This article reveals a 91-year-old cognitively intact man’s lived experiences of being cared for in a geriatric context in which the majority of the patients were cognitively impaired. A narrative patient story was analysed phenomenologically. The findings indicate that this patient’s basic needs for ethical care were not met. The staff did not see him as a unique individual with his own preferences, resources and abilities to master his life. In order to survive this lack of ethical care, he played the role of an ‘old cognitively impaired man’, which provided him with at least the understanding and attention the cognitively impaired patients received from the staff. The findings also indicate that ethical care is independent of whether or not older cognitively intact and impaired patients stay or live in the same unit, but it is more dependent on a caregiver’s ability to respect and confirm each and every patient for who he or she is and would like to be.
Mattiasson A-C , Andersson L.Quality of nursing home care assessed by competent nursing home residents . J Adv Nurs1997; 26: 1117-1124 .
2.
Randers I , Mattiasson A-C.The experience of older people in geriatric care with special reference to integrity . Nurs Ethics2000; 7: 503-519 .
3.
Hälso-och sjukvårdslagen (Health and Medical Services Act). SFS 1982:763. Stockholm, 1982 (in Swedish).
4.
Andersson M.Integritet som begrepp och princip. En studie av ett vårdetiskt ideal i utveckling (Integrity as a concept and a principle. A study of a nursing ethical ideal in progress). Åbo: Åbo Akademi , 1994 (in Swedish).
5.
Vonthron Good BA , Rodrigues-Fisher L.Vulnerability: an ethical consideration in research with older adults . West J Nurs Res1993; 15: 780-783 .
6.
Rogers AC.Vulnerability, health and health care . J Adv Nurs1997; 27: 65-72 .
7.
Spiers J.New perspectives on vulnerability using emic and etic approaches . J Adv Nurs2000; 31: 715-721 .
8.
Kihlgren M , Thorsén H.Violation of the resident’s integrity, seen by staff in long-term care . Scand J Caring Sci1996; 10: 103-107 .
9.
Gustavsson B.Bekräftande omvårdnad. SAUK-modellen för vård och omsorg (Confirming care. SAUC-confirmation-model in nursing care). Lund: Studentlitteratur , 1997 (in Swedish).
10.
Buber M.Distance and relation . Psychiatry1957; 20: 97-104 .
11.
Pörn I.Action theory and social science. Dordrecht: Reidel , 1981: 83-104.
12.
Pålsson M-B. Support for women with breast cancer, and for the district and hospital nurses involved (Umeå University Medical Dissertations, New Series no. 440). Umeå: Umeå University, 1995.
13.
Eriksson K.Mot en caritativ vårdetik. In K. Eriksson (eds). Mot en caritativ vårdetik (Towards a caritative caring ethics). (Swedish) Åbo Akademi: Reports from the Department of Caring Science 5. Åbo: Åbo Akademi , 1995 (in Swedish).
14.
Erikson EH.The life cycle completed: a review. New York: Norton , 1982.
15.
Erikson EH , Erikson JM , Kivnick H.Vital involvement in old age. New York: Norton , 1986.
16.
Tornstam L.Åldrandets psykologi (The psychology of ageing). Stockholm: Rabén & Sjögren , 1992 (in Swedish).
17.
Kihlgren M. Integrity promoting care of demented patients [Dissertation]. Umeå University Medical Dissertations, new series no. 351. Umeå: Umeå University, 1992.
18.
Randers I , Olson T , Mattiasson A-C.The ‘social self’: the eleventh category of integrity - implications for enhancing geriatric care . J Applied Gerontol (in press).
19.
Ragneskog H , Kihlgren M.Music and other strategies to improve the care of agitated patients with dementia . Scand J Caring Sci1997; 11: 176-182 .
20.
Ekman SL , Norberg A , Viitanen M , Winblad B.Care of demented patients with severed communication problems . Scand J Caring Sci1991; 5: 163-170 .
21.
Riter RN.To integrate or segregate the cognitively impaired and cognitively intact in nursing homes: lessons to be learned from educational mainstreaming . Am J Alzheimers Dis1995; 10(5): 12-16 .
