School Discipline Policies and Educational Outcomes for Urban Youth: The Consequences of the Impact Schools Initiative on Academic Achievement

Abstract

The past several decades have seen drastic changes in school policing and disciplinary policies across the United States with disproportionate impacts on students of color. Focusing on a school policing program that strictly enforced minor disciplinary matters and increased police presence in selected schools, we examine both differential exposure across groups and the effect of the program on grade point average (GPA). Using a matched difference-in-differences design, we find that the program had a negative effect on student GPA and did so for students of different races and genders, though students exposed to the program were more likely to be Black. We suggest that decreased school attendance may be one potential mechanism behind these results.

Keywords

school policing zero tolerance academic achievement

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander

(2011). The New Jim Crow. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law, 9(1), 7–26.

Allensworth

E. M.

Clark

(2020). High school GPAs and ACT scores as predictors of college completion: Examining assumptions about consistency across high schools. Educational Researcher, 49(3), 198–211.

Anderson

(2000). Code of the street: Decency, violence, and the moral life of the inner city. W. W. Norton & Company.

Anderson

K. P.

Ritter

G. W.

Zamarro

(2019). Understanding a vicious cycle: The relationship between student discipline and student academic outcomes. Educational Researcher, 48(5), 251–262.

Andrew

Blake

M. K.

(2023). The long arm of early exclusionary school discipline? A multi-model analysis. Youth & Society, 55(2), 238–258.

Ang

(2020). The effects of police violence on inner-city students. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 136(1), 115–168.

Angrist

J. D.

Pischke

J.-S.

(2008). Mostly harmless econometrics: An empiricist’s companion. Princeton University Press.

Anyon

Zhang

Hazel

(2016). Race, exclusionary discipline, and connectedness to adults in secondary schools. American Journal of Community Psychology, 57(3–4), 342–352.

Ayoub

L. H.

(2013). School safety in New York City policy, practice, and programs from 2002 to 2013. https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/school-safety-new-york-city-policy-practice-and-programs-2002-2013

10.

Bacher-Hicks

de la Campa

(2020). Social costs of proactive policing: the impact of NYC’s stop and frisk program on educational attainment. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1sSxhfmDY3N1VAN5XwyRObE65tmAZzhTj/view

11.

Bell

(2015). The hidden side of zero tolerance policies: The African American perspective. Sociology Compass, 9(1), 14–22.

12.

Bickel

Qualls

(1980). The impact of school climate on suspension rates in the Jefferson County Public Schools. The Urban Review, 12(2), 79–86.

13.

Bradshaw

C. P.

Sawyer

A. L.

O’Brennan

L. M.

(2009). A social disorganization perspective on bullying-related attitudes and behaviors: The influence of school context. American Journal of Community Psychology, 43(3–4), 204–220.

14.

Brady

K. P.

Balmer

Phenix

(2007). School–Police partnership effectiveness in urban schools: An analysis of New York City’s Impact Schools Initiative. Education and Urban Society, 39(4), 455–478.

15.

Braga

A. A.

Welsh

B. C.

Schnell

(2019). Disorder policing to reduce crime: A systematic review. Campbell Systematic Reviews, 15(3), e1051. https://doi.org/10.1002/cl2.1050

16.

Brayne

(2014). Surveillance and system avoidance: Criminal justice contact and institutional attachment. American Sociological Review, 79(3), 367–391.

17.

Browne

J. A.

(2003). Derailed! The schoolhouse to jailhouse track. http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED480206.pdf

18.

Burdick-Will

(2013). School violent crime and academic achievement in Chicago. Sociology of Education, 86(4), 343–361. https://doi.org/10.1177/0038040713494225

19.

Carroll

B. R.

(2006). The effects of school violence and crime on academic achievement. https://sites.duke.edu/djepapers/files/2016/10/Carroll.pdf

20.

Casella

(2003). Zero tolerance policy in schools: Rationale, consequences, and alternatives. Teachers College Record, 105(5), 872–892.

21.

Caton

M. T.

(2012). Black male perspectives on their educational experiences in high school. Urban Education, 47(6), 1055–1085.

22.

Cholewa

Hull

M. F.

Babcock

C. R.

Smith

A. D.

(2018). Predictors and academic outcomes associated with in-school suspension. School Psychology Quarterly, 33(2), 191–199.

23.

Costenbader

Markson

(1998). School suspension: A study with secondary school students. Journal of School Psychology, 36(1), 59–82.

