Some active video games have been found to promote physical activity adherence because of enjoyment. However, many active games are exercise themed, which may interfere with the distracting properties that make game-based exercise more enjoyable than traditional exercise. This study compared exercise-themed and game-themed active games to investigate differences in energy expenditure and enjoyment.
Method:
Young adults (N = 100, 50 female, 55 overweight, aged 18–35 years) played two of four Wii Fit games (one aerobic game and one balance game per person) for 10 min each. Of the two aerobic games, one was exercise themed (jogging) and the other was game themed (hula hooping). Both balance games were game themed. Energy expenditure and enjoyment were measured.
Results:
After adjustment for gender and weight, aerobic games produced 2.70 kcal/kg−1/h−1 (95% confidence interval 2.41, 3.00) greater energy expenditure than balance games (p < .001), but balance games were more enjoyable (p < .001). In aerobic games, jogging produced greater energy expenditure than hula hooping in normal-weight and male participants (p < .001); in overweight and female participants, no differences were found (p > .17). Hula hooping was enjoyed more than jogging (p = .008). Enjoyment predicted energy expenditure in aerobic games (B = 0.767, p = .010).
Conclusions:
Aerobic games produced greater energy expenditure but lower enjoyment than balance games, and a game-themed aerobic game was found more enjoyable than an exercise-themed aerobic game. Integrating more strenuous activity into entertaining games instead of games that simply simulate exercise may be a fruitful avenue for active game development.
DunstanDWBarrELHealyGNSalmonJShawJEBalkauBMaglianoDJCameronAJZimmetPZOwenN. Television viewing time and mortality: The Australian Diabetes, Obesity and Lifestyle Study (AusDiab). Circulation.2010;121 (3): 384–91.
3.
DunstanDWSalmonJOwenNArmstrongTZimmetPZWelbornTACameronAJDwyerTJolleyDShawJE; AusDiab Steering Committee. Associations of TV viewing and physical activity with the metabolic syndrome in Australian adults. Diabetologia.2005;48 (11): 2254–61.
GravesLStrattonGRidgersNDCableNT. Comparison of energy expenditure in adolescents when playing new generation and sedentary computer games: Cross sectional study. BMJ.2007;335 (7633): 1282–4.
6.
GrafDLPrattLVHesterCNShortKR. Playing active video games increases energy expenditure in children. Pediatrics.2009;124 (2): 534–40.
7.
MiyachiMYamamotoKOhkawaraKTanakaS. METs in adults while playing active video games: A metabolic chamber study. Med Sci Sports Exerc.2010;42 (6): 1149–53.
8.
EpsteinLHRoemmichJNSaadFGHandleyEA. The value of sedentary alternatives influences child physical activity choice. Int J Behav Med.2004;11 (4): 236–42.
9.
RyanRMDeciEL. Intrinsic and extrinsic motivations: Classic definitions and new directions. Contemp Educ Psychol.2000;25 (1): 54–67.
10.
HoffmanBNadelsonL. Motivational engagement and video gaming: A mixed methods study. Educ Technol Res Dev.2010;58 (3): 245–70.
11.
RyanRMRigbyCSPrzybylskiA. The motivational pull of video games: A self-determination theory approach. Motiv Emot.2006;30 (4): 347–63.
12.
PrzybylskiAKRyanRMRigbyCS. The motivating role of violence in video games. Pers Soc Psychol Bull.2009;35 (2): 243–59.
13.
RhodesREFialaBConnerM. A review and meta-analysis of affective judgments and physical activity in adult populations. Ann Behav Med.2009;38 (3): 180–204.
14.
AnnesiJJMazasJ. Effects of virtual reality-enhanced exercise equipment on adherence and exercise-induced feeling states. Percept Mot Skills.1997;85 (3 Pt 1): 835–44.
15.
WarburtonDEBredinSSHoritaLTZbogarDScottJMEschBTRhodesRE. The health benefits of interactive video game exercise. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab.2007;32 (4): 655–63.
16.
WarburtonDESarkanyDJohnsonMRhodesREWhitfordWEschBTScottJMWongSCBredinSS. Metabolic requirements of interactive video game cycling. Med Sci Sports Exerc.2009;41 (4): 920–6.
17.
IjsselsteijnWAde KortYAWesterinkJde JagerMBonantsR. Virtual fitness: Stimulating exercise behavior through media technology. Presence.2006;15 (6): 688–98.
18.
RhodesREWarburtonDEBredinSS. Predicting the effect of interactive video bikes on exercise adherence: An efficacy trial. Psychol Health Med.2009;14 (6): 631–40.