22.
Patton MQ.Qualitative evaluation and research methods, second edition. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE , 1990.
23.
Kvale S.Den kvalitativa forskningsintervjun (The qualitative research interview). Lund: Studentlitteratur , 1997 (in Swedish).
24.
Polit D , Hungler B.Nursing research: principles and methods, sixth edition. Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott-Raven , 1999.
25.
Malmsten K.Etik i basal omvårdnad - i någon annans händer (Ethics in basic nursing - in someone else’s hands). Lund: Studentlitteratur , 2001 (in Swedish).
26.
Hermerén G.Kunskapens pris. Forskningsetiska problem och principer i humaniora och samhällsvetenskap (The price of knowledge: research ethical problems and principles in the human and social sciences). Stockholm: Humanistisk-samhällsvetenskapliga forskningsrådet , 1992 (in Swedish).
27.
Kuczewski M , Wicclair M , Arnold R , Pinkus RL , Aumann G.Make my case: ethics teaching and case presentations . J Clin Ethics1994; 4: 310-315 .
28.
Husserl E.Cartesian meditations. An introduction to phenomenology. (Cairns D trans.) The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff , 1973.
29.
Giorgi A.Phenomenology and psychological research. Pittsburgh: Duquesne University Press , 1985: 8-85.
30.
Bengtsson J.Sammanflätningar. Husserls och Merleau-Pontys fenomenologi (Intertwinings. The phenomenologies of Husserl and Merleau-Ponty). Göteborg: Bokförlaget Daidaslos , 1988: 19-47 (in Swedish).
31.
Charon, J.Symbolic interactionism. An introduction, an interpretation, an integration, fifth edition. Old Tappan, NJ: Prentice-Hall , 1995.
32.
Eriksson, K.Broar. Introduktion i vårdvetenskaplig metod (Bridges. Introduction to methods in caring sciences). Åbo: Åbo Akademi, Institutionen för vårdvetenscap , 1991 (in Swedish).
33.
Giorgi A.Concerning the possibility of phenomenological psychological research . J Phenomenol Psychol1983; 14: 129-169 .
34.
Giorgi A.Validity and reliability from a phenomenological perspective. In: Baker WJ , Mos IP , Raffard HV , Stan HJ eds. Recent trends in theoretical psychology. New York: Springer Verlag , 1988: 167-176.
35.
Fagerberg I , Ekman SL.First-year Swedish nursing students’ experiences with elderly patients . West J Nurs Res1997; 19: 177-189 .
36.
Palo-Bengtsson L , Ekman SL.Social dancing in the care of persons with dementia in a nursing home setting; A phenomenological study . Schol Inquiry Nurs Pract1997; 11: 101-118 .
37.
Pursey A , Luker K.Attitudes and stereotypes: nurses’ work with older people . J Adv Nurs1995; 22: 547-555 .
38.
Elander G , Drechsler K , Wallin Persson K.Ethical dilemmas in long-term care settings; interviews with nurses in Sweden and England . Int J Nurs Stud1993; 30: 91-97 .
39.
Sidenvall B , Fjellström C , Ek AC.Kulturella föreställningar om måltidens dagliga planering inom geriatrisk vård. (Cultural conceps of everyday meal-planning in geriatric care) . Vård i Norden1994; 14(2-3): 11-16 (in Swedish).
40.
Weiss R.Issues in the study of loneliness. In: Peplau LA , Perlman D eds. Loneliness: a source-book of current theory, research and therapy. New York: Wiley , 1982: 71-80.
41.
Mullins L , Johnsson P , Andersson L.Loneliness of the elderly: the impact of family and friends . J Soc Behav Personality1987; 2(2 Pt 2): 225-238 .
42.
Mullins L , Johnsson P , Andersson L.Social and emotional isolation among the elderly: a conceptual view of loneliness . Dan Med Bull (Special Suppl Series)1988; 6: 26-29 .
43.
