Fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composites have been widely used to strengthen the deteriorated reinforced concrete structures due to their outstanding characteristics of light weight, high strength, as well as noncorrosion. A successful strengthening with the FRP composites would equip the existing structures with the prominent improvement in terms of the durability, ductility, and bearing capacity. Current studies indicate that a simple and reliable anchorage system for the FRP composites will help improve the performance of the strengthened structures both efficiently and economically. Up till now, various anchorage systems have been developed for the FRP composites. Therefore, it is necessary to select appropriate anchorage systems according to different needs and establish relevant design specifications. In view of the aforementioned objectives, this paper systematically summarizes the anchoring mechanism of anchorage systems for two commonly used FRP products (FRP laminates and FRP bars) in different strengthened systems. Additionally, a state-of-the-art review as well as the advantages and disadvantages of each anchorage system are presented. Finally, shortcomings in the current state of knowledge and recommendations beneficial to further study are put forward.
BakisCEBankLCBrownVL, et al.
Fiber-reinforced polymer composites for construction: state-of-the-art review. J Compos Constr2002;
6: 73–87.
2.
RobertMCousinPBenmokraneB.Durability of GFRP reinforcing bars embedded in moist concrete. J Compos Constr2009;
13: 66–73.
3.
WangZZhaoXLXianG, et al.
Long-term durability of basalt-and glass-fibre reinforced polymer (BFRP/GFRP) bars in seawater and sea sand concrete environment. Constr Build Mater2017;
139: 467–489.
4.
DongZWuGZhaoXL, et al.
Durability test on the flexural performance of seawater sea-sand concrete beams completely reinforced with FRP bars. Constr Build Mater2018;
192: 671–682.
5.
LiLHouBLuZ, et al.
Fatigue behaviour of sea sand concrete beams reinforced with basalt fibre-reinforced polymer bars. Constr Build Mater2018;
179: 160–171.
6.
LiuXSunYWuT.Flexural capacity and deflection of fiber-reinforced lightweight aggregate concrete beams reinforced with GFRP Bars. Sensors2019;
19: 873.
7.
TriantafillouTC.Shear strengthening of reinforced concrete beams using epoxy-bonded FRP composites. ACI Struct J1998;
95: 107–115.
8.
ChaallalONolletMJPerratonD.Strengthening of reinforced concrete beams with externally bonded fiber-reinforced-plastic plates: design guidelines for shear and flexure. Can J Civ Eng1998;
25: 692–704.
9.
KhalifaANanniA.Improving shear capacity of existing RC T-section beams using CFRP composites. Cem Concr Compos2000;
22: 165–174.
De LorenzisLTengJG.Near-surface mounted FRP reinforcement: an emerging technique for strengthening structures. Compos Part B: Eng2007;
38: 119–143.
12.
de DiegoAArteagaÁFernándezJ.Strengthening of square concrete columns with composite materials. Investigation on the FRP jacket ultimate strain. Compos Part B: Eng2019;
162: 454–460.
13.
BonacciJFMaalejM.Behavioral trends of RC beams strengthened with externally bonded FRP. J Compos Constr2001;
5: 102–113.
14.
BalsamoANardoneFIovinellaI, et al.
Flexural strengthening of concrete beams with EB-FRP, SRP and SRCM: experimental investigation. Compos Part B: Eng2013;
46: 91–101.
15.
WanBJiangCWuYF.Effect of defects in externally bonded FRP reinforced concrete. Constr Build Mater2018;
172: 63–76.
16.
ZhouYGuoMSuiL, et al.
Shear strength components of adjustable hybrid bonded CFRP shear-strengthened RC beams. Compos Part B: Eng2019;
163: 36–51.
17.
El-HachaRRizkallaSH.Near-surface-mounted fiber-reinforced polymer reinforcements for flexural strengthening of concrete structures. Struct J2004;
101: 717–726.
18.
BarrosJAODiasSJELimaJLT.Efficacy of CFRP-based techniques for the flexural and shear strengthening of concrete beams. Cem Concr Compos2007;
29: 203–217.
