When plastic surgeons meet with new cosmetic surgery clients, they routinely try to
get patients to `sign up' for elective surgery without forcing or pressuring them to
do it. On rare occasions, they face a prospective client who, in the course of
interaction, signals possible legal or medical risks, thereby calling on the surgeon
to screen the client more vigilantly to determine whether embarking on cosmetic
surgery will be reasonable. Grounded against nine-month field work at a cosmetic
surgery center, combined with 30+ hours of videotaped data of initial consultations,
this article investigates a unique situation in which a 74-year-old woman seeking
rhinoplasty and rhytidectomy is perceived as a difficult customer. Why this moment
was interpreted and emerged as difficult is the analytic focus of the article. Using
action-implicative discourse analysis (e.g. Tracy, 2001, 2005), the analysis
describes five communication challenges the plastic surgeon faced in the course of
the 60-minute encounter. In the article's conclusion, I reflect on what seems to be
a central issue for plastic surgeons: to act as gatekeepers of a fully elective and
pricy surgery in a service-oriented business.
American Society of Plastic Surgeons
(2006 ) `2005 Cosmetic Surgery Trends', available
online at:
[http://www.plasticsurgery.org/public_education/2005Statistics.cfm ],
accessed 30 July 2006.
2.
Askegaard, S.
,
Gertsen, M.C.
and
Langer, R.
(2002) `
The Body Consumed: Reflexivity and Cosmetic Surgery'
, Psychology & Marketing19:
793—812
.
3.
Atkinson, J.M.
and
Heritage, J.
(eds) (1984) Structures of Social Action: Studiesin
Conversation Analysis.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
4.
Blum, V.L.
(2003) Flesh Wounds: The Culture of Cosmetic Surgery.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
5.
Bordo, S.
(1993) Unbearable Weight: Feminism, Western Culture, and the
Body.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
6.
Bordo, S.
(1997) Twilight Zones: The Hidden Life of Cultural Images
from Plato to O.J.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
7.
Brooks, A.
(2004) `“
Under the Knife and Proud of It”: An Analysis of the
Normalization of Cosmetic Surgery'
, Critical Sociology30:
207—40
.
8.
Brown, P.
and
Levinson, S.C.
(1987) Universals in Language Usage: Politeness
Phenomena .
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
9.
Cegala, D.J.
(2005) `The First Three Minutes', in
E.B. Ray
(ed.) Health Communication in Practice: A Case Study Approach, pp.
3—10.
Mahwah, NJ : Erlbaum
.
10.
Clayman, S.E.
(1992) `Footing in the Achievement of Neutrality: The Case of
News-Interview Discourse', in
P. Drew
and
J. Heritage
(eds) Talk at Work: Interaction in Institutional Settings, pp.
163—98.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
11.
Costello, B.A.
and
Roberts, F.
(2001) `
Medical Recommendations as Joint Social Practice'
, Health Communication13:
241—60
.
12.
Craig, R.T.
(1989) `Communication as a Practical Discipline', in
B. Dervin
,
L. Grossberg
and
B.J. O'Keefe
(eds) Rethinking Communication: Vol. 1. Paradigm Issues, pp.
97—122.
Newbury Park, CA: Sage
.
13.
Craig, R.T.
and
Tracy, K.
(1995) `
Grounded Practical Theory: The Case of Intellectual Discussion'
, Communication Theory5:
248—72
.
14.
Davidson, J.
(1984) `Subsequent Versions of Invitations, Offers, Requests,
and Proposals Dealing with Potential or Actual Rejection', in
J.M. Atkinson
and
J. Heritage
(eds) Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation
Analysis, pp. 102—28.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
15.
Diagnostic Statistical Manual IV (4th edn) (1994)
Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association
.
16.
Drew, P.
(1984) `Speakers' Reportings in Invitation Sequences',
in
J.M. Atkinson
and
J. Heritage
(eds) Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation
Analysis, pp. 129—51.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
17.
du Pré, A.
(2002) `
Accomplishing the Impossible: Talking about Body and Soul and Mind during a
Medical Visit'
, Health Communication14:
1—21
.
18.
Edwards, D.
(2000) `
Extreme Case Formulations: Softeners, Investment, and Doing Nonliteral
', Research on Language and Social Interaction33:
347—73
.
19.
Frankel, R.
(1990)`
Talkingin Interviews: A Dispreference for Patient-Initiated Encounters
', in G. Psathas (ed.) Interaction Competence, pp.
231—62
.
Washington, DC: University Press of America
.
20.
Frankel, R.
(1995) `Some Answers about Questions in Clinical
Interviews ', in
G.H. Morris
and
R.J. Chenail
(eds) The Talk of the Clinic: Explorations in the Analysis of Medical
and Therapeutic discourse, pp. 233—58.
Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
21.
Gill, L.
(2005) `
After the Nip and Tuck: There's an Emotional Fallout with Cosmetic Surgery
That Few Patients — or Their Families — Expect
', Los Angeles Times, 10 October, p.
F1
.
22.
Gill, V.T.
(2005) `
Patient “Demand” for Medical Interventions: Exerting
Pressure For an Offer in a Primary Care Clinic
', Research on Language and Social Interaction38:
451—79
.
23.
Gill, V.T.
,
Halkowski, T.
and
Roberts, F.
(2001) `
Accomplishing a Request Without Making One: A Single Case Analysis of a
Primary Care Visit'
, Text21:
55—82
.
24.
Gilman, S.L.
(1999) Making the Body Beautiful: A Cultural History of
Aesthetic Surgery.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press
.
25.
Goffman, E.
(1959)
The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life
.
New York: Doubleday. Goodwin, C
. ( 1994) `
Professional Vision
', American Anthropologist96:
606—33
.
26.
Goodwin, C.
(1995) `
Seeing in Depth'
, Social Studies of Science25:
237—74
.
27.
Goodwin, C.
(2000a) `
Action and Embodiment within Situated Human Interaction
', Journal of Pragmatics32:
1489—522
.
28.
Goodwin, C.
(2000b) `Practices of Seeing: Visual Analysis: An
Ethnomethodological Approach', in
T. Van Leeuwen
and
C. Jewitt
(eds) Handbook of Visual Analysis , pp.
157—82.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
29.
Goodwin. C.
(2000c) `
Vision
', Journal of Linguistic Anthropology9:
267—70
.
30.
Goodwin, C.
(2000d) `
Vision and Inscription in Practice
', Mind, Culture and Activity7:
1—3
.
31.
Goodwin, C.
(2000e) `
Practices of Color Classification
', Mind, Culture and Activity7:
19—36
.
32.
Goodwin, C.
(2003) `Pointing as Situated Practice', in
S. Kita
(ed.) Pointing: Where Language, Culture, and Cognition Meet, pp.
217—42.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
33.
Heath, C.
(1981) `The Opening Sequence in Doctor—Patient
Interaction ', in
P. Atkinson
and
C. Heath
(eds) Medical Work: Realities and Routines, pp.
71—90.
Aldershot:Gower
.
34.
Heath, C.
(1986) Body Movement and Speech in Medical Interaction
.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
35.
Heath, C.
(2002) `
Demonstrative Suffering: The Gestural (Re)embodiment of Symptoms
', Journal of Communication52:
597—616
.
36.
Hobbs, P.
(2003) `
The Use of Evidentiality in Physicians' Progress Notes'
, Discourse Studies5:
451—79
.
37.
Jordan, J.W.
(2004) `
The Rhetorical Limits of the “Plastic Body
”', Quarterly Journal of Speech90:
327—58
.
38.
Kitzinger, C.
and
Frith, H.
(1999) `
Just Say No? The Use of Conversation Analysis in Developing a Feminist
Perspective on Sexual Refusal
', Discourse & Society10:
293—316
.
39.
LeBaron, C.D.
(2005) `
Considering the Social and Material Surround: Toward Microethnographic
Understandings of Nonverbal Communication
', in V.L. Manusov (ed.) The Sourcebook of Nonverbal Measures: Going
Beyond Words, pp.
493—506
.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
40.
Mattson, M.
and
Roberts, F.
(2001) `
Overcoming Truth Telling as an Obstacle to Initiating Safer Sex: Clients
and Health Practitioners Planning Deception During HIV Test Counseling'
, Health Communication13:
343—62
.
41.
Maynard, D.W.
(2003) Bad News, Good News: Conversational Order in Everyday
Talk and Clinical Settings.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
42.
Mechanic, D.
and
Schlesinger, M.
(1996) `
The Impact of Managed Care on Patients' Trust in Medical Care and Their Physicians
', Journal of the American Medical Association275:
1693—7
.
43.
Mirivel, J.C.
(in press) `
The Physical Examination in Cosmetic Surgery: Communication Strategies to
Promote the Desirability of Surgery
', Health Communication.
44.
Ochs, E.
(1993) `
Constructing Social Identity: A Language Socialization Perspective'
, Research on Language and Social Interaction26:
287—306
.
45.
Peräkylä, A.
(1998) `
Authority and Accountability: The Delivery of Diagnosis in Primary Health Care'
, Social Psychology Quarterly61:
301—20
.
46.
Platt, F.W.
(1995) Conversation Repair: Case Studies in
Doctor—Patient Communication.
Boston, MA: Little, Brown
.
47.
Pomerantz, A.
