The article examines and confirms the hypothesis that political decision makers
gather information and do not use it; ask for more information and ignore it; make
decisions first and look for relevant information afterwards; and, collect and
process a great deal of information that has little or no direct relevance to
decisions. The results are based on interviews with members of the Norwegian
national assembly’s Standing Committee on Transport and Communications. In
three parliamentary periods, members were interviewed about their use of results
from analytic planning models evaluating the projects and strategies of three
consecutive road and transport plans. It is studied how the attitudes of the
politicians towards the analytic results change as the planners supply increasingly
advanced means-ends models.
Albæk, E.
(1995)
‘Between Knowledge and Power: Utilization of Social Science in
Public Policy Making’
, Policy Sciences28(1):
79–100
.
2.
Alexander, E.R.
(2000)
‘Rationality Revisited: Planning Paradigms in a
Post-postmodernist Perspective’
, Journal of Planning Education and Research19(3):
242–256
.
3.
Batty, M.
(1994)
‘A Chronicle of Scientific Planning: The Anglo-American Modelling Experience’
, American Planning Association Journal60(1):
7–16
.
4.
Beeson, M.
and
Firth, A.
(1998)
‘Neoliberalism as a Political Rationality: Australian Public
Policy Since the 1980s’
, Journal of Sociology34(3):
215–231
.
5.
Brady, G.L.
,
Clark, J.R.
and
Davis, W.L.
(1995)
‘The Political Economy of Dissonance’
, Public Choice82(1–2):
37–51
.
6.
Bridgman, T.
and
Barry, D.
(2002)
‘Regulation is Evil: An Application of Narrative Policy Analysis
to Regulatory Debate in New Zealand’
, Policy Science35(2):
141–161
.
7.
Campbell, H.
and
Marshall, R.
(2000)
‘Public Involvement and Planning: Looking Beyond the One to the Many’
, International Planning Studies5(3):
321–344
.
8.
Caplan, N.
(1976)
‘Factors Associated with Knowledge Use among Federal Executives’
, Policy Studies Journal4(3):
229–234
.
9.
Caplan, N.
(1979)
‘The Two-communities Theory and Knowledge Utilization’
, American Behavioral Scientist22(3):
459–470
.
10.
Christensen, T.
,
Lægreid, P.
and
Roness, P.G.
(2002)
‘Increasing Parliamentary Control of the Executive? New
Instruments and Emerging Effects’
, Journal of Legislative Studies8(1):
37–62
.
11.
Diesing, P.
(1973) Reason in Society.
Westport, CT: Greenwood
.
12.
Dryzek, J.
(1982)
‘Policy Analysis as a Hermeneutic Activity’
, Policy Sciences14(4):
309–329
.
13.
Dryzek, J.
(1987)
‘Complexity and Rationality in Public Life’
, Political Studies35(3):
424–442
.
14.
Egeberg, M.
(1995)
‘The Policy-administration Dichotomy Revisited: The Case of
Transport Infrastructure Planning in Norway’
, International Review of Administrative Sciences61(4):
565–576
.
15.
Elkin, S.L.
(1985)
‘Economic and Political Rationality’
, Polity18(2):
253–271
.
16.
Elster, J.
(1987)
‘The Possibility of Rational Politics’
, Archives Européennes Sociologie28(1):
67–103
.
17.
Fischer, F.
(1990) Technocracy and the Politics of Expertise.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
18.
Fridstrøm, L.
and
Elvik, R.
(1997)
‘The Barely Revealed Preference Behind Road Investment Priorities’
, Public Choice92(1–2):
145–168
.
19.
Friedmann, J.
and
Abonyi, G.
(1976)
‘Social Learning: A Model for Policy Research’
, Environment and Planning A8(8):
927–940
.
20.
Friend, J.
and
Hickling, A.
(1997) Planning under Pressure: The Strategic Choice
Approach, 2nd edn.Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann
.
Gordon, C.
(1991) ‘Governmental Rationality: An
Introduction’, in
G. Burchell
,
C. Gordon
and
P. Miller
(eds) The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality, pp.
1–51.
London: Harvester Wheatsheaf
.
23.
Grauhan, R.-R.
and
Strubelt, W.
(1971)
‘Political Rationality Reconsidered: Notes on an Integrated
Evaluative Scheme for Policy Choices’
, Policy Sciences2(3):
249–270
.
24.
Guhathakurta, S.
(2002)
‘Urban Modeling as Storytelling: Using Simulation Models as a Narrative’
, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design29(6):
895–911
.
25.