24.

Cribb Fabersunne

Lee

S. Y.

McBride

Zahir

Gallegos-Castillo

LeWinn

K. Z.

Morris

M. D

. (2023). Exclusionary school discipline and school achievement for middle and high school students, by race and ethnicity. JAMA Network Open, 6(10), e2338989.

25.

Curran

F. C.

(2016). Estimating the effect of state zero tolerance laws on exclusionary discipline, racial discipline gaps, and student behavior. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 38(4), 647–668.

26.

de Chaisemartin

D’Haultfœuille

. (2020). Two-way fixed effects estimators with heterogeneous treatment effects. The American Economic Review, 110(9), 2964–2996.

27.

Del Toro

Wang

M.-T

. (2022). The roles of suspensions for minor infractions and school climate in predicting academic performance among adolescents. The American Psychologist, 77(2), 173–185.

28.

Diliberti

Jackson

Correa

Padgett

(2019). Crime, violence, discipline, and safety in U.S. Public Schools: Findings from the School Survey on Crime and Safety: 2017–18 (NCES 2019-061). National Center for Education Statistic. https://nces.ed.gov/pubs2019/2019061.pdf

29.

Dunbar

Villarruel

F. A.

(2002). Urban school leaders and the implementation of zero-tolerance policies: An examination of its implications. Peabody Journal of Education, 77(1), 82–104.

30.

Engen

R. L.

Steen

Bridges

G. S.

(2002). Racial disparities in the punishment of youth: A theoretical and empirical assessment of the literature. Social Problems, 49(2), 194–220.

31.

Ewing

C. P.

(2000). Sensible zero tolerance protects students. Harvard Education Letter, 16(1), 8–10. https://digitalcommons.law.buffalo.edu/journal_articles/504/

32.

Eyllon

Salhi

Griffith

J. L.

Lincoln

A. K.

(2022). Exclusionary school discipline policies and mental health in a national sample of adolescents without histories of suspension or expulsion. Youth & Society, 54(1), 84–103.

33.

Figures

K. D.

Legewie

(2019). Visualizing police exposure by race, gender, and age in New York City. Socius, 5, 2378023119828913.

34.

French

M. T.

Homer

J. F.

Popovici

Robins

P. K.

(2015). What you do in high school matters: High school GPA, Educational attainment, and labor market earnings as a young adult. Eastern Economic Journal, 41(3), 370–386.

35.

Gaure

(2013). OLS with multiple high dimensional category variables. Computational Statistics & Data Analysis, 66, 8–18.

36.

Geller

(2021). Youth–police contact: Burdens and inequities in an adverse childhood experience, 2014–2017. American Journal of Public Health, 111(7), 1300–1308.

37.

Goel

Rao

J. M.

Shroff

(2016). Precinct or prejudice? Understanding racial disparities in New York City’s stop-and-frisk policy. The Annals of Applied Statistics, 10(1), 365–394.

38.

Golden

Almo

(2004). Reducing gun violence: An overview of New York city’s strategies. https://www.vera.org/downloads/publications/Reducing_gun_violence.pdf

39.

Golub

Johnson

B. D.

Dunlap

(2007). The race/ethnicity disparity in misdemeanor marijuana arrests in New York City. Criminology & Public Policy, 6(1), 131–164.

40.

Goodman

(2014). Flaking out: Student absences and snow days as disruptions of instructional time (No. 20221). National Bureau of Economic Research. https://doi.org/10.3386/w20221

41.

Gregory

Cornell

Fan

(2011). The relationship of school structure and support to suspension rates for Black and White high school students. American Educational Research Journal, 48(4), 904–934.

42.

Harvard Civil Rights Project. (2002). The impact of racial and ethnic diversity on educational outcomes: Cambridge, MA school district. Harvard University Civil Rights Project.

43.

Hinojosa

M. S.

(2008). Black-White differences in school suspension: Effect of student beliefs about teachers. Sociological Spectrum, 28(2), 175–193.

44.

Hirschfield

(2009). Another way out: The impact of juvenile arrests on high school dropout. Sociology of Education, 82(4), 368–393.

45.

Hirschfield

P. J.

(2008). Preparing for prison?: The criminalization of school discipline in the USA. Theoretical Criminology, 12(1), 79–101.

46.

Hirschfield

P. J.

(2018). Schools and crime. Annual Review of Criminology, 1, 149–169. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-criminol-032317-092358

47.

