The Primary Social Education Curricula in Hong Kong and Singapore: A Comparative Study

Abstract

In the face of the challenges of globalization, nation states try to reinvigorate their traditional or national values and local identities as a kind of counterbalance to globalizing influences. Hence, social and citizenship education across nations in Asia takes different forms with certain distinctive varieties in terms of policies, practices and values in alignment with national priorities. Based on this premise, this article compares and contrasts the primary social education curricula in Hong Kong and Singapore in order to trace the differences and similarities in the responses of these two Asian city states to external and internal forces since the turn of the century. The article particularly sheds light on the tensions and contradictions in policies and practices in social and citizenship education as a result of the interaction of global and local perspectives.

References

Adler

S.A.

Sim

J.B.Y.

(2005) Social Studies in Singapore: Contradiction and control. Paper presented at Redesigning Pedagogy: Research, policy, practice, Centre for Research in Pedagogy and Practice, National Institute of Education, Singapore, 30 May–11 June.

Adler

S.A.

Sim

J.B.Y.

(2008) Secondary School Social Studies in Singapore: Intentions and contradictions, in Grossman

D.L.

J.T.Y.

(Eds) Social Education in Asia: Critical issues and multiple perspective, 163–182. Charlotte, NC: Information Age.

J.C.O.

(1997) Schooling for Singaporeans: The interaction of Singapore culture and values in the school, in Tan

Gopinathan

Kam

H.W.

(Eds) Education in Singapore: A book for readings, 75–91. Singapore: Prentice Hall.

Arnove

(2007) Introduction. Reframing Comparative Education: The dialectic of the global and the local, in Arnove

(Ed.) Comparative Education: The dialectic of the global and the local, 1–20. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield.

Avery

P.G.

(2004) Social Studies Teacher Education in an Era of Globalization, in Adler

(Ed.) Critical Issues in Social Studies Teacher Education, 37–57. Greenwich, CT: Information Age.

Banks

(2004) Introduction. Democratic Citizenship Education in Multicultural Societies, in Banks

(Ed.) Diversity and Citizenship Education: Global perspectives, 3–15. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Beane

(1997) Curriculum Integration: Designing the core of democratic education. New York: Teachers College Press.

Brady

Kennedy

(2003) Curriculum Construction. Sydney: Pearson Education.

Bray

(2007) Actors and Purposes in Comparative Education, in Bray

Adamson

Mason

(Eds) Comparative Education Research: Approaches and methods, 15–38. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.

10.

Bray

Thomas

R.M.

(1995) Levels of Comparison in Educational Studies: Different insights from different literatures and the value of multilevel analyses, Harvard Educational Review, 65(3), 472–490.

11.

Brophy

Alleman

(1993) Elementary Social Studies Should Be Driven by Major Social Education Goals, Social Education, 57(1), 27–32.

12.

Case

(1999) Global Education: It's largely a matter of perspective, in Case

Clark

(Eds) The Canadian Anthology of Social Studies, 75–82. Vancouver: Pacific Educational Press.

13.

Chai-Yip

W.L.

Cheng

N.Y.

(2004) Today's General Studies: New Horizons. Hong Kong: Educational Publishing House. [In Chinese.]

14.

Cheung

W.L.

Sidhu

(2003) A Tale of Two Cities: Education responds to globalisation in Hong Kong and Singapore in the aftermath of the Asian economic crisis, Asia Pacific Journal of Education, 23(1), 43–68. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/0218879030230104

15.

Cogan

(2000) Citizenship Education for the 21st Century: Setting the context, in Cogan

Derricott

(Eds) Citizenship for the 21st Century: An international perspective on education, 1–22. London: Kogan Page.

16.

Crossley

(2000) Bridging Cultures and Traditions in the Reconceptualisation of Comparative and International Education, Comparative Education, 36(3), 319–332. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/713656615

17.

Curriculum Development Council (2002) General Studies for Primary Schools Curriculum Guide (Primary 1-Primary 6). Hong Kong: Printing Department.

18.

