3): 287–315.

46.

Ponte

(2014) The evolutionary dynamics of biofuel value chains: From unipolar and government-driven to multipolar governance. Environment and Planning A 46: 353–372.

47.

Ponte

Sturgeon

(2014) Explaining governance in global value chains: A modular theory-building effort. Review of International Political Economy 21(1): 195–223.

48.

Posthuma

Nathan

(2010) Labour in Global Production Networks in India, Oxford: OUP.

49.

Proposed Government Changes Will Put Iwi Fishing Companies in Jeopardy, 2006, Joint Media Statement, 2 October. Available at: http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/BU0610/S00018.htm (accessed 16 May 2016).

50.

Rainnie

Herod

McGrath-Champ

(2011) Review and positions: Global production networks and labour. International Journal of Politics, Culture and Society 15(1): 55–76.

51.

Riisgaard

Hammer

(2011) Prospects for labour in global value chains: Labour standards in the cut flower and banana industries. British Journal of Industrial Relations 49(1): 168–190.

52.

Shepherd B (2013) Global value chains and developing country employment: A literature review. OECD Trade Policy Papers No. 156, OECD Publishing. Available at https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1787/5k46j0qw3z7k-en (accessed 16 May 2016).

53.

Shingal A (2015) Labour market effects of integration into GVCs: Review of the literature. R4D Working Paper, Swiss Programme for Research on Global Issues for Development, World Trade Institute, University of Berne.

54.

Siegmann K, Merk J and Knorringa P (2014) Voluntary initiatives in global value chains. Towards labour-led social upgrading. Working Paper 586, CIRI Working Paper Series, International Institute of Social Studies, Erasmus University Rotterdam.

55.

Skinner EB (2012) The cruelest catch. BloomsbergBusinessweek, 27 February – 12 March, 70–76.

56.

Strauss

(2012) Coerced, forced and unfree labour: Geographies of exploitation in contemporary labour markets. Geography Compass 6(3): 137–148.

57.

Strauss

(2013) Unfree again: Social reproduction, flexible labour markets and the resurgence of gang labour in the UK. Antipode 45(1): 180–197.

58.

Stringer C, Simmons G, Coulston D (2011a) Not in New Zealand’s waters, surely? Labour and human rights abuses aboard foreign fishing vessels. Working Paper, New Zealand Asia Institute Working Paper Series 11-01, University of Auckland.

59.

Stringer

Simmons

Rees

(2011b) Shifting post production patterns: Exploring changes in New Zealand's seafood processing industry. New Zealand Geographer 67(3): 161–173.

60.

Stringer

Simmons

Coulston

(2014) Not in New Zealand’s waters, surely? Linking labour issues to GPNs. Journal of Economic Geography 14(4): 739–758.

61.

Stringer

Whittaker

Simmons

(2016) New Zealand's turbulent waters: The use of forced labour in the fishing industry. Global Networks 16(1): 3–24.

62.

Sturgeon

(2001) How do we define value chains and production networks? IDS Bulletin 32(3): 9–18.

63.

Sturgeon

(2002) Modular production networks: A new American model of industrial organization. Industrial and Corporate Change 11: 451–496.

64.

Swain P (2004) Parliamentary debate: Questions for oral answer, 15 September. Wellington: Hansard. Available at: http://www.vdig.net/hansard/content.jsp?id=110405 (accessed 16 May 2016).

65.

Talley’s Group Ltd (2011) Submission on the Ministerial Inquiry into the use and operation of foreign charter vessels. Available at: www.mpi.govt.nz/document-vault/7551 (accessed 16 May 2016).