Imai

King

Stuart

E. A.

(2011). MatchIt: Nonparametric preprocessing for parametric causal inference. Journal of Statistical Software, 42, 1–28.

48.

Huang

Anyon

(2020). The relationship between school disciplinary resolutions with school climate and attitudes toward school. Preventing School Failure: Alternative Education for Children and Youth, 64(3), 212–222.

49.

Huang

F. L.

Cornell

D. G.

(2021). Teacher support for zero tolerance is associated with higher suspension rates and lower feelings of safety. School Psychology Review, 50(2–3), 388–405.

50.

Irby

D. J.

Coney

(2021). The 1994 Gun-Free Schools Act: Its effects 25 years later and how to undo them. Peabody Journal of Education, 96(5), 494–507.

51.

Jabbari

Johnson

(2022). The process of “pushing out”: Accumulated disadvantage across school punishment and math achievement trajectories. Youth & Society, 54(6), 911–934.

52.

Kang-Brown

Trone

Fratello

Daftary-Kapur

(2013). A generation later: What we’ve learned about zero tolerance in schools. Vera Institute of Justice. https://www.vera.org/publications/a-generation-later-what-weve-learned-about-zero-tolerance-in-schools

53.

Kirk

D. S.

Sampson

R. J.

(2013). Juvenile arrest and collateral educational damage in the transition to adulthood. Sociology of Education, 88(1), 36–62.

54.

Kohler-Hausmann

(2018). Misdemeanorland. Princeton University Press.

55.

Kupchik

(2010). Homeroom security: School discipline in an age of fear (Vol. 6). New York University Press.

56.

Lacoe

(2020). Too scared to learn? The academic consequences of feeling unsafe in the classroom. Urban Education, 55(10), 1385–1418.

57.

Lacoe

Steinberg

M. P.

(2018). Rolling back zero tolerance: The effect of discipline policy reform on suspension usage and student outcomes. Peabody Journal of Education, 93(2), 207–227.

58.

Lacoe

J. R.

(2015). Unequally safe: The race gap in school safety. Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice, 13(2), 143–168.

59.

Legewie

(2012). The estimation of causal effects: An introduction to methods of causal inference based on peer effects in education. KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift Für Soziologie Und Sozialpsychologie, 64(1), 123–153.

60.

Legewie

Cricco

N. J.

(2022). Long-term exposure to neighborhood policing and the racial/ethnic gap in high school graduation. Demography, 59(5), 1739–1761.

61.

Legewie

Fagan

(2019). Aggressive policing and the educational performance of minority youth. American Sociological Review, 84(2), 220–247.

62.

Leiber

M. J.

Nalla

M. K.

Farnworth

(1998). Explaining juveniles’ attitudes toward the police. Justice Quarterly, 15(1), 151–174.

63.

Leung-Gagné

McCombs

Scott

Losen

(2022). Pushed out: Trends and disparities in out-of-school suspension. Learning Policy Institute. https://doi.org/10.54300/235.277

64.

Losen

D. J.

(2011). Discipline policies, successful schools, and racial justice. National Education Policy Center. http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/detail?accno=ED524711

65.

Losen

D. J.

Gillespie

(2012). Opportunities suspended: The disparate impact of disciplinary exclusion from school. The Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles, University of California, Los Angeles. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED534178.pdf

66.

Losen

D. J.

Skiba

R. J.

(2010). Suspended education: Urban middle schools in crisis. The Civil Rights Project/Proyecto Derechos Civiles, University of California, Los Angeles. https://escholarship.org/content/qt8fh0s5dv/qt8fh0s5dv.pdf

67.

Mark

N. D. E.

Geller

Engberg

(2022). Adding insult to injury: Arrests reduce attendance through institutional mechanisms. Sociology of Education, 95(3), 189–215.

68.

McCarthy

J. D.

Hoge

D. R.

(1987). The social construction of school punishment: Racial disadvantage out of universalistic process. Social Forces, 65(4), 1101–1120.

69.

McFadden

A. C.

Marsh

G. E.

Price

B. J.

Hwang

(1992). A study of race and gender bias in the punishment of school children. Education & Treatment of Children, 15(2), 140–146.

70.

McNeely

C. A.

Nonnemaker

J. M.

Blum

R. W.

(2002). Promoting school connectedness: evidence from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health. The Journal of School Health, 72(4), 138–146.

71.

Mendez

L. M. R.

Knoff

H. M.

(2003). Who gets suspended from school and why: A demographic analysis of schools and disciplinary infractions in a Large School District. Education & Treatment of Children, 26(1), 30–51.