(1980) `
Telling My Side: “Limited Access” as a
“Fishing” Device
', Sociological Inquiry50:
186—98
.
48.
Pomerantz, A.
(1984a) `Agreeing and Disagreeing With Assessments: Some
Features of Preferred/Dispreferred Turn Shapes', in
J.M. Atkinson
and
J. Heritage
(eds) Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation
Analysis , pp. 57—101.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
49.
Pomerantz, A.
(1984b) `Pursuing a Response', in
J.M. Atkinson
and
J. Heritage
(eds) Structures of Social Action: Studies in Conversation
Analysis , pp. 152—64.
New York: Cambridge University Press
.
50.
Pomerantz, A.
(1986) `
Extreme Case Formulations: A Way of Legitimizing Claims'
, Human Studies9:
219—29
.
51.
Robinson, J.D.
(1998) `
Getting Down to Business: Talk, Gaze and Body Orientation During Openings
of Doctor—Patient Consultations
', Human Communication Research25:
97—123
.
52.
Robinson, J.D.
(2003) `
An Interactional Structure of Medical Activities during Acute Visits and
Its Implications for Patients' Participation
', Health Communication15:
27—59
.
53.
Stivers, T.
(2002a) `
Participating in Decisions About Treatment: Overt Parent Pressure for
Antibiotic Medication in Pediatric Encounters
', Social Science & Medicine54:
1111—30
.
54.
Stivers, T.
(2002b) `
Presenting the Problem in Pediatric Encounters: “Symptoms
Only” Versus “Candidate Diagnosis” Presentations
', Health Communication14:
299—338
.
55.
Stivers, T.
(2005) `
Parent Resistance to Physicians' Treatment Recommendations: One Resource
for Initiating a Negotiation of the Treatment Decision'
, Health Communication18:
41—74
.
56.
Streeck, J.
(1993) `
Gesture as Communication I: Its Coordination with Gaze and Speech
', Communication Monographs60:
275—99
.
57.
Streeck, J.
and
Mehus, S.
(2005) `Microethnography: The Study of Practices', in
K.L. Fitch
and
R.E. Sanders
(eds) Handbook of Language and Social Interaction , pp.
381—404.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
58.
Street, R.L., Jr
(2003) `Communication in Medical Encounters: An Ecological
Perspective', in
T.L. Thompson
,
A.M. Dorsey
,
K.I. Miller
and
R. Parrot
(eds) Handbook of Health Communication, pp.
63—89.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
.
59.
ten Have, P.
(1991)`
Talk and Institution: A Reconsideration of the
“Asymmetry” of Doctor— Patient Interaction
', in D. Boden and D.H. Zimmerman (eds)
Talk and Social Structure
: Studies in Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis, pp.
138—63
.
Berkeley: University of California Press
.
60.
Thompson, T.L.
,
Dorsey, A.M.
,
Miller, K.I.
and
Parrott, R.
(eds) (2003) Handbook of Health Communication.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
61.
Tracy, K.
(1995) `
Action-Implicative Discourse Analysis'
, Journal of Language and Social Psychology14:
195—215
.
62.
Tracy, K.
(2001) `Discourse Analysis in Communication', in
D. Schiffrin
,
D. Tannen
and
H. Hamilton
(eds) Handbook of Discourse Analysis, pp.
725—49.
Malden, MA : Blackwell
.
63.
Tracy, K.
(2002) Everyday Talk: Building and Reflecting
Identities .
New York: Guilford Press
.
64.
Tracy, K.
(2005) `Reconstructing Communicative Practices:
Action-Implicative Discourse Analysis',in
K.L. Fitch
and
R.E. Sanders
(eds) Handbook of Language and Social Interaction, pp.
301—19.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
65.
Tracy, K.
and
Mirivel, J.C.
(in press) `Discourse Analysis: The Practice and Practical Value of
Taping, Transcribing, and Analyzing', in
L.R. Frey
and
K.N. Cissna
(eds) Handbook of Applied Communication.
Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum
.
66.
Vanderford, M.L.
,
Stein, T.
,
Sheeler, R.
and
Skochelak, S.
(2001)`
Communication Challenges for Experienced Clinicians: Topics for an Advanced
Communication Curriculum
', Health Communication13:
261—84
.
67.
West, C.
(1984) Routine Complications: Troubles with Talk between
Doctors and Patients.
Bloomington: Indiana University Press
.
68.
Wetherell, M.
(1998) `
Positioning and Interpretative Repertoires: Conversation Analysis and
Post-Structuralism in Dialogue'
, Discourse & Society9:
387—412
.
69.
Willems, D.L.
(2001) `
Balancing Rationalities: Gatekeeping in Health Care', Journal of MedicalEthics27:
25—9
.
