Practical Ethical Issues Related To the Care of Elderly People With Dementia

Abstract

The care of elderly people with dementia poses ethical problems in several respects. This paper considers the problems in relation to treatment, withdrawal of treatment (including nutrition and hydration) in terminal care, and consent to involvement in research. It is ultimately the responsibility of the physician to take the decision about whether or not to proceed with treatment, according to the best interests of the patient, but nurses, families and significant others can be involved in making the decision. When withdrawal of treatment or withdrawal of nutrition and hydration in the terminal stages of dementia are being considered it is necessary to take into account the nature of the treatment, whether or not it is extraordinary, and the goals of continued nutrition. In some circumstances it may be possible for them to be withdrawn. Only research which is aimed at evaluating treatment for dementia may involve subjects who are suffering from dementia.

Soigner des personnes âgés souffrant de la démence pose plusieurs problèmes éthiques. Cet article considère les problèmes concernant le traitement, cessation de traitement (y inclus nutrition et hydration) dans la phase terminale, et consentement de participation dans les recherches. C'est ultimement la décision du docteur si oui ou non de continuer avec le traitement selon les meilleurs intérêts du malade, mais les infirmiers/ères, les familles et les personnes importantes autour du malade peuvent jouer un rôle dans les décisions. Si la cessation de traitement ou cessation de nutrition et hydration dans la phase terminale de démence est envisagée il est nécessaire de tenir compte de la nature du traitement, s'il est 'extraordinaire' ou non, et le but de nutrition si on continuait. Dans quelques circonstances il est possible de les discontinuer. Seuls les recherches qui ont pour but d'évaluer les traitements pour la démence peuvent utiliser des personnes souffrant de démence.

Die Pflege von älteren Personen mit Demenz stellt einige ethische Probleme. Dieser Artikel betrachtet die Probleme in Beziehung auf die Pflege, Zurückziehung von Pflege (auch von Nahrung und Getrank) der Sterbenden und der Entscheidung, in der Forschung beteiligt zu sein. Der Arzt hat die schlussendliche Verantwortung über die Entscheidung ob mit der Pflege weitergefahren werden soll oder nicht nach dem besten Interesse der Patienten. Aber das Krankenpflegepersonal, die Familie und bedeutende Andere können auch an dieser Entscheidung teilnehmen. Wenn es sich um Zurückziehung der Pflege, oder Zurückziehung von Nahrung oder Getrank in der Sterbepflege von Personen mit Demenz handelt, is es nötig, das Wesen der Pflege und die Ziele einer fortfahrenden Nahrung zu kennen. In gewissen Fällen ist es möglich, diese zurück zu ziehen. Es sollen nur Patienten mit Demenz an Forschungen teilnehmen die über die Pflege der Demenz einschätzt.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Johnstone M-J. Bioethics: a nursing perspective. Sydney: Saunders, 1989.

Thomson IE , Melia KM , Boyd KM Nursing ethics, second edition. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 1988.

Berrios GE Alzheimer's disease: a conceptual history. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1990; 5: 355-65.

Hughes CP , Berg L. , Warren LD , Coben LA , Martin RL A new clinical scale for the staging of dementia. Br J Psychiatry 1982; 140: 566-72.

Gilhooley Mlm. The law. In: Gilhooley MLM ed. Consent to treatment. Edinburgh: Scottish Action on Dementia, 1992: 2-3.

Watson R. Research on the elderly. Nurs Times 1990; 86 (16): 43-45.

McCall Smith A. Treatment of adults with mental incapacity. In: Gilhooley MLM ed. Consent to treatment. Edinburgh: Scottish Action on Dementia, 1992: 7-11.

Gilhooley Mlm. Proxy consent and the preservation of autonomy . In: Gilhooley MLM ed. Consent to treatment. Edinburgh: Scottish Action on Dementia, 1992: 26-34.

Veatch RM An ethical framework for terminal care decisions. J Am Geriatr Soc 1984; 32: 665-69.

10.

Atkinson GM Theological history of Catholic teaching on prolonging life. In: McCarthy DG , Moraczewski AS eds. Moral responsibility in prolonging life decisions . St Louis: Pope John XXIII Medical-Moral Research and Education Centre, 1981: 95-115.

11.

Ashley M. Principles for moral decisions about prolonging life. In: McCarthy DG , Moraczewski AS eds. Moral responsibility in prolonging life decisions . St Louis: Pope John XXIII Medical-Moral Research and Education Centre, 1985: 116-23.

12.

Arras JD The severely demented, minimally functional patient: an ethical analysis. J Am Geriatr Soc 1988; 36: 938-44.

13.

National Conference of Catholic Bishops Committee for Pro-Life Activities. Nutrition and hydration: moral and pastoral reflections. Catholic N Y 1992; (2 April): 18-23.

14.

Norberg A. , Athlin E. Eating problems in severely demented patients; issues and ethical dilemmas . Nurs Clin North Am 1989; 24: 781-89.

15.

Watson R. Caring for elderly people. London: Baillière Tindall, 1993.

16.

Norberg A. , Asplund K. , Waxman H. Withdrawing feeding and withholding artificial nutrition from severely demented patients: interviews with caregivers. West J Nurs Res 1987; 9: 348-56.

17.

Åkerlund B-M. , Norberg A. An ethical analysis of double bind conflicts as experienced by care workers feeding severely demented patients. Int J Nurs Stud 1985; 22: 207-16.

18.

Dresser R. When patients resist feeding: medical, ethical and legal considerations. J Am Geriatr Soc 1985; 33: 790-94.

19.

Lo B. , Dornbrand L. Guiding the hand that feeds. N Engl J Med 1984; 311: 402-404.

20.

Olins NJ Feeding decisions for incompetent patients. J Am Geriatr Soc 1986; 34: 313-17.

21.

Grimley-Evans J. From plaque to placement; a model for Alzheimer's disease. Age Ageing 1992; 21: 77-80.

22.

Norberg A. , Norberg B. , Bexell G. Ethical problems in feeding patients with advanced dementia. Br Med J 1980; 281: 847-49.

23.

McInerney F. Provision of food and fluids in terminal care: a sociological analysis. Soc Sci Med 1992; 34: 1271-76.

24.

Peck A. , Cohen CE , Mulvihill MN Long-term enteral feeding of aged nursing home patients. J Am Geriatr Soc 1990; 38: 1195-98.

25.

Miles SH The terminally ill elderly: dealing with the ethics of feeding. Geriatrics 1985; 40: 112-20.

26.

Norberg A. , Hirschfield M. Feeding of severely demented patients in institutions: interviews with caregivers in Israel. J Adv Nurs 1987; 12: 551-57.

27.

Watts DT , Cassel CK , Hickam DH Nurses' and physicians' attitudes toward tube-feeding decisions in long-term care. J Am Geriatr Soc 1986; 34: 607-11.

28.

Watts DT , Cassel CK Extraordinary nutritional support: a case study and ethical analysis. J Am Geriatr Soc 1984; 32: 237-42.

29.

Volicer L. , Rheaume Y. , Brown J. , Fabiszewski K. , Brady R. Hospice approach to the treatment of patients with advanced dementia of the Alzheimer type. JAMA 1986; 256: 2210-13.

30.

McCall Smith A. , Nichols D. What sorts of research are involved? In: McCall Smith A , Nichols D eds. Consent to research. Edinburgh: Scottish Action on Dementia, 1992: 38-42.

31.

Shum CM Informed consent: pitfalls and practicalities. Geriatr Med 1992; 22: 56-60.

32.

NHS Management Executive. Local research ethics committees. London: Department of Health, 1991.

33.

Duffy LM , Wyble SJ , Wilson B. , Miles SH Obtaining geriatric patient consent. J Gerontol Nurs 1989; 15: 21-24.

34.

High DM Research with Alzheimer's disease subjects: informed consent and proxy decision making. J Am Geriatr Soc 1992; 40: 950-75.

35.

Applegate WB , Curb JD Designing and executing randomised clinical trials involving elderly persons . J Am Geriatr Soc 1990; 38: 943-50.

36.

Rovner BW , Lucas-Blaustein J. , Folstein MF , Smith SW Stability over one year in patients admitted to a nursing home dementia unit . Int J Geriatr Psychiatry 1990; 5: 77-82.

37.

Warren JW , Sobal J. , Tenney JH et al. Informed consent by proxy: an issue in research with elderly patients. N Engl J Med 1986; 315: 1124-28.

38.

Melnick VL , Dubler NN , Weisbard A. , Butler RN Clinical research in senile dementia of the Alzheimer type: suggested guidelines addressing the ethical and legal issues. J Am Geriatr Soc 1984; 32: 531-36.