Numerical assessment of a deformable trailing-edge flap on aerodynamic load control of a pitching S809 airfoil using OpenFOAM

Abstract

Due to the unsteady nature of the flow around horizontal-axis wind turbines, the blades are subjected to severe unsteady and fatigue loads. This necessitates an in-depth aerodynamic analysis of flow control techniques to enhance the performance of a wind turbine as well as the lifetime of its components. Using OpenFOAM package in this study, a series of two-dimensional incompressible simulations are performed to present a deeper insight into the aerodynamic characteristics of an oscillating deformable trailing-edge flap, as a promising flow control device, in a sinusoidal pitching motion of an S809 airfoil. Herein, it is of particular interest to investigate the effects of deformable trailing-edge flap size, oscillation frequency, and the phase shift with reference to airfoil motion on lift and drag hysteresis loops. For this purpose, a pure-pitching motion of an S809 airfoil without flap deflection is considered as the benchmark problem in which the airfoil oscillates in the near-stall region at $Re = 10^{6}$ . After validation and verification of our simulations through comparison against the corresponding experimental and numerical work, a comprehensive investigation is conducted to study the effects of the aforementioned parameters on the aerodynamic loads. Our results reveal the fact that an out-of-phase deflection of the deformable trailing-edge flap with a frequency equal to the airfoil frequency can significantly mitigate the fatigue load. Under these circumstances, an increase in the deformable trailing-edge flap size can also help the airfoil experience less-severe loads in a cycle of motion. Furthermore, higher values of deformable trailing-edge flap frequency or other values of phase shift except the out-of-phase oscillation cannot alleviate fatigue loads. An airfoil under these conditions can, however, enhance the resultant load required for a blade rotation in the case of low wind periods.

Keywords

Active flow control deformable trailing-edge flap fatigue load unsteady aerodynamics wind turbine airfoil

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Leishman

. Challenges in modelling the unsteady aerodynamics of wind turbines. Wind Energy 2002; 5: 85–132.

Berg JC, Barone MF and Yoder NC. Smart wind turbine rotor: data analysis and conclusions. Technical Report, Sandia National Laboratory (SNL-NM), Albuquerque, NM, USA, 2014.

Hall SR, Anand RV, Straub FK, et al. Active flap control of the smart rotor for vibration reduction. In: American Helicopter Society 65th annual forum and technology display, Grapevine, TX, USA, 27–29 May 2009.

Liggett

Smith

. The physics of modeling unsteady flaps with gaps. J Fluids Struct 2013; 38: 255–272.

Ramsay R, Hoffman M and Gregorek G. Effects of grit roughness and pitch oscillations on the s809 airfoil. Technical Report, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO, USA, 1995.

Sheng

Galbraith

RAM

Coton

. On the s809 airfoil's unsteady aerodynamic characteristics. Wind Energy 2009; 12: 752–767.

Masdari

Seyednia

Tabrizian

. An experimental loading study of a pitching wind turbine airfoil in near- and post-stall regions. J Mech Sci Technol 2018; 32: 3699–3706.

Gharali

Johnson

. Dynamic stall simulation of a pitching airfoil under unsteady freestream velocity. J Fluids Struct 2013; 42: 228–244.

Kim

Xie

. Modelling the effect of freestream turbulence on dynamic stall of wind turbine blades. Comput Fluids 2016; 129: 53–66.

10.

Seyednia

Vakilipour

Masdari

. Numerical investigation of dynamic stall over a wind turbine pitching airfoil by using OpenFOAM. World Acad Sci Eng Technol 2017; 11: 1483–1494.

11.

Barlas

Van Kuik

. State of the art and prospectives of smart rotor control for wind turbines. J Phys Conf Ser 2007; 75: 012080.

12.

Plumley CE, Leithead W, Jamieson P, et al. Supplementing wind turbine pitch control with a trailing edge flap smart rotor. In: 3^rd renewable power generation conference, Naples, Italy, 24–25 September 2014.

13.

Bernhammer

van Kuik

De Breuker

. Fatigue and extreme load reduction of wind turbine components using smart rotors. J Wind Eng Ind Aerodyn 2016; 154: 84–95.

14.

Zhang

Tan

. Parameter study of sizing and placement of deformable trailing edge flap on blade fatigue load reduction. Renew Energy 2015; 77: 217–226.

15.

Friedmann

De Terlizzi

Myrtle

. New developments in vibration reduction with actively controlled trailing edge flaps. Math Comput Model 2001; 33: 1055–1083.

16.

Krzysiak

Narkiewicz

. Aerodynamic loads on airfoil with trailing-edge flap pitching with different frequencies. J Aircraft 2006; 43: 407–418.

17.

Madsen HA, Barlas T and Andersen TL. A morphing trailing edge flap system for wind turbine blades. In: Proceedings of the 7th ECCOMAS thematic conference on smart structures and materials (SMART 2015), vol. 7, 2015, Ponta Delgada, Azores, 3-6 June 2015.

18.

Troldborg

. Computational study of the risø-b1-18 airfoil with a hinged flap providing variable trailing edge geometry. Wind Eng 2005; 29: 89–113.

19.

Hao

, et al. Computational study on wind turbine airfoils based on active control for deformable flaps. J Mech Sci Technol 2017; 31: 565–575.

20.

Wolff T and Seume J. Airfoil with morphing trailing edge for load reduction in wind turbines. In: 33rd wind energy symposium, 2015, p. 1662, Kissimmee, Florida, USA, 5-9 January 2015.

21.

Zhu

. Numerical simulation of a wind turbine airfoil: dynamic stall and comparison with experiments. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Energy 2010; 224: 657–677.

22.

Nandi TN, Brasseur J and Vijayakumar G. Prediction and analysis of the nonsteady transitional boundary layer dynamics for flow over an oscillating wind turbine airfoil using the γ-reθ transition model. In: 34th wind energy symposium, 2016, p. 0520, San Diego, California, USA, 4-8 January 2016.

23.

Velasco

Mejia

Laín

. Numerical simulations of active flow control with synthetic jets in a Darrieus turbine. Renew Energy 2017; 113: 129–140.

24.

Somers DM. Design and experimental results for the s809 airfoil. Technical Report, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO, USA, 1997.

25.

Gharali

Gharaei

Soltani

, et al. Reduced frequency effects on combined oscillations, angle of attack and free stream oscillations, for a wind turbine blade element. Renew Energy 2018; 115: 252–259.

26.

Menter

. Two-equation eddy-viscosity turbulence models for engineering applications. AIAA J 1994; 32: 1598–1605.

27.

Sanei M and Razaghi R. Numerical investigation of three turbulence simulation models for s809 wind turbine airfoil. Proc IMechE, Part A: J Power and Energy 2018; 232: 1037–1048.

28.

Wang

Ingham

, et al. Numerical investigations on dynamic stall of low Reynolds number flow around oscillating airfoils. Comput Fluids 2010; 39: 1529–1541.

29.

Jasak

Tukovic

. Automatic mesh motion for the unstructured finite volume method. Trans FAMENA 2006; 30: 1–20.

30.

Hansen

. Aerodynamics of wind turbines, London: Routledge, 2015.