Assessing children with autism,mental retardation,and typical development using the Playground Observation Checklist

Abstract

Elementary school children with normal intelligence and autism (n = 20), mental retardation and no autism (n = 24), and typical development (n = 37) were observed for 15 minutes during recess at school. Ten behaviors were scored as present or absent using the Playground Observation Checklist. Children with autism were distinguished from children with mental retardation and typical development by their social problems, whereas children with typical development and mental retardation did not differ significantly in social competency. The four social behaviors on the checklist correctly identified 94 percent of the children as having or not having autism. All of the children with autism and all of the typical children were correctly classified. Our pilot findings suggest that the Playground Observation Checklist has potential as a simple and clinically useful component of a comprehensive evaluation for possible autism.

Keywords

autism mental retardation playground observations typical children

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

American Psychiatric Association (2000) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn text rev. (DSM-IV-R) . Washington, DC: APA .

Farmer-Dougan, V. & Kaszuba, T. (1999) ` Reliability and Validity of Play-Based Observations: Relationship between the PLAY Behaviour Observation System and Standardized Measures of Cognitive Social Skills ', Educational Psychology 19: 429—40 .

Hauck, M. , Fein,D. , Waterhouse,L. & Feinstein,C. ( 1995) ` SocialInitiations by Autistic Children to Adults and Other Children ', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 6: 579—95 .

Hobson, R.P. & Lee, A. (1998) ` Hello and Good-Bye: A Study of Social Engagement in Autism ', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 28: 117—27 .

Lord,C. , Storoschuk,S. , Rutter,M. & Pickles,A. ( 1993)` Usingthe ADI—R to Diagnose Autism in Preschool Children ', Infant Mental Health Journal 14: 234—52 .

Mayes, S.D. & Calhoun, S.L. (1999) ` Symptoms of Autism in Young Children and Correspondence with the DSM ', Infants and Young Children 12: 90—7 .

Mayes, S.D. & Calhoun, S.L. (2001) ` Non-Significance of Early Speech Delay in Children with Autism and Normal Intelligence and Implications for DSM-IV Asperger's Disorder ', Autism 5: 81—94 .

Mayes, S.D. & Calhoun, S.L. (2003) ` Influence of IQ and Age in Childhood Autism: Lack of Support for Asperger's Disorder ', Journal of Developmental and Physical Disabilities 16: 257—72 .

Mayes, S.D. , Calhoun, S.L. & Crites, D.L. (2001) ` Does DSM-IV Asperger's Disorder Exist? ', Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 29: 263—71 .

10.

Siegel, B. (1991) `Play Diagnosis of Autism: The ETHOS Play Session ', in C.E. Schaefer , K Gitlin & A. Sandgrund (eds) Play Diagnosis and Assessment, pp. 331—74. NewYork: Wiley .

11.

Sigman,M.D. , Kasari,C. , Kwon,J.-H. & Yirmiya,N. ( 1992)` Responsestothe Negative Emotions of Others by Autistic, Mentally Retarded, and Normal Children ', Child Development 63: 796—807 .

12.

Vanmeter,L. , Fein,D. , Morris,R. , Waterhouse,L. & Allen,D. ( 1997) ` Delay versus Deviance in Autistic Social Behavior ', Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders 5: 557—70 .

13.

Wing, L. (1991) `Mental Retardation and the Autistic Continuum ', in P. E . Bebbington (ed.) Social Psychiatry: Theory, Methodology, and Practice, pp. 113—38. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction .