Complexity theory (CT) has had a meteoric rise in management literature and the social sciences. Its fledgling importation into school leadership and management raises several questions and concerns. This article takes one view of CT and argues that, though its key elements have much to offer school leadership and management, caution has to be exercised in accepting CT too readily, as it: (1) is unclear on its own novelty, nature and status; (2) can be regarded as disguised ideology in conflating description and prescription; (3) confuses explanation with prediction; (4) is relativist, undermining its own status; (5) contains problems in its advocacy of self-organization; (6) neglects the ethical and emotional dimensions of leadership and management; and (7) risks exonerating school leaders and managers from reasonable expectations of accountability and responsibility. The article concludes that there are questions to CT at the levels of theory, ontology, deontology and ethics, but that it offers useful challenges for school leadership and management.
Amis J., Slack T., Hinings CR ( 2004) The pace, sequence, and linearity of radical change . Academy of Management Journal47(1): 15-39.
2.
Andriani P., Passiante G. ( 2004) Complexity theory and the management of networks . In: Assiante P, Passiante G (eds) Complexity Theory and the Management of Networks. London: Imperial College Press, 3-19.
3.
Aronson N., Mastorovich MJ, Arsht B. ( 2002) Letting go ... of control requires bold leadership . The Journal for Quality and Participation Summer2002: 36-39.
4.
Arshinow V, Fuchs C (eds) (2003) Causality, Emergence, Self-organization. Vienna, Vienna University of Technology: INTAS research project on Human Strategies in Complexity. Available at: http://www.self-organization.org (accessed 10 July 2004).
5.
Bai H. ( 2003) On the Edge of Chaos. Proceedings of the 2003 Complexity Science and Educational Research Conference, 16-18 October 2003, 19-30. Available at: http://www.complexityandeducation.ualberta.ca/conferences/2003/Documents/CSER_Bai.pdf (accessed 16 September 2006).
6.
Bailey R. ( 2000) Education in the Open Society: Karl Popper and Schooling . Aldershot: Ashgate Publishing Ltd.
7.
Bak P. ( 1996) How Nature Works. New York: Copernicus.
8.
Barabási AL ( 2002) Linked: The New Science of Networks. Cambridge, MA: Perseus.
9.
Barling J., Slater F., Kelloway EK ( 2000) Transformational leadership and emotional intelligence: an exploratory study. Leadership and Organization Development Journal21(3): 157-61.
10.
Battram A. ( 1999) Navigating Complexity. London : The Industrial Society.
11.
Black JA ( 2000) Fermenting change: capitalizing on the inherent change found in dynamic non-linear (or complex) systems. Journal of Organizational Change Management13(6): 520-25.
12.
Bourdieu P. ( 1977) Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
13.
Bourdieu P. ( 1986) Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste . London: Routledge.
14.
Brodbeck PW ( 2002) Complexity theory and organization procedure design . Business Process Management8(4): 377-402.
15.
Brooke-Smith R. ( 2003) Leading Learners, Leading Schools. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
16.
Brown SL, Eisenhardt KM ( 1998) Competing on the Edge: Strategy as Structured Chaos . Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
17.
Buchanan M. ( 2002) Nexus: Small Worlds and the Groundbreaking Theory of Networks . New York: W.W. Norton .
18.
Burnes B. ( 2005) Complexity theories and organizational change. International Journal of Management Reviews7(2): 73-90.
19.
Capra F. ( 1996) The Web of Life: A New Understanding of Living Systems . New York: Anchor Books .
20.
Capra F. ( 2007) Complexity and life. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 1-25.
21.
Capra F., Juarerro A., Sotolongo P., van Uden J. ( 2007) Reframing complexity: perspectives from the North and South. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, vii-xix.
22.
Carley KM, Hill V. ( 2001) Structural change and learning within organizations . In: Lomi A, Larsen ER (eds) Dynamics of Organizations: Computational Modeling and Organizational Theories. Menlo Park, CA: AAAI Press/MIT Press, 63-92.
23.
Carley KM, Svoboda DM ( 1996) Modeling organizational adaptation as a simulated annealing process. Sociological Methods and Research25(1): 138-68.
24.
Chu D., Strand R., Fjelland R. ( 2003) Theories of complexity: common denominators of complex systems. Complexity8(3): 19-30.
25.
Cilliers P. ( 1998) Complexity and Postmodernism. London : Routledge.
26.
Cilliers P. ( 2004) A framework for understanding complex systems. In: Assiante P, Passiante G (eds) Complexity Theory and the Management of Networks. London: Imperial College Press, 23-7.
27.
Cilliers P. ( 2007) Why we cannot know complex things completely. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 81-89.
28.
Clarke S., Wildy H. ( 2004) Context counts: viewing small school leadership from the inside out. Journal of Educational Administration42(5): 555-72.
29.
Cohen J., Stewart I. ( 1995) The Collapse of Chaos. Harmondsworth : Penguin.
30.
Cohen M. ( 1999) Commentary on the organization science special issue on complexity. Organizational Science10(3): 373-6.
31.
Cole K. ( 2007) Globalization and the complexity of human dignity . In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 219-38.
32.
Conner DR ( 1998) Leading at the Edge of Chaos. New York : John Wiley.
33.
Crow GM ( 2006) Complexity and the beginning principal in the United States: perspectives on socialization. Journal of Educational Administration44(4): 310-25.
34.
Cunningham R. ( 2001) Chaos, complexity and the study of educational communities . Paper presented at the British Educational Research Association conference, University of Leeds, September 2001. http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/00001895.doc . Retrieved 8 October 2007.
35.
Cunningham R. ( 2003) Complexity theory and school improvement: some possible connections. Paper presented at the British Education Research Association conference Edinburgh University , September 2003. http://www.leeds.ac.uk/educol/documents/00003214.doc . Retrieved 8 October 2007.
36.
Davis B., Sumara DJ ( 2005) Challenging images of knowing: complexity science and educational research. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education18(3): 305-21.
37.
Davis B., Sumara D. ( 2006) Complexity and Education. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
38.
Diaz CJD ( 2007) Complexity and environmental education. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 47-58.
39.
Doll WE, Fleener MJ, Trueit D., St. Julien J. ( 2005) Chaos Complexity and the Curriculum. New York: Peter Lang.
40.
Edmonds B. ( 1999) Syntactic Measures of Complexity. Available at: http://bruce.edmonds.name/thesis (accessed 8 December 2007).
41.
Espinosa A., Harnden R., Walker J. ( 2007) Beyond hierarchy: a complexity management perspective . Kybernetes36(3/4): 333-47.
42.
Falconer J. ( 2007) Emergence happens! Misguided paradigms regarding organizational change and the role of complexity and patterns in the change landscape. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from the North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 135-50.
43.
Fitzgerald LA, Van Eijnatten FM ( 2002) Reflections: chaos in organizational change. Journal of Organizational Change Management15(4): 402-11.
44.
Fuchs C. ( 2003a) Some implications of Pierre Bourdieu’s works for a theory of social self-organization. European Journal of Social Theory6(4): 387-408.
45.
Fuchs C. ( 2003b) Structuration theory and self-organization. Systematic Practice and Action Research16(2): 133-67.
46.
Fullan M. ( 1998) Change Forces: The Sequel. London: Paul Chapman.
47.
Fullan M. ( 2001) Leading in a Culture of Change. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
48.
Fullan M. ( 2002) Principals as leaders in a culture of change. Educational Leadership May. Available at: http://www.michaelfullan.ca/Articles_02/03_02.pdf (accessed 23 November 2007).
49.
Fullan M. ( 2005) Leadership and Sustainability: Systems Thinkers in Action . Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press .
50.
Galbraith P. ( 2004) Organizational leadership and chaos theory: let’s be careful. Journal of Educational Administration42(1): 9-28.
51.
Gibson D. ( 1999) Mapping the dynamics of change: a complexity theory analysis of innovation in five Vermont high schools. Unpublished doctorate dissertation, Graduate College, University of Vermont. Available at: http://www.vermontinstitutes.org/pub/MappingChange.pdf (accessed 1 November 2007).
52.
Giddens A. ( 1976) New Rules of Sociological Method. London: Hutchinson.
53.
Giddens A. ( 1984) The Constitution of Society: Outline of the Theory of Structuration. Cambridge: Polity Press.
54.
Goffman E. ( 1968) Asylums: Essays on the Social Situation of Mental Patients and Other Inmates. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
55.
Goldberg JA, Markoczy L. ( 2000) Complex rhetoric and simple games. Emergence2(1): 72-100.
56.
Goldstein JA ( 2000) Emergence: a construct amid a thicket of conceptual snares . Emergence2(1): 5-22.
57.