Curriculum Planning and Development Division (2005) Social Studies Syllabus (Primary). Singapore: Ministry of Education.

19.

Curriculum Planning and Development Division (2007) Social Studies: Interacting with our world. Singapore: Marshall Cavendish Education.

20.

Davis

M.C.

(1998) Constitutionalism and Hong Kong's Future. Journal of Contemporary China, 8(21), 263–273.

21.

Engle

Ochoa

(1988) Education for Democratic Citizenship: Decision making in the social studies. New York: Teachers College Press.

22.

Fairbrother

G.P.

(2003) Toward Critical Patriotism: Student resistance to political education in Hong Kong and China. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.

23.

Giddens

(1990) The Consequences of Modernity. Cambridge: Polity Press.

24.

Gopinathan

(1997) Education and State Development: Lessons for the United States? In Cummings

W.K.

Altbach

P.G.

(Eds) The Challenge of Eastern Asian Education: Implications for America, 249–264. Albany: State University of New York Press.

25.

Green

(1997) Education, Globalization and the Nation-state. New York: St. Martin's Press.

26.

Gutmann

(2004) Unity and Diversity in Democratic Multicultural Education: Creative and destructive tensions, in Banks

(Ed.) Diversity and Citizenship Education: Global perspectives, 71–96. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

27.

Hartoonian

H.M.

Laughlin

M.A.

(1986) Designing a Scope and Sequence, Social Education, 50(7), 502–512.

28.

Hartoonian

H.M.

Laughlin

M.A.

(1989) Designing a Social Studies Scope and Sequence for the 21st Century, Social Education, 53(6), 388–398.

29.

Hong Kong Examinations and Assessment Authority (2009) Territory-wide System Assessment 2008. Report on the Basic Competencies of Students in Chinese Language, English Language and Mathematics Key Stages 1–3. http://www.hkeaa.edu.hk/en/bca_tsa/

30.

Jacobs

H.H.

(1989) The Growing Need for Interdisciplinary Curriculum Content, in Jacobs

H.H.

(Ed.) Interdisciplinary Curriculum: Design and implementation, 1–13. Alexandria: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

31.

Joyce

W.W.

Little

T.H.

Wronski

S.P.

(1991) Scope and Sequence, Goals, and Objectives: Effects on social studies, in Shaver

J.P.

(Ed.) Handbook of Research on Social Studies Teaching and Learning, 321–331. New York: Macmillan.

32.

Kelly

G.P.

Altbach

P.G.

(1989) Comparative Education: Alternative approaches, in Husen

Postlethwaite

T.N.

(Eds) The International Encyclopedia of Education Research and Studies, supp. vol. 1, 37–144. New York: Pergamon.

33.

Kubow

P.K.

Fossum

P.R.

(2007) Comparative Education: Exploring issues in international perspective. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill/Prentice Hall.

34.

Lam

Y.S.

Leung

C.N.

Chung

(2004) Longman General Studies. Hong Kong: Longman Education. [In Chinese.]

35.

Lee

H.L.

(1997) Opening Speech at Education in Singapore 21, NTUC Pasir Ris Resort, Singapore, 24 November. http://www.moe.gov.sg/media/speeches/1997/241197.htm

36.

Lee

M.H.

(2002) A Tale of Two Cities: Comparing higher education policies and reforms in Hong Kong and Singapore, Australian Journal of Education, 46(3), 255–286.

37.

Lee

M.H.

Gopinathan

(2003) Reforming University Education in Hong Kong and Singapore, Higher Education Research and Development, 22(2), 167–182. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/07294360304108

38.

Lee

M.H.

Gopinathan

(2005) Convergence or Divergences? Comparing Education Reforms in Hong Kong and Singapore, in Zajda

(Ed.) International Handbook on Globalisation, Education and Policy Research, 253–278. Dordrecht: Springer. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/1-4020-2960-8_16

39.

Lee

W.O.

(1991) Social Change and Educational Problems in Japan, Singapore and Hong Kong. New York: St. Martin's Press.

40.

Lee

W.O.

