Liminality of Professional Identity and Caregiving Identity Among Women Professionals Working in Rural Development Nonprofits in India

Abstract

While the unique socioeconomic conditions of the Global South have created opportunities for women to work in rural development nonprofits, obstacles exist in the form of gendered social expectations. This study examines the experiences of women professionals working in rural development nonprofits who live in the liminality between “ideal professional identity” and “traditional caregiving identity.” We conducted in-depth interviews with 21 women professionals working in nonprofits in seven states of India. Our findings suggest that women professionals experience constant guilt in the liminality due to the conflicting obligations of caregiving and professional worker identities and their inability to justify both. We discuss how they use various performative practices and identity work, and sometimes engage in patriarchal bargaining to resolve the struggles arising from the conflicting obligations. Our study adds to the scarce research on women in the Global South working in rural development nonprofits and also discusses its practical organizational implications.

Keywords

gender nonprofit sector rural development in India identity work liminality

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acker

(1990). Hierarchies, jobs, bodies: A theory of gendered organizations. Gender & Society, 4(2), 139–158.

Acker

(2006). Inequality regimes: Gender, class, and race in organizations. Gender & Society, 20(4), 441–464.

Acker

(2012). Gendered organizations and intersectionality: Problems and possibilities. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal, 31(3), 214–224.

Alkhaled

Sasaki

(2022). Syrian women refugees: Coping with indeterminate liminality during forcible displacement. Organization Studies, 43(10), 1583–1605.

Almog-Bar

Livnat

(2019). Between the sticky floor and the glass ceiling: Employment of women as mid-level managers in Israeli non-profit organisations. Israel Affairs, 25(3), 467–487.

Alvesson

Lee Ashcraft

Thomas

(2008). Identity matters: Reflections on the construction of identity scholarship in organization studies. Organization, 15(1), 5–28.

Ansari

(2023, January 31). The social sector needs more women in leadership roles. Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/blogs/developing-contemporary-india/the-social-sector-needs-more-women-in-leadership-roles/?source=app&frmapp=yes

Ashforth

B. E.

Mael

(1989). Social identity theory and the organization. Academy of Management Review, 14(1), 20–39.

Beech

(2011). Liminality and the practices of identity reconstruction. Human Relations, 64(2), 285–302.

10.

Braun

Clarke

(2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101.

11.

Brislin

R. W.

(1970). Back-translation for cross-cultural research. Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 1(3), 185–216.

12.

Brown

A. D.

(2015). Identities and identity work in organizations. International Journal of Management Reviews, 17(1), 20–40.

13.

Brubaker

S. J.

Wright

(2006). Identity transformation and family caregiving: Narratives of African American teen mothers. Journal of Marriage and Family, 68(5), 1214–1228.

14.

Bryan

Mendaglio

(2020). Building leadership capacity in women: An NGO in India’s initiative towards women members of SHGs. Development in Practice, 30(7), 839–849.

15.

Burkinshaw

White

(2017). Fixing the women or fixing universities: Women in HE leadership. Administrative Sciences, 7(3), 30. https://doi.org/10.3390/admsci7030030

16.

Butler

(1988). Performative acts and gender constitution: An essay in phenomenology and feminist theory. Theatre Journal, 40(4), 519–531.

17.

Butler

(1990). Gender trouble: Feminism and the subversion of identity. Routledge.

18.

Camarena

Feeney

M. K.

Lecy

(2021). Nonprofit entrepreneurship: Gender differences in strategy and practice. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 50(6), 1170–1192.

19.

Caputo

R. K.

(1997). Women as volunteers and activists. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 26(2), 156–174.

20.

Carrim

N. M. H.

Nkomo

S. M.

(2016). Wedding intersectionality theory and identity work in organizations: South African Indian women negotiating managerial identity. Gender, Work & Organization, 23(3), 261–277.

21.

Chaudhuri

Ghosh

(2020). Making organisations gender equal—A long journey: Experience from a non-profit in India. Journal of International Women’s Studies, 21(2), 143–152.

22.

Collins

Landivar

L. C.

Ruppanner

Scarborough

W. J.

(2021). COVID-19 and the gender gap in work hours. Gender, Work & Organization, 28, 101–112.

23.

Conroy

S. A.

O’Leary-Kelly

A. M.

(2014). Letting go and moving on: Work-related identity loss and recovery. Academy of Management Review, 39(1), 67–87.

24.

Crenshaw

(1989). Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine. The University of Chicago Legal Forum.

25.

Cross

Bagilhole

(2002). Girls’ jobs for the boys? Men, masculinity and non-traditional occupations. Gender, Work & Organization, 9(2), 204–226.

26.

Daly

Armstrong

(2016). Liminal and invisible long-term care labour: Precarity in the face of austerity. Journal of Industrial Relations, 58, 473–490.

27.

Daly

Armstrong

Lowndes

(2015). Liminality in Ontario’s long-term care facilities: Private companions’ care work in the space “betwixt and between.” Competition & Change, 19, 246–263.

28.

Daskalaki

Butler

Petrovic

(2016). Some-where in-between: Narratives of place, identity, and translocal work. Journal of Management Inquiry, 25, 184–198.

29.

Doshi

(2022). Experiencing liminality: At the crossroads of neoliberal and gendered experiences. Gender, Work & Organization, 29(4), 1132–1148.

30.

Eagly

A. H.

(2009). The his and hers of prosocial behavior: An examination of the social psychology of gender. American Psychologist, 64(8), 644–658. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.64.8.644

31.

Eifert

E. K.

Adams

Dudley

Perko

(2015). Family caregiver identity: A literature review. American Journal of Health Education, 46(6), 357–367.

32.

Einolf

C. J.

(2011). Gender differences in the correlates of volunteering and charitable giving. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 40(6), 1092–1112.

33.

Ellis

Ybema

(2010). Marketing identities: Shifting circles of identification in inter-organizational relationships. Organization Studies, 31(3), 279–305.

34.

England

(2005). Emerging theories of care work. Annual Review of Sociology, 31(1), 381–399.

35.

Evans

C. A.

Mayo

L. M.

Quijada

M. A.

(2018). Women’s empowerment and nonprofit sector development. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 47(4), 856–871.

36.

Evetts

(2000). Analysing change in women’s careers: Culture, structure and action dimensions. Gender, Work & Organization, 7(1), 57–67.

37.

Faulk

Edwards

L. H.

Lewis

G. B.

McGinnis

(2013). An analysis of gender pay disparity in the nonprofit sector: An outcome of labor motivation or gendered jobs? Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 42(6), 1268–1287.

38.

Folbre

Nelson

J. A.

(2000). For love or money–or both? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 14(4), 123–140.

39.

Garsten

Haunschild

(2014). Transient and flexible work lives: Liminal organizations and the reflexive habitus. In Koene

Galais

Garsten

(Eds.), Management and organization of temporary agency work (pp. 23–37). Routledge.

40.

Gibbons

S. W.

Ross

Bevans

(2014). Liminality as a conceptual frame for understanding the family caregiving rite of passage: An integrative review. Research in Nursing & Health, 37(5), 423–436.

41.

Grünenfelder

(2013). Negotiating gender relations: Muslim women and formal employment in Pakistan’s rural development sector. Gender, Work & Organization, 20(6), 599–615.

42.

Handy

Kassam

Renade

(2002). Factors influencing women entrepreneurs of NGOs in India. Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 13(2), 139–154.

43.

Holvino

(2010). Intersections: The simultaneity of race, gender and class in organization studies. Gender, Work & Organization, 17(3), 248–277.

44.

Howard-Grenville

Golden-Biddle

Irwin

Mao

(2011). Liminality as cultural process for cultural change. Organization Science, 22(2), 522–539.

45.

Ibarra

Obodaru

(2016). Betwixt and between identities: Liminal experience in contemporary careers. Research in Organizational Behavior, 36, 47–64.

46.

Izak

Shortt

Case

(2023). Learning to inhabit the liquid liminal world of work: An auto-ethnographic visual study of work–life boundary transitions. Management Learning, 54(2), 198–222.

47.

Jakimow

(2010). Negotiating the boundaries of voluntarism: Values in the Indian NGO sector. VOLUNTAS: International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations, 21, 546–568.

48.

Jamjoom

L. A.

(2022). Tread lightly: Liminality and Covid-19 reflections. Gender, Work & Organization, 29(4), 1314–1330.

49.

Jogulu

Wood

(2011). Women managers’ career progression: An Asia Pacific perspective. Gender in Management: An International Journal, 26(8), 590–603.

