A comparison of two types of electrical stimulation of the quadriceps in the treatment of patellofemoral pain syndrome. A pilot study

Abstract

Objective: To compare a commercially available electrical muscle stimulation regime with a new form of stimulation for the rehabilitation of the quadriceps in patients with patellofemoral pain syndrome.

Setting: A research facility within a teaching hospital.

Methods: Sixteen patients (four men, 12 women) with patellofemoral pain, demonstrable quadriceps atrophy, but normal gait parameters were randomly allocated to one of two treatment groups. One group received a sequential mixed frequency stimulation pattern from a standard device. The other group received a new form of stimulation from an experimental stimulation device that contained simultaneous mixed frequency components.

Outcome measures: Isometric and isokinetic extension torque, muscle fatigue rate, pain, functional questionnaire, step test, knee flexion, and quadriceps cross-sectional area.

Results: These showed significant improvements for both groups after treatment (p < 0.05) in all outcome measures except flexion and fatigue rates, but no significant differences between the two stimulation regimes (p > 0.05).

Conclusion: Both stimulators performed similarly on patients with patellofemoral pain giving significant improvements for all patients for muscle strength, pain, self-reporting function and step testing. There were no significant differences between the two types of stimulation.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Morrissey MC , Brewster CE , Shields CL , Brown M . The effects of electrical stimulation on the quadriceps during post operative knee immobilisation. Am J Sports Med 1985; 13: 40–45.

Nitz AJ , Dobner JJ . High intensity electrical stimulation effect on thigh musculature during immobilisation following knee sprain. Phys Ther 1987; 67: 219–222.

Sisk TD , Stralka SW , Deering MB , Griffin JW . Effect of electrical stimulation on quadriceps strength after reconstructive surgery of the ACL. Am J Sports Med 1987; 15: 215–219.

Delitto A , Rose S , McKowen JM , Lehman RC , Thomas JA , Shively RA . Electrical stimulation versus voluntary exercise in strengthening thigh musculature after anterior cruciate ligament surgery. Phys Ther 1988; 68: 660–663.

Snyder-Mackler L , Ladin Z , Schepsis AA , Young JC . Electrical stimulation of the thigh muscles after reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. J Bone Joint Surg (Am) 1991; 73(A): 1025–1036.

Vinge O , Edvardsen L , Jensen F , Jensen FG , Wernerman J , Kehlet H . Effect of transcutaneous electrical muscle stimulation on post operative muscle mass and protein synthesis. Br J Surg 1996; 83: 360–363.

Wigerstad-Lossing I , Grimby G , Jonsson T , Morelli B , Peterson L , Renström P . Effects of electrical muscle stimulation combined with voluntary contractions after knee ligament surgery. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1988; 20: 93–98.

Callaghan MJ , Oldham JA . A critical review of electrical stimulation of the quadriceps muscles. Crit Rev Phys Rehabil Med 1997; 9: 301–314.

Callaghan MJ , Oldham JA . The role of quadriceps exercise in the treatment of patellofemoral pain. Sports Med 1996; 21: 384–391.

10.

Dye SF , Vaupel GL . The pathophysiology of patellofemoral pain. Sports Med Arthrosc Rev 1994; 2: 203–210.

11.

Laughman RK , Youdas JW , Garrett TR , Chao EY . Strength changes in the normal quadriceps femoris as a result of electrical stimulation. Phys Ther 1983; 63: 494–499.

12.

Lake DA . Neuromuscular electrical stimulation: an overview and its application in the treatment of sports injuries. Sports Med 1992; 13: 320–336.

13.

Jarvis JC . Power production and working capacity of rabbit tibialis anterior muscles after chronic electrical stimulation at 10 Hz. J Physiol 1993; 470: 157-157.

14.

Selkowitz DM . Improvement in isometric strength of the quadriceps femoris muscle after training with electrical stimulation. Phys Ther 1985; 65: 186–196.

