Abstract
The ‘business judgement rule’ requires corporate directors only to act with honesty and reasonable care in the interest of shareholders. A stronger ‘fiduciary’ duty is required where one party requires protection from another. This paper argues that where corporations take risks with the environment, directors are fiduciaries. Stakeholders are in that case the general public, future generations and other species, which have not voluntarily accepted risk and cannot limit liability. Recognition of fiduciary duty in such cases is consistent with recent trends in the law of equity. It would require all economic activities to move from open to closed (sustainable) systems.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.American Law Institute 1985 Principles of Corporate Governance: Analysis and Recommendations. Discussion Draft. Philadelphia , American Law Institute .
2.
Bishop
J.
Jr.
1968 “Sitting Ducks and Decoy Ducks: New Trends in the Indemnification of Corporate Directors and Officers ”, Yale L.J. 77 , 1078 .
3.
Feltham
I.
and
Rauenbusch
W.
1976 “Director's and Officer's Liabilities in Canada ”, 1 C.B.L.J. , 321 .
4.
Glasbeek
H.
1984 “Why Corporate Deviance is not Treated as a Crime – The Need to Make ‘Profits’ a Dirty Word ”, Osgoode Hall L.J. , 22 , 393 .
5.
Gower
L.
1969 The Principles of Modern Company Law. London , Stevens .
6.Institute of Law Research and Reform 1989 Corporate Directors’ Liability . Research Paper No. 17. Edmonton, The Institute.
7.
Maddaugh
Peter D.
and
McCamus
John D.
1990 The Law of Restitution . Aurora Ontario , Canada Law Book.
8.
Rawls
J.
1971 A Theory of Justice. Cambridge , Belknap Press of Harvard University Press .
9.
Riley
John
1980 “The Just Rate of Depletion of a National Resource ”, Journal of Environmental Economics and Management , 8 , 291 .
10.
Saxe
D.
1991 Environmental Offences: Corporate Responsibility and Executive Liability . Aurora Ontario , Canada Law Book.
11.
Scott
A.W.
1949 “The Fiduciary Principle ”, Cal. L. Rev . 37 , 539 –40 , cited in Maddaugh and McCamus, 1990, 588.
12.
Swaigen
John
1988 “Risk and Uncertainty in Environmental Law ”. Halifax, October 1988.
13.
Wainberg
J.
1987 Duties and Responsibilities of Directors in Canada , 6th ed. C.C.H., Don Mills.
14.
Waring
M.
1990 If Women Counted . New York , Harper Collins.
15.World Commission on Environment and Development 1987 Our Common Future . Oxford University Press .