72.

Mendez

L. M. R.

Knoff

H. M.

Ferron

J. M.

(2002). School demographic variables and out-of-school suspension rates: A quantitative and qualitative analysis of a large, ethnically diverse school district. Psychology in the Schools, 39(3), 259–277.

73.

Meyer

B. D.

(1995). Natural and quasi-experiments in economics. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics: A Publication of the American Statistical Association, 13(2), 151–161.

74.

Morris

(2016). Pushout: The criminalization of black girls in schools. The New Press.

75.

Morris

E. W.

Perry

B. L.

(2016). The punishment gap: School suspension and racial disparities in achievement. Social Problems, 63(1), 68–86.

76.

Gottfredson

D. C.

(2013). Police officers in schools: Effects on school crime and the processing of offending behaviors. Justice Quarterly, 30(4), 619–650.

77.

Nance

J. P.

(2016). Student surveillance, racial inequalities, and implicit racial bias. Emory Law Journal, 66, 765.

78.

Nguyen

B. M. D.

Noguera

Adkins

Teranishi

R. T.

(2019). Ethnic discipline gap: Unseen dimensions of racial disproportionality in school discipline. American Educational Research Journal, 56(5), 1973–2003.

79.

Nolan

(2011). Police in the hallways: Discipline in an urban high school. University of Minnesota Press.

80.

Ofer

(2012). Criminalizing the classroom: The rise of aggressive policing and zero tolerance discipline in New York City Public Schools. New York Law School Law Review, 56, 1374. https://digitalcommons.nyls.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1684&context=nyls_law_review

81.

Owens

E. G.

(2017). Testing the school-to-prison pipeline. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 36(1), 11–37.

82.

Perry

B. L.

Morris

E. W.

(2014). Suspending progress: Collateral consequences of exclusionary punishment in public schools. American Sociological Review, 79(6), 1067–1087.

83.

Perumean-Chaney

S. E.

Sutton

L. M.

(2013). Students and perceived school safety: The impact of school security measures. American Journal of Criminal Justice: AJCJ, 38(4), 570–588.

84.

Pyne

(2019). Suspended attitudes: Exclusion and emotional disengagement from school. Sociology of Education, 92(1), 59–82.

85.

Rausch

M. K.

Skiba

R. J.

(2005). The academic cost of discipline: The relationship between suspension/expulsion and school achievement. Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Montreal, Canada.

86.

Reyes

A. H.

(2006). Discipline, achievement, and race: Is zero tolerance the answer? Rowman & Littlefield Education.

87.

Rios

V. M.

(2011). Punished: Policing the lives of Black and Latino Boys (1 online resource (237 p.]). New York University Press.

88.

Roth

Sant’Anna

P. H. C.

Bilinski

Poe

(2023). What’s trending in difference-in-differences? A synthesis of the recent econometrics literature. Journal of Econometrics, 235(2), 2218–2244.

89.

Sewell

A. A.

Feldman

J. M.

Ray

Gilbert

K. L.

Jefferson

K. A.

Lee

(2021). Illness spillovers of lethal police violence: The significance of gendered marginalization. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 44(7), 1089–1114.

90.

Sewell

A. A.

Jefferson

K. A.

(2016). Collateral damage: The health effects of invasive police encounters in New York City. Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine, 93(Suppl 1), 42–67.

91.

Sewell

A. A.

Jefferson

K. A.

Lee

(2016). Living under surveillance: Gender, psychological distress, and stop-question-and-frisk policing in New York City. Social Science & Medicine, 159, 1–13.

92.

Shedd

(2015). Unequal city: Race, schools, and perceptions of injustice. Russell Sage Foundation.

93.

Shelton

A. J.

Owens

E. W.

Song

(2009). An examination of public school safety measures across geographic settings. The Journal of School Health, 79(1), 24–29.

94.

Shirrell

Bristol

T. J.

Britton

T. A.

(2023). The effects of student–teacher ethnoracial matching on exclusionary discipline for Asian American, Black, and Latinx Students: Evidence from New York City. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 46(3), 555–580. https://doi.org/10.3102/01623737231175461

95.

Skiba

R. J.

Chung

C.-G.

Trachok

Baker

T. L.

Sheya

Hughes

R. L.

(2014). Parsing disciplinary disproportionality: Contributions of infraction, student, and school characteristics to out-of-school suspension and expulsion. American Educational Research Journal, 51(4), 640–670.

