Despite an abundance of theoretical literature on virtue ethics in nursing and health care, very little research has been carried out to support or refute the claims made. One such claim is that ethical nursing is what happens when a good nurse does the right thing. The purpose of this descriptive, qualitative study was therefore to examine nurses’ perceptions of what it means to be a good nurse and to do the right thing. Fifty-three nurses responded to two open-ended questions: (1) a good nurse is one who...; and (2) how does a nurse go about doing the right thing? Three hundred and thirty-one data units were analysed using qualitative content analysis. Seven categories emerged: personal characteristics, professional characteristics, patient centredness, advocacy, competence, critical thinking and patient care. Participants viewed ethical nursing as a complex endeavour in which a variety of decision-making frameworks are used. Consistent with virtue ethics, high value was placed on both intuitive and analytical personal attributes that nurses bring into nursing by virtue of the persons they are. Further investigation is needed to determine just who the ‘good nurse’ is, and the nursing practice and education implications associated with this concept.
Kelly B.The ‘real world’ of hospital nursing practice as perceived by nursing undergraduates . J Prof Nurs1993; 9: 27-33 .
2.
Kohlberg L.The philosophy of moral development: moral stages and the idea of justice. San Francisco, CA: Harper and Row , 1981.
3.
Kohlberg LBG.Moral stages: a current formulation and a response to critics. New York: Karger , 1983.
4.
Crisham P.Measuring moral judgment in nursing dilemmas . Nurs Res1981; 30: 104-110 .
5.
Felton GM , Parsons MA.The impact of nursing education on ethical moral decision making . J Nurs Educ1987; 26: 7-11 .
6.
Gaul A.The effect of a course in nursing ethics on the relationship between ethical choice and ethical action in baccalaureate nursing students . J Nurs Educ1987; 26: 113-117 .
7.
Hilbert G.Moral development and unethical behavior among nursing students . J Prof Nurs1988; 4: 163-167 .
8.
Ketefian S.Critical thinking, educational preparation, and development of moral judgment among selected groups of practicing nurses . Nurs Res1981; 30: 98-103 .
9.
Ketefian S.Moral reasoning and moral behavior among selected groups of practicing nurses . Nurs Res1981; 30: 171-176 .
10.
Murphy CP.Moral reasoning in a selected group of nursing practitioners. In: Ketefian S ed. Perspectives on nursing leadership. New York: Teacher College Press , 1981: 45-75.
11.
Bouhmama D.Assessment of Kohlberg’s stages of moral development in two cultures . J Moral Educ1984; 13: 124-132 .
12.
Ernsberger DJ , Manaster GJ.Moral development, intrinsic or extrinsic religious orientation and denominational teaching . Genet Psychol Monogr1981; 104: 23-41 .
13.
Holstein CB.Irreversible, stepwise sequence in the development of moral judgment: a longitudinal study of males and females . Child Dev1976; 47(4): 51-61 .
14.
Rest J.Longitudinal study of Defining Issues Test of moral judgment: a strategy for analyzing developmental change . Dev Psychol1975; 11: 738-748 .
15.
Gilligan C.In a different voice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press , 1982.
16.
Pinch WJ.Feminine attributes in a masculine world . Nurs Outlook1981; 29: 596-599 .
17.
Cooper MC.Gilligan’s different voice: a perspective for nursing . J Prof Nurs1989; 5: 10-16 .
18.
Huggins EA , Scalzi CC.Limitations and alternatives: ethical practice theory in nursing . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1988; 10(4): 43-47 .
19.
Nokes KM.Rethinking moral reasoning theory . Image J Nurs Schol1989; 21: 172-175 .
Millette B.Using Gilligan’s framework to analyze nurses’ stories of moral choices . West J Nurs Res1994; 16: 660-674 .
22.
Chally PS.Nursing research: moral decision making by nurses . Plast Surg Nurs1995; 15: 120-124 .