19.
Al-MahmoudFCastelAFrançoisR, et al.
Strengthening of RC members with near-surface mounted CFRP rods.Compos Struct2009;
91: 138–147.
20.
ZhuHLiTZhuG, et al.
Fire Resistance of strengthened RC members using NSM CFRP bars with a cladding layer. J Compos Constr2018;
23: 0401806.
21.
GowdaCCBarrosJAOGuadagniniM.Experimental study of torsional strengthening on thin walled tubular reinforced concrete structures using NSM-CFRP laminates. Compos Struct2019;
208: 585–599.
22.
De LorenzisLNanniALa TegolaA. Strengthening of reinforced concrete structures with near surface mounted FRP rods. In: International meeting on composite materials, PLAST 2000, proceedings, advancing with composites, 2000, pp. 9–11.
23.
AzizMAAbdel-SayedGGhribF, et al.
Analysis of concrete beams prestressed and post-tensioned with externally unbonded carbon fiber reinforced polymer tendons. Can J Civ Eng2005;
32: 1138–1151.
24.
WangHJinWClelandDJ, et al.
Strengthening an in-service reinforcement concrete bridge with prestressed CFRP bar. J Zhejiang Univ Sci A2009;
10: 635–644.
25.
MacDougallCGreenMAmatoL.CFRP tendons for the repair of posttensioned, unbonded concrete buildings. J Perform Constr Facil2010;
25: 149–157.
26.
TuaktaCBüyüköztürkO.Deterioration of FRP/concrete bond system under variable moisture conditions quantified by fracture mechanics. Compos Part B: Eng2011;
42: 145–154.
27.
BiscaiaHCChastreCSilvaMAG.Estimations of the debonding process of aged joints through a new analytical method. Compos Struct2019;
211: 577–595.
28.
TuaktaCBüyüköztürkO.Conceptual model for prediction of FRP-concrete bond strength under moisture cycles. J Compos Constr2011;
15: 743–756.
29.
Silva M A G, Cidade M T, Biscaia H, et al. Composites and FRP-strengthened beams subjected to dry/wet and salt fog cycles[J]. Journal of Materials in Civil Engineering, 2014; 26: 04014092.
30.
BiscaiaHCChastreCSilvaMAG.A simple method for the determination of the bond-slip model of artificially aged joints. J Compos Constr2019;
23: 04019028.
31.
BiscaiaHCSilvaMAGChastreC.Influence of external compressive stresses on the performance of GFRP-to-concrete interfaces subjected to aggressive environments: an experimental analysis. J Compos Constr2015;
20: 04015044.
32.
ZhouYFanZDuJ, et al.
Bond behavior of FRP-to-concrete interface under sulfate attack: an experimental study and modeling of bond degradation. Constr Build Mater2015;
85: 9–21.
33.
LiuSPanYLiH, et al.
Durability of the bond between CFRP and concrete exposed to thermal cycles. Materials2019;
12: 515.
BuyukozturkOGunesOKaracaE.Progress on understanding debonding problems in reinforced concrete and steel members strengthened using FRP composites. Constr Build Mater2004;
18: 9–19.
36.
CoelhoMRFSena-CruzJMNevesLAC.A review on the bond behavior of FRP NSM systems in concrete. Constr Build Mater2015;
93: 1157–1169.
37.
ZhangSSYuTChenGM.Reinforced concrete beams strengthened in flexure with near-surface mounted (NSM) CFRP strips: current status and research needs. Compos Part B: Eng2017;
131: 30–42.
38.
Shi JZ. Long-term behaviors of RC beam prestressed with external BFRP tendons in marine environment. Dissertation, Southeast University, China, 2019.
39.
Zhang L. Study on optimization design for a wedge anchor of FRP tendon based on homologous materials and its performance. Dissertation, Southeast University, China, 2019.
EslamiAShayeghHRMoghavemA, et al.
Experimental and analytical investigations of a novel end anchorage for CFRP flexural retrofits. Compos Part B: Eng2019;
176: 107309.