Holmén K , Ericksson K , Andersson L , Winblad B.ADL capacity and loneliness among elderly persons with cognitive impairment . Scand J Primary Health Care1992; 11: 56-60 .
44.
Bondevik M , Skogstad A.Loneliness among the oldest old: a comparison between residents living in nursing homes and residents living in the community . Int J Aging Hum Dev1996; 43: 181-197 .
45.
Sarvimäki A , Stenbock-Hult B.Vård - Ett uttryck för omsorg (Care - an expression for caring), second edition. Stockholm: Liber AB , 1996 (in Swedish).
46.
Tschudin V.Counselling. In: V Tschudin ed. Nursing the patient with cancer. New York: Prentice Hall , 1988: 425-436.
47.
Pediani R.A reflection on nursing time . J Adv Nurs1998; 28: 693-694 .
48.
Miller PM.Factors promoting wellness in the aged person: an ethnographic study . ANS Adv Nurs Sci1991; 13: 38-51 .
49.
Brodozdina LV , Molchanova ON.The quality of self-concept in old age . Z Gerontol Geriatr1997; 30: 298-305 .
50.
Hillerås P , Jorm AF , Herlitz A , Winblad B.Negative and positive effect among the very old. A survey of a sample aged 90 years or above . Res Aging1998; 20: 593-610 .
51.
Nilsson M , Ekman SL , Sarvimäki A.Aging with joy or resigning to old age: older people’s experiences of quality of life in old age . Health Care Later Life1998; 3: 94-110 .
52.
Roberts BL.Nursing research in geriatric mental health . J Adv Nurs1990; 15: 1030-1035 .
53.
Wallace JB.Reconsidering the life review: the social construction of talk about the past . Gerontologist1992; 32: 120-125 .
54.
Elander G.Patienter och behovstillfredsställelse. Det goda valet - prioriteringar i omvårdnad (Patients and satisfaction of needs. The good choice - priorities in nursing). Stockholm: Spri , 1998 (in Swedish).
55.
Solomon K.Social antecedents of learned helplessness in the health care setting . Gerontologist1982; 22: 282-287 .
56.
Giorgi A.The status of Husserlian phenomenology in caring research . Scand J Caring Sci2000; 14: 3-10 .
57.
Frid I , Öhlén J , Bergbom I.On the use of narratives in nursing research . J Adv Nurs2000; 32: 695-703 .
58.
Halldórsdóttir S , Hamrin E.Caring and uncaring encounters within nursing and health care from the cancer patient’s perspective . Cancer Nurs1996; 20: 120-128 .
59.
Iurita VF.Factors and detractors in the delivery of quality nursing care. The patient’s perspective . Proceedings of the 8th Biennal Conference of the Workgroup of European Nurse Researchers. Research on nursing throughout the lifespan; 1996 Jun 24-25; Stockholm. Stockholm: Svenskan Hälso-och Sjukvårdens Tjänstemanna Förbund (Swedish Association of Health Officers), 1996: 234-247 .
60.
Tishelman C.Cancer patients’ hopes and expectations of nursing practice in Stockholm. Patients’ descriptions and nursing discourse . Scand J Caring Sci1994; 8: 213-222 .
61.
Sjukvården i Sverige 1998 (Health Care in Sweden 1998). Stockholm: Socialstyrelsen , 1998: 25-37 (in Swedish).
62.
Randers I , Mattiasson A-C.Den Aristoteliska Etiken: Förståelsegrund för den erfarna sjuksköterskans moraliskt goda handlande i vården och omsorgen om den gamla människan (Aristotelian Ethics. Grounds for understanding moral actions of experienced registered nurses in the care of elderly individuals) . Vård i Norden1999; 1: 18-23 (in Swedish).
63.
Bergum V.Knowledge for ethical care . Nurs Ethics1994; 1: 71-79 .
64.
Tschudin V.Ethical challenges in the health care system in the future. In: Det sygeplejeetiske råd 1990-2000 Jubelæumsskrift. Copenhagen: Dansk sygeplejeråd , 2000; 26-28.