Sweeting

(2001) Controversies in Hong Kong's Political Transition: Nationalism versus liberalism, in Bray

Lee

W.O.

(Eds) Education and Political Transition: Themes and experiences in East Asia, 101–121. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.

41.

Leung

Y.W.

(2002) Nationalistic Education as the Focus for Civics and Citizenship Education: The case of Hong Kong, Asia Pacific Education Review, 3(2), 197–209. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1007/BF03024912

42.

J.T.Y.

(2002) The Primary Social Education Curricula in Hong Kong and Shanghai: A comparative study, International Social Studies Forum, 2(1), 3–18.

43.

J.T.Y.

(2004) The Junior Secondary History Curricula in Hong Kong and Shanghai: A comparative study, Comparative Education, 40(3), 343–361. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/0305006042000274836

44.

J.T.Y.

(2006) The Use of Instructional Resources in Implementing Interdisciplinary Personal, Social, Humanities Education (PSHE) in the Junior Secondary Schools in Hong Kong, in Kwak

B.S.

Gim

C.C.

(Eds) Internet and Textbook, 67–84. Seoul: Kyoyook-kwahak-sa.

45.

J.T.Y.

(2007) Nationalism and Globalism in the Junior Secondary History Curricula of Hong Kong and Shanghai, Compare, 37(1), 37–51. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/03057920601061745

46.

J.T.Y.

(2008) Learning in the Museum: A case study, Pacific-Asian Education, 20(2), 17–28.

47.

Lui

T.Y.

(2007) Enhancing NE: Strengthening heartware and rootedness. FY 2007 Committee of Supply Debate, 3rd Reply by MOS Lui Tuck Yew on National Education. http://www.moe.gov.sg/media/speeches/2007/sp20070307c.htm

48.

Mathews

Lui

T.L.

(2008) Hong Kong, China: Learning to belong to a nation. London: Routledge.

49.

McNeil

J.D.

(2006) Contemporary Curriculum in Thought and Action. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

50.

Merryfield

M.M.

(2002) The Difference a Global Educator Can Make, Educational Leadership, 60(2), 18–21.

51.

Merryfield

M.M.

(2004) Elementary Students in Substantive Culture Learning, Social Education, 68(4), 270–273.

52.

Ministry of Education (2006) Nurturing Every Child: Flexibility and diversity in Singapore schools. Singapore: Ministry of Education. http://www.moe.gov.sg/education/files/edu-booklet/edu-booklet-english.pdf

53.

Ministry of Education (2008) National Education. http://www.ne.edu.sg/

54.

Ministry of Education (2009) Desired Outcomes of Education. http://www.moe.gov.sg/education/desired-outcomes/

55.

Mok

K.H.

Tan

(2004) Globalization and Marketization in Education: A comparative analysis of Hong Kong and Singapore. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

56.

Morris

(1995) The Hong Kong School Curriculum: Development, issues and policies. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.

57.

Morris

(1996) Asia's Four Little Tigers: A comparison of the role of education in their development, Comparative Education, 32(1), 95–109. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/03050069628948

58.

Nelson

J.L.

(1991) Communities, Local to National, as Influences on Social Studies Education, in Shaver

J.P.

(Ed.) Handbook of Research on Social Studies Teaching and Learning, 332–341. New York: Macmillan.

59.

Neubauer

(2007) Globalization and Education: Characteristics, dynamics, implications, in Hershock

P.D.

Mason

Hawkins

J.N.

(Eds) Changing Education: Leadership, innovation and development in a globalizing Asia Pacific, 29–62. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.

60.

E.H.

(2008) Speech by Dr Ng Eng Hen, Minister for Education and Second Minster for Defence, Ministry of Education Work Plan Seminar, Ngee Ann Polytechnic Convention Centre, Singapore, 25 September. http://www.moe.gov.sg/media/speeches/2008/09/25/speech-by-dr-ng-eng-hen-at-the-moe-work-plan-seminar-2008.php

61.

Nichol

Sim

J.B.Y.

