Do plans get better over time? This deceptively simple question goes to the heart of our profession’s effectiveness. We use a multi-state, longitudinal analysis of eighty-four local plans to add to our knowledge base about changes in plan quality over time. Our longitudinal findings reinforce and extend the conclusions of previous cross-sectional studies of hazard mitigation plan quality. Simply put, local planning to meet federal Disaster Mitigation Act requirements grossly underperforms compared with its potential. Our findings raise cautionary lessons beyond the realm of risk reduction, as well as federal and state policymakers who seek to incentivize local planning.
BaerWilliam C.1997. “General Plan Evaluation Criteria: An Approach to Making Better Plans.”Journal of the American Planning Association63 (3): 329–44.
2.
BerkePhilip R.1996. “Enhancing Plan Quality: Evaluating the Role of State Planning Mandates for Natural Hazard Mitigation.”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management39 (1): 79–96.
3.
BerkePhilip R.FrenchSteven P.1994. “The Influence of State Planning Mandates on Local Plan Quality.”Journal of Planning Education and Research13 (4): 237–50.
4.
BerkePhilip R.GodschalkDavid. 2009. “Searching for the Good Plan: A Meta-Analysis of Plan Quality Studies.”Journal of Planning Literature23 (3): 227–40.
5.
BerkePhilip R.LylesWardSmithGavin. 2014. “Impacts of Federal and State Hazard Mitigation Policies on Local land Use Policy.”Journal of Planning Education and Research34 (1): 60–76.
6.
BerkePhilip R.MalechaMatthew L.YuSiyuLeeJaekyungMastersonJaimie H.2019. “Plan Integration for Resilience Scorecard: Evaluating Networks of Plans in Six US Coastal Cities.”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management62 (5): 901–20.
7.
BerkePhilip R.NewmanGalenLeeJaekyungCombsTabithaKolosnaCarlSalvesenDavid. 2015. “Evaluation of Networks of Plans and Vulnerability to Hazards and Climate Change: A Resilience Scorecard.”Journal of the American Planning Association81 (4): 287–302.
8.
BirklandThomas A.2006. Lessons of Disaster: Policy Change after Catastrophic Events. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.
9.
BrodySamuel D.2003. “Are We Learning to Make Better Plans? A Longitudinal Analysis of Plan Quality Associated with Natural Hazards.”Journal of Planning Education and Research23 (2): 191–201.
10.
BunnellGeneJepsonEdward J.Jr.2011. “The Effect of Mandated Planning on Plan Quality: A Fresh Look at What Makes “A Good Plan.””Journal of the American Planning Association77 (4): 338–53.
11.
BurbyRaymond J.2003. “Making Plans that Matter: Citizen Involvement and Government Action.”Journal of the American Planning Association69 (1): 33–49.
12.
BurbyRaymond J.BeatleyTimothyBerkePhilip R.DeyleRobert E.FrenchSteven P.GodschalkDavid R.KaiserEdward J., et al. 1999. “Unleashing the Power of Planning to Create Disaster-Resistant Communities.”Journal of the American Planning Association65 (3): 247–58.
13.
BurbyRaymond J.MayPeter J.1997. Making Governments Plan: State Experiments in Managing Land Use. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
14.
ButlerWilliamHolmesTishaLangeZechariah. 2021. “Mandated Planning for Climate Change: Responding to the Peril of Flood Act for Sea Level Rise Adaptation in Florida.”Journal of the American Planning Association87 (3): 370–82.
15.
Department of Homeland Security Office of the Inspector General.2012. “Survey of Hazard Mitigation Planning.” OIG-12-109.
16.
DeyleRobert E.SmithRichard A.1998. “Local Government Compliance with State Planning Mandates: The Effects of State Implementation in Florida.”Journal of the American Planning Association64 (4): 457–69.
17.
ElgendawyAlaaDaviesPeterChangHsing-Chung. 2020. “Planning for Cooler Cities: A Plan Quality Evaluation for Urban Heat Island Consideration.”Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning22 (4): 531–53.
18.
GallMelanieFriedlandCarol J.2020. “If Mitigation Saves $6 Per Every $1 Spent, Then Why are we not Investing More? A Louisiana Perspective on a National Issue.”Natural Hazards Review21 (1): 04019013.
GodschalkDavid R.BrodySamuelBurbyRaymond. 2003. “Public Participation in Natural Hazard Mitigation Policy Formation: Challenges for Comprehensive Planning.”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management46 (5): 733–54.
21.
GodschalkDavid R.RoseAdamElliott MittlerPorterKeithWestCarol Taylor. 2009. “Estimating the Value of Foresight: Aggregate Analysis of Natural Hazard Mitigation Benefits and Costs.”Journal of Environmental Planning and Management52 (6): 739–56.
22.
