Who wants to terminate the game? The role of vested interests and metaplayers in the ATOLLGAME experience

Abstract

Low coral islands are heavily dependent on groundwater for freshwater supplies. The declaration by the government of Kiribati of water reserves over privately owned land has led to conflicts, illegal settlements, and vandalism. Also, the water consumption tends to increase toward Western-like standards, and human pollution has already contaminated most freshwater lenses. This project aims to provide relevant information to local stakeholders to facilitate dialogue and devise sustainable water management practices. A computer-assisted role-playing game is implemented to fulfill this aim. The following three-stage methodology is applied: collecting local and expert knowledge, blending the di ferent viewpoints into a game-based model, and playing the game with the di ferent stakeholders to explore di ferent scenarios. Although game sessions delivered successful outcomes, the final stage of the project is characterized by the upheaval of contradictory government stands that undermine the whole process. It is argued that heterogeneous viewpoints may be handled in a satisfactory manner during the gaming sessions but that long-term hidden agendas may override the outcomes. Beyond the inherent question of legitimacy attached to such approaches, some players clearly must deal with constraints that are often genuinely considered external to the ongoing negotiation process.

Keywords

ATOLLGAME contamination coral islands dialogue freshwater reserves groundwater role-playing game companion modeling entrenched agendas water management multi-agent system participation pollution poverty alleviation sustainable development Pacific staged process Tarawa water demand water reserves water management strategies

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aslin, H.J. , & Brown, V.A. (2004). Towards whole of community engagement: A practical toolkit. Canberra, Australia: Murray-Darling Basin Commission.

Becu, N. , Bousquet, F. , Barreteau, O. , Perez, P. , & Walker, A. (2003). A methodology for eliciting and modelling stakeholders' representations with agent based modelling. Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence, 2927, 131-149.

Bousquet, F. , Bakam, I. , Proton, H. , & Le Page, C. (1998). CORMAS: Common-pool resources and multi-agent systems. Lecture Notes in Artificial Intelligence, 1416, 826-837.

Bousquet, F. , Barreteau, O. , D'Aquino, P. , Etienne, M. , Boissau, S. , Aubert, S. , et al. (2002) Multi-agent systems and role games: Collective learning processes for ecosystem management. In M. A. Janssen (Ed.), Complexity and ecosystem management: The theory and practice of multi-agent systems (pp. 248-285). London: Edward Elgar.

Bradshaw, G.A. , & Borchers, J.G. (2000). Uncertainty as information: Narrowing the science-policy gap. Conservation Ecology, 4(1). Available at http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol4/iss1/art7/

Capenter, C. , Stubbs, J. , & Overmars, M. (2002). Proceedings of the Pacific Regional Consultation on Water in Small Island Countries, Sigatoka , Fiji Islands, 29 July-3 August 2002. Manila, Philippines: Asian Development Bank.

D'Aquino, P. , Le Page, C. , Bousquet, F. , & Bah, A. (2003) Using self-designed role-playing games and a multi-agent system to empower a local decision-making process for land use management: The SELF-CORMAS experiment in Senegal. Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation, 6(3). Available at http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/6/3/5.html

Descola, P. (1996). Constructing natures: Symbolic ecology and social practice. In P. Descola & G. Palsson (Eds.), Nature and society: Anthropological perspectives (pp. 82-102). London: Routledge .

Dray, A. , Perez, P. , Jones, N. , Le Page, C. , D'Aquino, P. , White, I. , et al. (2006). The ATOLLGAME experience: From knowledge engineering to a computer-assisted role playing game. Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation, 9(1). Available at http://jasss.soc.surrey.ac.uk/9/1/6.html

10.

Falkland, A.C. (1992). Review of Tarawa freshwater lenses, Republic of Kiribati (Report 92/682). Canberra, Australia: Hydrology and Water Resources Branch, ACT Electricity and Water.

11.

Falkland, A.C. , & Brunel, J.P. (1993). Review of hydrology and water resources of the humid tropical islands. In M. Bonell , M. M. Hufschmidt , & J. S. Gladwell (Eds.), Hydrology and water management in the humid tropics (pp. 135-163). Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.

12.

Falkland, T. (2003). Review of groundwater resources management for Tarawa (Kiribati SAPHE Project: Mid-term review, Loan No. 1648-KIR [SF], Ecowise Environmental Report No. EHYD 2003/10). Manila, Philippines: Asian Development Bank.

13.

Jones, P. (1997). The impact of the socio-cultural order on urban management in the Pacific: A case study of South Tarawa, Republic of Kiribati . Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Department of Geographical Sciences and Planning, University of Queensland, Australia.

14.

Ostrom, E. (2005). Understanding institutional diversity. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

15.

Perez, P. , Dray, A. , White, I. , Le Page, C. , & Falkland, T. (2003). ATOLLSCAPE: Simulating freshwater management in Pacific atolls: Spatial processes and time dependence issues. In D. Post (Ed.), Proceedings of the International Congress on Modelling and Simulation (Vol. 4 pp. 514-518). Canberra, Australia: Integrated Catchment Assessment and Management Centre.

16.

Volker, R.E. , Mariño, M.A. , & Rolston, D.E. (1985). Transition zone width in groundwater on ocean atolls. Journal of Hydrological Engineering, 111, 659-676.

17.

White, I. , & Falkland, A. (2004, November). E fects of pumping from infiltration galleries on crop health and production in low coral islands: Groundwater impacts. Canberra: Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research.

18.

White, I. , Falkland, A. , Crennan, L. , Jones, P. , Etuati, B. , Metai, E. , et al. (1999). Issues, traditions and conflicts in groundwater use and management (UNESCO International Hydrological Programme, Humid Tropics Programme, IHP-V Theme 6, Technical Documents in Hydrology No. 25). Paris: UNESCO.

19.

White, I. , Falkland, T. , Perez, P. , Dray, A. , Jones, P. , Metutera, T. , et al. (2002). An integrated approach to groundwater management and conflict reduction in low coral islands. In Proceedings of the International Symposium on Low-Lying Coastal Areas: Hydrology and integrated coastal zone management (pp. 249-256). Paris: UNESCO.