42.
CeroniFPecceM.Evaluation of bond strength in concrete elements externally reinforced with CFRP sheets and anchoring devices. J Compos Constr2010;
14: 521–530.
43.
LeeJLopezMM.Characterization of FRP Uwrap anchors for externally bonded FRP-reinforced concrete elements: an experimental study. J Compos Constr2016;
20: 04016012.
44.
SmithSTTengJG.Shear-bending interaction in debonding failures of FRP-plated RC beams. Adv Struct Eng2003;
6: 183–199.
45.
Buyle-BodinFDavidE.Use of carbon fibre textile to control premature failure of reinforced concrete beams strengthened with bonded CFRP plates. J Ind Text2004;
33: 145–157.
46.
ChenWPhamTMSichembeH, et al.
Experimental study of flexural behaviour of RC beams strengthened by longitudinal and U-shaped basalt FRP sheet. Compos Part B: Eng2018;
134: 114–126.
47.
FuBTangXTLiLJ, et al.
Inclined FRP U-jackets for enhancing structural performance of FRP-plated RC beams suffering from IC debonding. Compos Struct2018;
200: 36–46.
48.
YalimBKalayciASMirmiranA.Performance of FRP-strengthened RC beams with different concrete surface profiles. J Compos Constr2008;
12: 626–634.
49.
GB50608.Technical code for infrastructure application of FRP composites.
Beijing:
Chinese National Standard, 2010.
50.
ACI 440.2R-17.Guide for the design and construction of externally bonded FRP systems for strengthening concrete structures.
Farmington Hills, MI:
American Concrete Institute, 2017.
51.
Concrete Society Technical Report No. 55. Design guidance for strengthening concrete structures using fibre composite materials. 2nd ed. 2012.
52.
ReedCEPetermanRJRasheedHA. Evaluating FRP repair method for cracked prestressed concrete bridge members subjected to repeated loadings (Phase 1). 2005.
53.
FuBTengJGChenJF, et al.
Concrete cover separation in FRP-plated RC beams: mitigation using FRP U-jackets. J Compos Constr2016;
21: 04016077.
54.
MostafaAABRazaqpurAG.A new CFRP anchor for preventing separation of externally bonded laminates from concrete. J Reinf Plast Compos2013;
32: 1895–1906.
55.
MostafaARazaqpurAG.CFRP anchor for preventing premature debonding of externally bonded FRP laminates from concrete. J Compos Constr2013;
17: 641–650.
56.
WuYFHuangY.Hybrid bonding of FRP to reinforced concrete structures. J Compos Constr2008;
12: 266–273.
57.
YunYWuYFTangWC.Performance of FRP bonding systems under fatigue loading. Eng Struct2008;
30: 3129–3140.
58.
WuY.New technologies for safer application of FRP in RC structures. Ind Constr2011;
41: 20–27.
59.
WuZMHuCHWuYF, et al.
Improved hybrid bonding technique for attaching FRP to reinforced concrete beams. Mag Concr Res2011;
63: 861–869.
WuYFWangZLiuK, et al.
Numerical analyses of hybrid-bonded FRP strengthened concrete beams. Comput‐Aid Civil Infrast Eng2009;
24: 371–384.
62.
WuYFHeLBankLC.Bond-test protocol for plate-to-concrete interface involving all mechanisms. J Compos Constr2015;
20: 04015022.
63.
LeiGFengZ.Composite interfacial bonding characteristics of HB-FRP to concrete structures. J Build Mater2018;
21: 969–976.
64.
LeiGFengZJianshuY, et al.
Effects of lateral constraint on the behaviour of FRP-to-concrete bond. J Southeast Univ (Nat Sci Ed)2018;
48: 996–1003.
65.
FengZXiangfenXShucaiL.A unified bond-slip model for HB-FRP strengthened concrete structures. Appl Math Mech2015;
36: 1294–1305.
66.
FengZXiangfenXShucaiL.Bond-slip model for HB-FRP systems bonded to concrete. China J Highway Transport2015;
28: 38–44 + 53.
