The Structural Efficiency of Tube-plates for Heat Exchangers

Abstract

Experimental investigations are described in which the stress and deflexion distributions in models of tube-plates for high-pressure feed-water heaters were determined. The plates were drilled on a triangular pitch and the loading conditions of heaters employing hair-pin tubes were simulated by equivalent concentrated loads and by means of the ‘Flexible-bag’ technique. Direct measurement of the deflexion and the linear strain on the surface of the plate were made under a wide range of conditions.

Comparisons of deflexion and stress in a given test plate before and after drilling to a four-, two-, and one-pass drilling-pattern provided specific experimental values for the structural efficiency of each type of drilled plate. The dependence of this efficiency on the ratios of hole-size/pitch and pitch/thickness was also investigated.

Methods proposed by other authors for estimating structural efficiency are reviewed in the light of experimental findings and an analytical method of treating one-pass tube-plates, based on Horvay's thick-plate theory, is proposed.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bailey

R. W.

1951 Proc. I.Mech.E., vol. 164, p. 324, ‘Steam Piping for High Pressure and High Temperatures’.

Gardner

K. A.

1948 Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 15, p. 377, ‘Heat-exchanger Tube-sheet Design’.

1952 Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, pp. 159–66, ‘Heat-exchanger Tube-sheet Design—2, Fixed Tube-sheets’. 1952 Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, p. 573, Author's Reply to discussion of Paper 3.

Goodier

J. N.

Schoessow

G. J.

1943 Trans. A.S.M.E., vol. 65, p. 489, ‘The Holding Power and Hydraulic Tightness of Expanded Tube Joints’.

Green

A. E.

1940 Proc. Roy. Soc. A, vol. 176, pp. 121–39.

Holmberg

1947 539.384.08 Acta Polytechnica, 3. Civil Engineering and Building Construction Series, vol. 1, No. 1, ‘Tests with Circular Plates’.

Horvay

1951 Proc. of the First U.S. National Congress of Applied Mechanics (A.S.M.E., New York), p. 247, ‘Thermal Stresses in Perforated Plates’.

1952a Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, p. 122, ‘Bending of Honeycombs and of Perforated Plates’.

1952b Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, p. 355, ‘The Plane-stress Problem of Perforated Plates’.

10.

1952c Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, p. 406, Author's Reply to discussion of Paper 8.

11.

1952d Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, p. 572, Discussion of Paper 3.

12.

Malkin

1952 Trans. A.S.M.E., vol. 74, p. 387, ‘Notes on a Theoretical Basis for Design of Tube-sheets of Triangular Layout’.

13.

1952 Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 19, p. 405, Discussion of Paper 8.

14.

Miller

K. A. G.

1952 Proc. (B) I.Mech.E., vol. IB, p. 215, ‘The Design of Tube-plates in Heat-exchangers’.

15.

Nadai

1943 Trans. A.S.M.E., vol. 65, p. 865, ‘Theory of the Expanding of Boiler and Condenser Tube Joints Through Rolling’.

16.

Sachs

1947 Jl. Applied Mechanics, vol. 69, p. A285, ‘Notes on the Tightness of Expanded Tube Joints’.

17.

Schulz

1945 ‘Advances in Applied Mechanics’, vol. 1, p. 121 (Academic Press, New York).

18.

von Mises

von Kármán

(Editors) 1948 ‘Advances in Applied Mechanics’, p. 121 (Academic Press, New York).

19.

Wesstrom

D. B.

Bergh

S. E.

1951 Trans. A.S.M.E., vol. 73, p. 553, ‘Effect of Internal Pressure on Stresses and Strains in Bolted Flange Connections’.

20.

American Society of Mechanical Engineers 1950 Boiler Construction Code, Section VIII.

21.

British Standards Institution 1949 British Standard Code 1500: 1949 Provisional, ‘Fusion Welded Pressure Vessels’.

22.

Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers’ Association ‘Design Code for Tubular Exchangers’.

23.

Timoshenko

1940 ‘Theory of Plates and Shells’, first edition (McGraw-Hill Book Co., New York and London).

24.

Duncan

J. P.

1953 ‘The Design of Tube-plates for High-pressure Feed-water Heaters’, M.E. Thesis (100 pages with 90 (figures). Deposited in the Barr Smith Library, University of Adelaide.