The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UN, 1989), which applies to all children under the age of 18, established the overarching principles guiding pupil participation. In most European states, signatories to the Convention have enacted policies to promote the voice of the child or young person in decisions that affect them. In education systems strategies to enhance pupil participation are an increasing feature of deliberation on education for citizenship, curriculum flexibility, pedagogical approaches and assessment for learning. Despite the positive policy context and professional commitment to principles of inclusion, translating policy intentions so that the spirit of the legislation is played out in the day-to-day experiences of pupils is a constant challenge. This article reports on research that examines how pupil participation is understood and enacted in Scottish schools. It considers how the over-laying of diverse policies presents mixed messages to practitioners.
Alderson P. ( 2000) School students’ views on school councils and daily life at school. Children & Society14: 121-134.
2.
Allan J., I’Anson J., Fisher S. and Priestley A. ( 2005) Promising Rights: Introducing Children’s Rights in School. Edinburgh: Save the Children Fund.
3.
Ball SJ ( 2003) The teacher’s soul and the terrors of performativity . Journal of Educational Policy18(2): 215-228.
4.
Bowe R., Ball SJ and Gold A. ( 1992) Reforming Education and Changing Schools: Case Studies in Policy Sociology. London: Routledge .
5.
Bryk AS, Bender Sebring P., Allensworth E., Luppescu S. and Easton JQ ( 2010) Organizing Schools for Improvement. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
6.
Children in Scotland and University of Edinburgh ( 2010) Having a Say at School. Research Briefing2. Characteristics of Pupil Councils. Available at http://www.havingasayatschool.org.uk/documents/paper2_000.pdf, accessed 18 August 2010.
7.
Clarke A. ( 2005) The Voice of Children and Young People. Glasgow, Heads Up Scotland. National Project for Children and Young People’s Mental Health. Available at http://www.headsupscotland.co.uk/documents/ParticipationDiscussionDocument.pdf , accessed 21 August 2010.
8.
Cooper CW(2009) Performing cultural work in demographically changing schools: Implications for expanding transformative leadership frameworks. Educational Administration Quarterly45(5): 694-724.
9.
Cowan E. and McMurtry D.(2009) The implementation of education for citizenship in schools in Scotland: A research report. The Curriculum Journal20(1): 61-72.
10.
Cross B., Hall J., Hall S., Hulme M., Lewin J. and McKinney S. ( 2009) Pupil Participation in Scottish Schools: Final Report . Glasgow, Learning and Teaching Scotland/University of Glasgow Faculty of Education. Available at http://www.gla.ac.uk/media/media_115808_en.pdf, accessed 25 June 2010.
11.
Cuban L. ( 1998) How schools change reforms: redefining reform success and failure. Teachers College Record99(3): 453-477.
12.
Datnow A., Hubbard L. and Mehan H. ( 1998) Educational reform implementation: A co-constructed process . Available at http://www.cal.org/CREDE/pdfs/rr5.pdf , accessed 21 February 2010.
13.
Ecclestone K. and Hayes D. ( 2009) The Dangerous Rise of Therapeutic Education. London: Routledge. Elmore R. (1996) School reform, teaching and learning. Journal of Education Policy11: 449-505.
14.
Englund T. ( 2000) Rethinking democracy and education: Towards an education of deliberative citizens. Journal of Curriculum Studies32(2): 305-313.
15.
Englund T. ( 2006) Deliberative communication: A pragmatist proposal. Journal of Curriculum Studies38(5): 503-520.
16.
Enslin P., Pendlebury S. and Tjiattas M. ( 2001) Deliberative democracy, diversity and the challenges of citizenship education. Journal of the Philosophy of Education35(1): 115-130.
17.
Fenwick T. ( 2003) The good teacher in neo-liberal risk society: A Foucauldian analysis of professional growth plan. Journal of Curriculum Studies35(3): 335-354.
18.
Fielding M. ( 2001) Beyond the rhetoric of student voice: New departures or new constraints in the transformation of 21st century schooling. Forum43(2): 100-109.
19.
Fielding M. ( 2007) Beyond ‘voice’: New roles, relations and contexts in researching with young people. Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education28(3): 301-310.
20.
Furedi F. ( 2009) Wasted. Why Education Isn’t Working . London: Continuum.
21.
Galton M., Gray J. and Rudduck J. ( 2003) Transfer and Transition in the Middle Years of Schooling (7-14): Continuities and Discontinuities in Learning. Research Report443, Annesley, Department of Education and Science.
22.
Gewirtz S. ( 2002) The Managerial School: Post-Welfarism and Social Justice in Education. London: Routledge .
23.
Glatter R.(2009) Wisdom and bus schedules: Developing school leadership. School Leadership & Management29(3): 225-237.
24.
Gleeson D and Husbands C (eds) (2001) The Performing School: Managing, Teaching and Learning in a Performance Culture. London : Routledge Falmer.
25.
Hartley D. ( 2003) The instrumentalisation of the expressive in education . British Journal of Educational Studies51(1): 6-19.
26.
