The Need for Indigenous Voices in Discourse about Introduced Species: Insights from a Controversy over Wild Horses

Abstract

Culture, livelihoods and political-economic status all influence people's perception of introduced and invasive species, shaping perspectives on what sort of management of them, if any, is warranted. Indigenous voices and values are under-represented in scholarly discourse about introduced and invasive species. This paper examines the relationship between the Xeni Gwet'in First Nation (one of six Tsilhqot'in communities) and wild or free-roaming horses in British Columbia, Canada. We outline how Xeni Gwet'in people value horses and experience management actions, contextualising the controversy over wild horses amidst power imbalances in the expression of environmental values. We suggest that Indigenous voices are vital to include when evaluating impacts of controversial species and developing management strategies.

Keywords

First Nations invasive species free-roaming horses management power relations

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Balsiger

P.W.

2004. ‘Supradisciplinary research practices: history, objectives and rationale’. Futures 36: 407–421. CrossRef.

Beever

E.A.

and Brussard

P.F.

. 2000a. ‘Charismatic megafauna or exotic pest? Interactions between popular perceptions of feral horses (Equus Caballus) and their management and research’. Paper presented at the Vertebrate Pest Conference, University of California, Davis.

Beever

E.A.

and Brussard

P.F.

. 2000b. ‘Examining ecological consequences of feral horse grazing using exclosures’. Western North American Naturalist 60: 236–254.

Berger

1986. Wild Horses of the Great Basin. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Bhattacharyya

, Slocombe

D.S.

and Murphy

S.D.

. 2011. ‘The “wild” or “feral” distraction: Effects of cultural understandings on management controversy over free-ranging horses (Equus ferus caballus)’. Human Ecology 39: 613–625. CrossRef.

Bouchard

E.A.

1971. Memorandum – Attention: Grazing. (9 July 1971). Ministry of Forests, B.C., Canada.

Caplat

and Coutts

S.R.

. 2011. ‘Integrating ecological knowledge, public perception and urgency of action into invasive species management’. Environmental Management 48: 878–881. CrossRef.

Chew

M.K.

2009. ‘The monstering of tamarisk: How scientists made a plant into a problem’. Journal of the History of Biology 42: 231–266. CrossRef.

Chew

M.K.

and Hamilton

A.L.

. 2011. ‘The rise and fall of biotic nativeness: A historical perspective’. In Richardson

David M.

(ed.) Fifty Years of Invasion Ecology: The Legacy of Charles Elton. Chichester: Blackwell Publishing Ltd. pp. 35–47.

10.

Clarke

D.A.

and Slocombe

D.S.

. 2009. ‘Respect for grizzly bears: An aboriginal approach for co-existence and resilience’. Ecology and Society 14: 42.

11.

Clutton-Brock

1994. ‘The unnatural world: Behavioural aspects of humans and animals in the process of domestication’. In Manning

and Serpell

(eds) Animals and Human Society: Changing Perspectives. New York: Routledge. pp. 23–35.

12.

Collins

1995. ‘Mange on the range: The Chilcotin's wild horses are judged to be a nuisance’. British Columbia Report (24 April 1995): 42.

13.

Cothran

E.G.

and McCrory

W.P.

. 2013. A Preliminary Genetic Study of the Wild Horse (Equus caballus) in the Brittany Triangle (Tachelach'ed) Region of the ?Elegesi Qayus (Nemiah) Wild Horse Preserve of British Columbia. Professional Report completed for Valhalla Wilderness Society, Friends of Nemaiah Valley and Xeni Gwet'in First Nation. Texas, USA and New Denver, British Columbia, Canada: Texas A&M University. [Unpublished Draft, 6 June 2013.].

14.

Cowdrey

, Martin

and Martin

. 2011. Horses and Bridles of the American Indians. Nicasio, California: Hawk Hill Press.

15.

Davis

2009. The Wayfinders: Why Ancient Wisdom Matters in the Modern World. Toronto, ON: House of Anansi Press Inc.

16.

Emerson

R.M.

, Fretz

R.I.

and Shaw

L.L.

. 1995. Writing Ethnographic Fieldnotes. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. CrossRef.

17.

Fazey

, Fazey

J.A.

, Salisbury

J.G.

, Lindenmayer

D.B.

and Dovers

. 2006. ‘The nature and role of experiential knowledge for environmental conservation’. Environmental Conservation 33: 1–10. CrossRef.

18.

Foster

and Sandberg

L.A.

. 2004. ‘Friends or foe? Invasive species and public green space in Toronto’. Geographical Review 94: 178–198. CrossRef.