50.

Johnsen

C. G.

Sørensen

B. M.

(2015). “It’s capitalism on coke!” From temporary to permanent liminality in organization studies. Culture and Organization, 21(4), 321–337.

51.

Kamas

Preston

(2021). Empathy, gender, and prosocial behavior. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 92, 101654.

52.

Kandiyoti

(2005). Rethinking bargaining with patriarchy. In Jackson

Pearson

(Eds.), Feminist vision of development: Gender, analysis and policy (pp. 135–154). Routledge.

53.

Katila

Meriläinen

(1999). A serious researcher or just another nice girl? Doing gender in a male-dominated scientific community. Gender, Work & Organization, 6(3), 163–173.

54.

Kosny

MacEachen

(2010). Gendered, invisible work in non-profit social service organizations: Implications for worker health and safety. Gender, Work & Organization, 17(4), 359–380.

55.

Lee

Tang

(2015). More caregiving, less working: Caregiving roles and gender difference. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 34(4), 465–483.

56.

Leidner

(1991). Stretching the boundaries of liberalism: Democratic innovation in a feminist organization. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society, 16(2), 263–289.

57.

Lucas

(2014). Nomadic organization and the experience of journeying: Through liminal spaces and organizing places. Culture and Organization, 20, 196–214.

58.

Mahadevan

(2015). Understanding the process of inter-cultural negotiations through liminality: Insights on biculturality, marginality and cultural expertise from a Sino-German business context. International Journal of Cross Cultural Management, 15, 239–258.

59.

Martin

P. Y.

(2003). “Said and done” versus “saying and doing” gendering practices, practicing gender at work. Gender & Society, 17(3), 342–366.

60.

Martin

P. Y.

(2006). Practising gender at work: Further thoughts on reflexivity. Gender, Work & Organization, 13(3), 254–276.

61.

Marwah

(2022). Liminality as wage penalty for India’s women community health workers. Gender, Work & Organization, 30(2), 412–430. https://doi.org/10.1111/gwao.12938

62.

Mills

(2015). Conferencing as a site for the mobilization of Black feminist identities in the Congress of Black Women of Canada, 1973-1983. Journal of Black Studies, 46(4), 415–441.

63.

Mohanty

C. T.

(1984). Under Western eyes: Feminist scholarship and colonial discourses. Boundary 2, 12(3), 333–358.

64.

Muhr

S. L.

(2011). Caught in the gendered machine: On the masculine and feminine in cyborg leadership. Gender, Work & Organization, 18(3), 337–357.

65.

Nelson

Piatak

(2021). Intersectionality, leadership, and inclusion: How do racially underrepresented women fare in the federal government? Review of Public Personnel Administration, 41(2), 294–318.

66.

Nentwich

J. C.

Kelan

E. K.

(2014). Towards a topology of “doing gender”: An analysis of empirical research and its challenges. Gender, Work & Organization, 21(2), 121–134.

67.

NITI Aayog. (2021). National multidimensional poverty index: Baseline report. https://www.niti.gov.in/sites/default/files/2021-11/National_MPI_India-11242021.pdf

68.

Park

S. M.

Word

(2012). Serving the mission: Organizational antecedents and social consequences of job choice motivation in the nonprofit sector. International Review of Public Administration, 17(3), 169–206.

69.

Plump

Geist-Martin

(2013). Collaborative intersectionality: Negotiating identity, liminal spaces, and ethnographic research. Liminalities: A Journal of Performance Studies, 9(2), 59–72.

70.

Powell

Bagilhole

Dainty

(2009). How women engineers do and undo gender: Consequences for gender equality. Gender, Work & Organization, 16(4), 411–428.

71.

Pratt

M. G.

Rockmann

K. W.

Kaufmann

J. B.

(2006). Constructing professional identity: The role of work and identity learning cycles in the customization of identity among medical residents. Academy of Management Journal, 49(2), 235–262.

72.

Preston

A. E.

(1990). Women in the white-collar nonprofit sector: The best option or the only option? The Review of Economics and Statistics, 72, 560–568.

73.

Ravenswood

Harris

(2016). Doing gender, paying low: Gender, class and work–life balance in aged care. Gender, Work & Organization, 23(6), 614–628.