67.
GuanYHJiangBSJiangYD. Experimental study on RC beams strengthened in shear with the FRP-bolt strengthening technology. In: Design, construction, rehabilitation, and maintenance of bridges, 2011, pp. 57–64.
68.
FengZXiangfenXShucaiL.Meso-scale finite element analysis of HB-FRP strengthened reinforced concrete beams. J Harbin Inst Technol2015;
47: 125–128.
69.
LamLTengJG.Strength of RC cantilever slabs bonded with GFRP strips. J Compos Constr2001;
5: 221–227.
70.
KoutasLTriantafillouTC.Use of anchors in shear strengthening of reinforced concrete T-beams with FRP. J Compos Constr2012;
17: 101–107.
71.
LlauradóPVIbellTGómezJF, et al.
Pull-out and shear-strength models for FRP spike anchors. Compos Part B: Eng2017;
116: 239–252.
72.
OzbakkalogluTFangCGholampourA.Influence of FRP anchor configuration on the behavior of FRP plates externally bonded on concrete members. Eng Struct2017;
133: 133–150.
73.
del Rey CastilloEInghamJMSmithST, et al. A design approach for FRP anchors in FRP-strengthened RC structures. In: Proceedings of the 13th conference on Fiber Reinforced Polymers in Reinforced Concrete Structures (FRPRCS-13), American Concrete Institute (ACI), Anaheim, CA, USA, 2017.
74.
del Rey CastilloEDizhurDGriffithM, et al.
Strengthening RC structures using FRP spike anchors in combination with EBR systems. Compos Struct2019;
209: 668–685.
75.
SmithSTZhangHWangZ.Influence of FRP anchors on the strength and ductility of FRP-strengthened RC slabs. Constr Build Mater2013;
49: 998–1012.
76.
ZhangHWSmithSTKimSJ.Optimisation of carbon and glass FRP anchor design. Constr Build Mater2012;
32: 1–12.
77.
ZhangHSmithST.Influence of plate length and anchor position on FRP-to-concrete joints anchored with FRP anchors. Compos Struct2017;
159: 615–624.
78.
KimSJSmithST.Pullout strength models for FRP anchors in uncracked concrete. J Compos Constr2010;
14: 406–414.
79.
SinghAdel Rey CastilloEInghamJ.FRP-to-FRP bond characterization and force-based bond length model. Compos Struct2019;
210: 724–734.
80.
del Rey CastilloEGriffithMInghamJ.Straight FRP anchors exhibiting fiber rupture failure mode. Compos Struct2019;
207: 612–624.
81.
del Rey CastilloEDizhurDGriffithM, et al.
Experimental testing and design model for bent FRP anchors exhibiting fiber rupture failure mode. Compos Struct2019;
210: 618–627.
82.
SmithSTHuSKimSJ, et al.
FRP-strengthened RC slabs anchored with FRP anchors. Eng Struct2011;
33: 1075–1087.
83.
KimYQuinnKGhannoumWM, et al.
Strengthening of reinforced concrete T-beams using anchored CFRP materials. ACI Struct J2014;
111: 1027.
84.
KimYGhannoumWMJirsaJO.Shear behavior of full-scale reinforced concrete T-beams strengthened with CFRP strips and anchors. Constr Build Mater2015;
94: 1–9.
85.
del Rey CastilloEGriffithMInghamJ.Seismic behavior of RC columns flexurally strengthened with FRP sheets and FRP anchors. Compos Struct2018;
203: 382–395.
86.
QaziS.Mechanical behavior of RC walls under seismic activity strengthened with CFRP. Dissertation, INSA de Lyon, France, 2013.
87.
KimISJirsaJOBayrakO.Anchorage of carbon fiber-reinforced polymer on side faces of reinforced concrete beams to provide continuity. ACI Struct J2013;
110: 1089.
88.
BiscaiaHCMicaeloRTeixeiraJ, et al.
Numerical analysis of FRP anchorage zones with variable width. Compos Part B: Eng2014;
67: 410–426.
89.