Hammond, T.H.
and
Horn, J.H.
(1985)
‘ “Putting One Over on the Boss”: The
Political Economy of Strategic Behavior in Organizations’
, Public Choice45(1):
49–71
.
26.
Hammond, T.H.
and
Miller, G.J.
(1985)
‘A Social Choice Perspective on Expertise and Authority in Bureaucracy’
, American Journal of Political Science29(1):
1–28
.
27.
Harper, T.L.
and
Stein, S.M.
(1996) ‘Postmodernist Planning Theory: The
Incommensurability Premise’, in
S.J. Mandelbaum
,
L. Mazza
and
R.W. Burchell
(eds) Explorations in Planning Theory, pp.
414–429.
New Brunswick, NJ: Center for Urban Policy
Research, Rutgers
.
28.
Hoogerwerf, A.
(1981) ‘Planning Agencies: Bridges or Barriers
between Research and Policy Processes?’, in
P.R. Baehr
and
B. Wittrock
(eds) Policy Analysis and Policy Innovation. Patterns, Problems and
Potentials, pp. 27–44.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
.
29.
Innes, J.E.
(1990) Knowledge and Public Policy: The Search for Meaningful
Indicators.
New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers
.
30.
Innstilling S.
no. 232 (1992–3) Innstilling fra
Samferdselskomiteen om Norsk Vegog Vegtrafikkplan 1994–97
[Recommendation to the Storting from the Standing Committee on Transport and
Communications on the Norwegian Road and Road Traffic Plan
1994–97].
Oslo: Stortinget
.
31.
Innstilling S.
no. 184 (1993–4) Innstilling fra
Samferdselskomiteen om nytt Overordnet Styringssystem for Statens Vegvesen
[Recommendation to the Storting from the Standing Committee on Transport and
Communications on the New System of Strategic Steering and Control in the Public
Roads Organization].
Oslo: Stortinget
.
32.
Kaplan, T.J.
(1993) ‘Reading Policy Narratives: Beginnings,
Middles, and Ends’, in
F. Fischer
and
J. Forester
(eds) The Argumentative Turn in Policy Analysis and Planning, pp.
167–185.
London: UCL Press
.
33.
Laffont, J.J.
and
Meleu, M.
(1997)
‘Reciprocal Supervision, Collusion and Organizational Design’
, Scandinavian Journal of Economics99(4):
519–540
.
34.
Lee, D.B., Jr
(1973)
‘Requiem for Large-scale Models’
, Journal of the American Institute of Planners39(3):
163–178
.
35.
Lerstang, T.
and
Stenstadvold, M.
(1995) ‘Jeg bruker mitt eget
skjønn...’: Kritisk lys på Trafikkmodellers Rolle
i Dagens Planlegging [‘I use my Personal Judgement...’:
Critical Light on the Role of Traffic Models in Current Planning].
TØI Report 319/1995.
Oslo: Institute of Transport Economics
.
36.
Lichfield, N.
(1996) Community Impact Evaluation.
London: UCL Press
.
37.
Lindblom, C.E.
and
Cohen, D.K.
(1979) Usable Knowledge: Social Science and Social Problem
Solving.
New Haven, CT: Yale University Press
.
38.
MacRae, D., Jr
and
Whittington, D.
(1997) Expert Advice for Policy Choice.
Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press
.
39.
March, J.G.
(1994) A Primer on Decision Making: How Decisions
Happen.
New York: Free Press
.
40.
Marris, P.
(1997) Witnesses, Engineers, and Storytellers: Using Research
for Social Policy and Action.
College Park, MD: University of Maryland, Urban
Studies and Planning Program
.
41.
Naustdalslid, J.
and
Reitan, M.
(1992): Kunnskap og Styring: Om Forskningens Rolle i Politikk
og Forvaltning [Knowledge and Governance: Concerning the Role of Research in
Politics and the Administration]. NIBR Report 1992: 15.
Oslo: Norwegian Institute of Urban and Regional Research
.
42.
Nelson, R.H.
(1987)
‘The Economics Profession and the Making of Public Policy’
, Journal of Economic Literature25(1):
49–91
.
43.
Niemeyer, S.
and
Spash, C.L.
(2001)
‘Environmental Valuation Analysis, Public Deliberation, and their
Pragmatic Syntheses: A Critical Appraisal’
, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy19(4):
567–585
.
44.
Nilsson, J.-E.
(1991)
‘Investment Decisions in a Public Bureaucracy’
, Journal of Transport Economics and Policy25(2):
163–175
.
45.
Nyborg, K.