74.

Razvi

Roth

(2010). Non-governmental organizations and the socio-economic development of low-income women in India. Human Resource Development International, 13(1), 65–81.

75.

Revenson

T. A.

Griva

Luszczynska

Morrison

Panagopoulou

Vilchinsky

. . .Hagedoorn

(2016). Gender and caregiving: The costs of caregiving for women. Caregiving in the illness context (pp. 48–63). Palgrave Macmillan.

76.

Rollock

(2012). The invisibility of race: Intersectional reflections on the liminal space of alterity. Race Ethnicity and Education, 15(1), 65–84.

77.

Roth

(1998). Feminist boundaries in the feminist-friendly organization: The women’s caucus of ACT UP/LA. Gender & Society, 12(2), 129–145.

78.

Sampson

S. D.

Moore

L. L.

(2008). Is there a glass ceiling for women in development? Nonprofit Management and Leadership, 18(3), 321–339.

79.

Schein

V. E.

Mueller

(1992). Sex role stereotyping and requisite management characteristics: A cross cultural look. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 13(5), 439–447.

80.

Shelton

B. A.

(1990). The distribution of household tasks: Does wife’s employment status make a difference? Journal of Family Issues, 11(2), 115–135.

81.

Shortt

(2015). Liminality, space and the importance of “transitory dwelling places” at work. Human Relations, 68, 633–658.

82.

Smith

Shue

Vest

J. L.

Villarreal

(2021). Philanthropy in communities of color. In The nature of the nonprofit sector (pp. 393–403). Routledge.

83.

Snow

D. A.

Anderson

(1987). Identity work among the homeless: The verbal construction and avowal of personal identities. American Journal of Sociology, 92(6), 1336–1371.

84.

Söderlund

Borg

(2018). Liminality in management and organization studies: Process, position and place. International Journal of Management Reviews, 20(4), 880–902.

85.

Sveningsson

Alvesson

(2003). Managing managerial identities: Organizational fragmentation, discourse and identity struggle. Human Relations, 56(10), 1163–1193.

86.

Szakolczai

(2016). Permanent liminality and modernity: Analysing the sacrificial carnival through novels. Routledge.

87.

Tajfel

Turner

J. C.

(1986). The social identity theory of intergroup behavior. In Worchel

Austin

W. G.

(Eds.), Psychology of intergroup relations (pp. 7–24). Nelson-Hall.

88.

Takhar

Bebek

Jamal

(2021). Activists of themselves: Liminality of Instagram and its role in the ethnic identity construction processes of third generation British Sikhs to their imagined identities. International Journal of Information Management, 70, 102467.

89.

Taniguchi

(2006). Men’s and women’s volunteering: Gender differences in the effects of employment and family characteristics. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 35(1), 83–101.

90.

Themudo

N. S.

(2009). Gender and the nonprofit sector. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 38(4), 663–683.

91.

Thomassen

(2016). Liminality and the modern: Living through the in-between. Routledge.

92.

Thompson

(1991). Family work: Women’s sense of fairness. Journal of Family Issues, 12(2), 181–196.

93.

Turner

V. W.

(1969). The ritual process: Structure and antistructure. Routledge.

94.

Van Gennep

(1909). Les Rites de Passage. Emile Nourry.

95.

Van Maanen

J. E.

Schein

E. H.

(1977). Toward a theory of organizational socialization. Research in Organizational Behavior, 1, 209–264.

96.

Vasan

(2004). NGOs as employers. Economic and Political Weekly, 39(22), 2197–2198.

97.

Vesala

Tuomivaara

(2019). A temporary liminal space counteracting the permanent “in between” in working life. Nordic Journal of Working Life Studies, 9(1), 19–38.

98.

Winkler

Mahmood

M. K.

(2015). The liminality of temporary agency work: Exploring the dimensions of Danish temporary agency workers’ liminal experience. Nordic Journal of Working Life Studies, 5, 51–68.

99.

Ybema

Beech

Ellis

(2011). Transitional and perpetual liminality: An identity practice perspective. Anthropology Southern Africa, 34(1–2), 21–29.

100.

Zhao

(2020). Are nonprofits more equitable than for-profits? An estimate of the gender pay gap in the US human services field. Human Service Organizations: Management, Leadership & Governance, 44(4), 343–361.