This paper critically interrogates 10 dominant claims about teacher leadership that shape contemporary educational discourse. While often portrayed as universally empowering and beneficial, many claims rely on reductive assumptions that overlook power dynamics, cultural variation, and institutional inequities. Drawing on critical and international literature, the analysis reframes teacher leadership as a socially constructed and ethically situated practice. It challenges the notion that leadership is inherently inclusive or always positive, showing how it may reinforce exclusion or managerialism. The paper calls for a reimagining of teacher leadership rooted in equity, dialogue, and contextual responsiveness to foster more transformative leadership in schools.
ArrudaEBlaséJClarkeV (2002) Teacher Leadership in School Reform: Exploring the Central Role of Educators in Implementing Policy and Creating Change. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
2.
BeckJSHintonKButlerBM (2022) Truly open to all: Three ways to diversify teacher leadership. Phi Delta Kappan104(2): 8–13. September Issue.
3.
BeckJSHintonKButlerBM, et al. (2023) Open to all: Administrators’ and teachers’ perceptions of issues of equity and diversity in teacher leadership. Urban Education60(8): 2195–2222.
4.
BlaseJBlaseJ (2002) The dark side of leadership: Teacher perspectives of principal mistreatment. Educational Administration Quarterly38(5): 671–727.
5.
Bradley-LevineJ (2018) Advocacy as a practice of critical teacher leadership. International Journal of Teacher Leadership9(1): 47–62.
6.
Bradley-LevineJ (2021) Promoting Teacher Advocacy as Critical Teacher Leadership. New York, NY: Routledge.
7.
ClarkeM (2023) The subordination of teacher identity: Ethical risks and potential lines of flight. Teachers and Teaching29(3): 241–258.
8.
Domínguez-CastilloJGCisneros-CohernourEJVega-CauichJI (2024) Elements, contexts, and attributes of teacher leadership identified by college professors in southeastern Mexico. International Journal of Educational Leadership and Management12(3): 296–316.
9.
FreireP (1970) Pedagogy of the Oppressed. New York: Herder and Herder.
10.
GhamrawiN (2013a) Never underestimate the power of the sandwiched: Middle leaders and school culture. Basic Research Journal of Educational Research and Review2(2): 29–41.
11.
GhamrawiN (2013b) Leadership styles of school principals and their multiple intelligences profiles: Any relationship. International Journal of Research Studies in Education2(2): 37–49.
12.
GhamrawiNAbu-ShawishRKShalT, et al. (2024a) Destructive leadership behaviors: The case of academic middle leaders in higher education. International Journal of Educational Research126: 102382.
13.
GhamrawiNAl-ThaniH (2023) Wellbeing leadership: Perceptions of pre-service school leaders. Heliyon9(11). 10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e21706.
14.
GhamrawiNShalTGhamrawiNAR (2025a) Teacher leadership through an Arab lens: A contextual and culturally grounded reconceptualisation. School Leadership & Management: 1–26. 10.1080/13632434.2025.2585015.
15.
GhamrawiNShalTGhamrawiNA (2024b) Cultivating teacher leadership: Evidence form a transformative professional development model. School Leadership & Management44(4): 413–441.
16.
GhamrawiNShalTGhamrawiNA (2024c) The rise and fall of teacher leadership: A post-pandemic phenomenological study. Leadership and Policy in Schools23(3): 662–677.
17.
GhamrawiNShalTGhamrawiNA, et al. (2025b) Unleashing the potential of teacher leadership for ESD. Frontiers in Education10: 1614623. DOI: 10.3389/feduc.2025.1614623.
18.
GhamrawiNShalTGhamrawiNA, et al. (2025c) Leading backwards in a forward era: Destructive middle leadership in the pursuit of Higher Education 5.0. Educational Management Administration & Leadership. 10.1177/17411432251396298.
19.
GrissomJAEgaliteAJLindsayCA (2021) What great principals really do. Educational Leadership78(7): 21–25.
20.
HammadWBarakatMMoradH (2025) Perceptions of teacher leadership in Egyptian schools: A mixed-methods exploration. Leadership and Policy in Schools. 10.1080/15700763.2025.2503748.
21.
HargreavesAShirleyD (2009) The Fourth Way: The Inspiring Future for Educational Change. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
22.
HunzickerJ (2017) From teacher to teacher leader: A conceptual model. International Journal of Teacher Leadership8(2): 1–27.
