A New Approach to Assess the Retention of Allergen (Der f 1 and Der p 1) on Anionic and Nonanionic Cotton Bedding Sheets After a Vigorous Sequential Cleaning Regime as Assessed by ELISA

Abstract

Anionic surfaces can interact with a variety of biological molecules and when used on bedding material may have the potential of binding with and sequestering protein allergens such as those produced by dust mites. However, no method exists to evaluate the efficacy of this claim. The purpose of this study was to develop a method using enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to evaluate the capability of anionic treated cotton bedding sheet material to retain medically important dust mite allergens in direct comparison with nonanionic cotton bedding sheet material from a single manufacturer. Anionic, and nonanionic cotton bedding sheets were challenged singularly with water suspended pulverized dust mite Dermatophagoides farinae, water suspended pulverized dust mite D. pteronyssinus, or water alone as a negative control. All dried inoculums were subjected to four sequential extraction series using water in the first two separate extractions and water with surfactant in the last two separate extractions. All four extractions were assessed by ELISA using monoclonal antibodies specific for medically important protein allergens Der f 1 (D. farinae) or Der p 1 (D. pteronyssinus), respectively. There were a total of 25 replicates for each assessment. Our findings demonstrate that nearly all of the Der f 1 and Der p 1 was released from the nonanionic fabric after the first water extraction. Conversely, most of the Der f 1 and Der p 1 allergens were retained by the anionic fabric after both water extractions and was released only after surfactant was used. Our data indicated that >80% of Der f 1 and Der p 1 was released from the nonanionic fabric after the initial two water extractions while 80% of Der f 1 and Der p 1 was retained by anionic fabric after the same extractions. The method proved to be robust and data was reproducible. Protein extraction using less stringent to high stringent conditions demonstrated the effectiveness of anionic fabric in retaining dust mite proteins that cause allergy. This method can be used to assess other materials while allergists should consider the use of anionic bedding as it effectively retained dust mite allergens Der f 1 and Der p 1 until laundering can remove them from the household.

Keywords

dust mites Der f 1 Der p 1 cotton bedding sheet anionic ELISA.

References

Weiss, K.B. and Sullivan, S.D. ( 2001). The Health Economics of Asthma and Rhinitis: I. Assessing the Economic Impact, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology , 107: 3-8.

Arbes Jr, S.J. , Cohn, R.D. , Yin, M. , Muilenberg, M.L. , Burge, H.A. , Friedman, W. and Zeldin, D.C. (2003). House Dust Mite Allergen in US Beds: Results from the First National Survey of Lead and Allergens in Housing, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 111(2): 408-414.

Tunnicliffe, W.S. , Fletcher, T.J. , Hammond, K. , Roberts, K. , Custovic, A. , Simpson, A. , Woodcock, A. and Ayres, J.G. (1999). Sensitivity and Exposure to Indoor Allergens in Adults with Differing Asthma Severity, European Respiratory Journal, 13: 654-659.

Green, R.M. , Custovic, A. , Sanderson, G. , Hunter, J. , Johnston, S.L. and Woodcock, A. ( 2002). Synergism Between Allergens and Viruses and Risk of Hospital Admission with Asthma: A Case Control Study, British Medical Journal, 324: 763-766.

Ehnert, B. , Lau-Schadendorf, S. , Weber, A. , Buettner, P. , Schou, C. and Wahn, U. ( 1992). Reducing Domestic Exposure to Dust Mite Allergen Reduces Bronchial Hypersensitivity in Sensitive Children with Asthma, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 90: 135-138.

Tan, B.B. , Weald, D. , Strickland, I. and Friedman, P.S. (1996). Double-blind Controlled Trial of the Effect of House Dust Mite, Allergen Avoidance of Atopic Dermatitis, Lancet, 347: 15-18.

Uehara, S. , Franzolin, M.R. , Chiesa, S. , Moreira, D. , Gambale, W. and Paula, C.R. ( 2006). Effectiveness of House Dust Mite Acaricide Tri-n-butyl Tin Maleate on Carpets, Fabrics and Mattress Foam: A Standardization of Methodology , Revista do Instituto de Medicina Tropical de São Paulo, 48: 171-174.

Nadchatram, M. (2005). House Dust Mites, Our Intimate Associates, Tropical Biomedicine, 22: 23-37.

Arbes, S.J. , Sever, M. , Mehta, J. , Collette, N. , Thomas, B. and Zeldin, D.C. ( 2005). Exposure to Indoor Allergens in Day-care Facilities: Results from 2 North Carolina Counties, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 116: 133-139.

10.