23.
Dierckx de Casterlé B , Janssen PJ , Grypdonck M.The relationship between education and ethical behavior of nursing students . West J Nurs Res1996; 18: 330-350 .
24.
Dierckx de Casterlé B , Grypdonck M , Vuylsteke-Wauters M , Janssen PJ.Nursing students’ responses to ethical dilemmas in nursing practice . Nurs Ethics1997; 4: 12-28 .
25.
Dierckx de Casterlé B , Roelens A , Gastmans C.An adjusted version of Kohlberg’s moral theory: discussion of its validity for research in nursing ethics . J Adv Nurs1998; 27: 829-835 .
26.
Lipp A.An enquiry into a combined approach for nursing ethics . Nurs Ethics1998; 5: 122-138 .
27.
Gillon R.Deceit, principles and philosophical medical ethics . J Med Ethics1990; 16: 59-60 .
28.
Gauthier CC.Teaching the virtues: justifications and recommendations . Camb Q Healthc Ethics1997; 6: 339-346 .
29.
Loewy EH.Developing habits and knowing what habits to develop: a look at the role of virtue in ethics . Camb Q Healthc Ethics1997; 6: 347-355 .
MacIntyre A.After virtue. Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press , 1984.
32.
Pellegrino ED.Toward a virtue-based normative ethics for the health professions . Kennedy Inst Ethics J1995; 5: 253-277 .
33.
Loewy EH.The role of suffering and community in clinical ethics . J Clin Ethics1991; 2: 83-89 .
34.
Cassell EJ.The changing concept of the ideal physician . Daedalus1986; 115: 185-208 .
35.
Kass L.Neither for love nor money: why doctors must not kill . Public Interest1989; 94: 25-46 .
36.
Knight JA.Moral growth in medical students . Theor Med1995; 16: 265-280 .
37.
May WF.The medical covenant: an ethics of obligation or virtue? In: Fulford K , Soskice GGJ eds. Medicine and moral reasoning. New York: Cambridge University Press , 1994: 29-44.
38.
Meilaender G , Buchanan A , Brock DW , Sass HM , Sokolowski R.Are there virtues inherent in a profession? In: Pellegrino E , Langan RVJ eds. Ethics, trust and the professions: philosophical and cultural aspects. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press , 1991: 139-158.
39.
Pellegrino ED.Patient and physician autonomy: conflicting rights and obligations in the physician-patient relationship . J Contemp Health Law Policy1994; 10: 47-68 .
40.
Truog RD.Principles, rules and actions: a response to Devettere. In: Grodin MA ed. Meta medical ethics. Dordrecht: Kluwer , 1995: 49-59.
41.
Baly ME.Florence Nightingale and the nursing legacy. London: Croom Helm , 1986.
42.
Sellman D.The virtues in the moral education of nurses: Florence Nightingale revisited . Nurs Ethics1997; 4: 3-11 .
43.
Davis AJ.Ethical similarities internationally . West J Nurs Res1990; 12: 685-688 .
44.
Sarvimaki A.Aspects of moral knowledge in nursing . Schol Inquiry Nurs Pract1995; 9: 343-351 .
45.
Bishop AH , Scudder JR.Nursing ethics: therapeutic caring presence. Sudbury, MA: Jones and Bartlett , 1996.
46.
Alavi C , Cattoni J.Good nurse, bad nurse . J Adv Nurs1995; 21: 344-349 .
47.
Allen M , Frasure-Smith N , Gottlieb L.What makes a ‘good’ nurse ? Can Nurse1982; 78(9): 42-45 .
48.
Gallagher A.Care - old style: qualities of a good nurse . Austr Nurse J1989; 18(7): 9-9 .
49.
Girvin J.What makes a good nurse leader ? Elderly Care1998; 10(5): 34-45 .
50.
Haines J.The influence of one good nurse [Editorial] . Can Nurse1997; 93(6): 3-3 .