WeiS.Experimental Research of prestressed reinforced concrete shear T beam using self-anchorage CFRP of U shape. Dissertation, Central South University, China, 2012.
90.
ChaoyangZJunLZhonghuiW.Experimental study on shear performance of RC beams strengthened with hybrid-anchored and prestressed CFRP U-strips. China Civil Eng J2018;
51: 1–10.
91.
JunLChaoyangZD-M-YHan, et al.
Design and experiment study of prestressing system for U-shaped FRP sheet in shear strengthening. J Hunan Univ (Nat Sci)2016;
43: 47–54.
92.
ChaoyangZYananYZaoX, et al.
Flexure tests on narrow concrete beams strengthened with CFRP sheets end-locked by winding around twin-rods. Acta Mater Compos Sin2018;
35: 2216–2221.
93.
ChaoyangZBoyongZJunL, et al.
Shear tests of RC beams strengthened with unbounded prestressed U-straps of CFRP. J Harbin Inst Technol2017;
49: 15–20.
94.
MeierUStöcklinIWinistörferA. Method and device for applying pretensed tension-proof reinforcing strips to a construction. U.S. Patent 6,464,811[P], 2002.
95.
StöcklinIMeierU. Strengthening of concrete structures with prestressed and gradually anchored CFRP strips. In: FRPRCS-6, Singapore, 2003.
96.
StöcklinI. A novel carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP) system for post-strengthening. In: International conference on concrete repair, rehabilitation and retrofitting (ICCRRR), Cape Town, South Africa, 21–23 November 2005.
97.
MichelsJSena-CruzJCzaderskiC, et al.
Structural strengthening with prestressed CFRP strips with gradient anchorage. J Compos Constr2013;
17: 651–661.
98.
Motavalli M, Czaderski C, Pfyl-Lang K. Prestressed CFRP for strengthening of reinforced concrete structures: Recent developments at Empa, Switzerland[J]. Journal of Composites for construction, 2011; 15: 194-205.
99.
CzaderskiCMotavalliM.40-Year-old full-scale concrete bridge girder strengthened with prestressed CFRP plates anchored using gradient method. Compos Part B: Eng2007;
38: 878–886.
100.
MichelsJCzaderskiCEl-HachaR, et al.
Temporary bond strength of partly cured epoxy adhesive for anchoring prestressed CFRP strips on concrete. Compos Struct2012;
94: 2667–2676.
101.
FischliFCléninRDSilvaA, et al. Strengthening of structures with the CARBOSTRESS system. In: Proceedings of the first Asia-Pacific conference on FRP in structures (APFIS 2007), 2007, pp. 387–392.
102.
ZoghiMFosterDC.Preservation of Hopkins Street Bridge via externally bonded prestressed CFRP laminates. Bridge Struct2007;
3: 133–146.
103.
JingZTangningL.Mechanism of an innovative wave-shape-teeth-grip anchor of FRP sheets. China Civil Eng J2005;
53–57: 75.
104.
JingZTangningL.Application of wave-shaped-gear-grip (WSGG) anchor in strengthened and pretensioned experiments by CFRP laminations. Technol Highway Transp2005; 1: 100-104..
105.
JingZTangningLQingxueZ, et al.
Test on beams strengthened with carbon fiber sheets and anchored by wave-shaped-gear-grip anchorage. Build Struct2005;
7: 63–66.
106.
Li Gaohua. Experimental study of prestressed carbon fiber reinforced damaged components. Dissertation, Chong Qing Jiaotong University, China, 2014.
107.
GB 50367-2013 code for design of strengthening concrete structures. Chinese National Standard, China’s Construction Industry, 2013.
108.
XiaoyingCJingZTangningL, et al.
FEM analysis of RC T-beams strengthened with unbonded pre-stressed CFRP belts anchored on multiple points. J Chongqing Univ2017;
40: 57–64.
109.
Puigvert CobosF.Analysis of circular bond-type anchorages for prestressing composite rods under quasi-static, fatigue and time-dependent loads.