GonickShannon A.ErrettNicole A.2018. “Integrating Climate Change into Hazard Mitigation Planning: A Survey of State Hazard Mitigation Officers.”Sustainability10 (11): Article 4150.
23.
GuyadeenDaveSeasonsMark. 2018. “Evaluation Theory and Practice: Comparing Program Evaluation and Evaluation in Planning.”Journal of Planning Education and Research38 (1): 98–110.
24.
KimHyunMarcouillerDavid W.2018. “Mitigating Flood Risk and Enhancing Community Resilience to Natural Disasters: Plan Quality Matters.”Environmental Hazards17 (5): 397–417.
25.
KimHyunMarcouillerDavid W.2020. “Making Sense of Resilience Planning and Policy in the Pursuit of Sustainable Development and Disaster Risk Reduction.”Climate and Development12 (3): 228–40.
26.
LohCarolyn G.KimRose. 2021. “Are We Planning for Equity? Equity Goals and Recommendations in Local Comprehensive Plans.”Journal of the American Planning Association87 (2): 181–96.
27.
LohCarolyn G.NortonRichard K.2015. “Planning Consultants’ Influence on Local Comprehensive Plans.”Journal of Planning Education and Research35 (2): 199–208.
28.
LukasiewiczAnnaVellaKarenMayereSeverineBakerDouglas. 2020. “Declining Trends in Plan Quality: A Longitudinal Evaluation of Regional Environmental Plans in Queensland, Australia.”Landscape and Urban Planning203: Article 103891.
29.
LylesWardBerkePhilipSmithGavin. 2014. “A Comparison of Local Hazard Mitigation Plan Quality in Six States, USA.”Landscape and Urban Planning122: 89–99.
30.
LylesWardStevens.Mark2014. “Plan Quality Evaluation 1994–2012: Growth and Contributions, Limitations, and New Directions.”Journal of Planning Education and Research34 (4): 433–50.
31.
MeerowSaraWoodruffSierra C.2020. “Seven Principles of Strong Climate Change Planning.”Journal of the American Planning Association86 (1): 39–46.
NelsonArthur C.FrenchSteven P.2002. “Plan Quality and Mitigating Damage from Natural Disasters: A Case Study of the Northridge Earthquake with Planning Policy Considerations.”Journal of the American Planning Association68 (2): 194–207.
34.
NortonRichard K.2008. “Using Content Analysis to Evaluate Local Master Plans and Zoning Codes.”Land Use Policy25 (3): 432–54.
35.
PraterCarla S.LindellMichael K.“Politics of hazard mitigation. 2000.”Natural Hazards Review1(2): 73–82.
36.
SamuelCarlosSiebeneckLaura K.2019. “Roles Revealed: An Examination of the Adopted Roles of Emergency Managers in Hazard Mitigation Planning and Strategy Implementation.”International Journal of Disaster Risk Reduction39: Article 101145.
37.
SchwabJames C.ToppingKenneth C.2010. “Integrating Hazard Mitigation throughout the Comprehensive Plan.”Planning Advisory Service Report560: 23–40.
38.
SmithGavinLylesWardBerkePhilip. 2013. “The Role of the State in Building Local Capacity and Commitment for Hazard Mitigation Planning.”International Journal of Mass Emergencies & Disasters31 (2): 178–203.
39.
SmithGavinMartinAmandaWengerDennis E.2018. “Disaster recovery in an era of climate change: The unrealized promise of institutional resilience.”Handbook of Disaster Research595–619.
40.
SmithGavinViláOlivia. 2022. “Governors and Hazard Mitigation Grants Management: Observations of State and Local Officials.”Natural Hazards Review23 (4): 04022031.
41.
StevensMark R.LylesWardBerkePhilip R.2014. “Measuring and Reporting Intercoder Reliability in Plan Quality Evaluation Research.”Journal of Planning Education and Research34 (1): 77–93.
42.
StultsMissyWoodruffSierra C.2017. “Looking under the Hood of Local Adaptation Plans: Shedding Light on the Actions Prioritized to Build Local Resilience to Climate Change.”Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change22 (8): 1249–79.
43.
WoodruffSierra C.MeerowSaraStultsMissyWilkinsChandler. 2022. “Adaptation to Resilience Planning: Alternative Pathways to Prepare for Climate Change.”Journal of Planning Education and Research42 (1): 64–75.
44.
YuSiyuBrandA. D.BerkePhilip. 2020. “Making Room for the River: Applying a Plan Integration for Resilience Scorecard to a Network of Plans in Nijmegen, the Netherlands.”Journal of the American Planning Association86 (4): 417–30.
45.
ZahranSammyBrodySamuel D.VedlitzArnoldGroverHimanshuMillerCaitlyn. 2008. “Vulnerability and Capacity: Explaining Local Commitment to Climate-Change Policy.”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy26 (3): 544–62.