Goldstein JA, Hazy JK ( 2006) Editorial introduction to the special issue: from complexity to leadership and back to complexity. Emergence: Complexity and Organization8(4): v-vii.
58.
Goleman D. ( 2000) Leadership that gets results. Harvard Business Review March/April: 78-90.
59.
Goleman D., Boyarzis R., McKee A. ( 2002) The New Leaders. London: Little Brown.
60.
Gregson RAM, Guastello SJ ( 2005) Introduction to nonlinear methodology, part 1: challenges we face and those we offer. Nonlinear Dynamics, Psychology, and Life Sciences9(4): 371-4.
61.
Gronn P. ( 2000) Distributed properties: a new architecture for leadership . Educational Management & Administration28(3): 317-38.
62.
Gronn P. ( 2002) Distributed leadership as a unit of analysis. The Leadership Quarterly13(4): 423-52.
63.
Gronn P. ( 2003) The New Work of Educational Leaders: Changing Leadership Practice in an Era of School Reform. London: Paul Chapman.
64.
Guastello SJ, Craven J., Zygowicz KM, Bock BR ( 2005) A rugged landscape model for self-organization and emergent leadership in creative problem solving and production groups . Nonlinear Dynamics, Psychology and Life Sciences9(3): 297-334.
65.
Gunter H. ( 2003) Introduction-the challenge of distributed leadership . School Leadership and Management23(3): 261-5.
66.
Hammond SC, Glenn LM ( 2004) The ancient practice of Chinese social networking: Guanxi and social network theory. Emergence: Complexity and Organization6(1): 24-31.
67.
Hannay LM, Seltzer EC, Ross JA ( 2001) Building change capacity within secondary schools through goal-driven and living organisations. School Leadership and Management21(3): 271-87.
68.
Hargreaves A. ( 1994) Changing Teachers, Changing Times: Teachers Work and Culture in the Postmodern Age. London: Cassell.
69.
Harris A. ( 2003) Teacher leadership as distributed leadership: heresy, fantasy or possibility?School Leadership and Management23(3): 313-24.
70.
Heck RH, Hallinger P. ( 2005) The study of educational leadership and management . Educational Management Administration & Leadership33(2): 229-44.
71.
Houchin K., MacLean D. ( 2005) Complexity theory and strategic change: an empirically informed critique. British Journal of Management16(2): 149-66.
72.
Hübler AW ( 2007) Understanding complex systems: defining an abstract concept . Complexity12(5): 9-11.
73.
Hundnes T., Meyer CB ( 2006) Living with paradoxes of corporate strategy. Journal of Organizational Change Management19(4): 437-46.
74.
Juarrero A. ( 2007) Complex dynamical systems and the problem of identity . In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 107-18.
75.
Kauffman SA ( 1995) At Home in the Universe: The Search for the Laws of Self-Organization and Complexity. Harmondsworth: Penguin.
76.
Kelly K. ( 1994) Out of Control. Cambridge, MA : Perseus.
77.
Kelly S., Allison MA ( 1999) The Complexity Advantage: How the Science of Complexity Can Help Your Business Achieve Peak Performance. New York : McGraw-Hill.
78.
Klein JK ( 2004) Interdisciplinarity and complexity: an evolving relationship . Emergence: Complexity and Organization, 6(1-2): 2-10.
79.
Lakatos I. ( 1970) Falsification and the methodology of scientific research . In: Lakatos I, Musgrave A (eds) Criticism and the Growth of Knowledge. London: Cambridge University Press, 91-195.
80.
Lakomski G. ( 2000) Leadership: how to manage without it. Paper prepared for the Centre for Educational Leadership , University of Hong Kong, 27 September 2000. Available at: http://www.hku.hk/educel/Handout-ProfLakomski.PDF (accessed 4 April 2001).
81.
Leban W., Zulauf C. ( 2004) Linking emotional intelligence abilities and transformational leadership styles. Leadership and Organizational Development Journal25(7): 554-64.
82.
Laudan L. ( 1990) Science and Relativism. Chicago, IL : University of Chicago Press.
83.
Leithwood KA, Riehl C. ( 2003) What do we already know about successful school leadership?Paper presented to the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, IL. Available at: http://www.cepa.gse.rutgers.edu/What%20We%20Know%20_long_%202003.pdf (accessed 24 November 2007).
84.
Levin HM ( 1991) Why isn’t educational research more useful? . In: Anderson DS, Biddle BJ (eds) Knowledge for Policy: Improving Education through Research. London: Falmer, 70-8.