15.

Callaghan MJ , Baltzopoulos V . Gait analysis in patients with anterior knee pain. Clin Biomech 1994; 9: 79–84.

16.

Wilk KE , Davies GJ , Mangine RE , Malone TR . Patellofemoral disorders: a classification system and clinical guidelines for non operative rehabilitation. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1998; 28: 307–322.

17.

Callaghan MJ , McCarthy C , Al-Omar A , Oldham JA . The reproducibility of multi joint isokinetic and isometric assessments in a healthy and patient population. Clin Biomech 2000; 15: 678–683.

18.

Steinkamp LA , Dillingham MF , Markel MD , Hill JA , Kaufman KR . Biomechanical considerations in patellofemoral joint rehabilitation. Am J Sports Med 1993; 21: 438–444.

19.

Steine HA , Brosky T , Reinking MF , Nyland J , Mason MB . A comparison of closed kinetic chain and isokinetic joint isolation exercise in patients with patellofemoral pain. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1996; 24: 136–141.

20.

Belanger AY , McComas AJ . Extent of motor unit activity during effort. J Appl Physiol 1981; 51: 1131–1135.

21.

Basmajian JV . Muscles alive. Their function revealed by electromyography. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins, 1987.

22.

Roy SH , Emley M , Buijs RJC . Spectral electromyographic assessment of back muscles in patients with low back pain undergoing rehabilitation. Spine 1995; 20: 38–48.

23.

Kujala UM , Jaakkola LH , Koskinen SK , Taimela S , Hurme M , Nelimarkka O . Scoring of patellofemoral problems. Arthroscopy 1993; 9: 159–163.

24.

Scott J , Huskisson EC . Graphic representation of pain. Pain 1976; 2: 175–184.

25.

Oldham JA , Stanley JK . Rehabilitation of atrophied muscle in the arthritic hand: a comparison of two methods of electrical stimulation. J Hand Surg 1989; 14: 294–298.

26.

Rutherford OM , Jones DA . Contractile properties and fatigability of the human adductor pollicis and first dorsal interosseous: a comparison of the effects of two chronic stimulation patterns. J Neurol Sci 1988; 85: 319–331.

27.

Kwende MMN , Jarvis JC , Salmons S . The input output relations of skeletal muscle. Proc R Soc Lond 1995; 261: 193–210.

28.

Sharp RL . Effects of electrical simulation on subjects with patellofemoral pain syndrome. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1995; 27: 255-255.

29.

Werner S , Arvidsson H , Arvidsson I , Eriksson E . Electrical stimulation of vastus medialis and stretching of lateral thigh muscles in patients with patello-femoral symptoms. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthroscopy 1993; 1: 85–92.

30.

Howe TE. Evaluation of muscle performance measures used to assess electrotherapeutic rehabilitation of the quadriceps. PhD thesis, University of Manchester, 1994.

31.

Kasman GS , Cram JR , Wolf SL . Knee dysfunction. In: Kasman GS , Cram JR , Wolf SL eds. Clinical applications in surface electromyography. Gaithersburg: Aspen Publishers, 1998: 363–389.

32.

Grabiner MD , Koh TJ , Miller JP . Fatigue rates of vastus medialis oblique and vastus lateralis during static and dynamic knee extension. J Orthop Res 1991; 9: 391–397.

33.

Vaatainen U , Nurmi H , Airaksinen O . Muscle spectral analysis in anterior knee pain. Hung Rev Sports Med 1991; 32: 281–285.

34.

Grelsamer RP , McConnell J . The patella. A team approach. Gaithersburg: Aspen Publishers, 1998: 137–164.

35.

Shelton GL , Thigpen LK . Rehabilitation of patellofemoral dysfunction: a review of the literature. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1991; 14: 243–249.

36.

Woodall W , Welsh J . A biomechanical basis for rehabilitation programs involving the patellofemoral joint. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 1990; 11: 535–542.