19.

[GCC] Grasslands Conservation Council of British Columbia. 2010. Cariboo-Chilcotin and Central Interior: In Depth http://www.bcgrasslands.org/cc_cidigdeeper.htm (accessed 9 May 2010).

20.

Gobster

P.H.

(2001). ‘Visions of nature: Conflict and compatibility in urban park restoration’. Landscape and Urban Planning 56: 35–51. CrossRef.

21.

Goddard

and Smitten

. 2002. Wild Horses, Unconquered People. B. Hamilton (Producer). Canada: Omni Film Productions, Ltd.

22.

Hall

S.J.

2009. ‘Cultural disturbances and local ecological knowledge mediate cattail (Typha domingensis) invasion in Lake Patzcuaro, Mexico’. Human Ecology 37: 241–249. CrossRef.

23.

[INAC] Indian and Northern Affairs Canada. 2009. Pronunciation Guide to First Nations in British Columbia. http://www.ainc-inac.gc.ca/ai/scr/bc/fnbc/fsnst/prnfneng.asp. (accessed 7 December 2010).

24.

Ingold

2000. The Perception of the Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill. London: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group. CrossRef.

25.

Jerolmack

2008. ‘How pigeons became rats: The cultural-spatial logic of problem animals’. Social Problems 55: 72–94. CrossRef.

26.

Kavar

and Dovc

. 2008. ‘Domestication of the horse: Genetic relationships between domestic and wild horses’. Livestock Science 116: 1–14. CrossRef.

27.

Kendle

A.D.

and Rose

J.E.

. 2000. ‘The aliens have landed! What are the justifications for “native only” policies in landscape plantings?’ Landscape and Urban Planning 47: 19–31. CrossRef.

28.

King

S.R.B.

2002. ‘Home range and habitat use of free-ranging Przewalski horses at Hustai National Park, Mongolia’. Applied Animal Behaviour Science. 78: 103–113. CrossRef.

29.

Kirkpatrick

J.F.

and Fazio

P.M.

. 2010. Wild Horses as Native North American Wildlife. http://www.awionline.org/ht/d/sp/i/18457/pid/18457 (accessed 28 April 2010).

30.

Knights

2008. ‘Native species, human communities and cultural relationships’. Environmental Values 17: 353–373. CrossRef.

31.

Lutz

J.S.

2008. Makuk: A New History of Aboriginal-White Relations. Vancouver, BC: UBC Press.

32.

Marshall

N.A.

, Friedel

, van Klinken

R.D.

and Grice

A.C.

. 2011. ‘Considering the social dimension of invasive species: the case of buffel grass’. Environmental Science and Policy 14: 327–338. CrossRef.

33.

McCrory

2002. Preliminary conservation assessment of the Rainshadow Wild Horse Ecosystem, Brittany Triangle, Chilcotin, British Columbia, Canada. New Denver, BC: McCrory Wildlife Services Ltd.

34.

McNeely

J.A.

(ed.). 2001. The Great Reshuffling: Human Dimensions of Invasive Alien Species. Cambridge: IUCN.

35.

Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary. 2011 ‘cayuse’. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cayuse (accessed 16 November 2012).

36.

Miles

M.B.

and Huberman

A.M.

. 1994. Qualitative Data Analysis: And Expanded Sourcebook (2nd Edition). London: Sage.

37.

Nimmo

D.G.

, Miller

K.K.

and Adams

. (2007). ‘Managing feral horses in Victoria: A study of community attitudes and perceptions’. Ecological Management and Restoration 8: 237–243. CrossRef.

38.

Norgaard

K.M.

2007. ‘The politics of invasive weed management: Gender, race, and risk perception in rural California’. Rural Sociology 72: 450–477. CrossRef.

39.

O'Brien

2006. ‘Exotic invasions, nativism, and ecological restoration: On the persistence of a contentious debate’. Ethics, Place and Environment: A Journal of Philosophy and Geography 9: 63–77.

40.

Paulson

, Laudati

, Doolittle

, Welsh-Devine

and Pena

. 2012. ‘Indigenous Peoples’ participation in global conservation: Looking beyond headdresses and face paint’. Environmental Values 21: 255–276. CrossRef.

41.

Pedersen

M.C.

2008. Personal Letter File: 292–30/General, 15640–04. Chilcotin Forest District: Ministry of Forests and Range, British Columbia.

42.

Petrie

2011. ‘Satisfaction in a horse: The perception and assimilation of an exotic animal into Maori custom law’. In Rotherham

I.D.

and Lambert

R.A.

(eds). pp. 313–326.

43.