85.
Lewin R. ( 1993) Complexity: Life on the Edge. London : Phoenix.
86.
Lichtenstein BMB ( 2000) Emergence as a process of self-organizing: new assumptions and insights from the study of non-linear dynamic systems. Journal of Organizational Change Management13(6): 526-44.
87.
Lichtenstein BMB., Uhl-Bien M., Marion R., Seers A., Orton JD, Schreiber C. ( 2006) Complexity leadership theory: an interactive perspective on leading in complex adaptive systems. Emergence: Complexity and Organization8(4): 2-12.
88.
Lissack M. ( 1999) Complexity: the science, its vocabulary, and its relations to organizations. Emergence1(1): 110-25.
89.
MacIntosh R., MacLean D. ( 1999) Conditioned emergence: a dissipative structures approach to transformation. Strategic Management Journal20(4): 297-316.
90.
Mackenzie A. ( 2003) The practice of complexity. Unpublished paper, Institute for Cultural Research, University of Lancaster .
91.
Majchrzak A., Logan D., McCurdy R., Kirchmer M. ( 2006) Four keys to managing emergence. MIT Sloan Management Review47(2): 14-18.
92.
Mansfield D. ( 2003) Complexity Theory and Educational Leadership. Nottingham: National College for School Leadership.http://www.ncsl.org.uk/media/F7B/99/randd-practitioner-award-mansfield.pdf . Retrieved 8 October 2007.
93.
Marion R. ( 1999) The Edge of Organization: Chaos and Complexity Theories of Formal Social Systems. London: SAGE.
94.
Marion R., Bacon J. ( 2000) Organizational extinction and complex systems. Emergence1(4): 71-94.
95.
Marion R., Uhl-Bien M. ( 2001) Leadership in complex organizations. The Leadership Quarterly12(4): 389-418.
96.
McElroy MW ( 2000) Integrating complexity theory, knowledge management and organizational learning. Journal of Knowledge Management4(3): 195-203.
97.
McKelvey W. ( 2004) Simple rules for improving corporate IQ: basic lessons from complexity science. In: Assiante P, Assiante G (eds) Complexity Theory and the Management of Networks. London : Imperial College Press, 39-52.
98.
McMaster MD ( 1996) The Intelligence Advantage: Organizing for Complexity . Boston, MA: Butterworth-Heinemann .
99.
Moreno A., Ruiz-Mirazo K. ( 2007) Key issues regarding the origin, nature, and evolution of complexity in nature: information as a central concept to understanding biological organization. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 59-77.
100.
Morrison KRB ( 1998) Management Theories for Educational Change. London: Paul Chapman.
101.
Morrison KRB ( 2002) School Leadership and Complexity Theory. London: RoutledgeFalmer.
102.
Morrison KRB ( 2005) Structuration, habitus and complexity theory: elective affinities or new wine in old bottles?British Journal of Sociology of Education26(3): 311-26.
103.
Morrison KRB ( 2006) Complexity theory and education. Paper presented at the Asia-Pacific Educational Research Association , Hong Kong Institute of Education, November 2006.
104.
Murray PJ ( 2003) So what’s new about complexity?Systems Research and Behavioural Science20(5): 409-17.
105.
Ortegón-Monroy MC ( 2003) Chaos and complexity theory in management: an exploration from a critical systems thinking perspective. Systems Research and Behavioral Science20(5): 387-400.
106.
Osberg D., Biesta GJ ( 2003) Complexity, representation and the epistemology of schooling . Proceedings of the 2003 Complexity Science and Educational Research Conference, 16-18 October 2003, 83-99. Available at: http://www.complexityandeducation.ualberta.ca/conferences/2003/Documents/CSER_Osberg_Biesta.pdf (accessed 15 September 2006).
107.
Parellada RJF ( 2007) Modeling of social organizations: necessity and possibility . In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from the North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 151-68.
108.
Popper K. ( 1963) Conjectures and Refutations. London : Routledge and Kegan Paul.
109.
Popper K. ( 1990) A World of Propensities. Bristol : Thoemmes Antiquarian Books.
110.
Popper K. ( 1992) The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London: Routledge.
111.
Prigogine L., Stengers I. ( 1985) Order Out of Chaos. London: Flamingo.
112.
Rivkin JW, Siggelkow N. ( 2003) Balancing search and stability: interdependencies among elements of organizational design. Management Science49(3): 290-311.
113.