Spain:
Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya, 2014.
110.
KimYJKangJYParkJS, et al.
Prestress loss of post-tensioned near-surface-mounted carbon fiber-reinforced polymer for bridge strengthening. ACI Struct J2018;
115.
111.
ParkHParkJSKangJY, et al.
Fatigue behavior of concrete beam with prestressed near-surface mounted CFRP reinforcement according to the strength and developed length. Materials2019;
12: 51.
112.
LeeHLeeWJungWT, et al.
Bond characteristics of near-surface-mounted anchorage for prestressing. Constr Build Mater2017;
148: 748–756.
113.
PuigvertFCrocombeADGilL.Fatigue and creep analyses of adhesively bonded anchorages for CFRP tendons. Int J Adhes Adhes2014;
54: 143–154.
114.
PuigvertFGilLEscrigC, et al.
Stress relaxation analysis of adhesively bonded anchorages for CFRP tendons. Constr Build Mater2014;
66: 313–322.
115.
PuigvertFCrocombeADGilL.Static analysis of adhesively bonded anchorages for CFRP tendons. Constr Build Mater2014;
61: 206–215.
116.
XieGFengQWangCM, et al.
Prediction and optimization of stress distribution in bonded anchors for CFRP tendons. Eng Struct2019;
180: 50–66.
117.
ZhangBBenmokraneB.Large model test of prestressed carbon fibre reinforced polymer ground anchors. Can J Civ Eng2005;
32: 1064–1074.
118.
XieGTangYWangCM, et al.
Experimental study on fatigue performance of adhesively bonded anchorage system for CFRP tendons. Compos Part B: Eng2018;
150: 47–59.
119.
SchmidtJWBennitzAGoltermannP, et al. External post-tensioning of CFRP tendons using integrated sleeve-wedge anchorage. In: 6th international conference on FRP composites in civil engineering: CICE 2012, 2012.
120.
SchmidtJWSmithSTTäljstenB, et al.
Numerical simulation and experimental validation of an integrated sleeve-wedge anchorage for CFRP rods. J Compos Constr2010;
15: 284–292.
ShaheenEShriveNG.Reactive powder concrete anchorage for post-tensioning with carbon fiber-reinforced polymer tendons. ACI Mater J2006;
103: 436.
124.
CaiDYinJLiuR.Experimental and analytical investigation into the stress performance of composite anchors for CFRP tendons. Compos Part B: Eng2015;
79: 530–534.
125.
CaiDXuZYinJ, et al.
A numerical investigation on the performance of composite anchors for CFRP tendons. Constr Build Mater2016;
112: 848–855.
126.
TianyongJZhiF.Experimental investigation on the performance of wedge-bond anchors for CFRP tendons. China Civil Eng J2010;
43: 79–87.
127.
ElsayedTAEldalyAMEl-HefnawyAA, et al.
Behaviour of concrete beams reinforced with hybrid fiber reinforced bars. Adv Compos Mater2011;
20: 245–259.
128.
AshrafiHBazliMOskoueiAV.Enhancement of bond characteristics of ribbed-surface GFRP bars with concrete by using carbon fiber mat anchorage. Constr Build Mater2017;
134: 507–519.
129.
MarananGBManaloACKarunasenaW, et al.
Pullout behaviour of GFRP bars with anchor head in geopolymer concrete. Compos Struct2015;
132: 1113–1121.
130.
LiTZhuHWangQ, et al.
Experimental study on the enhancement of additional ribs to the bond performance of FRP bars in concrete. Constr Build Mater2018;
185: 545–554.
131.
LiJ.Study on the forming method of additional ribs of FRP bars and the effects on anchorage performance. Dissertation, Southeast University, China, 2017.
132.
XingGOzbulutOE.Flexural performance of concrete beams reinforced with aluminum alloy bars. Eng Struct2016;
126: 53–65.
133.
WangQZhuHLiT, et al.
Bond performance of NSM FRP bars in concrete with an innovative additional ribs anchorage system: an experimental study. Constr Build Mater2019;
207: 572–584.