23.
KatzenmeyerMHMollerGV (2009) Awakening the Sleeping Giant: Helping Teachers Develop as Leaders. 3rd ed.Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.
24.
LiuPChenXFChengYX, et al. (2023) Understanding the relationship between teacher leadership and teacher well-being: The mediating roles of trust in leaders and teacher efficacy. Journal of Educational Administration61(6): 646–661.
25.
LiuY (2021) Contextual influence on formal and informal teacher leadership. International Journal of Educational Research Open2: 100028.
26.
Marchant-PérezPLeitãoJNunesA (2024) Abusive leadership: A systematic review of the literature. In: Innovations for Healthcare and Wellbeing: Digital Technologies, Ecosystems and Entrepreneurship. Cham, Switzerland: Springer, pp. 423–455.
27.
MsilaV (2022) Teacher leadership in times of disorder: Building effective leadership in a time of pandemic. In: INTED2022 Proceedings. Valencia, Spain: IATED, pp. 2313–2318.
28.
NaccacheHGhamrawiNShalT, et al. (2025) The latent influence of teacher leadership: Alleviating teaching anxiety in the classroom. Management in Education: 08920206251343998.
29.
NguyenDHarrisANgD (2020) A review of the empirical research on teacher leadership (2003–2017) evidence, patterns and implications. Journal of Educational Administration58(1): 60–80.
30.
NomanMGurrD (2020) Contextual leadership and culture in education. In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. 10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.013.1234
31.
NomanMKaurAZhangR, et al. (2024) Leading to succeed: Contextual leadership practices of semi-urban school principals in China. International Journal of Leadership in Education: 1–20. DOI: 10.1080/13603124.2023.2298205.
32.
PanHLWWiensPDMoyalA (2023) A bibliometric analysis of the teacher leadership scholarship. Teaching and Teacher Education121: 103936.
33.
PfefferJ (2021) The dark triad may be not so dark: Exploring why ‘toxic’leaders are so common—with some implications for scholarship and education. Psychoanalytic Inquiry41(7): 540–551.
34.
RaynerS (2009) Making leadership learning visible: The role of post-compulsory education leaders in generating epistemological insight. Management in Education23(2): 51–56.
35.
RosenML (2017) Teacher leaders as professional development providers: Factors driving teacher learning opportunities. Journal of Education and Human Development6(2): 1–15.
36.
SamCH (2021) What are the practices of unethical leaders? Exploring how teachers experience the “dark side” of administrative leadership. Educational Management Administration & Leadership49(2): 303–320.
37.
SantoroDA (2018) Demoralized: Why Teachers Leave the Profession they Love and how they can Stay. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.
38.
SavaşGArslanKKılınçAÇ (2025) When teacher leadership backfires: Exploring the unintended consequences of teacher leadership in a centralized education system. Educational Management Administration & Leadership. (Advance online publication).
39.
SkourdoumbisARawolleS (2020) The Metrics of Teacher Effectiveness and Teacher Quality Research: Sidelining the Issues that Really Count. London, UK: Routledge.
40.
SmylieMAConleySMarksHM (2002) Section four: Reshaping leadership in action: Exploring new approaches to teacher leadership for school improvement. Teachers College Record104(9): 162–188.
41.
SmylieMAEckertJ (2018) Beyond superheroes and advocacy: The pathway of teacher leadership development. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46(4): 556–577.
SteinmetzJI (2018) Self-efficacy and Its IMPACT on Teacher-leader Burnout (Publication No. 10936200). Doctoral Dissertation, University of La Verne, La Verne, CA. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global.
44.
TriguerosRPadillaAAguilar-ParraJM, et al. (2020) The influence of transformational teacher leadership on academic motivation and resilience, burnout and academic performance. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health17(20): 7687.
45.
WebberCF (ed.) (2023) Teacher Leadership in International Contexts. Cham, Switzerland: Springer.
46.
WennerJACampbellT (2017) The theoretical and empirical basis of teacher leadership: A review of the literature. Review of Educational Research87(1): 134–171.
47.
WoodD (2020) Learning Leadership in Practice: The Power of Being Present. New York, NY: Routledge.
48.
York-BarrJDukeK (2004) What do we know about teacher leadership? Findings from two decades of scholarship. Review of Educational Research74(3): 255–316.