Pfeiffer

J.M.

, and Voeks

R.A.

. 2008. ‘Biological invasions and biocultural diversity: linking ecological and cultural systems’. Environmental Conservation (Foundation for Environmental Conservation): 1–13.

44.

Reed

C.M.

2008. ‘Wild horse protection policies: Environmental and animal ethics in transition’. International Journal of Public Administration 31: 277–286. CrossRef.

45.

Reed

2012. ‘Enriching the Lives of Wild Horses: Designing Opportunities for Them to Flourish’. Environmental Values 21: 317–329. CrossRef.

46.

Reid

2008/09. ‘The grasslands debates: Conservationists, ranchers, first nations, and the landscape of the Middle Fraser’. BC Studies 160: 93–118.

47.

Rikoon

J. S.

2006. ‘Wild horses and the political ecology of nature restoration in the Missouri Ozarks’. Geoforum 37: 200–211. CrossRef.

48.

Robert

, Walzer

, Ruegg

S.R.

, Kaczensky

, Ganbaatar

and Stauffer

. 2005. ‘Pathologic findings in reintroduced Przewalski's horses (Equus caballus przewalskii) in Southwestern Mongolia’. Journal of Zoo and Wildlife Medicine 36: 273–285. CrossRef.

49.

Robinson

C.J.

, Smyth

and Whitehead

P.J.

. 2005. ‘Bush tucker, bush pets, and bush threats: Cooperative management of feral animals in Australia's Kakadu National Park’. Conservation Biology 19: 1385–1391. CrossRef.

50.

Robinson

and Wickwire

. 2005. Living by Stories: A Journey of Landscape and Memory. Vancouver: Talonbooks.

51.

Rotherham

I.D.

and Lambert

R.A.

(eds). 2011. Invasive and Introduced Plants and Animals: Human Perceptions, Attitudes, and Approaches to Management. London: Earthscan.

52.

Salter

R.E.

and Hudson

R.J.

. 1978. ‘Distribution and management of feral horses in Western Canada’. Rangeman's Journal 5: 190–192.

53.

Scott Jones

and Watt

. (eds). 2010. Ethnography in Social Science Practice. New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group.

54.

Schwartz

K.Z.S.

2005. ‘Wild horses in a “European wilderness”: imagining sustainable development in the post-Communist countryside’. Cultural Geographies 12: 292–320. CrossRef.

55.

Setah

2010. Personal Communication. Nemiah Valley, British Columbia, Canada.

56.

Simberloff

and Rejmánek

. 2011. Encyclopedia of Biological Invasions. Berkeley: University of California Press.

57.

Steiner

and Posch

. 2006. ‘Higher education for sustainability by means of trans-disciplinary case studies: An innovative approach for solving complex, real-world problems’. Journal of Cleaner Production 14: 877–890. CrossRef.

58.

Stokes

J.S.

1975. Permit (File# 052130). Files on Horse Control Program obtained through Freedom of Information Request from Ministry of Forests and Range, British Columbia, Canada. Request by Jonaki Bhattacharyya and Katherine Card.

59.

Storrar

J.A.

, Hudson

R.J.

and Salter

R.E.

. 1977. ‘Habitat use behavior of feral horses and spatial relationships with moose in central British Columbia’. Syesis 10: 39–44.

60.

Swart

J.A.A.

2005. ‘Care for the wild: An Integrative View On Wild And Domesticated Animals’. Environmental Values 14: 251–263. CrossRef.

61.

Thistle

2008/9. ‘Accommodating cattle: British Columbia's “wars” with grasshoppers and “wild horses”’. BC Studies 160: 67–92.

62.

Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia: Argument of the Plaintiff, No. BCSC 1700 Registry No. 90–0913 (British Columbia Supreme Court 2007).

63.

Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia: Reasons for Judgment, No. 90–0913, BCSC 1700 (British Columbia Supreme Court 2007).

64.

Wagner

F.H.

1983. ‘Status of wild horse and burro management on public rangelands’. Paper presented at the Transactions of the Forty-eighth North American Wildlife and Natural Resources Conference, Washington, D.C.

65.

Warren

C.R.

2007. ‘Perspectives on the “alien” versus “native” species debate: A critique of concepts, language and practice’. Progress in Human Geography 31: 427–446.

66.

White

J.R.

1970. Memorandum – Attention: Grazing (Vol. G.R.I. Horse Control). Forest Agrologist, Kamloops BC: Ministry of Forests, British Columbia.

67.

Wilson

2008. Research is Ceremony: Indigenous Research Methods. Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada: Fernwood Publishing.