(1998)
‘Some Norwegian Politicians’ Use of Cost-benefit Analysis’
, Public Choice95(3–4):
381–401
.
46.
Nyborg, K.
and
Spangen, I.
(1996) Politiske Beslutninger om Investeringer i Veger
[Political Decisions on Road Investments]. TØI Working
Report 1026/1996.
Oslo: Institute of Transport Economics
.
47.
Oakeshott, M.
(1974) Rationalism in Politics and Other Essays.
London: Methuen
.
48.
Odeck, J.
(1996)
‘Ranking of Regional Road Investment in Norway: Does
Socioeconomic Analysis Matter?’
, Transportation23(2):
123–140
.
49.
Ouellette, L.
(1999)
‘TV Viewing as Good Citizenship? Political Rationality,
Enlightened Democracy and PBS’
, Cultural Studies13(1):
62–90
.
50.
Pancer, S.M.
,
Hunsberger, B.
,
Pratt, M.W.
,
Boisvert, S.
and
Roth, D.
(1992)
‘Political Roles and the Complexity of Political Rhetoric’
, Political Psychology13(1):
31–43
.
51.
Peters, B.G.
(1987) ‘Politicians and Bureaucrats in the
Politics of Policy-making’, in
J.-E. Lane
(ed.) Bureaucracy and Public Choice, pp.
256–282.
Beverly Hills, CA: Sage
.
52.
Pollitt, C.
,
Girre, X.
,
Lonsdale, J.
,
Mul, R.
,
Summa, H.
and
Waerness, M.
(1999) Performance or Compliance?: Performance Audit and
Public Management in Five Countries.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
53.
Portugali, J.
,
Benenson, I.
and
Omer, I.
(1997)
‘Spatial Cognitive Dissonance and Sociospatial Emergence in a
Self-organizing City’
, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design24(2):
263–285
.
54.
Ravlum, I.-A.
and
Stenstadvold, M.
(1997) Fra Vegstubber til Strategi og Helhet? [Towards a Goal
Oriented and Comprehensive Road Policy Process?]. TØI
Report 374/1997.
Oslo: Institute of Transport Economics
.
55.
Ravlum, I.-A.
and
Stenstadvold, M.
(2001) Overordnet og Helhetlig Politisk Styring? [Strategic
and Comprehensive Decision Making Report] 543/2001.
Oslo: Institute of Transport Economics
.
56.
Richardson, H.S.
(2000)
‘The Stupidity of the Cost-benefit Standard’
, Journal of Legal Studies29(2):
971–1003
.
57.
Sabatier, P.
(1978)
‘The Acquisition and Utilization of Technical Information by
Administrative Agencies’
, Administrative Science Quarterly23(3):
396–417
.
58.
Sager, T.
(1990) Communicate or Calculate. Dissertation 11.
Stockholm: Nordic Institute for Research in
Urban and Regional Planning
.
59.
Sager, T.
(1995)
‘From Impact Assessment to Recommendation: How are the Impact
Assessment Results Presented and Used?’
, Environmental Impact Assessment Review15(4):
377–397
.
60.
Sager, T.
(1999)
‘Rhetoric of Economic Rationality: The Foundation of Norwegian
Transport Planning’
, European Planning Studies7(4):
501–518
.
61.
Sager, T.
(2002) Democratic Planning and Social Choice Dilemmas:
Prelude to Institutional Planning Theory.
Aldershot: Ashgate
.
62.
Sandercock, L.
(2003)
‘Out of the Closet: The Importance of Stories and Storytelling in
Planning Practice’
, Planning Theory and Practice4(1):
11–28
.
63.
Schmidtz, D.
(2001)
‘A Place for Cost-benefit Analysis’
, Nous35(Supplement 1):
148–171
.
64.
Throgmorton, J.A.
(1996) Planning as Persuasive Storytelling: The Rhetorical
Construction of Chicago’s Electric Future.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
65.
Webber, D.J.
(1984)
‘Political Conditions Motivating Legislators’ Use of
Policy Information’
, Policy Studies Review4(1):
110–118
.
66.
Weiss, C.H.
(1991) ‘Policy Research: Data, Ideas, or
Arguments?’, in
P. Wagner
,
C.H. Weiss
,
B. Wittrock
and
H. Wollman
(eds) Social Sciences and Modern States, pp.
307–322.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
67.
Wittrock, B.
(1982)
‘Social Knowledge, Public Policy and Social Betterment: A Review
of Current Research on Knowledge Utilization in Policy-making’
, European Journal of Political Research10(1):
83–89
.