Woodcock, A. , Forster, L. , Matthews, E. , Martin, J. , Letley, L. , Vickers, M. , Britton, J. , Strachan, D. , Howarth, P. , Altmann, D. , Frost, C. and Custovic, A. (2003). Control of Exposure to Mite Allergen and Allergen-impermeable Bed Covers for Adults with Asthma, New England Journal of Medicine, 349(3): 225-236.

11.

Burr, M.L. , St Leger, A.S. and Neale, E. ( 1976). Anti-mite Measures in Mite-sensitive Adult Asthma: A Controlled Trial, Lancet, 1: 333-335.

12.

Marks, G.B. , Tovey, E.R. , Green, W. , Shearer, M. , Salome, C.M. and Woodcock, A.J. ( 1994). House Dust Mite Allergen Avoidance: A Randomized Controlled Trial of Surface Chemical Treatment and Encasement of Bedding, Clinical and Experimental Allergy, 24: 1078-1083.

13.

Carswell, F. , Birmingham, K. , Oliver, J. , Crewes, A. and Weeks, J. ( 1996). The Respiratory Effects of Reduction of Mite Allergen in the Bedroom of Asthmatic Children - a Double-blind, Controlled Trial, Clinical and Experimental Allergy, 26: 386-396.

14.

van der Heide, S. , Kauffman, H.F. , Dubois, A.E.J. and de Monchy , J.G.R. (1997). Allergen Reduction Measures in Houses of Allergic Asthmatic Patients: Effects of Air Cleaners and Allergen Impermeable Mattress Covers, European Respiratory Journal, 10: 1217-1223.

15.

Cloosterman, S.G. , Schermer, T.R. , Bijl-Hofland , I.D. , Van Der Heide, S. , Brunekreef, B. , Van Den Elshout, F.J. , Van Herwaarden, C.L. and Van Schayck, C.P. ( 1999). Effects of House Dust Mite Avoidance Measures on Der p 1 Concentrations and Clinical Condition of Mild Adult House Dust Mite-allergic Asthmatic Patients, Using no Inhaled Steroids, Clinical and Experimental Allergy, 29: 1336-1346.

16.

Custovic, A. , Murray, C.S. , Gore, R.B. and Woodcock, A. (2002). Controlling Indoor Allergens . Annals of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology, 88: 432-441.

17.

Vaughan, J.W. , McLaughlin, T.E. , Perzanowski, M.S. and Platts-Mills , T.A. (1999). Evaluation of Materials used for Bedding Encasement: Effect of Pore Size in Blocking Cat and Dust Mite Allergen, Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 103(2Pt1): 227-231.

18.

Peroni, D.G. , Ress, M. , Pigozzi, R. , Miraglia del Giudice , M. , Bodini, A. and Piacentini, G.L. (2004). Efficacy in Allergen Control and Air Permeability of Different Materials used for Bed Encasement, Allergy, 59: 969-972.

19.

Griffin, J.H. (1978). Role of Surface in Surface-dependent Activation of Hageman Factor (Blood Coagulation Factor XII), Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America , 75: 1998-2002.

20.

McMillin, C.R. , Saito, H. , Ratnoff, O.D. and Walton, A.G. (1974). The Secondary Structure of Human Hageman Factor (factor XII) and its Alteration by Activating Agents , Journal of Clinical Investigation, 54(6): 1312-1322.

21.

Davies, J.K. , Thumser, A.E.A. and Wilton, D.C. (1999). Binding of Recombinant Rat Liver Fatty Acid-binding Protein to Small Anionic Vesicles Results in Ligand Release: A Model for Interfacial Binding and Fatty Acid Targeting, Biochemistry, 38: 16932-16940.

22.

Buckland, A.G. and Wilton, D.C. (2000). Anionic Phospholipids, Interfacial Binding and the Regulation of Cell Functions, Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, 1483(2): 199-216.

23.

Vzorov, A.N. , Bozja, J. , Dixon, D.W. , Marzilli, L.G. and Compans, R.W. (2007). Parameters of Inhibition of HIV-1 Infection by Anionic Microbiocides, Antiviral Research , 73: 60-68.

24.

Terreehorst, I. , Hak, E. , Oosting, A.J. , Tempels-Pavlica , Z. , de Monchy, J.G.R. , Bruijnzeel-Koomen, C. , Aalberse, R.C. and van Wijk, R.G. ( 2003). Evaluation of Impermeable Covers for Bedding in Patients with Allergic Rhinitis, New England Journal of Medicine, 349: 237-346.

25.

Recer, G.M. ( 2004). A Review of the Effects of Impermeable Bedding Encasements on Dust-mite Allergen Exposure and Bronchial Hyper-responsiveness in Dust-mite-sensitized Patients, Clinical and Experimental Allergy, 34: 268-275.