51.
Khoza L.The nurse. Caring for the newly qualified professional nurse... a good care-giver could be a person who portrays the eight major ingredients necessary for caring . Nurs News S Afr1997; 21(10): 42-43 .
Shepherd E , Bassett C.Is having strong clinical skills the measure of a good nurse? [Editorial] . Nurs Times2000; 96(13): 18-18 .
54.
Stewart E.The nurse and good nature . Nurs J India1988; 79(11): 302-302 .
55.
Zilkha D.Mental health. Addicted to self-affirmation?... explanations for what makes a good nurse . Nurs Times1999; 95(22): 52-52 .
56.
Kelly B.Preserving moral integrity: a follow-up study with new graduate nurses . J Adv Nurs1998; 28: 1134-1145 .
57.
Allen D.Nursing, knowledge and practice . J Health Serv Res Policy1997; 2(3): 190-193 .
58.
Hicks C.A study of nurse managers’ constructs of nurse researchers . J Nurs Manage1995; 3: 237-245 .
59.
Kiger A.Accord and discord in students’ image of nursing . J Nurs Educ1993; 32: 309-317 .
60.
Wilson A , Startup R.Nurse socialization: issues and problems . J Adv Nurs1991; 16: 1478-1486 .
61.
Andersson E.Nursing education in the global community: from vocational training to academic education: the situation in the schools of nursing in Sweden . J Nurs Educ1999; 38: 33-38 .
62.
Häggman-Laitila A , Åstedt-Kurki P.What is expected of the nurse-client interaction and how these expectations are realized in Finnish health care . Int J Nurs Stud1994; 31: 253-261 .
63.
Robertson DW.Ethical theory, ethnography, and differences between doctors and nurses in approaches to patient care . J Med Ethics1996; 22: 292-299 .
64.
Davis AJ , Hershberger A , Ghan LC , Lin JY.The good nurse: descriptions from the People’s Republic of China . J Adv Nurs1990; 15: 829-834 .
65.
Burns N , Grove SK.The practice of nursing research, third edition. Philadelphia, PA: Saunders , 1997.
66.
Morgan DL.Qualitative content analysis: a guide to paths not taken . Qual Health Res1993; 3: 112-121 .
67.
American Nurses Association . The code for nurses with interpretive statements. Washington, DC: ANA , 1985.
Miles MB , Huberman AM.Qualitative data analysis: an expanded sourcebook, second edition. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE , 1994.
70.
Cameron M , Crisham P , Lewis D.The basic nature of ethical problems experienced by persons with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome: implications for nursing ethics education and practice . J Prof Nurs1993; 9: 327-335 .
Hutchinson S.Responsible subversion: a study of rule-bending among nurses . Schol Inquiry Nurs Pract1990; 4: 3-17 .
73.
Leners D , Beardslee NQ.Suffering and ethical caring: incompatible entities . Nurs Ethics1997; 4: 361-369 .
74.
Lützén K , Nordin C.Structuring moral meaning in psychiatric nursing practice . Scand J Caring Sci1993; 7: 175-180 .
75.
Sherman D.Taking the fear out of AIDS nursing: voices from the field . J N Y State Nurs Assoc1996; 27: 4-8 .
76.
Viens D.The moral reasoning of nurse practitioners . J Am Acad Nurse Pract1995; 7: 277-285 .
77.
Whitler JM.Ethics of assisted autonomy in the nursing home: types of assisting among long-term care nurses . Nurs Ethics1996; 3: 224-235 .
78.
Jansson L , Norberg A.Ethical reasoning concerning the feeding of terminally ill cancer patients: interviews with registered nurses experienced in the care of cancer patients . Cancer Nurs1989; 12: 352-358 .
79.
Webb A , Bunting S.Ethical decision making by nurses in HIV or AIDS situations . J Assoc Nurs AIDS Care1992; 3(2): 15-18 .