96.

Skiba

R. J.

Horner

R. H.

Chung

C.-G.

Rausch

M. K.

May

S. L.

Tobin

(2011). Race is not neutral: A national investigation of African American and Latino disproportionality in school discipline. School Psychology Review, 40(1), 85–107.

97.

Skiba

R. J.

Knesting

(2001). Zero tolerance, zero evidence: an analysis of school disciplinary practice. New Directions for Youth Development, 92, 17–43.

98.

Skiba

R. J.

Michael

R. S.

Nardo

A. C.

Peterson

R. L.

(2002). The color of discipline: Sources of racial and gender disproportionality in school punishment. The Urban Review, 34(4), 317–342.

99.

Smith

A. P. D.

(2007). An empirical assessment of NYPD’s “operation impact”: A targeted zone crime reduction strategy. https://marroninstitute.nyu.edu/uploads/content/Dennis_Smith_Impact_Zone_Policing_Report.pdf

100.

Sorensen

L. C.

Avila

A. M.

Engberg

Bushway

S. D.

(2021). The thin blue line in schools: New evidence on school-based policing across the U.S (No. 21-476). Annenberg Institute at Brown University. https://doi.org/10.26300/HEQX-RC69

101.

Sorensen

L. C.

Shen

Bushway

S. D.

(2021). Making schools safer and/or escalating disciplinary response: A study of police officers in North Carolina Schools. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 43(3), 495–519.

102.

Sousa

Kelling

(2014). Order maintenance policing. In D. Weisburd & G. Bruinsma (Eds.), Encyclopedia of criminology and criminal justice (pp. 3349–3358). Springer New York.

103.

Steinberg

M. P.

Allensworth

Johnson

D. W.

(2011). Student and teacher safety in Chicago public schools: The roles of community context and school social organization. Consortium on Chicago School Research. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED519414.pdf

104.

Stitt

M. E.

(2021). “Broken windows” discipline and racial disparities in school punishment. Punishment & Society, 25(1), 241–263.

105.

Sugie

N. F.

Turney

(2017). Beyond incarceration: Criminal justice contact and mental health. American Sociological Review, 82(4), 719–743.

106.

Sweeten

(2006). Who will graduate? Disruption of high school education by arrest and court involvement. Justice Quarterly, 23(4), 462–480.

107.

Teske

S. C.

(2011). A study of zero tolerance policies in schools: A multi-integrated systems approach to improve outcomes for adolescents. Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing, 24(2), 88–97.

108.

U.S. Department of Education: Office for Civil Rights. (2021). An Overview of exclusionary discipline practices in public schools for the 2017–18 school year. https://ocrdata.ed.gov/assets/downloads/crdc-exclusionary-school-discipline.pdf

109.

Wald

Losen

D. J.

(2003). Defining and redirecting a school-to-prison pipeline. New Directions for Youth Development, 2003(99), 9–15.

110.

Walton

(2014). Zero tolerance policing: An evaluation of the NYPD’s use of stop and frisk ( Estrella-Luna

, Ed.) [Doctor of Law and Policy Program]. Northeastern University.

111.

Weiler

S. C.

Cray

(2011). Police at school: A brief history and current status of School Resource Officers. Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas, 84(4), 160–163.

112.

Weisburst

E. K.

(2019). Patrolling public schools: The impact of funding for school police on student discipline and long-term education outcomes. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 38(2), 338–365.

113.

Widdowson

A. O.

Siennick

S. E.

Hay

(2016). The implications of arrest for college enrollment: An analysis of long-term effects and mediating mechanisms. Criminology; an Interdisciplinary Journal, 54(4), 621–652.

114.

S.-C.

Pink

Crain

Moles

(1982). Student suspension: A critical reappraisal. The Urban Review, 14(4), 245–303.

115.

Zhang

(2019). The effects of a school policing program on crime, discipline, and disorder: A quasi-experimental evaluation. American Journal of Criminal Justice: AJCJ, 44(1), 45–62.

116.

Zhao

C.-M.

Kuh

G. D.

(2004). Adding value: Learning communities and student engagement. Research in Higher Education, 45(2), 115–138.

117.

Zimmerman

(2020, June 4). Activists demand removing the NYPD from schools. De Blasio plans to give school police more money. Chalkbeat New York. https://ny.chalkbeat.org/2020/6/4/21280549/nypd-schools-funding

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.33 MB

0.00 MB