(2007) Singaporean Citizenship, National Education and Social Studies: Control, constraints, contradictions and possibilities, Citizenship Teaching and Learning, 3(1), 17–31.

62.

Noah

Eckstein

(1998) Doing Comparative Education: Three decades of collaboration. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.

63.

Ochoa-Becker

(2007) Democratic Education for Social Studies: An issues-centered decision making curriculum. Greenwich, CT: Information Age.

64.

Ong

(1999) Flexible Citizenship: The cultural logics of transnationality. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

65.

Osborne

(1997) Citizenship Education and Social Studies, in Wright

Sears

(Eds) Trends and Issues in Canadian Social Studies, 39–67. Vancouver: Pacific Educational Press.

66.

Osborne

(2004) History and Social Studies: Partners or rivals? In Sears

Wright

(Eds) Challenges and Prospects for Canadian Social Studies, 73–89. Vancouver: Pacific Educational Press.

67.

Parker

W.C.

(2001) Toward Enlightened Political Engagement, in Stanley

W.B.

(Ed.) Critical Issues in Social Studies Research for the 21st Century, 97–118. Greenwich, CT: Information Age.

68.

S.C.

Merryfield

M.M.

J.T.Y.

(2007) Problems and Practices in Promoting Global Education in Hong Kong Primary Schools: A case study, Education and Society, 25(1), 39–56.

69.

Posner

G.J.

(1995) Analysing the Curriculum. New York: McGraw-Hill.

70.

(1993) Curriculum Development and Design. St Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin.

71.

Reed

G.G.

(2004) Multidimensional Citizenship, Confucian Humanism and the Imagined Community: South Korea and China, in Lee

W.O.

Grossman

D.L.

Kennedy

K.J.

Fairbrother

G.P.

(Eds) Citizenship Education in Asia and the Pacific: Concepts and issues, 239–256. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.

72.

Robertson

(1992) Globalization: Social theory and global culture. London: Sage.

73.

Sim

H.H.

Chee

M.F.

(2005) Infusion of National Education into Primary Social Studies, in Lee

Chang

C.H.

(Eds) Primary Social Studies: Exploring pedagogy and content, 68–73. Singapore: Marshall Cavendish Education.

74.

Sim

J.B.Y.

(2005) Citizenship Education and Social Studies in Singapore: A national agenda, International Journal of Citizenship and Teacher Education, 1(1) 58–73.

75.

Sim

J.B.Y.

Tan

Sim

H.H.

(2005) Exploring the Use of Inquiry-based Learning through Fieldwork, in Lee

Chang

C.H.

(Eds) Primary Social Studies: Exploring pedagogy and content, 33–43. Singapore: Marshall Cavendish International.

76.

Singapore 21 Committee (1999) Singapore 21: Together we make the difference. Singapore: Singapore 21 Committee.

77.

Skelton

Wigford

Harper

Reeves

(2002) Beyond Food, Festivals, and Flags, Educational Leadership, 60(2), 52–55.

78.

Stahl

R.J.

(2005) How Learners Think and Learn: Applications for social studies educators, in Lee

Chang

C.H.

(Eds) Primary Social Studies: Exploring pedagogy and content, 3–19. Singapore: Marshall Cavendish Education.

79.

Tan

(1997) Education and Colonial Transition in Singapore and Hong Kong: Comparisons and contrasts, Comparative Education, 33(2), 303–312. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/03050069728587

80.

Tan

(2007) Pulling Together and Globalization: National education in Singapore schools, in Hershock

P.D.

Mason

Hawkins

J.N.

(Eds) Changing Education: Leadership, innovation and development in a globalizing Asia Pacific, 183–197. Hong Kong: Comparative Education Research Centre, The University of Hong Kong.

81.

Tse

T.K.C.

(2007) Remaking Chinese Identity: Hegemonic struggles over national education in post-colonial Hong Kong, International Studies in Sociology of Education, 17(3), 231–248. https://dx-doi-org.web.bisu.edu.cn/10.1080/09620210701543908

82.

Waters

(2001) Globalization. London: Routledge.