The Companies Act 1879 has traditionally been perceived as an important measure in
the history of audit regulation in Britain. The Act provided for the external audit
of banks and did so several years in advance of a similar requirement for general
companies. It is contended here that the circumstances attending the framing and
implementation of the auditing provisions contained in the 1879 Act are suggestive
of an incrementalist approach to policy making. The character of the discussion of
auditor independence and the scope of the bank audit after 1879 indicate that the
regulations contained in the Act instituted changes which appear to have been
marginal in their practical effects.
Anderson, M.
,
Edwards, J.R.
and
Matthews, D.
, (1996),
“A Study of the Quoted Company Audit Market in 1886”
, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol.6,
No.3, pp.
363-387
.
2.
3.
Bankers' Magazine.
4.
Brown, R.G.S.
, (1974), Approaches to the Study of Public
Administration. Part 3 The Administrative Process as
Incrementalism,
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
.
5.
Brown, R.G.S.
and
Steel, D.R.
, (1979), The Administrative Process in Britain,
London: Methuen
.
6.
Burch, M.
and
Wood, B.
, (1983), Public Policy in Britain,
Oxford: Martin Robertson
.
7.
Capie, F.
and
Webber, A.
, (1985), A Monetary History of the United Kingdom, 1870-1982.
Volume 1 Data, Sources, Methods,
London: George Allen & Unwin
.
8.
Chandler, R.A.
, (1997),
“Judicial Views on Auditing From the Nineteenth Century”
, Accounting History, NS Vol.2, No.1,
May, pp.
61-80
.
9.
Chandler, R.
and
Edwards, J.R.
, (1994), Recurring Issues in Auditing.
Professional Debate 1875-1900,New York: Garland Publishing
.
10.
Chandler, R.
and
Edwards, J.R.
, (1996),
“Recurring Issues in Auditing: Back to the Future?”
, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal,
Vol.9, No.2, pp.
4-29
.
11.
Checkland, S.
, (1985), British Public Policy 1776-1939. An
Economic, Social and Political Perspective,
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
12.
Companies Act
, 1879, The Public General Acts Passed in the Forty-Second and
Forty-Third Years of the Reign of Her Majesty Queen Victoria,
London: Eyre & Spottiswoode
.
13.
Crouzet, F.
, (1982), The Victorian Economy,
London: Routledge
.
14.
15.
Dror, Y.
, (1968), Public Policy Making Re-examined,San Francisco: Chandler
.
16.
17.
Edey, H.C.
and
Panitpakdi, P.
, (1956), “British Company Accounting and the Law
1844-1900”, in
Littleton, A.C.
and
Yamey, B.S.
(eds.), Studies in the History of Accounting,
London: Sweet and Maxwell
, pp.356-379.
18.
Edwards, J.R.
(ed.), (1986), Legal Regulation of British Company Accounts 1836-1900,New York: Garland Publishing
.
19.
Edwards, J.R.
, (1989), A History of Financial Accounting,
London: Routledge
.
20.
Edwards, J.R.
,
Anderson, M.
and
Matthews, D.
, (1997),
“Accountability in a Free-Market Economy: The British Company
Audit, 1886”
, Abacus, Vol.33, No.1, pp.
1-25
.
21.
Etzioni, A.
, (1967),
“Mixed Scanning: A ‘Third' Approach to Decision-Making”
, Public Administration Review, Vol.27,
No.5, pp.
385-392
.
22.
23.
Glasgow News.
24.
Goodhart, C.A.E.
, (1972), The Business of Banking, 1891-1914,London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson
.
25.
Gourlay, K.M.
, (1895), “Bank Auditing”, in
Transactions of the Chartered Accountants Students' Society of
Edinburgh,
Edinburgh: Macniven & Wallace
, Vol.7, pp.135-146.
26.
Great Britain
, (1867), “Select Committee on the Limited
Liability Acts”, British Parliamentary Papers,
Vol.X, 393-393.
27.
Great Britain
, (1878-79), “Banking and Joint Stock Companies
Bill”, British Parliamentary Papers, Vol.I, 395-395.
28.
Great Britain
, (1895), “Report of the Departmental Committee
Appointed by the Board of Trade to Inquire What Amendments are Necessary in the
Acts Relating to Joint Stock Companies Incorporated With Limited Liability Under
the Companies Acts 1862 to 1890”, British Parliamentary
Papers, Vol. LXXXVIII, 28-28.
29.
Great Britain
, (1898), “Select Committee of the House of Lords
on the Companies Bill, Minutes of Evidence”, British
Parliamentary Papers, Vol. IX.
30.
Greenleaf, W.H.
, (1983), The British Political Tradition. Volume
1, The Rise of Collectivism,
London: Methuen
.
31.
Gregory, R.
, (1989),
“Political Rationality or ‘Incrementalism'?
Charles E. Lindblom's Enduring Contribution to Public Policy Making Theory”
, Policy and Politics, Vol.17, No.2, pp.
139-153
.
32.
Ham, C.
and
Hill, M.
, (1993), The Policy Process in the Modern Capitalist
State,
London: Harvester Wheatsheaf
.