Rosete D., Ciarrochi J. ( 2005) Emotional intelligence and its relationship to workplace performance outcomes of leadership effectiveness. Leadership and Organizational Development Journal26(5): 388-99.
114.
Ryle G. ( 1949) The Concept of Mind. Harmondsworth : Penguin.
115.
Sawyer RK ( 2005) Social Emergence: Societies as Complex Systems . New York: Cambridge University Press.
116.
Schneider M., Somers M. ( 2006) Organizations as complex adaptive systems: implications of complexity theory for leadership research. The Leadership Quarterly17(4): 351-65.
117.
Schreiber C., Carley KM ( 2006) Leadership style as an enable of organizational complex functioning. Emergence: Complexity and Organization8(4): 61-76.
118.
Siegel H. ( 1987) Relativism Refuted. Dordrecht : D. Reidel.
119.
Siggelkow N., Rivkin JW ( 2005) Speed and search: designing organizations for turbulence and complexity. Organization Science16(2): 101-22.
120.
Siggelkow N., Rivkin JW ( 2006) When exploration backfires: unintended consequences of multilevel organizational search. Academy of Management Journal49(4): 779-96.
121.
Simms JR ( 2003) Living systems science methodology for managing complexity and change. Systems Research and Behavioral Science20(5): 401-8.
122.
Smith ACT, Humphries CE ( 2004) Complexity theory as a practical management tool: a critical evaluation. Organization Management Journal1(2): 91-106.
123.
Solow D., Szmerekovsky JG ( 2006) The role of leadership: what management science can give back to the study of complex systems. Emergence: Complexity and Organization8(4): 52-60.
124.
Sorenson OJ ( 2000) Letting the market work for you: an evolutionary perspective on product strategy. Strategic Management Journal21(5): 577-92.
125.
Sotolongo P. ( 2007) Complexity, society and everyday life. In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 119-132.
126.
Stacey RD ( 1992) Managing the Unknowable. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
127.
Stacey RD ( 1995) The science of complexity: an alternative perspective for strategic change processes. Strategic Management Journal16(6): 477-95.
128.
Stacey RD ( 1996) Complexity and Creativity in Organizations. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler.
129.
Stacey RD ( 2000) Strategic Management and Organizational Dynamics: The Challenge of Complexity. New York: Prentice Hall.
130.
Stacey RD ( 2001) Complex Response Processes in Organizations: Learning and Knowledge Creation. London: Routledge.
131.
Stacey RDGriffin D., Shaw P. ( 2000) Complexity and Management: Fad or Radical Challenge to Systems Thinking?London: Routledge .
132.
Stewart M. ( 2001) The Co-Evolving Organization. Rutland : Decomplexity Associates. Available at: http://www.decomplexity.com/Coevolving%20Organization%20US.pdf (accessed 27 August 2001).
133.
Sundarasaradula D., Hasan H., Walker DS, Tobias AM ( 2005) Self-organization, evolutionary and revolutionary change in organizations. Strategic Change14(7): 367-80.
134.
Surie G., Hazy JK ( 2006) Generative leadership: nurturing innovation in complex systems. Emergence: Complexity and Organization8(4): 13-26.
135.
Swieringa J., Wierdsma AFM ( 1992) Becoming a Learning Organization: Beyond the Learning Curve. Wokingham: Addison-Wesley .
136.
Tetenbaum T. ( 1998) Shifting paradigms: from Newton to chaos. Organizational Dynamics26(4): 21-32.
137.
Ulanowicz RE ( 2007) Ecology, a dialog between the quick and the dead . In: Capra F, Juarerro A, Sotolongo P, van Uden J (eds) Reframing Complexity: Perspectives from North and South. Mansfield, MA: ISCE Publishing, 27-46.
138.
Van Eijnatten FM, Van Galen M. ( 2002) Chaos, dialogue and the dolphins strategy. Journal of Organizational Change Management15(4): 391-401.
139.
Waldrop MM ( 1992) Complexity: The Emerging Science at the Edge of Order and Chaos. Harmondsworth: Penguin .
140.
Wheatley M. ( 1999) Leadership and the New Science: Discovering Order in a Chaotic World (second edition). San Francisco, CA : Berrett-Koehler.
141.
Willis R. ( 2004) A complexity and Darwinian approach to management with failure avoidance as the key tool. In: Assiante P, Passiante G (eds) Complexity Theory and the Management of Networks. London : Imperial College Press, 74-88.