Hill M., Davis J., Prout A. and Tisdall K. ( 2004) Moving the participation agenda forward. Children and Society18: 77-96.
27.
HM Inspectorate of Education (HMIE) (2006) The Journey to Excellence. Livingston: HMIE.
28.
Hutchinson C. and Hayward L. ( 2005) The journey so far: Assessment for learning in Scotland . The Curriculum Journal16(2): 225-248.
29.
Ireland E., Kerr D., Lopes J. and Nelson J. with Cleaver L. ( 2006) Active Citizenship and Young People: Opportunities, Experiences and Challenges In and Beyond School Citizenship Education. Longitudinal Study: Fourth Annual Report (DfES Research Report 732). London: DfES.
30.
Kane J., Lloyd G., McCluskey G., Riddell S., Stead J. and Weedon E. ( 2007) Full report of evaluation of restorative practices in three Scottish councils. Available at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2007/08/24093135/0, accessed 20 June 2010.
31.
Learning and Teaching Scotland (LTS) (2002 ) Education for citizenship inScotland: A document for discussion and development. Learning and Teaching Scotland, Dundee.
32.
Learning and Teaching Scotland (LTS) (2007 ) Learning about learning. Teaching for effective learning: How we learn. Learning and Teaching Scotland, Glasgow. Available at http://www.ltscotland.org.uk/learningaboutlearning/images/TEFL%20complete_tcm4-435808.pdf , accessed 20 June 2010.
33.
Learning and Teaching Scotland (LTS) (2010 a) Online Communities. Available at http://www.ltscotland.org.uk/onlinecommunities/login.asp, accessed 26 June 2010.
34.
Learning and Teaching Scotland (LTS) (2010 b) Scottish Schools Online. Available at http://www.ltscotland.org.uk/scottishschoolsonline/index.asp, accessed 21 August 2010.
35.
Learning and Teaching Scotland (LTS) and Save the Children ( 2007) Participation and Learning. Glasgow : Learning and Teaching Scotland.
36.
Leithwood K. ( 1994) Leadership for school restructuring. Educational Administration Quarterly30(4): 498-518.
37.
Lumby J. and Coleman M. ( 2007) Leadership and Diversity: Challenging Theory and Practice in Education. London: Sage.
38.
Macdonald D. ( 2003) Curriculum change and the post-modern world: Is the school curriculum-reform movement an anachronism. Journal of Curriculum Studies35(2): 139-149.
39.
Maitles H. and Deuchar R. ( 2006) ‘We don’t learn democracy, we live it!’: Consulting the pupil voice in Scottish schools. Education Citizenship and Social Justice. 1(3): 249-266.
40.
Maitles H. and Gilchrist I. ( 2006) Never too young to learn democracy! A case study of a democratic approach to learning in a Religious and Moral Education secondary class in the West of Scotland. Educational Review58(1): 67-85.
41.
Mills I. ( 2004) Citizenship: Pupil involvement in Scottish secondary schools. Pedagogy, Culture and Society12(2): 259-280.
42.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) (2007) Reviews of National Policies for Education - Quality and Equity of Schooling in Scotland. Paris: OECD.
43.
Roberts J. and Bolstad R. ( 2010) Better than a Professional? Students as Co-contributors to Educational Design. Wellington: New Zealand Council for Educational Research.
44.
Rose N. ( 1996) The death of the social? Reconfiguring the territory of government. Economy and Society25(3): 327-356.
45.
Rose N. ( 1999) Governing the Soul: The Shaping of the Private Self, 2nd edn. London: Free Association.
46.
Rudduck J. and McIntyre D. ( 2007) Improving Learning Through Consulting Pupils. London: Routledge.
47.
Sachs J. ( 2003) The Activist Teaching Profession. Buckingham: Open University Press.
48.
Scottish Consumer Council (2007) School Councils and Pupil Participation in Scottish Secondary Schools. Glasgow: Scottish Consumer Council.
49.
Scottish Executive (2004) Protecting Children and Young People: The Charter. Edinburgh: Scottish Executive.
Scottish Government (2007) Findings of the 18-month evaluation of three pilot initiatives aimed to improve the transition between primary and secondary school. Available at http://openscotland.gov.uk/Resource/Doc/163851/0044590.pdf, accessed 20 January 2009.
52.
Scottish Government (2008) Statistical Bulletin Education Series: School Estate Statistics 2008. Available at http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2008/09/29091400/0 , accessed 22 July 2010.
53.
Thomson P. and Holdsworth R. ( 2003) Theorising change in the educational ‘field’: Re-readings of ‘student participation’ projects. International Journal of Leadership in Education6(4): 371-391.
54.
United Nations (UN) (1989) Convention on the Rights of the Child. New York: United Nations.
55.
Whitty G. ( 2006) Teacher professionalism in a new era. General Teaching Council for Northern Ireland Annual Lecture, Queen’s University, Belfast, 14 March.
56.
Wyse D. ( 2001) Felt tip pens and school councils: Children’s participation rights in four English schools. Children and Society15(4): 209-218.