33.
Hansard's Parliamentary Debates, (1879), third
series,
London: Cornelius Buck
.
34.
Hein, L.W.
, (1978), The British Companies Acts and the Practice of
Accounting 1844-1962,
New York: Arno Press
.
35.
Henriques, U.R.Q.
, (1979), Before the Welfare State. Social
Administration in Early Industrial Britain,
London: Longman
.
36.
Hill, M.
, (1993a), “Introduction”, in
Hill, M.
(ed.), New Agendas in the Study of the Policy Process,
London: Harvester Wheatsheaf
, pp.1-24.
37.
Hill, M.
(ed.), (1993b), The Policy Process. A Reader,
London: Harvester Wheatsheaf
.
38.
39.
Kerr, A.W.
, (1898), Scottish Banking During the Period of Published
Accounts 1865-1896,
London: Effingham Wilson
.
40.
Lee, T.A.
, (1979), “A Brief History of Company Audits:
1840-1940”, in
Lee, T.A.
and
Parker, R.H.
(eds.), The Evolution of Corporate Financial Reporting,
Sudbury: Nelson
.
41.
Lindblom, C.E.
, (1959),
“The Science of Muddling Through”
, Public Administration Review, Vol.19,
No.2, pp.
79-88
.
42.
Lindblom, C.E.
, (1965), The Intelligence of Democracy: Decision Making
Through Mutual Adjustment,
New York: Free Press
.
43.
Lindblom, C.E.
, (1979),
“Still Muddling, Not Yet Through”
, Public Administration Review, Vol.39,
No.6, pp.
517-526
.
44.
Lubenow, W.C.
, (1971), The Politics of Government Growth.
Early Victorian Attitudes Toward State Intervention, 1833-1848,
Newton Abbot: David & Charles
.
45.
MacDonagh, O.
, (1958),
“The Nineteenth-Century Revolution in Government: A Reappraisal”
, Historical Journal, Vol.1, pp.
54-67
.
46.
Mitchell, W.
, (1879), Our Scotch Banks. Their Position and Their
Policy,
Edinburgh: David Douglas
.
47.
Money Market Review.
48.
Munn, C.W.
, (1988), Clydesdale Bank. The First One
Hundred & Fifty Years,
London & Glasgow: Collins
.
49.
Munro, N.
, (1928), The History of the Royal Bank of Scotland,
Edinburgh: privately
.
50.
51.
North British Economist.
52.
Parker, R.H.
, (1990),
“Regulating British Corporate Financial Reporting in the Late
Nineteenth Century”
, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol.1,
No.1, October, pp.
51-71
.
53.
Rosenblum, L.
, (1933), “The Failure of the City of Glasgow
Bank”, The Accounting Review, Vol.8, pp.285-291.
54.
Saville, R.
, (1996), Bank of Scotland. A History 1695-1995,Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press
.
55.
56.
Scottish Banking and Insurance Magazine.
57.
Shannon, H.A.
, (1931),
“The Coming of General Limited Liability”
, Economic History, Vol.11, No.6,
January, pp.
267-291
.
58.
Smith, G.
and
May, D.
, (1980),
“The Artificial Debate Between Rationalist and Incrementalist
Models of Decision Making”
, Policy and Politics, Vol.8, No.2, pp.
147-161
.
59.
Society of Accountants in Edinburgh (SAE)
, Registers of Indentures,
Scottish Records Office, Edinburgh
.
60.
61.
Tamaki, N.
, (1983), The Life Cycle of the Union Bank of Scotland 1830-1954,Aberdeen: Aberdeen University Press
.
62.
63.
The Times.
64.
Tyson, R.E.
, (1974),
“The Failure of the City of Glasgow Bank and the Rise of
Independent Auditing”
, The Accountant's Magazine, Vol.LXXVII,
No.814, pp.
126-131
.
65.
Walker, S.P.
, (1993),
“Anatomy of a Scottish CA Practice: Lindsay, Jamieson &
Haldane 1818-1918”
, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol.3,
No.2, September, pp.
127-154
.
66.
Walker, S.P.
, (1996a), “George Auldjo Jamieson: A Victorian
‘Man of Affairs’”, in
Lee, T.A.
(ed.), Shaping the Accountancy Profession. The Story of Three Scottish
Pioneers,
New York: Garland
, pp.1-79.
67.
Walker, S.P.
, (1996b),
“Laissez-Faire, Collectivism and Companies Legislation in
Nineteenth Century Britain”
, British Accounting Review, Vol.28,
No.4, December, pp.
305-324
.
68.
Wallace, W.
(ed.), (1905), Trial of the City of Glasgow Bank
Directors,
Glasgow & Edinburgh: William Hodge
& Co.
69.
Whinney, F.
, (1892),
“Audits and Certificates”
, in Transactions of the Chartered Accountants Students’
Society of Edinburgh,
Edinburgh: Macniven & Wallace
, Vol.4, No.22, pp.
17-34
.
70.
Wilson, A.J.
, (1879), Banking Reform. An Essay on Prominent Banking
Dangers and the Remedies They Demand,
London: Longmans, Green & Co.