19.
VossenDP. The nature and classification of games. Avante.2004;10 (1): 53–68.
20.
De BourdeaudhuijICrombezGDeforcheBVinaimontFDebodePBouckaertJ. Effects of distraction on treadmill running time in severely obese children and adolescents. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord.2002;26 (8): 1023–9.
21.
LombardMDittonT. At the heart of it all: The concept of presence. J Comp Mediat Comm.1997;3 (2): 1–22.
22.
SkalskiPLangeRTamboriniR. Mapping the way to fun: The effect of video game interfaces on presence and enjoyment. Proceedings of the Ninth Annual International Workshop on Presence, Cleveland, OH, 2006.
23.
Bianchi-BerthouzeNKimWWPatelD. Does body movement engage you more in digital game play? And why?. Proc ACII.2007;4738: 102–13.
24.
GravesLERidgersNDWilliamsKStrattonGAtkinsonGCableNT. The physiological cost and enjoyment of Wii Fit in adolescents, young adults, and older adults. J Phys Act Health.2010;7 (3): 393–401.
25.
LyonsEJTateDFWardDSBowlingJMRibislKMKalyararamanS. Energy expenditure and enjoyment during video game play: Differences by game type. Med Sci Sports Exerc.2011;43 (10): 1987–93.
26.
Gordon-LarsenPNelsonMCPopkinBM. Longitudinal physical activity and sedentary behavior trends: Adolescence to adulthood. Am J Prev Med.2004;27 (4): 277–83.
27.
ClarkePO'MalleyPMJohnstonLDSchulenbergJE. Social disparities in BMI trajectories across adulthood by gender, race/ethnicity and lifetime socio-economic position: 1986–2004. Int J Epidemiol.2009;38 (2): 499–509.
28.
TruesdaleKPStevensJLewisCESchreinerPJLoriaCMCaiJ. Changes in risk factors for cardiovascular disease by baseline weight status in young adults who maintain or gain weight over 15 years: The CARDIA study. Int J Obes (Lond).2006;30 (9): 1397–407.
29.
CooperJAWatrasACO'BrienMJLukeADobratzJREarthmanCPSchoellerDA. Assessing validity and reliability of resting metabolic rate in six gas analysis systems. J Am Diet Assoc.2009;109 (1): 128–32.
30.
WahrlichVAnjosLAGoingSBLohmanTG. Validation of the VO2000 calorimeter for measuring resting metabolic rate. Clin Nutr.2006;25 (4): 687–92.
31.
McAuleyEDuncanTTammenVV. Psychometric properties of the Intrinsic Motivation Inventory in a competitive sport setting: A confirmatory factor analysis. Res Q Exerc Sport.1989;60 (1): 48–58.
32.
SlaterM. Measuring presence: A response to the Witmer and Singer Presence Questionnaire. Presence.1999;8 (5): 560–5.
33.
PateRRO'NeillJRLobeloF. The evolving definition of “sedentary.” Exerc Sport Sci Rev. Oct2008;36 (4): 173–8.
34.
UnnithanVBHouserWFernhallB. Evaluation of the energy cost of playing a dance simulation video game in overweight and non-overweight children and adolescents. Int J Sports Med.2006;27 (10): 804–9.
35.
TanBAzizARChuaKTehKC. Aerobic demands of the dance simulation game. Int J Sports Med.2002;23 (2): 125–9.
36.
Lanningham-FosterLJensenTBFosterRCRedmondABWalkerBAHeinzDLevineJA. Energy expenditure of sedentary screen time compared with active screen time for children. Pediatrics.2006;118 (6): e1831–5.
37.
StrakerLAbbottR. Effect of screen-based media on energy expenditure and heart rate in 9- to 12-year-old children. Pediatr Exerc Sci.2007;19 (4): 459–71.
38.
Lanningham-FosterLFosterRCMcCradySKJensenTBMitreNLevineJA. Activity-promoting video games and increased energy expenditure. J Pediatr.2009;154 (6): 819–23.
39.
ByrneNMHillsAPHunterGRWeinsierRLSchutzY. Metabolic equivalent: One size does not fit all. J Appl Physiol.2005;99 (3): 1112–9.
40.
BaileyBWMcInnisK. Energy cost of exergaming: A comparison of the energy cost of 6 forms of exergaming. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.2011;165 (7): 597–602.
41.
HarrellJSMcMurrayRGBaggettCDPennellMLPearcePFBangdiwalaSI. Energy costs of physical activities in children and adolescents. Med Sci Sports Exerc.2005;37 (2): 329–36.
